Medical Marijuana

  • Thread starter Thread starter utunumsint
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Ethically speaking; our perception of Marijuana is simply wrong. We appear to categorise it alongside illicit use of cocaine, or heroin; however this view is simply wrong and flies in the face of everything we know about the chemical make up on the plant. First we assume that Marijuana impairs the cognitive faculties at all doses, this assertion is simply not true. Some strains of the plant impair cognitive faculties at higher doses, some strains appear to have no effect on cognitive faculties. This means our categorising marijuana as a stupefying medicative substance like Heroin can not be substantiated; and we are forced to concede that it would be better categorised alongside another stupefying substance that we call Alcohol.

Medically speaking, the circa 23 active cannabinoids in Cannabis each have different, and sometimes contradictory, effects. The two main ones are actually contradictory to each other; the one is psychoactive, whilst the other is anti-psychotic. The NHS in Britain has just applied for a license to research CBD in treatment of Schizophrenia. The research results coming out of Belgium on the same subject matter has shown it to be stronger than any of the current anti-psychotics in use with none of the side effects commonly associated with anti-psychotics.

I see nothing morally problematic here from a Natural Law perspective.
Skeptic92 - My experience of the drug was in the wild of high school and university where it was used a great deal. If scientists can isolate the active ingredients that are beneficial from those that cause harm, I would agree with you that there would be nothing preventing us from using it medicinally. That said, Canabis has a long road to climb out of the negative cultural association that it comes with. Those kids in high school and university I saw using, also used other drugs like LDS. I think now days, they use even stronger more dangerous stuff like Oxycontin, cocaine, and so on. And even if we were to legalize Marijuana for medical reasons, I do not want my kids to be recreationally using drugs like that. Underage drinking is already a bad enough problem to deal with. What is going to happen when we legalize Pot?

My nagging doubt is that medical marijuana is a first step towards a general legalization. At least in Canada, that is where the Liberal party already wants to take us.

God bless,
Ut
 
Its pathetic that some people in this country wish to deny people treatment JUST because it comes from a plant, that SOME people use to get high from. LOL I laugh when I hear people make these arguments!

Law enforcement and Govt have done a GREAT job at brainwashing a large percentage of the population.

Btw, Heroin is recognized as having medical uses in the UK and some other countries, yet not so in the US. but we claim to be on the cutting edge of medicine and other treatments…?? I truly dont understand this country anymore.
Opiates like Oxycontine (basically medicinal heroine) are one of the major causes of youth death in Canada. 1 in 8 deaths cbc.ca/news/health/oxycontin-and-other-opioids-tied-to-1-in-8-deaths-in-young-adults-ontario-study-shows-1.2696995

Yes, we do have a problem with drugs of all sorts in North America. Just because a drug is legal does not make it good for society. Honestly, drug abuse is the real problem here.

God bless,
Ut
 
Skeptic92 - My experience of the drug was in the wild of high school and university where it was used a great deal. If scientists can isolate the active ingredients that are beneficial from those that cause harm, I would agree with you that there would be nothing preventing us from using it medicinally. That said, Canabis has a long road to climb out of the negative cultural association that it comes with. Those kids in high school and university I saw using, also used other drugs like LDS. I think now days, they use even stronger more dangerous stuff like Oxycontin, cocaine, and so on. And even if we were to legalize Marijuana for medical reasons, I do not want my kids to be recreationally using drugs like that. Underage drinking is already a bad enough problem to deal with. What is going to happen when we legalize Pot?

My nagging doubt is that medical marijuana is a first step towards a general legalization. At least in Canada, that is where the Liberal party already wants to take us.

God bless,
Ut
I have to inquire; where does the State receive its mandate from to employ its power of prohibition? I have been debating this question for a while now with other Natural Law Theorists, including those much better informed and read than I, and the answer seems to come up blank. I’m unsure whether prohibition of Cannabis can actually be justified from Natural Law, without at the same time presenting an argument for the prohibition of Alcohol. Which is absurd.
 
