missing Mass...??

  • Thread starter Thread starter 4EverHis
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
4

4EverHis

Guest
I have laryngitis… and I lost my voice 😦 and my family is telling me that I shouldn’t go to Mass today. Also I guess it can be contagious… I’m wondering, would it be a sin if I missed Mass? If it was all up to me, and if the disease wasn’t contagious, I’d go… but my family really doesn’t want me to (ie: I might not get a ride, and I can’t drive yet), and also we’re getting the car repaired and I don’t know when it will be fixed

🤷

what do you all think?:confused:

I’m really sad cause I was really looking forward to Mass all week 😦
 
Catholics may use their own prudential judgment, no one is required to attend Mass if they are ill, caring for a sick person, caring for an infant, or other good reason. You don’t need to ask permission, if you are an adult with ordinary capacity to reason you can make this judgement yourself. The same goes for the Eucharistic fast.

My personal opinion is-I don’t know the Church teaching-if you come to Mass when you are sick esp. if you may be nauseous (possible disrespect to the Eucharist) or when you might be contagious, or when you have obvious cold and flu symptoms, it may be a sin to come to church, especially during flu season, but that is opinion, not doctrine.
 
Catholics may use their own prudential judgment, no one is required to attend Mass if they are ill, caring for a sick person, caring for an infant, or other good reason.
Things happen. I confess that I probably would have missed last night if I didn’t absolutely have to be there. I felt terrible. I came home and went straight to bed. If one may be contagious, one should not go. Charity puts the needs of others ahead of oneself.
 
thanks!

well it seems that now I won’t be able to go to Mass anyways, because the car completely broke and is now in the repair shop… so now I don’t have a choice. lol! I do hope it gets fixed soon though.
 
Yeah. I guess it depends how sick you are, but I’m sick and attending, only I’m only taking the bread for now, and in the hand rather than by mouth as I usually do. That, I think, will keep me from infecting anyone while still giving me my spiritual nourishment.

I’m sorry you can’t make it :(.
 
Yeah. I guess it depends how sick you are, but I’m sick and attending, only I’m only taking the bread for now, and in the hand rather than by mouth as I usually do. That, I think, will keep me from infecting anyone while still giving me my spiritual nourishment.

I’m sorry you can’t make it :(.
I think anyone who is sick and attends mass is being selfish. You are potentially spreading your illness to others and making them sick. If you are sick, STAY HOME. Have some concern for others, not just yourself.

See, if you are sick, you can easily spread your illness. You, for example, blow your nose before you get out of your car (hands are now dirty with the virus/bacteria). You must open the door to the church, thus the door handles now have your viruses/bacteria. Anything you touch is dirty. How many times do you touch your nose, eyes, etc. while in church? Then you touch something else. You are spreading your illness.
 
I think anyone who is sick and attends mass is being selfish. You are potentially spreading your illness to others and making them sick. If you are sick, STAY HOME. Have some concern for others, not just yourself.

See, if you are sick, you can easily spread your illness. You, for example, blow your nose before you get out of your car (hands are now dirty with the virus/bacteria). You must open the door to the church, thus the door handles now have your viruses/bacteria. Anything you touch is dirty. How many times do you touch your nose, eyes, etc. while in church? Then you touch something else. You are spreading your illness.
I’d like to illustrate my feelings about this through a fiction story. It’s the best way I know of to explain myself.

Once upon a time, there was a man who was dirt poor and had nowhere to eat except at a soup kitchen. Lots of other people around him also were dirt poor and had nowhere else to eat, so each day when he went to eat, hundreds of people were at the soup kitchen were he collected his meal. He worked in a factory nearby with electrical wiring, and any slip-up could give him an electric shock.

One day, he caught a cold. He went to the soup kitchen anyway, for he had nowhere else to eat. He carefully washed his hands before entering the building, but when he went in to get his food, someone heard he had a cold. The person went up to him and said, “You must not eat here. Go and stay at your home for the next one or two weeks until your cold is completely gone.”

