A
AlanFromWichita
Guest
I brought up the Geto Boys example I originally used to make a slightly different point, to demonstrate to you that I was not using some big broad brush to paint songs as “evil” just because of their genre. Besides, I just watched the movie Office Space with my friend and my mother last week and it was fresh on my mind.For crying out loud, indeed. Why are you giving such obscure - and extreme - examples to make a point? Geto Boys? Are they even around anymore? (Wikipedia says they haven’t an album since 2005…we’re almost in 2012.) And an equally extreme Billy Joel song that no kids today even know about unless they watch “Glee.” Why? I don’t see how you can expect people to take you seriously if you’re so melodramatic and hyperbolic with your examples.
As far as Billy Joel, it may be dated but I hardly consider it extreme. But if you want to call it extreme, be my guest; I won’t try to stop you.
You are shooting blanks with your claim that I erred in using the word “much.” Do you wish to challenge me and other posters here to come up with more “bad” songs than the three you just mentioned?Shooting blanks? How so? I gave specific, timely - as in, not from before a lot of kids were even born - examples of CLEAN and DECENT music: Tony Bennet’s “Duets II” album which is #1 in the country right now - features songs like “On The Sunny Side of The Street.” American Idol winner Scotty McCreery’s debut album, which came out this week, features innocent songs like “I Love You This Big” and “The Trouble With Girls.” With all due respect, I’m a bit skeptical Scotty McCreery’s a bad influence on any kids.
So I still say you should either take back your criticism of my word “much” or provide the analysis I requested. You have now given three songs as positive examples. Only 12 gazillion to go so we can rule out that there is “much.” That brings up the point, how much is “much?” If one single song gives my kids bad ideas that they then go act on, it is too much IMO.
I already shot down 99% and even “most,” but I’m sticking by “much” until you prove me wrong, with references and clear criteria cited.
I’m accusing you of shooting blanks because of you telling me that “much” is wrong. Not because I gave examples you don’t find apropos.The thread title is “modern” pop music. Not classic rock or K-Tel or long-forgotten rap from before a lot of kids were born. Please don’t accuse me of “shooting blanks” when I am sticking to the designated thread topic.
Besides, not a bit of this has anything to do with what the OP was looking for in the first place as I can tell. Unless you want to argue about the 99% figure which has already been retracted, sticking to the thread topic is not to pick fights with other posters about the use of the word “much.” To refresh your memory, as it stands now, to be ON topic would be to respond to the following:
I say that we as parents should be aware of what our kids are listening to, and not make them hide it from us, but rather explore – preferably while they are still under our roof – what they get out of it and why, especially to determine whether there are deeper issues that such discussion could bring to the surface before either the kids move out or we die and leave them on their own to fight the same battles many of us (ok maybe “some” of us … lol) did when we were young – independence, feelings of helplessness or oppression, and the like.promotes violence, sex, drug and alcohol abuse, and wild parties.
What should we as catholic’s do, to protect our world, how can you play your role?
Why does families today accept this kind of music in our homes?
Now I’m ready to hear your On-Topic response to the thread. I’m all ears.
http://bestsmileys.com/listening/2.gif
Peace and joy,
Alan