Miaphysite - orthodox or heterodox?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JohnVIII
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
J

JohnVIII

Guest
The Miaphysite position is held by Oriental Orthodox such as the Coptic Orthodox Church. They confess that our Lord Jesus is both true man and true God, just as do both Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches do, except only that the divine and the human nature is but ONE nature in Christ. Those holding to the Miaphysite view are called “non-Chalcedonians” because they seem to be in disagreement with the 4th Ecumenical Council (The Council of Chalcedon). Never-the-less …

It is evident that both the Chalcedonians and non-Chalcedonians agree on the following points:

1- They all condemn and anathematize Nestorius, Apollinarius and Eutyches.
2- The unity of the divinity and humanity of Christ was realized from the moment of His conception, without separation or division and also without confusing or changing.
3- The manhood of Christ was real, perfect and had a dynamic presence.
4- Jesus Christ is one Hypostasis in real oneness and not mere conjunction of natures; He is the Incarnate Logos of God.

Furthermore … The idea that Christ has but one nature that is a nature that is both human and divine comes from Saint Cyril of Alexandria who said “one [Mia] incarnate nature [Physis] of God the Word”. The Cyrillian formula was accepted by the Council of Ephesus in 431. It was neither nullified nor condemned at Chalcedon. On the contrary, it continued to be considered an orthodox formula.

The whole controversy in the East about the Monothelitism heresy (Christ has one will rather than two wills) in the 7th century was mainly an effort to unify the split caused by the Miaphysite tradition. Here then is a problem: If you hold to the Miaphysite tradition you must also hold the Monothelitism heresy! That is, if you confess that Jesus has one nature, he must also have but one will! Nevertheless, many say that the Miaphysite view is actually orthodox because it is really not a different view but merely a different expression of the same view. (Copts are permitted to commune in Roman Catholic Churches!)

The Coptic Orthodox Church says that their Miaphysite tradition has ALWAYS been that teaching of the Church since the apostles. Is it orthodox or is it heterodox?
 
The Miaphysite position is held by Oriental Orthodox such as the Coptic Orthodox Church. They confess that our Lord Jesus is both true man and true God, just as do both Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches do, except only that the divine and the human nature is but ONE nature in Christ. Those holding to the Miaphysite view are called “non-Chalcedonians” because they seem to be in disagreement with the 4th Ecumenical Council (The Council of Chalcedon). Never-the-less …

It is evident that both the Chalcedonians and non-Chalcedonians agree on the following points:

1- They all condemn and anathematize Nestorius, Apollinarius and Eutyches.
2- The unity of the divinity and humanity of Christ was realized from the moment of His conception, without separation or division and also without confusing or changing.
3- The manhood of Christ was real, perfect and had a dynamic presence.
4- Jesus Christ is one Hypostasis in real oneness and not mere conjunction of natures; He is the Incarnate Logos of God.

Furthermore … The idea that Christ has but one nature that is a nature that is both human and divine comes from Saint Cyril of Alexandria who said “one [Mia] incarnate nature [Physis] of God the Word”. The Cyrillian formula was accepted by the Council of Ephesus in 431. It was neither nullified nor condemned at Chalcedon. On the contrary, it continued to be considered an orthodox formula.

The whole controversy in the East about the Monothelitism heresy (Christ has one will rather than two wills) in the 7th century was mainly an effort to unify the split caused by the Miaphysite tradition. Here then is a problem: If you hold to the Miaphysite tradition you must also hold the Monothelitism heresy! That is, if you confess that Jesus has one nature, he must also have but one will! Nevertheless, many say that the Miaphysite view is actually orthodox because it is really not a different view but merely a different expression of the same view. (Copts are permitted to commune in Roman Catholic Churches!)

The Coptic Orthodox Church says that their Miaphysite tradition has ALWAYS been that teaching of the Church since the apostles. Is it orthodox or is it heterodox?
The Oriental Orthodox position has been officially accepted as orthodox by the Catholic Church. This has occured in numerous joint-Christological declarations. For the Catholic Church, at least, the doctrinal question has been put to rest; what remains is ecclesiological in nature. 🙂

Peace and God bless!
 