I have to inquire; where does the State receive its mandate from to employ its power of prohibition? I have been debating this question for a while now with other Natural Law Theorists, including those much better informed and read than I, and the answer seems to come up blank. I’m unsure whether prohibition of Cannabis can actually be justified from Natural Law, without at the same time presenting an argument for the prohibition of Alcohol. Which is absurd.
I think the state ought to measure the costs versus the benefits of legalizing any substance. Alcohol has benefits, but some obvious draw backs, such as alcoholism, impaired driving, impaired thinking leading to the outbreak of violence, wife abuse, child abuse, and so on. I think the question has to be asked whether society benefits, despite such obvious draw backs.

When coming to the idea of legalizing pot, I would suggest that having two such substances causing similar negative consequences becomes too much, and the state has the moral responsibility to step in as it does in other such cases.

God bless,
Ut
 
I think the state ought to measure the costs versus the benefits of legalizing any substance. Alcohol has benefits, but some obvious draw backs, such as alcoholism, impaired driving, impaired thinking leading to the outbreak of violence, wife abuse, child abuse, and so on. I think the question has to be asked whether society benefits, despite such obvious draw backs.

When coming to the idea of legalizing pot, I would suggest that having two such substances causing similar negative consequences becomes too much, and the state has the moral responsibility to step in as it does in other such cases.

God bless,
Ut
Professor David Nutt released the culmination of years of research into the Drug Laws in Britain, and noted that the negative social and health affects of Cannabis have very little in common with Alcohol. Relatively speaking, Cannabis is harmless compared to Alcohol especially socially. So your argument is a non-sequitur, as your assumption that the negative affects of alcohol are the same as cannabis is evidently false.
 
Professor David Nutt released the culmination of years of research into the Drug Laws in Britain, and noted that the negative social and health affects of Cannabis have very little in common with Alcohol. Relatively speaking, Cannabis is harmless compared to Alcohol especially socially. So your argument is a non-sequitur, as your assumption that the negative affects of alcohol are the same as cannabis is evidently false.
My evidence is personal experience as observed through high school and university. I don’t agree with you or the study.

God bless,
Ut
 
My evidence is personal experience as observed through high school and university. I don’t agree with you or the study.

God bless,
Ut
I also have evidence from personal experience as observed through high school and university, and I am also backed up by medical professionals. Appealing just to anecdotal evidence without it being substantiated by large scale research is a logical fallacy, also rejecting a conclusion without showing one of the premises to be false is also a logical fallacy- you have to show WHY my argument is wrong. Not simply assert that it is; that is not how Philosophical or Theological Ethics works.

God Bless
 
I also have evidence from personal experience as observed through high school and university, and I am also backed up by medical professionals. Appealing just to anecdotal evidence without it being substantiated by large scale research is a logical fallacy, also rejecting a conclusion without showing one of the premises to be false is also a logical fallacy- you have to show WHY my argument is wrong. Not simply assert that it is; that is not how Philosophical or Theological Ethics works.

God Bless
Well, I would say we tolerate the evils that come with Alcohol, which mainly stem from excessive use of Alcohol. I believe those same evils occur through Cannabis. In general, they both stem back from a loss of self control. Being drunk, with respect to alcohol equates to being stoned with respect to Cannabis. They both impair judgement.

The question I posed in this thread is whether such substances are acceptable in a medical context. I think it may be. But I am still not convinced.

God bless,
Ut
 
Well, I would say we tolerate the evils that come with Alcohol, which mainly stem from excessive use of Alcohol. I believe those same evils occur through Cannabis. In general, they both stem back from a loss of self control. Being drunk, with respect to alcohol equates to being stoned with respect to Cannabis. They both impair judgement.

The question I posed in this thread is whether such substances are acceptable in a medical context. I think it may be. But I am still not convinced.

God bless,
Ut
Yes, and I have already presented an argument which is based on the chemical make up of the plant in regards to cognitive impairment. It appears to be dose specific and not happen at any dose that is taken. This places it within the same category (or type) as Alcohol; unless you concede that Alcohol is also to be prohibited under the law, your argument is inconsistent. That alcohol should also be prohibited though is an absurd conclusion and inconsistent with the Natural Law conception of the power of the State (cf; Jacques Maritain, Man and the State) in regards to employment of its power of prohibition.

Medicinally Cannabis has shown enormous potential, the problem is in the way that the law is written makes research into the medicinal properties of the plant very difficult. Even though this plant that apparently is correlated with Schizophrenia, is now being looked into for treatment of Schizophrenia. Much of what you have peddled in this thread in regards to the negative affects of the drug is little more than a myth.
 