“It’s just a little cold!” the man replied, “You may be right that I may sneeze, and maybe I will get one or two people sick. But I have nowhere else to eat! You expect me to fast from all three meals, every day between now and whenever the cold lifts?”

“Yes. I know you’ll be extremely hungry, that you’ll have hunger pangs, but I don’t want you near us as long as there’s any chance I, or someone else here, might catch this cold from you.”

“But listen!” the man protested. “It’s not only the physical hunger of fasting for one or two weeks that I’m complaining about. I have a job in a factory, and if hunger makes me shaky and weak, and I slip up, a shock from the electrical wiring could give me great pain. Also, if I fumble the wiring, the result could shock others as well.”

“Listen,” the person said. “We don’t want to have any risks of anyone here catching your cold. Just do the best you can with the factory work and hold out as best you can while you fast for a week or two. You can’t be so selfish.”

The Eucharist is my food. I live on God. I don’t think you would do what I present happening in this story, asking me to withdraw from all earthly meals as long as I have a cold, if there was only one place I could eat, and there were people there who might catch the cold from me. How much less, then, should you ask me to abstain from Heavenly Food, on which our souls live? How much more do our souls need Heavenly Food than our bodies need physical food? Moses giving Israel manna in the desert when their stomachs were hungry was only a symbol of Christ providing the Food that satisfies our souls.

Also, I do this “factory work,” the work of sanctification, and if I make a false move because of weakness, as a result of having not eaten my spiritual food, that false move is sin. Which is far worse than an electrical shock to the body. I don’t think you would urge me to not eat the Eucharist if the consequence of my abstaining was electric shocks to my body, but sin is much worse than that, for it pierces the soul. Also, if I sin because of lacking the daily grace that comes from the Eucharist, I might cause others to sin in reaction to me, which spreads the evil beyond myself.

I don’t think you are the person in this story. I don’t think you’ve fully thought through everything about the Eucharist though, and neither have I, of course. But I’m just trying to clarify some about the vital importance of participating regularly in the Eucharistic Celebration, and how that’s so much more important than the body.

I appreciate very much your concern for people’s health. I try to protect their health too; I didn’t shake people’s hands yesterday at Mass, during the time of peace, and today I only did because I felt they were safe from germs, as I washed my hands in the parish bathroom before entering the church building. Also, if I was sick with something really severe, I wouldn’t risk their health. I would abstain. But I feel very strongly the need to put the spiritual life as #1 priority, for myself and others.
 
yes and the soup kitchen could have given the man a meal to go

the person who is confined to home because of illness or incapactiy can also request the parish send someone to administer communion.

how about the person with a compromised immune system who is forced to stay home from Mass because inevitably everyone around him is coughing and sneezing, and then offering a hand to shake. If I were making the rules, and I am not, it would also be a sin to go to work or school when you are contagious.
 
yes and the soup kitchen could have given the man a meal to go
I excluded that possibility from the scenario because they aren’t going to send me someone to give me the Eucharist at my house just because I have a cold.
how about the person with a compromised immune system who is forced to stay home from Mass because inevitably everyone around him is coughing and sneezing, and then offering a hand to shake. If I were making the rules, and I am not, it would also be a sin to go to work or school when you are contagious.
The parish cannot be sterilized for people with a compromised immune system. You’re not going to get church walls and floors covered with sterile white material and have the priests put on plastic white gloves. People with severely compromised immune systems, like people with other medical disabilities that prevent their attendance, have to stay home. You’re being unrealistic, IMO. This would be a cross for them, and I sympathize with such people, but there’s always more that could be done to transform churches into hospital wards so that the sickest people can attend and the far more numerous mostly healthy people can’t, but this doesn’t make sense. The present practice of taking the Eucharist to the sickest people, rather than excluding anyone who has a little cold or cough from the Mass, makes far more sense.
 
We have to let people like Lief make adult decisions. Yes, it is selfish if you are so sick that spreading germs is unavoidable. However, if one is borderline and can take precautions against spreading germs, such a person may be as safe as anyone. Keep some pocket sanitizer and use it, cough in your elbow, etc.
 