This is interesting; first time I’ve heard of it. So I have a question: Do Miaphysites say that the (human) nature of Christ died on the Cross? If so, do they say the (divine) nature died as well? Do they separate the nature from the Person of God, as do Catholics?
 
The Oriental Orthodox position has been officially accepted as orthodox by the Catholic Church. This has occured in numerous joint-Christological declarations. For the Catholic Church, at least, the doctrinal question has been put to rest; what remains is ecclesiological in nature.
For Catholics, can there be more than one view on a doctrinal issue and both views be orthodox? Miaphysites also believe Jesus has one will. Is it orthodox to believe Christ has one will and also orthodox as well to believe that Christ has two wills? Maybe Pope Honorius was orthodox after all. Perhaps St. Maximos the Confessor wasted his efforts since his view was just one of at least two views that were both equally orthodox.

Perhaps I’m too much of a fundamentalist. I think it is possible that the Miaphysite view is the correct one; however, for me this means that the 4th Ecumenical Council made an error. To the Orthodox it is unthinkable that the 4th Ecumenical Council made an error; and for a Roman Catholic I would think this to be unthinkable as well since the 4th Ecumenical Council was presided over by Pope Leo the Great who probably spoke infallibly!

The various patriarchs of Constantinople in the 7th century who were condemned with teaching Monothelitism and condemned as Monophysite heretics (but who were actually Miaphysites) were actually doing a good work as they sought after UNITY among all the ancient Christian Churches. But with the advent of the 4th Ecumenical Council unity was replaced by division. This also resulted it the martyrdom of many Egyptian Christians! I say that the 4th Ecumenical Council was in error! If I am right, I unfortunately don’t have a solution. It is hard for anyone to convince a Roman Catholic that the Pope is not infallible; but what is even harder than this is to convince an Orthodox Christian that an Ecumenical Council is not infallible - much, much harder! 🤷
 
I’ve never heard that the Miaphysites embrace monothelitism, at least as it’s defined as a heresy. It’s quite likely that, if anything, they would be “miathelites”, which is the same position as the Chalcedonian Churches (that the two wills were united to one end, not opposed). Miaphysites do NOT believe that Christ had only one nature, but rather that Christ’s two natures were united into one Person (hence mia, which means unity, rather than mono), so it’s possible that they believe that the Divine and human wills of Christ are united, just as the natures themselves are.

Incidentally, Pope Honorius was actually speaking of this notion (miathelitism), and not true monothelitism (that only the Divine operations remain in Christ, with the human drive utterly removed or absent). He was condemned for allowing the monothelites to continue, not because he held a view identical to theirs. He wasn’t very theologically competant, unfortunately, and didn’t understand the monothelite position, as is clear in his writings because he referred only to Christ not having “two wills” in the sense that our human will is often divided against itself (“I do what I hate”).

Peace and God bless!
 
This is interesting; first time I’ve heard of it. So I have a question: Do Miaphysites say that the (human) nature of Christ died on the Cross? If so, do they say the (divine) nature died as well? Do they separate the nature from the Person of God, as do Catholics?
Their Christology is utterly identical to Catholics, they simply use the terminology of St. Cyril of Alexandria, as opposed to that of the “Antiochian School” which dominated Chalcedon (two different theological approaches, using terms slightly differently). Where the Antiochian School put a primacy on emphasizing the distinction of natures, the Alexandrian School emphasized the unity of Person (much the way we emphasize the unity of human Persons, despite being composed of a dual-nature of sorts, the spiritual and physical).

The Alexandrian School was the one which defeated Nestorianism, because its terminology made it quite clear that Christ was one Person and not two, but the language and approach made it easier for Monophysitism to appear orthodox (at first) for them. They actually condemned Monophysitism shortly after Chalcedon, entirely on their own, but they still viewed Chalcedon as a robber council that gave too much leeway for Nestorians (and, indeed, many Nestorians and quasi-Nestorians viewed Chalcedon as their vindication, until they realized that the core dogma hadn’t changed). After all, the emphasis on distinguishing the natures (Christ’s human nature died on the Cross, not the Divine Nature, for example) makes it very easy to move towards Nestorianism (God turned away from Christ on the Cross, hence “why have you forsaken me”; this view is upheld by many Protestants today).