Yes, and I have already presented an argument which is based on the chemical make up of the plant in regards to cognitive impairment. It appears to be dose specific and not happen at any dose that is taken. This places it within the same category (or type) as Alcohol; unless you concede that Alcohol is also to be prohibited under the law, your argument is inconsistent. That alcohol should also be prohibited though is an absurd conclusion and inconsistent with the Natural Law conception of the power of the State (cf; Jacques Maritain, Man and the State) in regards to employment of its power of prohibition.

Medicinally Cannabis has shown enormous potential, the problem is in the way that the law is written makes research into the medicinal properties of the plant very difficult. Even though this plant that apparently is correlated with Schizophrenia, is now being looked into for treatment of Schizophrenia. Much of what you have peddled in this thread in regards to the negative affects of the drug is little more than a myth.
Myths are not based on experience.

I am not a natural law theorist, so I can’t comment on Jacques Maritain’s conception of the power of the State. But I do believe that sometimes inconsistencies can and ought to be tolerated in a democratic society on the basis of the social consequences of legalizing various practices. For example, I strongly believe that government ought to be in the business of censoring. Pornography should be illegal, the internet should be policed. I believe these things because of the evident social consequences that have occurred because they have been legalized. I would apply the same argument to prostitution if it were legal in Canada. I believe that many countries where it has been legalized are now reversing those laws for the sake of the public good.

God bless,
Ut
 
Myths are not based on experience.

I am not a natural law theorist, so I can’t comment on Jacques Maritain’s conception of the power of the State. But I do believe that sometimes inconsistencies can and ought to be tolerated in a democratic society on the basis of the social consequences of legalizing various practices. For example, I strongly believe that government ought to be in the business of censoring. Pornography should be illegal, the internet should be policed. I believe these things because of the evident social consequences that have occurred because they have been legalized. I would apply the same argument to prostitution if it were legal in Canada. I believe that many countries where it has been legalized are now reversing those laws for the sake of the public good.

God bless,
Ut
Well; the Churches Social and Moral Teaching is based on Natural Law 😉
 
Well; the Churches Social and Moral Teaching is based on Natural Law 😉
Have you looked at this article? crisismagazine.com/2014/marijuana-legalization-what-would-aquinas-say

I liked this quote from one of the comments:
The difference between drug addiction and alcoholism was emphasized in
these terms by the Holy Father John Paul 11: “It is true that there is a
distinct difference between the use of drugs and the use of alcohol: while a
moderate use of the latter as a drink does not offend moral principles, only its
abuse can be condemned; instead, the use of drugs is always unlawful because it
implies an unjustified and unreasonable renunciation of thinking, desiring and
acting as a free person” (, 19, VII, 1992, n. 1).
God bless,
Ut
 
I have, have you ever read the Latin of the Catechism which gives the definition of “drugs” in Catholic Moral Theology? “Stupefactivorum medicamentorum” is the term used, do you understand what this means or shall I translate and explain it for you?
Brother - I am apologize if my opinion frustrates you. I am seeking to inform my conscience. Pope Francis has strongly condemned the idea of legalizing Marijuana and I assume he has done his homework. His opinion also correlates with my experience.

As to your question, yes, I do understand what those words mean.

God bless,
Ut
 
Brother - I am apologize if my opinion frustrates you. I am seeking to inform my conscience. Pope Francis has strongly condemned the idea of legalizing Marijuana and I assume he has done his homework. His opinion also correlates with my experience.

As to your question, yes, I do understand what those words mean.

God bless,
Ut
Then how about my previous argument which stipulates that to categorise Cannabis as a stupefying substance simply (simpliciter if you’re a fan of Latin) would be an assertion that is evidently false? Yes, cannabis is a stupefying substance this, however, is only in a qualified sense (secundum quid, if you’re a fan of Latin) the same as Alcohol. Which makes it difficult to formulate the argument that Cannabis must be prohibited whilst Alcohol is not. Otherwise we are saying that the same category of drugs must be legal and illegal in the same sense, at the same time. Which is a violation of non-contradiction; and therefore necessarily false.

Brother don’t worry, I wasn’t frustrated- I simply wanted to know if I could gloss over the explanation of Stupefying Medicative Substances, and jump straight into the argument.
 
