Modern Pop Music

  • Thread starter Thread starter TradionalWay
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
For crying out loud, indeed. Why are you giving such obscure - and extreme - examples to make a point? Geto Boys? Are they even around anymore? (Wikipedia says they haven’t an album since 2005…we’re almost in 2012.) And an equally extreme Billy Joel song that no kids today even know about unless they watch “Glee.” Why? I don’t see how you can expect people to take you seriously if you’re so melodramatic and hyperbolic with your examples.
I brought up the Geto Boys example I originally used to make a slightly different point, to demonstrate to you that I was not using some big broad brush to paint songs as “evil” just because of their genre. Besides, I just watched the movie Office Space with my friend and my mother last week and it was fresh on my mind.

As far as Billy Joel, it may be dated but I hardly consider it extreme. But if you want to call it extreme, be my guest; I won’t try to stop you. 🤷
Shooting blanks? How so? I gave specific, timely - as in, not from before a lot of kids were even born - examples of CLEAN and DECENT music: Tony Bennet’s “Duets II” album which is #1 in the country right now - features songs like “On The Sunny Side of The Street.” American Idol winner Scotty McCreery’s debut album, which came out this week, features innocent songs like “I Love You This Big” and “The Trouble With Girls.” With all due respect, I’m a bit skeptical Scotty McCreery’s a bad influence on any kids.
You are shooting blanks with your claim that I erred in using the word “much.” Do you wish to challenge me and other posters here to come up with more “bad” songs than the three you just mentioned?

So I still say you should either take back your criticism of my word “much” or provide the analysis I requested. You have now given three songs as positive examples. Only 12 gazillion to go so we can rule out that there is “much.” That brings up the point, how much is “much?” If one single song gives my kids bad ideas that they then go act on, it is too much IMO.

I already shot down 99% and even “most,” but I’m sticking by “much” until you prove me wrong, with references and clear criteria cited.
The thread title is “modern” pop music. Not classic rock or K-Tel or long-forgotten rap from before a lot of kids were born. Please don’t accuse me of “shooting blanks” when I am sticking to the designated thread topic.
I’m accusing you of shooting blanks because of you telling me that “much” is wrong. Not because I gave examples you don’t find apropos.

Besides, not a bit of this has anything to do with what the OP was looking for in the first place as I can tell. Unless you want to argue about the 99% figure which has already been retracted, sticking to the thread topic is not to pick fights with other posters about the use of the word “much.” To refresh your memory, as it stands now, to be ON topic would be to respond to the following:
promotes violence, sex, drug and alcohol abuse, and wild parties.

What should we as catholic’s do, to protect our world, how can you play your role?
Why does families today accept this kind of music in our homes?
I say that we as parents should be aware of what our kids are listening to, and not make them hide it from us, but rather explore – preferably while they are still under our roof – what they get out of it and why, especially to determine whether there are deeper issues that such discussion could bring to the surface before either the kids move out or we die and leave them on their own to fight the same battles many of us (ok maybe “some” of us … lol) did when we were young – independence, feelings of helplessness or oppression, and the like.

Now I’m ready to hear your On-Topic response to the thread. I’m all ears.
http://bestsmileys.com/listening/2.gif

Peace and joy,
Alan
 
I say that we as parents should be aware of what our kids are listening to, and not make them hide it from us, but rather explore – preferably while they are still under our roof – what they get out of it and why, especially to determine whether there are deeper issues that such discussion could bring to the surface before either the kids move out or we die and leave them on their own to fight the same battles many of us (ok maybe “some” of us … lol) did when we were young – independence, feelings of helplessness or oppression, and the like.

Now I’m ready to hear your On-Topic response to the thread. I’m all ears.
http://bestsmileys.com/listening/2.gif

Peace and joy,
Alan
That’s been our parenting position on topics such as this, and any other type of media to allow or not allow in our household. I’d rather equip my child with the tools and skills to think and discern why a certain song or book or tv show invokes a certain passion or dislike then to never have the conversation with them by banning all types of questionable material. I hope that we as parents are teaching our daughter to defend her beliefs and values and gain a sense of who she is in our open dialogues about the music of today and other media. I don’t see much good coming from making her avoid all questionable material other than she won’t have a clue on how to properly discern for herself when she is more independent.
 
It’s right to educate children, let them experience, this wrath for them self if they don’t want to follow, because, you can always learn the hard way 😛 We just pray, that children will follow the warning, and choose the path of our Lord 🙂
👍
Me thinks there’s an obvious selection of songs you have in mind when you wrote this but seriously, do you actually believe you can lump all of so-called ‘modern pop music’ with just that?
 
I say that we as parents should be aware of what our kids are listening to, and not make them hide it from us, but rather explore – preferably while they are still under our roof – what they get out of it and why, especially to determine whether there are deeper issues that such discussion could bring to the surface before either the kids move out or we die and leave them on their own to fight the same battles many of us (ok maybe “some” of us … lol) did when we were young – independence, feelings of helplessness or oppression, and the like.

