W
weirdcatholic
Guest
Is there anything heretical about meister eckhart’s view of mysticism/spirituality and the catholic church? Specifics would be appreciated. Thanks 
I think of the marvellous history of Rheno-Flemish mysticism of the thirteenth and especially of the fourteenth centuries… Did not Eckhart teach his disciples: “All that God asks you most pressingly is to go out of yourself … and let God be God in you” [cf Walshe Sermon 13b]? One could think that in separating himself from creatures the mystic leaves his brother humanity behind. The same Eckhart affirms that on the contrary the mystic is marvellously present to them on the only level where he can truly reach them, that is, in God.’
- Blessed Pope John Paul II, in “Ecclesiastical Mission of Adrienne Speyr” (1987)
**From a CAF apologist: **
Question: I have read a bit of M. Eckhart because I feel attracted to mystical works (St. John if the Cross, Teresa of Avila). I understand that he is considered a heretic. I am just wondering where he crossed the line. So far everything seems in the mystical tradition as does his defense.I have the Harper and Row 1941 edition translated by Raymond B. Blakney. thanks, nicolo
**Answer from Fr. Vincent Serpa: **
Hey Nicolo,
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=80878Meister Eckhart was a Dominican like me and is no heretic.
I suspect that your friend is attracted to the mystical and philosophical aspects of Taoism. It could be that his own Christian tradition is devoid of these. Perhaps you could whet his appetite with the writings of some of our Catholic mystics. I would recommend the work of Meister Eckhart whose work develops themes that are congruent with Taoism but also thoroughly Christian.
Thanks for the sources. I think getting in tap with our eastern brothers is super imporrtant.His own order, the Dominicans, never regarded him as a heretic. Neither did his followers, two of whom were beatified and one much later one - that is Cardinal Nicholas of Cusa who read Eckhart’s works - was of course the most powerful cardinal in the catholic church during the 14th century.
Every Catholic mystic post-Eckhart has practically fallen under his influence to some degree.
Blessed Pope John Paul II held him in high regard:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=80878
The apologetics part of this website even recommends him for the purposes of missionary activity:
catholic.com/quickquestions/what-do-you-recommend-when-evangelizing-a-taoist
It’s good to know he wasn’t considered a heretic.His own order, the Dominicans, never regarded him as a heretic. Neither did his followers, two of whom were beatified and one much later one - that is Cardinal Nicholas of Cusa who read Eckhart’s works - was of course the most powerful cardinal in the catholic church during the 14th century.
Every Catholic mystic post-Eckhart has practically fallen under his influence to some degree.
Blessed Pope John Paul II held him in high regard:
forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=80878
The apologetics part of this website even recommends him for the purposes of missionary activity:
catholic.com/quickquestions/what-do-you-recommend-when-evangelizing-a-taoist
Absolutely.Is there any caution or approach that should be taken when reading his works so as to avoid misinterpreting them heretically?
“…Our loving Master taught you and told you about these matters and you did not understand him. He spoke from the point of view of eternity, and you understood him from the point of view of time…”
Eckhart often speaks from inside the mystical experience of union with God. In this respect some of his statements can seem auto-theistic or pantheistic. He speaks of how one feels during the unio mystica when the lines between Lover and Beloved become indistinct from the perspective of the person experiencing it, even while they remain different from God in essence. If one were to read these statements straight, nonetheless, one could think that he was claiming to be God.***- Johannes Tauler (c.1300-1361), Catholic mystic & Dominican priest ***
“…My I is God, and I know of no other I than this my God…In this way God so transforms the soul into Himself, its God, that it sees nothing but God…The more the soul is purified, so much the more it annihilates self till at last it becomes quire pure and rests in God…Thus purified the soul rests in God without any alloy of self; my very being is God…Everything that has being has it from God’s highest essence through participation; but the pure and clear love cannot be content with seeing that it has acquired God through participation, nor with his being in it as a creature…My being is God, not through participation only, but through true transformation and through annihilation of my own being…So in God is my me, my I, my strength, my bliss, my desire…”
- Saint Catherine of Genoa (1447-1510), Catholic mystic
Interesting. Could you expand a little more on this God-seeing perspective outside of time and how it is non-quietistic/auto-theistic/pantheistic?Absolutely.
