J
JohnVIII
Guest
The Miaphysite position is held by Oriental Orthodox such as the Coptic Orthodox Church. They confess that our Lord Jesus is both true man and true God, just as do both Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches do, except only that the divine and the human nature is but ONE nature in Christ. Those holding to the Miaphysite view are called “non-Chalcedonians” because they seem to be in disagreement with the 4th Ecumenical Council (The Council of Chalcedon). Never-the-less …
It is evident that both the Chalcedonians and non-Chalcedonians agree on the following points:
1- They all condemn and anathematize Nestorius, Apollinarius and Eutyches.
2- The unity of the divinity and humanity of Christ was realized from the moment of His conception, without separation or division and also without confusing or changing.
3- The manhood of Christ was real, perfect and had a dynamic presence.
4- Jesus Christ is one Hypostasis in real oneness and not mere conjunction of natures; He is the Incarnate Logos of God.
Furthermore … The idea that Christ has but one nature that is a nature that is both human and divine comes from Saint Cyril of Alexandria who said “one [Mia] incarnate nature [Physis] of God the Word”. The Cyrillian formula was accepted by the Council of Ephesus in 431. It was neither nullified nor condemned at Chalcedon. On the contrary, it continued to be considered an orthodox formula.
The whole controversy in the East about the Monothelitism heresy (Christ has one will rather than two wills) in the 7th century was mainly an effort to unify the split caused by the Miaphysite tradition. Here then is a problem: If you hold to the Miaphysite tradition you must also hold the Monothelitism heresy! That is, if you confess that Jesus has one nature, he must also have but one will! Nevertheless, many say that the Miaphysite view is actually orthodox because it is really not a different view but merely a different expression of the same view. (Copts are permitted to commune in Roman Catholic Churches!)
The Coptic Orthodox Church says that their Miaphysite tradition has ALWAYS been that teaching of the Church since the apostles. Is it orthodox or is it heterodox?
It is evident that both the Chalcedonians and non-Chalcedonians agree on the following points:
1- They all condemn and anathematize Nestorius, Apollinarius and Eutyches.
2- The unity of the divinity and humanity of Christ was realized from the moment of His conception, without separation or division and also without confusing or changing.
3- The manhood of Christ was real, perfect and had a dynamic presence.
4- Jesus Christ is one Hypostasis in real oneness and not mere conjunction of natures; He is the Incarnate Logos of God.
Furthermore … The idea that Christ has but one nature that is a nature that is both human and divine comes from Saint Cyril of Alexandria who said “one [Mia] incarnate nature [Physis] of God the Word”. The Cyrillian formula was accepted by the Council of Ephesus in 431. It was neither nullified nor condemned at Chalcedon. On the contrary, it continued to be considered an orthodox formula.
The whole controversy in the East about the Monothelitism heresy (Christ has one will rather than two wills) in the 7th century was mainly an effort to unify the split caused by the Miaphysite tradition. Here then is a problem: If you hold to the Miaphysite tradition you must also hold the Monothelitism heresy! That is, if you confess that Jesus has one nature, he must also have but one will! Nevertheless, many say that the Miaphysite view is actually orthodox because it is really not a different view but merely a different expression of the same view. (Copts are permitted to commune in Roman Catholic Churches!)
The Coptic Orthodox Church says that their Miaphysite tradition has ALWAYS been that teaching of the Church since the apostles. Is it orthodox or is it heterodox?