Missing Men and the Biolgical Clock

  • Thread starter Thread starter JimG
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This thread is one of the worst I have ever read, and on CAF, that’s saying a lot.

So Limbaugh has decreed that men have been emasculated? Well, you’ll pardon me if I give him all the respect a four-time divorced drug addict deserves in the area of male-female relationships.
Twice divorced and a recovered “drug addict” who became addicted to pain pills after a surgery (extremely common). Total lack of charity here and bearing false witness.
Women are no longer financially dependent upon men. They can have careers and provide for themselves. Women are no longer willing to settle for the self-absorbed, misogynistic man who is looking for a subservient wife, who will gaze at him adoringly no matter what idiotic clap-trap falls from his lips.
Strong Independent Womyn? Men don’t want her and she pretends not to want men, so everyone is happy.
Real men (and in my book, thrice-married John Wayne didn’t fall into that category) appreciate intelligent, well educated, independent women.
Are you a man?
The fact that there are a good number of men who listen to what Rush Limbaugh has to say may well be one of the reasons women are reluctant to marry.
Probably true. I wouldn’t want to marry a Strong Independent Womyn so I don’t expect she’d want to marry me.
 
Promoting singleness as a “vocation” does not help.
(…)
I agree, for a lot of reasons but one that I haven’t discussed for some time is the reason I heard from a priest years ago. He was concerned that too many men would avoid the responsibilities of marriage and family if given a “vocation” they could use as an out. He said women were less likely to do this because women are more given to self-sacrifice. It’s one of the reasons I don’t see a male version of Canon 604 happening. And from what I’ve observed on these fora over the last 13 years is a lot of men looking for something to bless their single state. Without a doubt many should not seek marriage but nor should they stop working toward being marriageable., Maturity, holiness, selflessness are important no matter what one’s vocation.
 
This thread is one of the worst I have ever read, and on CAF, that’s saying a lot.
If you skip over all the replies on the Rush-Limbaugh-themed thread derailment, the rest of the thread is not bad. There are some thoughtful replies and respectful dialogue.
 
I’m not convinced that being able to buy a house should be the measuring stick for “ready to marry” - though that seems to be the prevailing opinion on CAF.
With the most basic detached houses going for $1.5 million plus here in Vancouver, and rising by the day, I honestly have no interest.
I think people mean “buy a reasonably priced house”, not buy one in some ridiculous market like Vancouver or San Francisco. To be very honest, if I were in a market like that, I would move before I’d pay those prices for a house. I did not buy any house in the District of Columbia for the same reason. I am currently sitting in essentially the same era and type of house I would have bought in DC but it is located somewhere else and hence cost under half as much (and still is verging on “too expensive” for my taste).

If a couple discusses it and decides to stay in some crazy priced market because of jobs or family or whatever, that is a choice, and the two people should at least be able to (a) pay a reasonable rent and (b) be equipped to move elsewhere if it might provide a better life for their family on balance.
 
Nah, I’m actually serious.

Nationally, the median woman is getting married for the first time at 27, so a 35-year-old never-married woman is not the norm.

I know that the national press loves running articles about sad 30-something single women wringing their hands over Mr. Big, but those are almost always stories about New Yorkers or other big coastal cities. Interestingly, even Washington DC (which is the “state” with the highest median age at first marriage), the median for women is 29.8 and it’s 28.8 for both NY and Massachusetts.

womc.cbslocal.com/2015/11/17/the-average-age-of-marriage-in-every-u-s-state/

There actually seems to be a pretty hard ceiling of 30 for the median, even in areas with painfully high cost of living.
I have known some women who were not married in their mid-30s. I’d say maybe 1/3 to 1/2 were divorcees and the other batch had just been involved in their careers or had not met the right man. To characterize them as “mostly divorcees” is a bit off.

Cohabitation likely skews it these days since many 35-year-old women would have lived with at least one man for some time without marrying him.
 
I recall firmly having to take a required “Sociology, Family, & Society” course for the general education requirement at my university. Even then, the class was skewed about 85%female and 15%male.

This precise topic came up and the majority of young women in the course both proudly and firmly stated that they must first: graduate university, obtain either a Master’s degree or PhD, be secure in a job, develop a financial portfolio, home and car…before even entertaining the idea of marriage.
 
