Michelle Arnold says God did not create hell

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rogerteder
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
R

Rogerteder

Guest
Her words:

Q
If God created everything, then didn’t he create hell, too? If he created hell, then is hell good, since everything God created was good?
”
A:

“Hell is primarily an eternal state of separation between God and those creatures—angels and humans—who have permanently chosen to reject him. God created free will, which is good, but hell is the result of the abuse of free will. God did not create hell; he only allowed for its possibility. Thus it cannot be said that hell is good.” Arnold

Thoughts???
 
Hell is a real place and God had to have created it because He creates all. To say that He didn’t create it is confusing.

Hell began when Lucifer (Satan) and other angels fell from heaven. You can see this here:
Then he shall say to them also that shall be on his left hand: Depart from me, you cursed, into everlasting fire, which was prepared for the devil and his angels.–Matthew 25:41
Hell is an eternal place of suffering and fire. Just because God created good does not mean that He is not a just God who delivers just punishment.
 
Hell is created by absence, of God’s love and indwelling. This absence is the choice that one third of angels made, or we make, to reject the goodness and love and indwelling of God. God can’t create His absence! I suppose we have this situation to some degree in extreme despair, where someone is unable to absorb even what is most kindly and lovingly offered.

When Peter, for instance, realized what a terrible thing he did in abandoning Jesus and ever denying Him to others, it wasn’t an insignificant sin, in fact Jesus had said, “if you deny me before men I will deny you before my Father in heaven.”

Peter did just that. He was never going to get back that moment to stand by the Cross as his friend and Lord hung dying. He could have despaired, like Judas who’d betrayed this wonderful Man whose love and miracles had been their daily fare for at least two years. Judas rejected all possiblity of forgiveness and restitutiona nd couldn’t believe or accept the love of one who had proved Himself to be Love.

Both men were traitors, but Peter chose to accept forgiveness, to welcome and proclaim love.

Devils are devils because they were glorious angels, glorious only because of God’s life and love and goodness within…they rejected It, for their own ends. So they lost the beauty and the wonder and the love and the goodness, and like an animal who lies dead on the grass, they are empty of Life, but the angels now ugly and horrible and evil without God indwelling still have existence as like us they were given eternal spirits.

Does that help?

If I am a house full of light, but I make a final choice to extiguish the love/light within forever by choosing to live without light, then I remain, but I remain in eternal darkness. The Light didn’t make this choice. It gave me light. It was I who made darkness.
 
Hell is created by absence, of God’s love and indwelling. This absence is the choice that one third of angels made, or we make, to reject the goodness and love and indwelling of God. God can’t create His absence!
Excellent.
 
40.png
Trishie:
Hell is created by absence, of God’s love and indwelling. This absence is the choice that one third of angels made, or we make, to reject the goodness and love and indwelling of God. God can’t create His absence! I suppose we have this situation to some degree in extreme despair, where someone is unable to absorb even what is most kindly and lovingly offered.
God can’t create His own absence, but to a traditionalist, He sure can create a place of punishment.

As for Aquinas, I think he believes it is a corporeal fire that punishes,
Thomas Aquinas:
I answer that, Given that the fire of hell is not so called metaphorically, nor an imaginary fire, but a real corporeal fire, we must needs say that the soul will suffer punishment from a corporeal fire, since our Lord said (Mat. 25:41) that this fire was prepared for the devil and his angels, who are incorporeal even as the soul.
Whether the separated soul can suffer from a bodily fire?

Also:

Whether Hell will be corporeal?

Hope these help,

God Bless.

Chris.
 
So God created/allowed (hard to properly word here) the possibility of hell, not the place because nothing like that can come from HIM?
 
I would go the direct opposite route and say that Hell is good because it is where God’s wrath is poured out and the unjust receive their punishment. Hell, like Heaven, is a corporeal manifestation of God’s justice and judgment. Such is truth and truth can only be good.

As for whether or not God created Hell, that is another matter. God cannot create separation from Himself; people do that although God does indeed allow people to do that and so in that sense, He bears a certain responsibility for its existence. Why it would be a “bad” or “contradictory” thing for God to have created Hell, I do not know.
 
I would go the direct opposite route and say that Hell is good because it is where God’s wrath is poured out and the unjust receive their punishment. Hell, like Heaven, is a corporeal manifestation of God’s justice and judgment. Such is truth and truth can only be good.

As for whether or not God created Hell, that is another matter. God cannot create separation from Himself; people do that although God does indeed allow people to do that and so in that sense, He bears a certain responsibility for its existence. Why it would be a “bad” or “contradictory” thing for God to have created Hell, I do not know.
I was thinking the same thing. Could hell be considered good because the unjust are punished? Also, the verse says (mentioned above) the “fire prepared for the devil and his angels.” Doesnt that imply God prepared it for them?
 