From what I have read it seems to manage pain symptoms for chronic conditions and palliative care as previously mentioned. I don’t think there is any moral issue to producing or using it any more than there is a moral issue to producing hydrocodone or oxycontin. These two pain killers can wreak havoc in an addict but they also improve quality of life for sufferers of things like rheumatoid arthritis. I don’t use it and don’t drink but I see little difference between it and alcohol, really, Excess and escapism is the moral issue. Gluttony, in other words.

Would you fault your friend if he were a pharmacist mixing a cocktail of opioid medications for a sick person with stage 4 cancer? Would you judge him if he were brewing holiday beer and giving it away to friends or sharing it at a party in moderation?

Actually, you will find that this statement isn’t entirely accurate. Addiction is not caused by drugs any more than obesity is caused by food. It triggers the condition but there are underlying issues (in the case of addiction, there are genetic factors in play). One cannot be turned into an addict any more than one can be turned into a kleptomaniac. You are or you aren’t. For more information from the same site on addiction (see the long definition):

asam.org/for-the-public/definition-of-addiction

I take misinformation of addiction seriously as my mother is a recovering alcoholic who struggles with our extended family who thinks she is just weak willed and judge her, harshly, based off of what is essentially a disease that she is seeking treatment for in a 12 Step program.
My point is that marijuana is not an approved medication by the FDA. If it was, it would be sold in pharmacies. The cancer comparison is unusual. Having worked in a hospital for nearly 10 years, liability is a primary concern. A friend who recently died from pancreatic cancer, had to sign off on an experimental medication. It’s a little sad that, in some cases, family members will sue the doctor and hospital for providing medications that are experimental or unapproved. The doctor can lose his license and/or pay a substantial amount. Malpractice is not a good thing. With all medications, doctors are required to get the informed consent of a patient in writing. The hospital I worked at specialized in cancer treatment.

The fact that some people try other means to deal with their pain outside of a hospital or while not under a physician’s care, or without his knowledge, is the issue.

According to Bloomberg, “The National Institutes of Health has funded 196 projects on marijuana in fiscal 2014, according to an NIH database.” Research is expensive, and putting a new medication on the market has serious liability concerns if there is not enough unbiased science to back up its use. The makers/growers of medical marijuana will face lawsuits and recalls if their product causes harm that was not detected during the research phase.

Peace,
Ed
 
Then how about my previous argument which stipulates that to categorise Cannabis as a stupefying substance simply (simpliciter if you’re a fan of Latin) would be an assertion that is evidently false? Yes, cannabis is a stupefying substance this, however, is only in a qualified sense (secundum quid, if you’re a fan of Latin) the same as Alcohol. Which makes it difficult to formulate the argument that Cannabis must be prohibited whilst Alcohol is not. Otherwise we are saying that the same category of drugs must be legal and illegal in the same sense, at the same time. Which is a violation of non-contradiction; and therefore necessarily false.

Brother don’t worry, I wasn’t frustrated- I simply wanted to know if I could gloss over the explanation of Stupefying Medicative Substances, and jump straight into the argument.
So you are telling me that like Alcohol, you can smoke two joints and not get stoned, or be under some legally defined limit for impaired driving, for example?

But regardless, even if this were true, and the stupefying effects of cannabis could be offset through moderation, we are still adding a second substance to our cultural buffet of potentially abusable substances. By legalizing it you are not making a neutral statement about its use. Governments would be endorsing it. At least, that is how youth and entrepreneurs (drug dealers) would interpret such a ruling. So no, on top of a alcohol problem, we would have a pot head problem. The first to suffer on account of such a ruling would be the youth.

So yes, it is potentially a contradiction, but I believe it is a justified one given fallen human nature.

God bless,
Ut
 
So you are telling me that like Alcohol, you can smoke two joints and not get stoned, or be under some legally defined limit for impaired driving, for example?

But regardless, even if this were true, and the stupefying effects of cannabis could be offset through moderation, we are still adding a second substance to our cultural buffet of potentially abusable substances. By legalizing it you are not making a neutral statement about its use. Governments would be endorsing it. At least, that is how youth and entrepreneurs (drug dealers) would interpret such a ruling. So no, on top of a alcohol problem, we would have a pot head problem. The first to suffer on account of such a ruling would be the youth.

