Metropolitan of OCA resigns!

  • Thread starter Thread starter jam070406
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Something important to remember.

The answer should be based on where the truth lies, and not who has the least scandal.
Definitely! Because the Church militant is full of sinners, it is “normal” to see the effects of sin and death happen within the confines of the Church. But the reason we are all in Church is to get better, not because we are saints.
 
I didn’t mean to engage in polemic or insult anybody, I was just answering a question. Sorry if I hit a nerve, I’m new on this forum. I don’t expect Orthodox forum members to agree with me on Petrine primacy…I guess the name ‘Catholic Answers Forum’ made me think *explaining *it here was ok, since I was asked.

I know no ecclesial body is perfect, because they all consist of fallen humans despite being founded by Christ. I love and respect the Eastern Orthodox tradition. I have icons, I pray daily from a Melkite prayer book, and I recognize that both East and West are part of the same validly sacramental body.

I am glad for the explanation about all the different Orthodox Churches recognizing each other as validly sacramental. I wasn’t sure what the ‘autocephaly’ dispute was all about.
 
I didn’t mean to engage in polemic or insult anybody, I was just answering a question. Sorry if I hit a nerve, I’m new on this forum. I don’t expect Orthodox forum members to agree with me on Petrine primacy…I guess the name ‘Catholic Answers Forum’ made me think *explaining *it here was ok, since I was asked.

I know no ecclesial body is perfect, because they all consist of fallen humans despite being founded by Christ. I love and respect the Eastern Orthodox tradition. I have icons, I pray daily from a Melkite prayer book, and I recognize that both East and West are part of the same validly sacramental body.

I am glad for the explanation about all the different Orthodox Churches recognizing each other as validly sacramental. I wasn’t sure what the ‘autocephaly’ dispute was all about.
Petrine Primacy and Supremacy doesn’t even have anything to do with your comment. Fact is, no matter what we believe about the Pope, the Catholic Church has been rocked by similar scandals as the one that has rocked the OCA and other Apostolic Churches. As Catholics we must be fair and honest here, let us not pretend that having the Pope has protected us from petty quarrels among bishops.
 
I liked Metropolitan Jonah. My prayer is that he will be reassigned as bishop to the Diocese of the South…and the Synod of Bishops will elect a worthy and pious bishop to lead the Church.

The OCA will be just fine.
 
Petrine Primacy and Supremacy doesn’t even have anything to do with your comment. Fact is, no matter what we believe about the Pope, the Catholic Church has been rocked by similar scandals as the one that has rocked the OCA and other Apostolic Churches. As Catholics we must be fair and honest here, let us not pretend that having the Pope has protected us from petty quarrels among bishops.
I never SAID that having a Pope has protected the Catholic Church from scandals or petty quarrels among bishops. All I said was that I am glad we have a Pope. Surely as a Roman Catholic I’m allowed to be glad about that.

Can we please let it go and get back to the original topic now?

I understand that *some *people weren’t comfortable with Metropolitan Jonah’s outspokeness on issues like abortion and same sex marriage. Do you guys think that maybe that had something to do with his abrupt resignation?
 
I understand that *some *people weren’t comfortable with Metropolitan Jonah’s outspokeness on issues like abortion and same sex marriage. Do you guys think that maybe that had something to do with his abrupt resignation?
No.
 
I understand that *some *people weren’t comfortable with Metropolitan Jonah’s outspokeness on issues like abortion and same sex marriage. Do you guys think that maybe that had something to do with his abrupt resignation?
No.
 
I understand that *some *people weren’t comfortable with Metropolitan Jonah’s outspokeness on issues like abortion and same sex marriage. Do you guys think that maybe that had something to do with his abrupt resignation?
Hmm …:hmmm: - two quick, short answers.

Mickey, glad to see you weighing in on this. No one can truly wish this kind of turmoil within a Church community, and it pains me to see it from a distance. The little I know of the matters of the OCA leading up to this most recent result suggests there is much more to the story. Perhaps as he has suggested he was the wrong man for the job at such a critical time, yet from what I had seen of him in public strongly suggested he was a man of conviction who spoke well for his Church and Orthodox beliefs, yet also with compassion. His homily at St. John’s (ROCOR) in Mayfield, PA was certainly moving and resonated in many circles, including among your Catholic cousins from the Carpathians. I do appreciate that there may have been some that were not as positively disposed with his ecumenism and his positions on societal issues of current and contemporary importance.

I do hope the next chapter brings stability and harmony in the OCA. We pray for the hierarchs and the faithful.
 
I liked Metropolitan Jonah. My prayer is that he will be reassigned as bishop to the Diocese of the South…and the Synod of Bishops will elect a worthy and pious bishop to lead the Church.

The OCA will be just fine.
I listened to a few of his talks. I liked him too.
 
Hmm …:hmmm: - two quick, short answers.
The answers are quick because there is no evidence that this occurred due to His Beatitude being “too anti-abortion” or too “anti gay marriage.” To make such a statement feeds into a rumour mill. I have to take the Metropolitan at his word. He was an abbot of a monastery. That does not always translate to Leading Hierarch and administrator of the Orthodox Church in America. He was made bishop and then Metropolitan within a two week period after a lengthy financial scandal. That is a lot of pressure.

Are there liberal factions within the OCA? I am certain that there are. Did they conspire to force His Beatitude to resign? I think that is a reach. As I said…the OCA will be fine. The gates of hell will not prevail.
 