In short, a Miaphysite might say “Christ, who is both Divine and Human, died on the Cross”, rather than “Christ, in His human nature, died on the Cross”. In the former, the distinction and properties of the two natures are assumed to be understood, in the latter the unity of Person is assumed to be understood. In both cases there is potential for misunderstanding, which is why no language is truly adequate to speak of such matters.

Peace and God bless!
 
Miaphysites do NOT believe that Christ had only one nature, but rather that Christ’s two natures were united into one Person (hence mia, which means unity, rather than mono), !
Hmm. I can’t see how this is any different from the position of the CC, or of any orthodox believers. 🤷 Is it different? :confused:
 
Hmm. I can’t see how this is any different from the position of the CC, or of any orthodox believers. 🤷 Is it different? :confused:
It’s not, hence the joint-Christological agreements. In the eyes of the Catholic Church, the Oriental Orthodox are entirely orthodox. 🙂

Peace and God bless!
 
The Miaphysite faith is not identical with the orthodox faith; “identical” is not the right word. Perhaps it could be said that in essence there is no essential difference. The prefix “Mia” in Miaphysite does mean “one”, but is not one that has always been one but one that has come to be one from two. The two natures, human and divine, have been made into one nature in the person of Christ - this is the Miaphysite faith. The orthodox faith, on the other hand, is that the two natures, human and divine, remain to separate natures in the one person of Christ.

It is true that the Roman Catholic Church accepts those who embrace the Miaphysite faith. But it is not true that the Miaphysite position is identical with either Roman Catholic or Orthodox; but perhaps it could be said that it is the same on the essentials of the faith - of course we may not all agree on what the essentials of the faith are! I wish someone who embraces this faith could make a posting here and explain the differences. Here is a paragraph that a man of the Coptic Faith posted on an Orthodox forum on March 10, 1994 - consider this:
Ever since the fifth century, we have used different formulae to confess our common faith in the One Lord Jesus Christ, perfect God and perfect Man. Some of us affirm two natures, wills and energies hypostatically united in the One Lord Jesus Christ. Some of us affirm one united divine-human nature, will and energy in the same Christ. But both sides speak of a union without confusion, without change, without division, without separation. The four adverbs belong to our common tradition. Both affirm the dynamic permanence of the God-head and the Manhood, with all their natural properties and faculties, in the one Christ. Those who speak in terms of “two” do not thereby divide or separate. Those who speak in terms of “one” do not thereby commingle or confuse.
The Fourth Ecumenical Council - the Council of Chalcedon, presided over by St. Pope Leo the Great clearly did not speak of “one united divine-human nature, will and energy in the same Christ”; but perhaps it can be interpreted that the Council did not specifically condemn that teaching either. I am not qualified to say for sure, that is why I posed the question “Miaphysite - orthodox or heterodox?”. It simply is not accurate to say that the Miaphysite and non-Miaphysite faith is “identical”! As I have already stated, I believe the Miaphysite view is the correct one - now, since the Roman Catholic Church is required to accept this view is orthodox I suppose no one here is going to call me a heretic, but perhaps some Orthodox may not be so charitable. There is one Orthodox jurisdiction that has taken steps to accept the Miaphysite faith as essentially orthodox in a way similar to the way the Roman Catholic Church has done so. That Orthodox jurisdiction happens to be the one that I belong to, namely the Antiochian Orthodox Church.
 