I was thinking the same thing. Could hell be considered good because the unjust are punished? Also, the verse says (mentioned above) the “fire prepared for the devil and his angels.” Doesnt that imply God prepared it for them?
It depends on how you look at it, but it could be argued that Satan’s choice created a set of circumstances whereby the environment of hell (separation from God) took form, or that God simply turned His back on Satan, “creating” hell simply by withdrawing His presence (“uncreating”?) and love. The “fire prepared for the devil and his angels” doesn’t necessarily require direct action on the part of God. Once a series of events are set in motion, there is a logical result–i.e. falling line of dominoes.

I think it’s also important for people to remember that Christ’s sacrifce gives us the option of seeking grace and forgiveness when we fail, but angels who choose against God can not seek this redemption. Christ did not die for the angles, and the effect of their free will is much more permanent and eternal in nature. I think this fundamental difference in our natures sheds light on how hell is less a creation than a withdrawl.

I think Michelle Arnold answered the question correctly.
 
Her words:

Q
If God created everything, then didn’t he create hell, too? If he created hell, then is hell good, since everything God created was good?
”
A:

“Hell is primarily an eternal state of separation between God and those creatures—angels and humans—who have permanently chosen to reject him. God created free will, which is good, but hell is the result of the abuse of free will. God did not create hell; he only allowed for its possibility. Thus it cannot be said that hell is good.” Arnold

Thoughts???

Two:​

    1. Disappointment that someone in her position could say that
    1. What is said is wishy-washy. The fact of Hell should be uncompromisingly & unambiguously preached. Hell is…Hellish; nothing can alter this.
God is not a grandfather-in-heaven, who pats everyone on the head and ignores their wickedness; but a God of Wrath, Who hates the wicked, & destroys them. God’s Hatred of all unrighteousness is the other “side” of His Love - they can’t be separated. Men are amoral when they are not immoral - but God is neither; He loves righteousness, & hates unrighteousness.

In Revelation, He is praised by the Saints for the judgements He inflicts upon the Great Whore. His “winepress” in chapter 14 is “the winepress of the fury of the wrath of God” - there is nothing wishy-washy about that ! The Wrath [of God] is very prominent in the NT - it is what believers are “saved from” by the Death of Christ. Take the Death of Christ away - & one is exposed to the full weight of the Wrath of of God in all its severity. If there is a Hell, I for one want to know about it, so that I can avoid it - being wishy-washy about it does not help; on the contrary, it makes it sound quite unalarming 😦

Hell must be good - because it is good that evil should be punished. A universe in which evil was unpunished eternally would be a universe in which evil would have had the final word. But God has the final Word. Therefore, evil cannot be unpunished - it is condemned even before it is committed. If men love evil so much that they refuse to put it from them, then they must go whither it goes, & receive from God what it receives.
 
Hell is a real place and God had to have created it because He creates all. To say that He didn’t create it is confusing.

Hell began when Lucifer (Satan) and other angels fell from heaven. You can see this here:

Hell is an eternal place of suffering and fire. Just because God created good does not mean that He is not a just God who delivers just punishment.

👍 Really good post - short, sharp, and to the point. 😃​

 
also, (I think this is relevant) hell isnt just the absence of God (pain of loss) but also the pain of sense (physical pain) is suffered by the souls in hell—
 
Here is an excerpt from Pope John Paul II that was helpful to me when I was researching elements of this issue. The emphasis is most definitely on hell as more of a state of being than a place. In one sense, I can see how this might be seen as “wishy washy,” but the bottom line seems to be that the separation from God is a more terrible thing than we can perhaps grasp or imagine.

"At the General Audience of Wednesday, 28 July 1999, the Holy Father reflected on hell as the definitive rejection of God. In his catechesis, the Pope said that care should be taken to interpret correctly the images of hell in Sacred Scripture, and explained that “hell is the ultimate consequence of sin itself… Rather than a place, hell indicates the state of those who freely and definitively separate themselves from God, the source of all life and joy”.
  1. God is the infinitely good and merciful Father. But man, called to respond to him freely, can unfortunately choose to reject his love and forgiveness once and for all, thus separating himself for ever from joyful communion with him. It is precisely this tragic situation that Christian doctrine explains when it speaks of eternal damnation or hell. It is not a punishment imposed externally by God but a development of premises already set by people in this life. The very dimension of unhappiness which this obscure condition brings can in a certain way be sensed in the light of some of the terrible experiences we have suffered which, as is commonly said, make life “hell”.
In a theological sense however, hell is something else: it is the ultimate consequence of sin itself, which turns against the person who committed it. It is the state of those who definitively reject the Father’s mercy, even at the last moment of their life.