One of his disciples, Johannes Tauler (a highly respected mystical theologian), once noted:
Eckhart often speaks from inside the mystical experience of union with God. In this respect some of his statements can seem auto-theistic or pantheistic. He speaks of how one feels during the unio mystica when the lines between Lover and Beloved become indistinct from the perspective of the person experiencing it, even while they remain different from God in essence. If one were to read these statements straight, nonetheless, one could think that he was claiming to be God.
He speaks from the perspective of “eternity”, the perspective of the God-seeing contemplative, as opposed to time.
Another person in the Catholic mystical tradition who does this is St. Catherine of Genoa:
"…**THROUGH THREE THINGS A MAN BECOMES GOD-SEEING **
Further, you must know that if this spiritual man would now become a God-seeing man, he needs must have three other things. The first is the feeling that the foundation of his being is abysmal, and he should possess it in this manner; the second is that his inward exercise should be wayless; the third is that his indwelling should be a divine fruition.
Now understand, you who would live in the spirit, for I am speaking to no one else. The union with God which a spiritual man feels, when the union is revealed to the spirit as being abysmal—that is, measureless depth, measureless height, measureless length and measureless breadth—in this manifestation the spirit perceives that through love it has plunged itself into the depth and has ascended into the height and escaped into the length; and it feels itself to be wandering in the breadth, and to dwell in a knowledge which is ignorance. And through this intimate feeling of union, it feels itself to be melting into the Unity; and, through dying to all things, into the life of God. And there it feels itself to be one life with God. And this is the foundation, and the first point, of the God-seeing life.
And from this there arises the second point, which is an exercise above reason and without condition: for the Divine Unity, of which every God-seeing spirit has entered into possession in love, eternally draws and invites the Divine Persons and all loving spirits into its self. And this inward drawing is felt by each lover, more or less, according to the measure of his love and the manner of his exercise. And whosoever yields himself to this indrawing, and keeps himself therein, cannot fall into mortal sin. But the God-seeing man who has forsaken self and all things, and does not feel himself drawn away because he no longer possesses anything as his own, but stands empty of all, he can always enter, naked and unencumbered with images, into the inmost part of his spirit. There he finds revealed an Eternal Light, and in this light, he feels the eternal demand of the Divine Unity; and he feels himself to be an eternal fire of love, which craves above all else to be one with God. The more he yields to this indrawing or demand, the more he feels it. And the more he feels it, the more he craves to be one with God; for it urges him to pay the debt which is demanded of him by God. This eternal demand of the Divine Unity kindles within the spirit an eternal fire of love; and though the spirit incessantly pays the debt, an eternal burning continues within it. For, in the transformation within the Unity, all spirits fail in their own activity, and feel nothing else but a burning up of themselves in the simple Unity of God. This simple Unity of God none can feel or possess save he who maintains himself in the immeasurable radiance, and in the love which is above reason and wayless. In this transcendent state the spirit feels in itself the eternal fire of love; and in this fire of love it finds neither beginning nor end, and it feels itself one with this fire of love. The spirit for ever continues to burn in itself, for its love is eternal; and it feels itself ever more and more to be burnt up in love, for it is drawn and transformed into the Unity of God, where the spirit burns in love. If it observes itself, it finds a distinction and an otherness between itself and God; but where it is burnt up it is undifferentiated and without distinction, and therefore it feels nothing but unity; for the flame of the Love of God consumes and devours all that it can enfold in its Self.