Now I’m ready to hear your On-Topic response to the thread. I’m all ears.
http://bestsmileys.com/listening/2.gif

Peace and joy,
Alan
What is ur suggestion, that music turned out this way. Lets put it this way the “evolution of music”. The music known first was with the voice, then later joined by music, no today its BEAT, BASS, music and voice…
Me thinks there’s an obvious selection of songs you have in mind when you wrote this but seriously, do you actually believe you can lump all of so-called ‘modern pop music’ with just that?
Well the main misunderstanding of all the post above might be the confusion of genre… there is a difference
 
Well the main misunderstanding of all the post above might be the confusion of genre… there is a difference
Well with all due respect, you’re only adding to that confusion by not elaborating. You should at very least have the intellectual courtesy to clarify on what kind of music you have issues with without painting with a broad brush.
 
Don’t listen to anything you wouldn’t want your little siblings to listen to…
That’s my general rule. 🙂
 
Dearly beloved friends,

Cordial greetings and a very good day.

What does, I think, admit of no doubt is that there is a philosphy of rock/pop music, irrespective of sub-genres, and as Steven Lawhead (a chap who is by no means anti-rock) concedes “there is more blatant immorality being peddled in popular music now than ever before”. This inferior art form is so wedded to an anti-religious, anti-authoritarian and anti-morality world view that it would not be an exaggeration or an unfair use of emotive language to call it sympathy for the Devil. Incontrovertibly, it is debased sensory material that makes its appeal to and chimes with something very basic and primitive within man’s fallen nature - those “elemental passions”, which are all too easily stimulated by rock and pop music. One could say that men are drawn to this music in the same way that opposite poles of a magnet are drawn to each other.

Many within the pro-rock/pop camp freely admit that this debased music has been the occasion of an immense amount of high moral damage, especially among youth. This really should come as no great surprise, since the predominant message of rock/pop has always been sexual permissiveness and revolt against lawful authority and convention. As *Time *magazine once observed, “In a sense all rock is revolutionary. By its very beat and sound it has always implicitly rejected restraints and has celebrated freedom and sexuality”. Unfortunately, the entire world of rock/pop is adapted to titillating the young and arousing them to a frenzied ecstasy, as erotically and unconventionaly attired pop performers scream inivitations to sexual and revolutionary conduct far beyond their target audience’s years. This is, my dear friends, nothing short of a slaying of childhood and we Catholics ought to denounce this unwholesome and egregious art form in the strongest terms, warning our young of its exceedingly deleterious influence upon their moral health. St. Paul tells us that “Bad company ruins good morals” (I Cor. 15: 33), and, by a logical extension, that can surely be applied to bad films, bad literature, bad video games and bad music. Undeniably, rock/pop poisons the mind and demoralizes the life, so as we value our souls we would be well advised to give it a wide-berth, for its waters are too polluted to even paddle in, let alone fully immerse ourselves in. In this instance there can be no contact without contamination - “Can a man carry fire in his bosom and his clothes not be burned? Or can walk upon hot coals and his feet not be scorched” (Prov. 6: 27,28). Rock and pop have, without any doubt, played a key role in prompting youth to discard cultural and sexual restraints and this is precisely what it was created to do by godless and unsavoury rock artists.

Rock and pop music inclines its devotees away from self control, respect for tradition, one’s elders and sublimation; it breeds quarrelsome and arrogant teenagers, who later grow up to be quarrelsome and arrogant adults, wanting in the social graces. Moreover, those who assimilate the vulgarity of rock/pop are unlikely to develop a passionate attachment to that which is pure, lovely and virtuous (Phillip. 4: 8) or be renowned for outstanding moral excellence. Sadly, It will always gravitate in the direction of rebellion, sexual licentiousness and anti-authoritarian tendencies, it simply cannot help itself, which is why it requires a devastating exposure.

Invariably, when this deplorable and culturally unhealthy art form is negatively appraised it elicits a hostile response, even from those within the bosom of the Church, and one is accused of attempting to drive men into a confined and very prudish world. Or if we are not accused of wanting to take the Church in a Puritan direction (not that the Protestant Puritan saints could not teach us a thing or two about sanctity and separation from the the godless world), then it is alleged that we are seriously tarnishing the Credibility of the Catholic Church in the eyes of the world (especially youth) and hampering its mission by being overly prissy respecting moral demands. Quite frankly, my dear friends, this is utter balderdash and evinces most clearly the extent to which worldliness and an earthbound outlook have infiltrated the Church in recent decades. Is not the Christian, who is supposed to be engaged in the daily pursuit of holiness, enjoined to keep himself “unstained from the world” (Jam. 1: 27) and its many pollutions?; this is “the religion that is pure and undefiled before God and the Father”. It is hardly “Puritanism” to insist that a Catholic must work hard to keep himself pure, amidst all of the distracting and demoralizing influences of the godless world around him. On the contrary, this is living up to the arduous demands of our most holy religion by perpetually striving after that personal holiness “…without which no one will see the Lord” (Heb. 12: 14). “Keep thyself pure” was one of St. Paul’s last admonitions to young Timothy. Alas, in these Laodicean times in which our lot is cast, men have adopted a hand in hand with the world type of religious practice, a sort of ‘Catholicism Lite’ (George Weigel), which makes no serious demands upon them in terms of sanctity and separation from the world.