I have known some women who were not married in their mid-30s. I’d say maybe 1/3 to 1/2 were divorcees and the other batch had just been involved in their careers or had not met the right man. To characterize them as “mostly divorcees” is a bit off.
And there we go, a key factor in this. Almost no one “has to” get married. There are plenty of pursuits in life beyond marriage for both sexes.
Cohabitation likely skews it these days since many 35-year-old women would have lived with at least one man for some time without marrying him.
I wonder about this. Had they refused to cohabitate, I very much doubt their exes would have proposed. In a way I think we are on the verge of an era where few attempt to date because the process is not worth it.

It’s not that far fetched. Look at Japan and a few other places.
 
It shouldn’t be.
Who’s ready to marry? A 25 year old wealthy fund manager with an ego problem who binge drinks, consumes party drugs and street races during weekends OR a 25 year old who is humble in character, renting an apartment, works at a locally owned café and is just managing?
Those aren’t the only options, thank goodness.

Also, the second 25-year-old is going to have a heck of a time managing to feed a growing Catholic family without food stamps if he can just barely manage to take care of himself.

The only way that is going to work is some combination of a) high earning wife b) birth control and c) federal aid (Medicaid and food stamps). Also, unless the wife is a) a very high earner, the kids are going to public school.
 
I have known some women who were not married in their mid-30s. I’d say maybe 1/3 to 1/2 were divorcees and the other batch had just been involved in their careers or had not met the right man. To characterize them as “mostly divorcees” is a bit off.

Cohabitation likely skews it these days since many 35-year-old women would have lived with at least one man for some time without marrying him.
I suspect the geography matters a lot with regard to mix of divorcees, with more divorcees in areas with early marriage and fewer in areas with older marriage.

I think you’re right about cohabitation.
 
I recall firmly having to take a required “Sociology, Family, & Society” course for the general education requirement at my university. Even then, the class was skewed about 85%female and 15%male.

This precise topic came up and the majority of young women in the course both proudly and firmly stated that they must first: graduate university, obtain either a Master’s degree or PhD, be secure in a job, develop a financial portfolio, home and car…before even entertaining the idea of marriage.
I think that’s what you say when you haven’t met the right person yet.

When I was 19, I told my boyfriend (who really wanted to marry me) that I only wanted to marry at 25. I actually got married to somebody else at 22 (almost 23).

The explanation for that was a) I wasn’t crazy about my boyfriend at 19 and b) I was crazy about the guy I actually married.

I think giving that big list of things to do is mostly a defensive measure to deal with questions from family and friends and not wanting to look like a loser if there isn’t a boyfriend in the picture.

Edited to add: Anecdotally, there are many guys who tell long-suffering girlfriends “I’m not ready yet” and then marry their next girlfriend within six months. You gotta watch what people do, not so much what they say.
 
I wonder about this. Had they refused to cohabitate, I very much doubt their exes would have proposed. In a way I think we are on the verge of an era where few attempt to date because the process is not worth it.
It’s not just a matter of getting the man to propose. Sorry if I left that impression. The woman is just as likely to “not to want to get married” as the guy.

I wasn’t Miss America or anything but I had about three proposals that I turned down during my 20s, for good reasons. In addition, I’m pretty sure my husband, who I knew during that time, would have proposed if I’d given him reason to think I wanted that. I was making it pretty clear I did not want that and a proposal at that time would not have been well received.

The fact that as a Catholic I could probably only get married once (unless the guy died) definitely made me think very long and hard before entering into the big commitment with anybody. I get the impression that many non-Catholic people may not be driven by religious concerns, but they do not want to go through a divorce; in many cases they saw a parent or friend going through that and suffering emotionally and financially and they just don’t want to go there and would rather live together. Which to me makes a lot of rational sense, morals aside.
 
I think that’s what you say when you haven’t met the right person yet.

When I was 19, I told my boyfriend (who really wanted to marry me) that I only wanted to marry at 25. I actually got married to somebody else at 22 (almost 23).

The explanation for that was a) I wasn’t crazy about my boyfriend at 19 and b) I was crazy about the guy I actually married.

I think giving that big list of things to do is mostly a defensive measure to deal with questions from family and friends and not wanting to look like a loser if there isn’t a boyfriend in the picture.