And thus you may see that the indrawing Unity of God is nought else than the fathomless Love, which lovingly draws inward, in eternal fruition, the Father and the Son and all that lives in Them. And in this Love we shall burn and be burnt up without end, throughout eternity; for herein lies the blessedness of all spirits. And therefore we must all found our lives upon a fathomless abyss; that we may eternally plunge into Love, and sink down in the fathomless Depth. And with that same Love, we shall ascend, and transcend ourselves, in the incomprehensible Height. And in that Love which is wayless, we shall wander and stray, and it shall lead us and lose us in the immeasurable Breadth of the Love of God. And herein we shall flee forth and flee out of ourselves, into the unknown raptures of the Goodness and Riches of God. And therein we shall melt and be melted away, and shall eternally wander and sojourn within the Glory of God. Behold! by each of these images, I show forth to God-seeing men their being and their exercise, but none else can understand them. For the contemplative life cannot be taught. But where the Eternal Truth reveals Itself within the spirit all that is needful is taught and learnt…"
saints.sqpn.com/the-sparkling-stone-by-blessed-jan-van-ruysbroek/***- Blessed John of Ruysbroeck (1293 – 1381), The Sparkling Stone ***
Thanks for the awesome quote and explanation! I really appreciate this as well as the links you provided!Dear Weird,
To use the schema drawn up by St. Teresa of Avila (and mind there are no clear-cut definitions of spiritual states, this would vary between persons) contemplation is broadly divided up into acquired contemplation and infused contemplation and subdivided again within these broad categories into: (1) vocal prayer, (2) meditation, (3) affective prayer, (4) prayer of simplicity, (5) infused contemplation, (6) prayer of quiet, (7) prayer of union, (8) prayer of conforming union, and (9) prayer of transforming union.
Acquired contemplation begins with “affective prayer” and ends at the “infused” stage (5).
Acquired contemplation can be attained through human effort aided by grace.
Infused contemplative prayer, or “the God-seeing life” is the most perfect and it cannot be attained by human effort, rather only God when He finds us ready.
Read:
saints.sqpn.com/the-sparkling-stone-by-blessed-jan-van-ruysbroek/
I am glad that you liked it!Thanks for the awesome quote and explanation! I really appreciate this as well as the links you provided!
If we reflect upon this, I think that we can get a sense of what the God-seeing life of “infused contemplation” is like and thus understand where Meister Eckhart is coming from.The spirit for ever continues to burn in itself, for its love is eternal; and it feels itself ever more and more to be burnt up in love, for it is drawn and transformed into the Unity of God, where the spirit burns in love. If it observes itself, it finds a distinction and an otherness between itself and God; but where it is burnt up it is undifferentiated and without distinction, and therefore it feels nothing but unity; for the flame of the Love of God consumes and devours all that it can enfold in its Self.
“…There follows a third kind of experience, namely, that we feel ourselves to be one with God, for by means of our transformation in God we feel ourselves to be swallowed up in the groundless abyss of our eternal blessedness, in which we can never discover any difference between ourselves and God…When love has carried us above all things, into the Divine Dark, we receive in peace the Incomprehensible Light, enfolding us and penetrating us. What is this Light, if it be not a contemplation of the Infinite, and an intuition of Eternity?..God in the depths of us receives God who comes to us: it is God contemplating God… This brightness is so great that the loving contemplative, in his ground wherein he rests, sees and feels nothing but an incomprehensible Light; and through that Simple Nudity which enfolds all things, he finds himself and feels himself to be that same Light by which he sees and nothing else. This resplendence is nothing other than an act of gazing and seeing which has no ground: What we are is what we see, and what we see is what we are, for our mind, our life, and our very being are raised up in a state of oneness and united with the truth that is God himself. We feel no difference between ourselves and God, for we have been breathed forth in his love above and beyond ourselves and all orders of being…and in this loving and being loved we always feel a difference and a duality: this is the nature of eternal love. And there we find distinction and otherness between God and ourselves, and find God as an Incomprehensible One exterior to us. There in the mystical experience all is full and overflowing, for the spirit feels itself to be one truth and one richness and one unity with God. Yet here there is an essential tending forward, and therein is an essential distinction between the being of the soul and the Being of God; and this is the highest and finest distinction which we are able to feel…”
You can also read this book online but it is REALLY long:***- Blessed Jan Van Ruysbroeck (1294-1381), Flemish Catholic mystic ***
Bless you brother! Your words are very kind. I hope you are keeping well!Vouthon,
As usual, you bring a wealth of knowledge and wisdom to the forum.
Thanks for the links.
Jim