Missing Mass because of allergy - urgent help

  • Thread starter Thread starter ladysherlockian
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

ladysherlockian

Guest
Missing Mass because of allergy

Since I was a child, I have suffered from allergy. It was quite hard during my childhood, but as I was adolescent the allergy became mild and more bearable. Now I’m 26 and this year the allergy has become severe again. Since the beginning of May I have suffered from running and stuffed nose. These symptoms are now cured, but now I cough a lot and have difficulty speaking (these symptoms also have lasted two weeks or so, I’ve got some medicine but it doesn’t help much). My doctor says it’s a severe allergy, so I’m not contagious and not dangerous to other people in church. I haven’t been to the university for a week, my parents advised me to stay home so I may get better. It doesn’t help much, I still cough and have difficulty speaking. Apart from this, I sometimes feel a bit weaker than usual and have more appetite – this is because of the medicine I take. Is it a reason to miss Mass? My Mum told me that if I continue to cough, she wouldn’t let me go to church. I know that missing Mass is wrong and I don’t want to commit a mortal sin. What shall I do? I’m adult but I still haven’t managed to find a job so I live with my parents and they sustain me financially. Without their support I would probably die, as it’s extremely hard to find a job and I have never worked so I’m not eligible for unemployment benefit. My father says that I have to obey him and my Mum as long as I’m not self-sufficient. I don’t want to make it look as if my parents were some kind of tyrants. I love my parents dearly and they are my best friends, though I have better contact with my Mum. There is a problem with Mum, because she’s very sensitive as far as my health is concerned. During winter she often advises me not to go to Mass in case I get ill. I always listen to her advice, but then I confess missing Masses as a sin. I must write something about my family to help you understand my situation. My Mum has always wanted to have a lot of children, but she had serious problems with becoming pregnant, before I was born she had two miscarriages as far as I know. One of the children, who would be my elder brother if he lived, died soon after birth. I was born as a premature baby and I was quite a sickly child. I already had the allergy and in primary school I was ill very often. When I was a teenager, the allergy became mild, but now it’s seems it’s back. I don’t know what to do with the Mass. I hate missing Masses, and I’d love to go to the Mass, I don’t want to offend God and commit a mortal sin. But my Mum is against my going to Mass. I’m so worried about this, and since she often tells me not to go to Mass because I may possibly get sick or worsen my condition, I can no longer await the approaching Sunday with joy. When a Sunday is approaching, I’m full of dread that something will happen, e.g. I will cough too much and my Mum will decide that I’m staying home and I will commit this dreadful mortal sin. Most often I don’t feel too sick to go to Mass but I stay home because my Mum asks me to do so. I don’t go when I have a cold as during the first day of the cold I usually vomit. But now I have no cold but severe allergy. My Mum says I shouldn’t and cannot go, but I believe I should go and I would commit a mortal sin if I listen to what my Mum says. I don’t want to sin so gravely, but every time I want to convince my parents to let me go to church, there is a quarrel, and my father says it would be very selfish of me to go to Mass disregarding my Mum’s feelings. She’s so sensitive about my health. I would like to add that both my parents are Catholics, so it’s not the case of their anti-religious stance. My Mum and Father are so convincing that usually I don’t go to Mass if they ask me not to go, even though I want to go very much. What should I do now? How to deal with this situation? Please, please, reply before Sunday, I beg you…
 
You are 26 years old. You need to start acting like it, unless there is a reason that you haven’t mentioned that you can’t. If you feel well enough to go, then go to Mass. Ask your doctor for some alternative treatments if your allergies are so disabling. Are you able to work?
 
I can’t really tell you what is right or wrong here. Talk to a priest that knows you.

Not going to Mass because of pressure from your mother isn’t a valid reason. As the person above me said, if you feel well enough to go, then go. Mom’s going to have to get over it!

Also, for future posts, breaking up your post into paragraphs will make it much easier to read. I honestly only read a small portion of it because it was one big lump of text.
 
Have you asked your parents, or at least your mother if she might be more sympathetic, to speak to your doctor about whether attending mass would cause you harm? I can understand why your parents would be very concerned about their child who suffers severe allergic attacks, but if you are well enough to attend university after a two-week absence, then you should be well enough to attend mass this Sunday. Under the circumstances you describe I do not believe you are commiting a sin, but by not attending mass, you are also missing out on the graces that come from receiving Our Blessed Lord in the Holy Eucharist as well. I would not advise that you disobey your parents, even though you are an adult, but speak to them seriously about how not being allowed to attend mass is hurting you spiritually and emotionally. Could you persuade one or both of your parents to attend mass with you, and then for the remainder of the day you will rest and refresh yourself? God bless.
 