I’m glad to be corrected when people think I’m wrong. It gives me a chance to do God’s will more perfectly than I could if I was just trying on my own. I get more points of view and the opportunity to correct mistakes or sins.
 
well I can’t wait for next Sunday 🙂 it’s going to be a long week… lol… I’m still sick and the car still doesn’t work 🤷
 
According to Catholicism For Dummies, Canon Law says your obligated to faithfully attend and participate at a Catholic Mass each and every Sunday and holy day of obligation. Missing Mass is a mortal sin. However, inclement weather and bad health, which would prevent you from leaving home at all, excuse you for that day.

I would think minor illnesses wouldn’t be a good reason, but if your in bad shape…
 
I agree, I never missed a mass on Sunday, it is an obligation, the only reason not to go and participate can be a sickness or work on this day. But if i do work on this day I have to go to church on another day or pray at home or TV mass. For me not to go to church even a one time is a mortal sin . So I have to go to confession and ask God to forgive me my lazyness or what a reason was. I remember I never left a mass on Sunday for a years
and when it happened for the first time I felt so bad. It is my expierience .
 
If we as Catholics believe and have faith in the presence of Jesus in the Holy Eucharist, then like the disciples of old we would not be afraid when people with any kind of diseases comes to Jesus for healing.

"Do not condemn, even with your eyes, for they are often deceived” — St John Cliacus
 
If we as Catholics believe and have faith in the presence of Jesus in the Holy Eucharist, then like the disciples of old we would not be afraid when people with any kind of diseases comes to Jesus for healing.

"Do not condemn, even with your eyes, for they are often deceived” — St John Cliacus
I get a slight feeling of a mixed message from you. However, if I guy with leprosy was before me at communion, would I leave or at least change lines? I’m quite dualistic on this. Right now, I’d have to say no. Because I believe, right now, that sickness and the loss of extremities are extremely less significant occurances than communing with the Lord and the Mother Church. However, ask me again on a lousy day. I know that’s a poorly put together comment, but hopefully you understand what I’m trying to say.
 
I excluded that possibility from the scenario because they aren’t going to send me someone to give me the Eucharist at my house just because I have a cold.
And yet, if you call the parish, you can receive the Eucharist at home because you are sick, with a cold.
The parish cannot be sterilized for people with a compromised immune system. You’re not going to get church walls and floors covered with sterile white material and have the priests put on plastic white gloves. People with severely compromised immune systems, like people with other medical disabilities that prevent their attendance, have to stay home. You’re being unrealistic, IMO. This would be a cross for them, and I sympathize with such people, but there’s always more that could be done to transform churches into hospital wards so that the sickest people can attend and the far more numerous mostly healthy people can’t, but this doesn’t make sense. The present practice of taking the Eucharist to the sickest people, rather than excluding anyone who has a little cold or cough from the Mass, makes far more sense.
It doesn’t have to be someone with a “severely” compromised immune system. It could be someone with something like diabetes or simply someone elderly. It seems that in your opinion they would stay home every week rather than someone with a cold staying home one week. 🤷

It seems that if you are sick, stay home that one week, That way people with compromised immune systems receive the healing benefit of the Eucharist at the Mass.
 
When I am sick and cannot attend mass I always watch mass on tv. I always confess and have been told by the priest that it could not be helped and it was good that I tried by watching mass on tv. I still feel the need to confess but I don’t think of it as a mortal sin.
 
When I am sick and cannot attend mass I always watch mass on tv. I always confess and have been told by the priest that it could not be helped and it was good that I tried by watching mass on tv. I still feel the need to confess but I don’t think of it as a mortal sin.
If you think it’s any kind of sin, you shouldn’t commit it. I personally don’t think it’s a sin for you to abstain from Mass when you’re sick, and your priest seems to have said the same thing. However, if you think it’s a venial sin, then you’re going against your conscience when you stay home. Don’t do that! Decide for yourself whether you believe your priest or not and then act according to what you believe God’s will is.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top