So yes, it is potentially a contradiction, but I believe it is a justified one given fallen human nature.

God bless,
Ut
No, you are still committing a Formal Contradiction. Through the legality of alcohol and tobacco, is the Government actively endorsing their use?
Your argument is of the form;

If X is legalised, then Government is actively endorsing X
X is legalised
Therefore the Government actively endorses X

I deny the major premise, I do not see the necessary link between the antecedent and the consequent. I can see the premise “If the Government has no mandate to prohibit X, then X is to be legalised”, but this does not necessarily mean that the Government is actively promoting X. The reverse of your premise would entail that the Government MUST prohibit every potentially sinful activity, which is absurd. As this would entail that we must prohibit alcohol, driving, TV, etc. This is an absurd conclusion, therefore your argument is absurd.

An example that shows the falsity of your argument

If binge drinking is legalised, then the Government is actively endorsing binge drinking
Binge drinking is legalised
Therefore the Government actively endorses binge drinking.

The conclusion is absurd, therefore we know there is a problem is the premises. The second premise is true, therefore it is the major premise that is false- for the reasons already discussed.

Also; no I’m saying you can smoke a joint and your cognitive faculties not be any more impaired than drinking 2 pints. There are certain strains of Cannabis where the effect, even at high doses, on the cognitive faculties is remote is not non-existent. You talk about the chemical make up of the plant as if it is homogeneous, which is evidently false to anyone that has ever researched the chemical make up of the plant and its different strains.
 
No, you are still committing a Formal Contradiction. Through the legality of alcohol and tobacco, is the Government actively endorsing their use?
Your argument is of the form;

If X is legalised, then Government is actively endorsing X
X is legalised
Therefore the Government actively endorses X

I deny the major premise, I do not see the necessary link between the antecedent and the consequent. I can see the premise “If the Government has no mandate to prohibit X, then X is to be legalised”, but this does not necessarily mean that the Government is actively promoting X. The reverse of your premise would entail that the Government MUST prohibit every potentially sinful activity, which is absurd. As this would entail that we must prohibit alcohol, driving, TV, etc. This is an absurd conclusion, therefore your argument is absurd.

An example that shows the falsity of your argument

If binge drinking is legalised, then the Government is actively endorsing binge drinking
Binge drinking is legalised
Therefore the Government actively endorses binge drinking.

The conclusion is absurd, therefore we know there is a problem is the premises. The second premise is true, therefore it is the major premise that is false- for the reasons already discussed.
You missed this part of my argument:
At least, that is how youth and entrepreneurs (drug dealers) would interpret such a ruling.
And that is my key point. This drug will be marketed and it will be abused. This will be the direct result of decriminalization. And I believe the government would be directly responsible for such an action and the social consequences that ensue.
Also; no I’m saying you can smoke a joint and your cognitive faculties not be any more impaired than drinking 2 pints. There are certain strains of Cannabis where the effect, even at high doses, on the cognitive faculties is remote is not non-existent. You talk about the chemical make up of the plant as if it is homogeneous, which is evidently false to anyone that has ever researched the chemical make up of the plant and its different strains.
Perhaps, if such strains could be manufactured and only such strains sold, then your argument might hold. But for most people who smoke pot (youth), they want the impairment. There would be no draw otherwise. I think this argument is naive about what will actually happen when legalization occurs (I mean this with all kindness).

God bless,
Ut
 
You missed this part of my argument:

And that is my key point. This drug will be marketed and it will be abused. This will be the direct result of decriminalization. And I believe the government would be directly responsible for such an action and the social consequences that ensue.

Perhaps, if such strains could be manufactured and only such strains sold, then your argument might hold. But for most people who smoke pot (youth), they want the impairment. There would be no draw otherwise. I think this argument is naive about what will actually happen when legalization occurs (I mean this with all kindness).

God bless,
Ut
You have yet to address any of my argument, and you haven’t repaired the fact your argument still does not follow. At this point you are rejecting the conclusion of my argument without demonstrating that any of the premises are false; this is a procedural fallacy, or mistake in reasoning. I think you are being rather naive and dogmatic in your opinion, rather than actually reading and engaging with my argument. So I’ll ask again;

What grants the State its mandate to employ its power of prohibition, without falling into formal contradiction?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top