Modesty poll

  • Thread starter Thread starter 1inICXC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
1

1inICXC

Guest
Just something very basic that I’m curious to see how we CAF members would vote.

I know there is no detailed teaching about it so it might be arbitrary but I think one argument is true: the more lust an outfit produces the less modest it is and the more one shows the more lust one peoduces.

I"m asking especially because I’ve been looking at Leah Darrow who is the modesty spokes-person and she wears lots of above the knee dresses. While I do think they look rather modest on her, since she has a very petite figure, i don’t think those fitted, above the knee dresses would be very modest on women with a large bust and a rounder “derriere.”

I think kimono tops( loose around the bust and sleeves and narrow at the waist,)along with longer skirts, preferably non-fitted, would be a much safer choice. Or Kimono type dress that goes in at the waist and flows baxk out to the knee or slightly past.
 
I think I’m confused what opinions you’re trying to get, that what Leah Darrow wears is immodest or that anything above the knee is immodest in dress? Or that the more a dress choice produces lust the more immodest it must be?

Frankly, I hate the kimono style dresses. Never liked them.

And the pictures I have seen of Leah Darrow and her choice of clothes, seem fine in my book. In fact I would love to know where she got a few of the dresses she’s worn in the pictures I’ve seen of her lately, I’d like to purchase a few for myself.
 
I’d like to get the opinions of CAF members, whichever those may be.

Like I said, I don’t think that Leah Darrow dresses immodestly, but her choice of dresses did get me thinking about the issue. While I think that on her they look perfectly proper I also think that on a more curvacious woman they would be outright sexy.

I myslef sometimes wear skirts or dresses that show the knee but I am quite conflicted about it, when I have the choice I always go for the floor-length ones.
 
I think of “immodest” as showing cleavage, being strapless or thin-strap, having a net panel in the midriff, etc. Dresses slightly above the knee but that aren’t cut low, strapless, etc. are fine with me. And a modest dress is preferable to little shorts or tight pants or sagging/bagging pants.

Some of immodesty is in the attitude of the wearer, too. I’m sure there are women who could wear a floor length dress and be scandalous in it. And, there are modest women who could wear a skirt above the knee and be ladylike wearing it.

🤷
 
If modest clothing depends on how much lust is produced, does that mean an ugly person can wear what they want while a beautiful person shouldn’t wear anything less than a burka?
 
I answered “no and I am a woman”, however there are places where it would be innappropriate.
 
If modest clothing depends on how much lust is produced, does that mean an ugly person can wear what they want while a beautiful person shouldn’t wear anything less than a burka?
Ugly is in the eye of the beholder, to misquote the old proverb. And most men can look at a woman’s body and never see her face, so I would say, no.
 
You must not live in the US - or your poll would have read, “…how much cleavage to show?”
 
I answered ‘No/male’. If the Church teaches otherwise, I change my vote.

But no, knees are not immodest, if the outfit is otherwise modest.

There’s a woman in our parish who is ALWAYS the best-dressed at Mass. Lovely, modest, feminine and not over-dressed. Wish more women were like her.
 
I know where this thread is heading… 😉 But anyway I think that a woman should at least wear a dress that comes to the knee. I won’t really call it ‘immodest’ because that word can be very relative. But it also depends on the woman’s body type in many cases. Women who are more, ahem, “blessed” in certain areas may not be able to get away with wearing certain dresses and tops because it will draw unneccesay attention. I personally have been feeling more convicted about how I should dress and am thinking about how dress shows others how a person values themselves. When I go to church, I always where dresses that come to or below the knee. It’s just more comfortable because you don’t have to worry as much about how to sit properly in a skirt with your legs together the whole time.
 
I think from the knee down is generally acceptable but not above !
 
Most women can modestly wear skirts a few inches above the knee as long as they aren’t so tight they make sitting a problem.
 
I’ll stick with the Vatican on this one. If you can’t go into St Peter’s ( the basilica or the square) with a dress above the knees, then it seems the Church must not think it’s modest.

http://wwwdelivery.superstock.com/WI/223/1960/PreviewComp/SuperStock_1960-1362.jpg
But even on the St. