Meditation as a Christian

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tyler1234
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

Tyler1234

Guest
I have recently discovered the many benefits of meditation.
However, I fear that it is dangerous, as it is very similar to a key Buddhist practice.
When I’ve meditated, I’ve meditated while holding a cross necklace in my hand, and focusing on the love of Christ. It still scares be though

Also, as a secondary, optional question, what is your opinion of Buddhism?

Thanks
God bless 🙂
 
I have recently discovered the many benefits of meditation.
However, I fear that it is dangerous, as it is very similar to a key Buddhist practice.
When I’ve meditated, I’ve meditated while holding a cross necklace in my hand, and focusing on the love of Christ. It still scares be though

Also, as a secondary, optional question, what is your opinion of Buddhism?

Thanks
God bless 🙂
I’m not too familiar with meditation per se, but more with contemplative forms. From what I can gather, the main difference I see between Buddhism and contemplative prayer, is that in Buddhism they focus on a mantra, where in Christian contemplation we do not. In contemplation the idea is not to focus the mind on anything at all, but to rest it as much as possible. Another term for this type of prayer is “resting in God.” (My daughter used to observe I sometimes fell asleep during prayer, and called it “taking a nap with God.” 🙂 )

For an overview of the three expression of prayer, vocal, meditation, and contemplative prayer, see the article in the CCC, paragraphs 2700-2724.

Honestly, I have gained from listening to eastern philosophy from Alan Watts, who was an Anglican priest turned Buddhist “guru” and then as far as I know didn’t consider himself any religion in particular before he died. He lectured a lot, and specialized in explaining eastern philosophy and religions to western audiences. He said some things I let go by, but he had much wisdom, and I found when I started into Christian contemplative prayer that there are some parallels between Buddhist thinking and the teachings of Jesus, although it may not sound that way on the surface to someone who is hearing it for the first time. Plus, it helped to step outside the box of Catholicism to hear his well-articulated lectures coming from a different point of view, so that I may look at Catholicism from the outside and see what our house actually looks like. He even had a lecture on the real Jesus v the Jesus many Christians tend to portray, and frankly that put me on fire for Jesus more than I ever was before. Now, I really don’t need anybody to tell me that I am being dangerously new-agey or worse; I’ve heard it before and it didn’t “fix” me then, but if you feel you must then I understand. 😉

Alan
 
I have recently discovered the many benefits of meditation.
However, I fear that it is dangerous…
Not all forms of meditation are beneficial for any one person. There are many types of Buddhist meditation, Christian meditation, Hindu meditation, etc. Find that which is beneficial for you and your spiritual life.
 
I have recently discovered the many benefits of meditation.
However, I fear that it is dangerous, as it is very similar to a key Buddhist practice.
When I’ve meditated, I’ve meditated while holding a cross necklace in my hand, and focusing on the love of Christ. It still scares be though

Also, as a secondary, optional question, what is your opinion of Buddhism?

Thanks
God bless 🙂
since this is a CAtholic spirituality forum I have no opinion of Buddhism.

meditation by itself is neutral neither dangerous nor advantageous except for its non-spiritual effects such as relaxation and focus.

The matter for the meditation, that is, how one prepares the mind and heart to enter into meditation, holds either reward or danger, however. Meditation is inherent in Christian prayer and spirituality from its inception, especially meditation on the gospels, life of Christ, his passion, death and resurrection, on the other fruits of the Church such as the rest of the new testament, church fathers, lives and works of the saints etc.

Meditation on pagan subjects, topics, personages, myths, ethos etc. will carry the danger that they will supplant what should be the true realm of the Christian and remove one’s focus from Christ to the world and non-Christian world views.
 
If you’re meditating on the love of Christ, there’s nothing wrong with that. That’s not the kind of meditation you want to avoid.

The key feature of Christian meditation is being present to the Person of Jesus Christ, while the key feature of secular or Eastern meditation is being present to yourself. (There’s nothing wrong with the latter per se, but we are interested in more than producing psychological effects through self-observation.)
 
ewtn.com/library/CURIA/CDFMED.HTM

From the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith
This is the response of the Church …(written with the Bishops as the audience).

I will add that while perhaps some things can be useful to a Christian there can be some real questions and problems. Especially in terms of their world view…and the use of religious aspects not compatible with Christianity which can end one up practicing another religion (which is contrary to the commandments) etc. etc
 
Are you saying that practicing non-Catholic religions automatically implies worshiping false Gods?

Alan
No … for example …the Jewish religion.

But certainly a Christian should not be “practicing” any non-Christian religion.

Say burning incense to a Hindu deity or chanting their name… is well…worshiping other than God…

As to looking to some aspects of say meditation etc …divorced from the religion…see the document from the Holy See.
 
No … for example …the Jewish religion.

But certainly a Christian should not be “practicing” any non-Christian religion.

Say burning incense to a Hindu deity or chanting their name… is well…worshiping other than God…

As to looking to some aspects of say meditation etc …divorced from the religion…see the document from the Holy See.
Thanks for clearing that up. 👍

A couple months ago one of my daughters married a Hindu from Nepal. They had a Hindu wedding on Friday and a Catholic wedding on Saturday. My mother couldn’t get over seeing the photos of the Hindu wedding where the priest had no shirt on. 😛

Alan
 
I have recently discovered the many benefits of meditation.
However, I fear that it is dangerous, as it is very similar to a key Buddhist practice.
When I’ve meditated, I’ve meditated while holding a cross necklace in my hand, and focusing on the love of Christ. It still scares be though

Also, as a secondary, optional question, what is your opinion of Buddhism?

Thanks
God bless 🙂
Yeah, I think you should be scared. As a person who was a Buddhist before becoming an adult convert to Catholicism, I would be scared too.
Catholic meditation is dangerous too.
Any practice where you “open the mind” is dangerous because guess what… the devil LOVES that. It creates a perfect gap where he can mosey on in.

Keep your mind focused on philosophy, theology, scripture, gospels etc…
Pray with a focused mind directed towards God.
Meditate ON the bible and what it says.

Do NOT sit there like some idiot with an “open mind” just expecting spiritual experiences of God to just dawn on you. More likely, the devil will waltz in. And you DON’T want that.

God works through the analytical mind and brings you wisdom through understanding of scripture.
The devil works with putting vain ideas INTO your head and making you think you are something special and “spiritual” when in fact you are not.

And any exercise which divorces you from your intellect is dangerous because it is actually our reasoning abilities that keep us.

Now sometimes it happens that we are minding our own business and a spiritual experience happens to us without our asking for it. These are of two types, one is from God and the other is from the devil. And 9 times out of 10 its the devil.😦
 
Thanks for clearing that up. 👍

A couple months ago one of my daughters married a Hindu from Nepal. They had a Hindu wedding on Friday and a Catholic wedding on Saturday. My mother couldn’t get over seeing the photos of the Hindu wedding where the priest had no shirt on. 😛

Alan
The Buddha was from Nepal, too. Perhaps your new son-in-law is related to the Buddha.👍
 
The Buddha was from Nepal, too. Perhaps your new son-in-law is related to the Buddha.👍
Could be. If so then weight problems must not run in the family because Prashanta is not overweight. 😛

Alan
 
People are afraid…and spread their fear. I say walk with the Lord in meditation and nothing can harm you. God is the strongest force so the Devil has no power. Now, if you are not walking with the Lord I see why you would be afraid of the Boogy Man.
 
People are afraid…and spread their fear. I say walk with the Lord in meditation and nothing can harm you. God is the strongest force so the Devil has no power. Now, if you are not walking with the Lord I see why you would be afraid of the Boogy Man.
👍
 
Could be. If so then weight problems must not run in the family because Prashanta is not overweight. 😛

Alan
That’s a common misconception, that Siddhartha Gautama, the Buddha, was overweight. This misconception comes from Chinese folklore, in which a Chinese legendary deity, depicted as overweight and smiling, has been equated with the Buddha named “Maitreya”, who is to appear sometime in the far future. (Other Buddhist cultures, outside of Chinese influence, do not depict Maitreya as overweight.) In Chinese-influenced cultures, Maitreya is depicted:

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)

But, the historical Buddha, named Siddhartha Gautama, who took birth 2500 years ago in what is now Nepal, is never depicted as overweight. In fact, during one time period when he was engaging in extreme fasting, Gautama was so thin that He could, when touching his stomach, also feel his spine:



After realizing the futility of such extreme fasting (as well as the futility of extreme indulgence), Siddhartha Gautama discovered that Truth was in the “Middle Way”:

http://profile.ak.fbcdn.net/hprofile-ak-snc4/203222_100002409138900_4393309_n.jpg
 
That’s a common misconception, that Siddhartha Gautama, the Buddha, was overweight.
I was just being glib, but thank you for the fascinating history lesson. I love to know these things, even though I’m usually to lazy too seek them out without help. :rolleyes:

Alan
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top