Hell is a state of eternal damnation
  1. To describe this reality Sacred Scripture uses a symbolical language which will gradually be explained. In the Old Testament the condition of the dead had not yet been fully disclosed by Revelation. Moreover it was thought that the dead were amassed in Sheol, a land of darkness (cf. Ez. 28:8; 31:14; Jb. 10:21f.; 38:17; Ps 30:10; 88:7, 13), a pit from which one cannot reascend (cf. Jb. 7:9), a place in which it is impossible to praise God (cf. Is 38:18; Ps 6:6).
The New Testament sheds new light on the condition of the dead, proclaiming above all that Christ by his Resurrection conquered death and extended his liberating power to the kingdom of the dead.

Redemption nevertheless remains an offer of salvation which it is up to people to accept freely. This is why they will all be judged “by what they [have done]” (Rv 20:13). By using images, the New Testament presents the place destined for evildoers as a fiery furnace, where people will “weep and gnash their teeth” (Mt 13:42; cf. 25:30, 41), or like Gehenna with its “unquenchable fire” (Mk 9:43). All this is narrated in the parable of the rich man, which explains that hell is a place of eternal suffering, with no possibility of return, nor of the alleviation of pain (cf. Lk. 16:19-3 1).

The Book of Revelation also figuratively portrays in a “pool of fire” those who exclude themselves from the book of life, thus meeting with a “second death” (Rv. 20:13f.). Whoever continues to be closed to the Gospel is therefore preparing for 'eternal destruction and exclusion from the presence of the Lord and from the glory of his might" (2 Thes 1:9).
  1. The images of hell that Sacred Scripture presents to us must be correctly interpreted. They show the complete frustration and emptiness of life without God. Rather* than a place, hell indicates the state of those who freely and definitively separate themselves from God, the source of all life and joy. This is how the Catechism of the Catholic Church summarizes the truths of faith on this subject: “To die in mortal sin without repenting and accepting God’s merciful love means remaining separated from him for ever by our own free choice. This state of definitive self-exclusion from communion with God and the blessed is called ‘hell’” (n. 1033).
“Eternal damnation”, therefore, is not attributed to God’s initiative because in his merciful love he can only desire the salvation of the beings he created. In reality, it is the creature who closes himself to his love. Damnation consists precisely in definitive separation from God, freely chosen by the human person and confirmed with death that seals his choice for ever. God’s judgement ratifies this state."

As a parting thought on this issue, I think I have been guilty of taking some to task in the past for what I considered a diminished emphasis on the nature of hell when it is seen as a state of being and not a place. After all, it’s easy to continue on that direction of thinking and saying, well, maybe it’s not really a state of being, but a state of “un-being”. You get the picture perhaps. In no way, then, should an understanding of hell in these terms diminish our legitimate horror and dread of its reality and sin-created purpose.
 
Sorry to share another thought, but I think another reason Michelle Arnold’s answer rang true was the issue of heretical predestinarianism. God does not predestine anyone for hell; they choose it themselves. If God created hell, this would seem to suggest at least that God was creating hell for particular sinners. It’s more complicated than this, of course, but this is my “Reader’s Digest” version from a tired poster. 🙂
 
I would go the direct opposite route and say that Hell is good
Unfortunately, I can’t provide any authoritative quotes on the creation of hell either, but I do think I remember reading somewhere the idea that damnation can be seen as a form of mercy on God’s part, in that He does not force those who, during their lives, made clear by deliberately choosing sin that they did not want to be with Him in eternity to enter the beatific vision.

I think that goes in the direction of saying that hell is good, and it helps reconcile God’s justice with His mercy, which really is a very tricky topic.

Also I seem to remember that hell is both a place of physical suffering and the state of separation from God, but that being separated from God and knowing one can never regain what one has lost is the worst of both punishments.

In that case, is it possible God created the place (material things have to have been created at some point), but only allowed the state to be when He chose to create beings with a free will (same reasoning as with evil, which God also allows, but does not actively bring about Himself)? This is pure speculation on my part.

In defense of Michelle Arnold’s post, note the “primarily” at the beginning, on which the rest of the post follows up (even if the answer may possibly be a little simplistic this time with respect to Catholic Theology?).
 
Although I can’t wholeheartedly recommend the last edition of Dr. Peter Kreeft’s book entitled Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About Heaven, but Never Dreamed of Asking, he does touch on some of the same issues being asked here. A good fictional work on hell is also C.S. Lewis’ The Great Divorce. Still, I think the simplest support for Michelle Arnold’s answer is found in that quote I shared from Pope John Paul II. It’s pretty clear in my reading that hell must be less a place than a state of being. That should not, however, in any way minimize either its existence or the horrifying nature of hell.

(If you want to read my review of Dr. Kreeft’s book, you can find it at Amazon. It’s entitled “A Great Start”.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top