Edited to add: Anecdotally, there are many guys who tell long-suffering girlfriends “I’m not ready yet” and then marry their next girlfriend within six months. You gotta watch what people do, not so much what they say.
Looking back on that course, there was a subconscious layer of feminism there. I know a friend of ours well who is 35years old, a “sophomore” in college, majoring in journalism and Japanese culture. She is also a career waitress. Has no husband, children, or ownership of anything. Not even a car. She has been to dinner with my wife and I, telling us that she doesn’t need a “husband or marriage or worse…children”. I simply offered if she was much older and gets sick, who would take care of her which she had no reply.
 
Looking back on that course, there was a subconscious layer of feminism there. I know a friend of ours well who is 35years old, a “sophomore” in college, majoring in journalism and Japanese culture. She is also a career waitress. Has no husband, children, or ownership of anything. Not even a car. She has been to dinner with my wife and I, telling us that she doesn’t need a “husband or marriage or worse…children”. I simply offered if she was much older and gets sick, who would take care of her which she had no reply.
Seriously, do you think this woman would be mother of the year?
 
This precise topic came up and the majority of young women in the course both proudly and firmly stated that they must first: graduate university, obtain either a Master’s degree or PhD, be secure in a job, develop a financial portfolio, home and car…before even entertaining the idea of marriage.
None of the things a man finds attractive or desirable and she will be 15 years past her prime when she finally gets it. Of course since we assume a normal rate of sexual partners for these young women she will also have all that emotional baggage and a few STDs.

Walking talking divorce factories in the making. Assuming they actually manage to be chosen. If trends continue… Well, we’re gonna need a lot more cats.
 
None of the things a man finds attractive or desirable and she will be 15 years past her prime when she finally gets it. Of course since we assume a normal rate of sexual partners for these young women she will also have all that emotional baggage and a few STDs.

Walking talking divorce factories in the making. Assuming they actually manage to be chosen. If trends continue… Well, we’re gonna need a lot more cats.
I know you don’t find it attractive, but middle class American men mostly marry middle class American women with educations and careers.

That’s how it works nowadays.
 
This was one of the good things that comes out of infertility.

Due to medical issues I suffered as a teen, I was told by doctors that it would be next to impossible for me to have kids.

I never had a ticking biological clock since it was broken in the first place.

Can’t lose what you never had.

I have had a number of men interested in me but as soon as I tell them I’m infertile they leave.

I never had the choice of marriage or a career. The first option was never available to me in the first place.

As for a career, I’ve never had one. I have a job not a career.

As for cats, well not even cats like me. 😃
 
I know you don’t find it attractive, but middle class American men mostly marry middle class American women with educations and careers.

That’s how it works nowadays.
Dumb, submissive, and pretty… that seems to sum up certain posters’ “ideal” woman. Sad.
 
Dumb, submissive, and pretty… that seems to sum up certain posters’ “ideal” woman. Sad.
Except it’s all in theory–they can never find one that’s dumb, submissive and pretty enough.

(Pro-tip: you don’t actually want a dumb wife carrying around your credit cards, checkbook, dealing with tradesmen on your behalf, and raising your kids. One of my close male relatives has a wife he doesn’t really respect intellectually, and he has spent a substantial portion of his life explaining things to her and her not getting it. It looks and soundsexhausting.)
 
Those aren’t the only options, thank goodness.

Also, the second 25-year-old is going to have a heck of a time managing to feed a growing Catholic family without food stamps if he can just barely manage to take care of himself.

The only way that is going to work is some combination of a) high earning wife b) birth control and c) federal aid (Medicaid and food stamps). Also, unless the wife is a) a very high earner, the kids are going to public school.
That is quite judgmental and untrue. Many, if not most, married couples in large sections of the country manage just fine without being high earners, and dual income high earners are rare in even larger sections of the country.

Besides that, what is wrong with public schools? Most Americans attend public schools. I dare say that the majority of high income earners are the product of public schools. And quite a few went to the not so great public schools at that.
 
I’m glad that I dropped out of this whole romantic nonsense. When ‘my happiness’ (individualism) trumps all other values/sense of collective society, you have a very messy clash of ambitions between everybody (nobody wants to be a commoner when anybody can be king, right?)

And allow me to answer the question ‘who will take care of me when I’m old?’ Well I won’t possibly grow old because all the alcohol and tobacco will catch up eventually, sparing me too long life.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top