Finally, it should be remembered that the Devil and his evil forces have deeply invaded man’s social and cultural structures and music has not been omitted. Only the secularist, the worldly or the wholly distracted would ever deny this. The Devil is a past master at making that which deleteriously harmful and morally depraved, appear innocuous and inoffensive, how otherwise could he dupe so many, including many Catholics, into believing that is was perfectly acceptable to listen to the bilge water that is rock and pop music package.

God bless.

Warmest good wishes,

Portrait

Pax
 
Should we tolerate this music to be played, or listened to by our youth?
99% of all modern music, promotes violence, sex, drug and alcohol abuse, and wild parties.

What should we as catholic’s do, to protect our world, how can you play your role?
Why does families today accept this kind of music in our homes?

All answer contributions are happily accepted, share your point of view
Unless you can back up such a number you should withdraw it. I do not believe that number and I also do not have any problem with pop music in general.
 
i don’t think popular music today is anti-christian…i just think sex sells, so they sign girls who are willing to exude a forbidden (and sometimes trashy) sexuality in order to get their voices heard. what i never understood about female pop singers is that they know their target audiences are 8-18 year old girls, and yet they are marketed to teen and adult men because sex appeal is important for “sales” …?? a few artists really can sing, but i never got the deal with britney spears…someone else writes her lyrics and produces her beats and dresses her and tells her how to dance in each video and provides backup vocals and electronic exaggerations of her voice. without all these things what does she contribute? not a britney hater but that was one thing about that model of pop singer that i never understood.

i do have to provide a different perspective on eminem. im pretty familiar with his music. a lot of it is party music, but a lot of it isn’t. he’s an ironic artist…he’ll say things deliberately to offend you because he feels like he’s always been crucified no matter what. i think he’s just starting to come out of that phase…ever since he overdosed on pills and realized he could have lost his life and made the commitment to stay off drugs, he’s been pretty peaceful. he said he would try to stop being as violent as he used to be because that person put hands on his child’s mother and he didn’t want to be that person anymore. you don’t have to like him obviously, but he’s probably one of the most misunderstood artists in pop culture today. he’s offensive, crude, and irreverant, and those are bad things. but sometimes you have to go through a lot of bad stuff before you can see the good. the majority of his songs do have a lot of lyrical meaning and substance if you can get past the rough way he chooses to express it.

for example if you listen to his past music he frequently says he’s going to hell. it’s funny when he says this because it’s so blunt. but then you start to wonder if he really thinks it. not because he’s afraid of hell but because he feels like he abused a few things on his way up. he never hesitates to shout “F You” to the critics because he feels like the only one he truly has to answer to is god. he’s strong and hard-spoken and a superstar, but undoubtably he knows there are things he regrets. for example, in these lyrics:

In my mind I’ma fighter, my heart’s a lighter
My soul is the fluid, my flow sparks it right up
Arsenic writer, author with arthritis
Carpel tunnel, Marshall will start ****-itis
Hard headed and hot headed, bull headed and pig headed,
Dick headed, a prick, a big headache I’m sick
Quick witted, for every lyric spitted there are 6 critics
Who wait for me to slip with it, so quick
No apologies, not even acknowledging you at all
'till I get a call that god’s coming.

everyone in this community probably is familiar with the christian artist KJ-52, but here is a song where he reaches out to eminem and asks him to ask for help:
youtube.com/watch?v=_Aff1_mu1GQ

and here’s eminem’s response (not what you’d expect!) in a song “Careful What You Wish For”:

I got a letter from a fan, that said
He’s been praying for me
Every day and for some reason
It’s been weighing on my mind heavy
'Cause I don’t read every
Letter I get, but something told me to go ahead and open it, but
Why would someone pray for you when they don’t know you?
You didn’t pray for me when I was local
And as I lay these vocals
I think of all the **** I had to go through
Just to get to where I’m at
I’ve already told you at least

A thousand times in these rhymes
I appreciate the prayer, but I’ve already got
God on my side
And it’s been one hell of a ride, hasn’t it?

anyway, not that everyone has to give eminem a 2nd chance but i have, and he’s helped me to feel brave enough to ask for a 2nd chance myself. i think it’s perfectly okay when a song is about sex, drugs and violence in some regard, but when it glorifies it without showing the consequences, then we have a problem. not so much in the catholic community itself but more in the broader arena of glorifying behavior that depletes physical and emotional health.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top