=ladysherlockian;7867051]Missing Mass because of allergy
Since I was a child, I have suffered from allergy. It was quite hard during my childhood, but as I was adolescent the allergy became mild and more bearable. Now I’m 26 and this year the allergy has become severe again. Since the beginning of May I have suffered from running and stuffed nose. These symptoms are now cured, but now I cough a lot and have difficulty speaking (these symptoms also have lasted two weeks or so, I’ve got some medicine but it doesn’t help much). My doctor says it’s a severe allergy, so I’m not contagious and not dangerous to other people in church. I haven’t been to the university for a week, my parents advised me to stay home so I may get better. It doesn’t help much, I still cough and have difficulty speaking. Apart from this, I sometimes feel a bit weaker than usual and have more appetite – this is because of the medicine I take. Is it a reason to miss Mass? My Mum told me that if I continue to cough, she wouldn’t let me go to church. I know that missing Mass is wrong and I don’t want to commit a mortal sin. What shall I do? I’m adult but I still haven’t managed to find a job so I live with my parents and they sustain me financially. Without their support I would probably die, as it’s extremely hard to find a job and I have never worked so I’m not eligible for unemployment benefit. My father says that I have to obey him and my Mum as long as I’m not self-sufficient. I don’t want to make it look as if my parents were some kind of tyrants. I love my parents dearly and they are my best friends, though I have better contact with my Mum. There is a problem with Mum, because she’s very sensitive as far as my health is concerned. During winter she often advises me not to go to Mass in case I get ill. I always listen to her advice, but then I confess missing Masses as a sin. I must write something about my family to help you understand my situation. My Mum has always wanted to have a lot of children, but she had serious problems with becoming pregnant, before I was born she had two miscarriages as far as I know. One of the children, who would be my elder brother if he lived, died soon after birth. I was born as a premature baby and I was quite a sickly child. I already had the allergy and in primary school I was ill very often. When I was a teenager, the allergy became mild, but now it’s seems it’s back. I don’t know what to do with the Mass. I hate missing Masses, and I’d love to go to the Mass, I don’t want to offend God and commit a mortal sin. But my Mum is against my going to Mass. I’m so worried about this, and since she often tells me not to go to Mass because I may possibly get sick or worsen my condition, I can no longer await the approaching Sunday with joy. When a Sunday is approaching, I’m full of dread that something will happen, e.g. I will cough too much and my Mum will decide that I’m staying home and I will commit this dreadful mortal sin. Most often I don’t feel too sick to go to Mass but I stay home because my Mum asks me to do so. I don’t go when I have a cold as during the first day of the cold I usually vomit. But now I have no cold but severe allergy. My Mum says I shouldn’t and cannot go, but I believe I should go and I would commit a mortal sin if I listen to what my Mum says. I don’t want to sin so gravely, but every time I want to convince my parents to let me go to church, there is a quarrel, and my father says it would be very selfish of me to go to Mass disregarding my Mum’s feelings. She’s so sensitive about my health. I would like to add that both my parents are Catholics, so it’s not the case of their anti-religious stance. My Mum and Father are so convincing that usually I don’t go to Mass if they ask me not to go, even though I want to go very much. What should I do now? How to deal with this situation? Please, please, reply before Sunday, I beg you…
My dear friend in Christ!

Didn’t mom ever thell you that “I’m ALWAYS RIGHT” 😃 She is this time too.

God is a God of Love and Mercy; and yes He is JUST!

Missing ones Sunday or Holyday obligation by intent without a valid reason is as you say a Mortal Sin.

However being SICK [God made us that way] is a VALID reason. NO SIN COMMITTED.

However it is a good idea to try to attend a weekly Mass to make up for it; OR watch Mass on TV… EWTN broadcast Mass at 8; 12; 7 pm. It’ll cover your obligationn IF there is valid reason why you can’t attend. Your reason is VALID!

Get well soon!

God Bless,
Pat
 
I will say this as gently as possible…

It’s time to grow up and cut the apron strings. You are 26 years old, and an “allergy” is hardly a reason to constantly miss Mass; it’s not as if you have something contagious that you could spread to others.

Clearly, your mother has overprotected you because of her sad pregnancy history and the fact you were a fragile child. You’re no longer a child, by far.

Finish your university degree, get a job, and get out on your own. In the meantime, be pleasant and respectful to your parents, but get yourself to Mass unless you are truly ill or contagious to others. Plenty of people have allergies; speak with your doctor and try to come up with a treatment plan that helps your symptoms.

God bless.
 
First of all, you don’t commit a mortal sin by missing Mass if you reasonably and sincerely believe your physical condition prohibits it. You don’t have to have something catching. You do not have to attempt to hear the Mass on EWTN or the radio, although that would be a praiseworthy way to reflect on the Word of God you were intended to hear at Mass that week.

You cannot miss Mass because of outside persecution, including persecution from your parents. That doesn’t mean you have to go looking for a fight with them. It only means that if you reasonably believe you have the capacity to go, you need to use your imagination and summon the determination to find a way to go. That is your duty, even if your parents punish you for it emotionally or financially.

I don’t think your mom intends to persecute you, but I do think she is trying to impose a degree of control over you that is inappropriate for your age, regardless of whether or not she’s feeding you. The history she went through before she had you and the troubles she had before you were born may make her less culpable for her conduct, but it does not let you off the hook.

This is one of those times you would do well to schedule a time to talk to your pastor. He can help you decide under what conditions your physical state warrants a dispensation from your obligation. (There probably are some.) He may be able to help you find a Mass in which the conditions are easier for you: perhaps a local nursing home has a Sunday Mass that is not so long or as exhausting as the ones at your parish.

He can also help you to figure out the best way to handle the situation with your parents. He will also give you the confidence that you are doing the right thing and advice on how to do it in the right way, even when your parents oppose you, accuse you of being ungrateful or disrespectful, threaten you with poverty, or the like. Consult with your pastor, and you will know when your parents are right and when they are perhaps sincere but unfortunately out of bounds.

Good luck, God bless you, and do not beat yourself up about this. It’s time to do better. God will give help if you ask for it, and then you can do it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top