Their Christology is utterly identical to Catholics, they simply use the terminology of St. Cyril of Alexandria
Dear brother Ghosty:

I would love to hear from you a clarification. Some time ago you made the assertion that the Catholic Church does NOT teach that the divine and human are united at the level of nature, now you say “their Christology is utterly identical to Catholics”. You said:

[post]4205418[/post]
… Instead we have the Divine Essence, and the human nature, not united and mingled on the level of nature, but in the Person of Christ. If they were mingled and merged we would have to confess something similar to the Monothelites or the Monophysites, and we do not.
The thread back then was the issue of the filioque. I stated back then that I could not accept the filioque a because the divine and human nature are in union with each other therefore the Holy Spirit would have to acquire both the divine and the human nature of Christ if indeed the Holy Spirit proceeded eternally through the Son. I stated at:

[post]4221518[/post]
If the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Son, or through the Son, but only through the divine nature of the Son, then this divides the unity of the divine and human nature of Christ.
Since it is evident that the Holy Spirit has only a divine nature and not a human nature, it is clear that those who hold to the Miaphysite Christology cannot rightly confess the filioque either! :yup:

In Chist,
-John VIII
 
JohnVIII: This is the text of the prayer said at the end of every Coptic Divine Liturgy:
Amen. Amen. Amen. I believe, I believe, I believe and confess to the last breath, that this is the life-giving body that your only-begotten Son, our Lord, God and Saviour Jesus Christ took from our lady, the lady of us all, the holy Theotokos Saint May. He made it one with his divinity without mingling, without confusion and without alteration. He witnessed the good confession before Pontius Pilate. He gave it up for us upon the holy wood of the cross, of his own will, for us all. Truly I believe that his divinity parted not from his humanity for a single moment nor a twinkling of an eye. Given for us for salvation, remission of sins and eternal life to those who partake of him. I believe, I believe, I believe that this is so in truth. Amen.
They do not believe, nor have they ever believed, that Christ’s humanity and Divinity ever “became one” on the level of nature, only on the level of Person (the orthodox belief). It’s also clear, given that they say there was “no alteration”, that they don’t subscribe to the Monothelite heresy. There is no difference in Christology between our Churches.

The Eastern Orthodox have yet to resolve this issue with the Oriental Orthodox, but the Catholic Church and the Oriental Orthodox have officially and formally done so.

Peace and God bless!
 
They do not believe, nor have they ever believed, that Christ’s humanity and Divinity ever “became one” on the level of nature, only on the level of Person (the orthodox belief).
Dear Ghosty:

You’re a very informed individual and in the past you have corrected me on several points that I was very much mistaken about, but now it seems it’s my turn to make the correction. Not only does the Coptic Orthodox Church now believe but they say that they have always believed that Christ’s humanity and Divinity became one on the level of nature. In fact they teach that it had to be thus in order for Christ to bring about our salvation! Here’s another quote from a Coptic information website:

gotquestions.org/Coptic-Christianity.html
Prior to the “great” East/West schism of AD 1054, the Coptics were separated from the rest by the Council of Chalcedon in AD 451. The council met to discuss the Incarnation of Christ and declared that Christ was “one hypostasis in two natures” (i.e., one person who shares two distinct natures). This became standard orthodoxy for Eastern Orthodox, Roman Catholic, and Protestant churches from then on. The Coptic understanding is that Christ is one nature from two natures: “the Logos Incarnate.” In this understanding, Christ is from, not in, two natures: full humanity and full divinity. Some in the Coptic Orthodox Church believe that their position was misunderstood at the Council of Chalcedon and take great pains to ensure that they are not monophysite (denying the two natures of Christ), but rather “miaphysite” (one composite/conjoined nature from two). Some believe that perhaps the Council understood the Church correctly, but wanted to exile the Church for its refusal to take part in politics or due to the rivalry between the Bishops of Alexandria and Rome. To this day 95% of Christians in Alexandria are members of the Coptic Orthodox Church.
Peace in Christ 😉
-JohnVIII
 
To your original question:
  1. From the point of view of Catholic and (eastern) Orthodox Christians, the view is heterodox because it is contrary to the received teaching of the Council of Chalcedon.
  2. Of course, from the point of view of Oriental Orthodox Christians (which includes the Coptics you note) the view is orthodox.
  3. The fact that the Oriental Orthodox and Catholic Christian communities have resolved or agreed on certain Christological definitions is helpful, but does not restore full communion.
Cheers
 
Dear Ghosty:

You’re a very informed individual and in the past you have corrected me on several points that I was very much mistaken about, but now it seems it’s my turn to make the correction. Not only does the Coptic Orthodox Church now believe but they say that they have always believed that Christ’s humanity and Divinity became one on the level of nature. In fact they teach that it had to be thus in order for Christ to bring about our salvation! Here’s another quote from a Coptic information website:

gotquestions.org/Coptic-Christianity.html

Peace in Christ 😉
-JohnVIII
That’s not a Coptic website, but a general “Bible Based” question-answer website. Given their statements, I can only assume it is Protestant:

gotquestions.org/about.html

Here is some information from an actual Coptic website:

coptic.net/articles/MonophysitismReconsidered.txt

When Oriental Orthodox speak of “one nature”, they are simply using St. Cyril of Alexandria’s formula “one Incarnate Nature of Christ” (which was his formula against Nestorius, accepted at the Third Ecumenical Council), referring to the unity between the Divine and Human natures. They are not referring to any alteration of either nature, and they believe that Christ possesses both in their fullness.

An easy illustration of this use of terminology can be seen when we say we have a spiritual nature (our soul), and a physical nature, as human beings. The two natures are not united so as to become a new, third nature (as if it was something of an in-between nature, or something entirely different from both), but the unity of these two natures is itself referred to as “human nature”. This is similar to what Oriental Orthodox mean when they say “one Incarnate Nature”; it’s referring to the unique property of the Incarnation, being one Divine Person with a full human and Divine nature.

Peace and God bless!
 
The current Pope of the Coptic Church, Pope Shenouda III, wrote a book called “The Nature of Christ”. Here’s a paragraph from this book:
St. Cyril the Great taught us not to talk about two natures after their unity. So we can say that the Divine nature united hypostatically with the human nature within the Virgin’s womb, but after this unity we do not ever speak again about two natures of Christ. In fact, the expression “two natures” implies in itself division or separation, and although those who believe in “the two natures” admit unity, the tone of separation was obvious in the Council of Chalcedon - a matter which prompted us to reject the Council and caused the exile of St. Dioscorus of Alexandria.
Without accepting the premise that the non-Chalcedonian view is not the same as the Chalcedonian view we are never going to get anywhere in this thread. Perhaps the Roman Pope somewhere said the two views are identical, so now, I suppose, Catholics are honorbound to believe that this is true without question. I am not Roman Catholic, and as such not just going to blindly accept anything the Roman Pope says. I was once in a religion in which I believed without question anything the leader said; that religion was the Mormon Church. Try to tell a Mormon that Brigham Young used to teach that Adam was God and he will deny it no matter how much evidence you present to the contrary.

I have sort of a dilemma here. I feel I may have to reject The Fourth Ecumenical Council. Just saying “believe what the pope said” will not do it for me. But we got a little bit further on the Catholic forum then on an Orthodox forum. On an Orthodox forum I wasn’t even given the time of day!

Best wishes,
-JohnVIII
 
Again, Pope Shenouda III is refering to St. Cyril’s terminology which was accepted at the Third Council, and has been jointly-agreed upon by both the Oriental Orthodox and the Catholic Church. You can’t accept the Miaphysite view without accepting the Catholic view as well.

The reason that you didn’t get far on an Orthodox Forum is because there is no official agreement between the Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox, while there is between the Oriental Orthodox and the Catholics. If anything you’re simply stating that the Eastern Orthodox are wrong to reject the Oriental Orthodox, and any Catholic should agree with you on this point. There is no way to reconcile a rejection of the Catholic view while holding to the Oriental Orthodox view, however, unless you also reject the Oriental Orthodox and their joint-statements with the Catholic Church.

Perhaps you’re merely encountering the introverted and closed-minded approach of some Eastern Orthodox, and you’re reading that understanding on to all dialogues between Chalcedonians and non-Chalcedonians? This is, IMO, one of the most poingent examples of Eastern Orthodox intrasigence, in the most negative sense.