I liked Metropolitan Jonah. My prayer is that he will be reassigned as bishop to the Diocese of the South…and the Synod of Bishops will elect a worthy and pious bishop to lead the Church.

The OCA will be just fine.
Diocese of the South would probably be a great fit for him since he spent so much time in the area, but there seem to be quite a few vacancies at the moment.
 
The answers are quick because there is no evidence …
I didn’t think so, yet from everything an outsider can read about this (even with an extreme amount of skepticism), it seems like a holy man was chosen, but one who otherwise met resistence in many forms as relates to the administration of the Church. One cannot even be so sure as to how accurate that may be, but surely Metropolitan Jonah felt he was in a no win situation.

Again, we pray for the OCA and those now most responsible for the care of this Church and its faithful!
 
I didn’t think so, yet from everything an outsider can read about this (even with an extreme amount of skepticism), it seems like a holy man was chosen, but one who otherwise met resistence in many forms as relates to the administration of the Church. One cannot even be so sure as to how accurate that may be, but surely Metropolitan Jonah felt he was in a no win situation.

Again, we pray for the OCA and those now most responsible for the care of this Church and its faithful!
There is no doubt he met resistance…from the evil one.

Prayers are appreciated.🙂
 
I didn’t think so, yet from everything an outsider can read about this (even with an extreme amount of skepticism), it seems like a holy man was chosen, but one who otherwise met resistence in many forms as relates to the administration of the Church. One cannot even be so sure as to how accurate that may be, but surely Metropolitan Jonah felt he was in a no win situation.

Again, we pray for the OCA and those now most responsible for the care of this Church and its faithful!
My own impression is that he is a good and holy man, very knowledgeable, and someone worthy of the role which he took.

However he may not have been what was needed at this time.
 
The OCA should just join the Catholic Church

Makes it easy for me 😃
 
There is no doubt he met resistance…from the evil one.

Prayers are appreciated.🙂
We all need to be praying for these our brothers, and sisters in the OCA. I do believe the evil one is creating dangerous times for some in Orthodoxy in America at this time. I have spent almost as much time in OCA parishes, one in particular, as in my own ECC parish. The news and events of the past days, both nationally and another separate, but in the end probably related very troubling situation, have me deeply saddened and disturbed. The lack of transparency saddens me. It has left much room for speculation, and I suspect allowed some of the back story to go on which contributes to the actions this past week.

The evil one is not only attacking the OCA. We have just been rocked by the arrest of a local Orthodox priest, not OCA, in the past couple of weeks. I’ve spent time with him at many Orthodox events. The pain is tremendous to all of us who know him, know his parishioners and who just plain never want to see this happen again anywhere. I was reeling from that when the OCA news began to come in. Please also pray for those involved in this situation.

I know it is somewhat “codependent” of me but I don’t think CAF forum is at all a safe place to be airing what is going on in this even though pieces of information are available elsewhere on line for people to see. All who have posted here so far are Orthodox or lovers of Orthodoxy, but many here are not. We need to be praying for all involved. I’m doing a lot of praying, along with crying…
 
The evil one is not only attacking the OCA. We have just been rocked by the arrest of a local Orthodox priest, not OCA, in the past couple of weeks. I’ve spent time with him at many Orthodox events. The pain is tremendous to all of us who know him, know his parishioners and who just plain never want to see this happen again anywhere. I was reeling from that when the OCA news began to come in. Please also pray for those involved in this situation.
Amen. I knew a priest (Catholic) personally who I later found out had been a molester and was eventually removed from his ministry. It really rocked me. Some of the scandal stories actually pushed me away from the Church for a while. Of course this is what Satan wants.

One day I was thinking about it though, and three words just sort of popped into my head. ‘Jesus chose Judas.’ It was like a light switch had been turned on, and I understood: The Church has always had corruption, even from its inception, but that’s no reason to discount Her teachings or Sacraments. Like someone said in an earlier post, the gates of Hell will not prevail. 👍
 
Amen. I knew a priest (Catholic) personally who I later found out had been a molester and was eventually removed from his ministry. It really rocked me. Some of the scandal stories actually pushed me away from the Church for a while. Of course this is what Satan wants.

One day I was thinking about it though, and three words just sort of popped into my head. ‘Jesus chose Judas.’ It was like a light switch had been turned on, and I understood: The Church has always had corruption, even from its inception, but that’s no reason to discount Her teachings or Sacraments. Like someone said in an earlier post, the gates of Hell will not prevail. 👍
The Church is perfect, the people in it are not. We should remember that distinction 😉
 
It’s a bit of a shame that there has been so little willingness, here, to discuss the situation in the OCA; there is so much to learn from what is going on. Much more than in almost any of the threads that go on and on.

I fully agree with Mickey’s adamant conclusion. But one should also ask why so much bandwidth (eg at Monomakhos (monomakhos.com), and from Rod Dreher among others) is being spent to spin these events as a culture war coup d’etat.

Perhaps this time is also a good moment to reconsider the thinking of those who, with such enthusiasm, put someone of so little experience in such a position.
 
It is difficult to discuss this because we know so little of the situation. Some comments you will read online signal this as the beginning of the end of the OCA, while others will say this is an incredible act of charity and humility by Met. Jonah. And of course the long list of positions in between. Who’s telling the truth? We don’t have the facts here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top