Peace and God bless!
The current Pope of the Coptic Church, Pope Shenouda III, wrote a book called “The Nature of Christ”. Here’s a paragraph from this book:

Without accepting the premise that the non-Chalcedonian view is not the same as the Chalcedonian view we are never going to get anywhere in this thread. Perhaps the Roman Pope somewhere said the two views are identical, so now, I suppose, Catholics are honorbound to believe that this is true without question. I am not Roman Catholic, and as such not just going to blindly accept anything the Roman Pope says. I was once in a religion in which I believed without question anything the leader said; that religion was the Mormon Church. Try to tell a Mormon that Brigham Young used to teach that Adam was God and he will deny it no matter how much evidence you present to the contrary.

I have sort of a dilemma here. I feel I may have to reject The Fourth Ecumenical Council. Just saying “believe what the pope said” will not do it for me. But we got a little bit further on the Catholic forum then on an Orthodox forum. On an Orthodox forum I wasn’t even given the time of day!

Best wishes,
-JohnVIII
 
The Oriental Orthodox position has been officially accepted as orthodox by the Catholic Church. This has occured in numerous joint-Christological declarations. For the Catholic Church, at least, the doctrinal question has been put to rest; what remains is ecclesiological in nature. 🙂

Peace and God bless!
Hello Ghosty. Good to see you again.

Does this basically put them in the same position, vis-a-vis Catholicism, as the “Eastern” Orthodox churches?

salaam.
 
Hello Ghosty. Good to see you again.

Does this basically put them in the same position, vis-a-vis Catholicism, as the “Eastern” Orthodox churches?

salaam.
Yep, and in fact they are closer in some respects. The Syriac and Armenian Churches, for example, have official policies and agreements with the Catholic Churches to share the Sacraments with the members of their corresponding Churches, and visa versa. On a less official level there has even been concelebration between Catholics and Oriental Orthodox, including at a number of Liturgies I’ve attended (with the Bishop presiding at one).

Peace and God bless!
 
This is interesting; first time I’ve heard of it. So I have a question: Do Miaphysites say that the (human) nature of Christ died on the Cross? If so, do they say the (divine) nature died as well? Do they separate the nature from the Person of God, as do Catholics?
A common statement of the Miaphysites is that ‘one of the Trinity died on the cross’. What they mean by that is that God the Son died on the cross. This was one of their major problems with Nestorius and some of the Chalcedonians. The Nestorians and Nestorian minded Chalcedonians like Theodoret refused to profess that one of the Trinity died on the cross. The Miaphysites tend to focus on the unity of Christ.
I’ve never heard that the Miaphysites embrace monothelitism, at least as it’s defined as a heresy. It’s quite likely that, if anything, they would be “miathelites”, which is the same position as the Chalcedonian Churches (that the two wills were united to one end, not opposed). Miaphysites do NOT believe that Christ had only one nature, but rather that Christ’s two natures were united into one Person (hence mia, which means unity, rather than mono), so it’s possible that they believe that the Divine and human wills of Christ are united, just as the natures themselves are.
Seveus of Antioch spoke of there being one energy. The monothelitism tends to go with this monoenergism. When the ekthesis was promulgated by Heraclius and it was accepted by both miaphysite and Chalcedonian bishops some of the miaphysites said ‘we have not communed with the two natures doctrine of the Chalcedonians but rather they with us’ (paraphrase) The point is that even though the Chalcedonians spoke of two wills the miaphysites viewed them as having changed their minds with the ekthesis. You are probably right though about it being ‘miathelitism’ rather than monothelitism though.
Their Christology is utterly identical to Catholics, they simply use the terminology of St. Cyril of Alexandria, as opposed to that of the “Antiochian School” which dominated Chalcedon (two different theological approaches, using terms slightly differently). Where the Antiochian School put a primacy on emphasizing the distinction of natures, the Alexandrian School emphasized the unity of Person (much the way we emphasize the unity of human Persons, despite being composed of a dual-nature of sorts, the spiritual and physical).
The miaphysites focus on unity to the point of saying that there is one hypostasis, one nature, and one person. Hypostasis and nature are pretty much synonymous in their view. After the union there can be no division into two. The hypostasis in Christ is that of the Son of God and it took on human nature or a human hypostasis but this nature does not constitute a second nature in Christ.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top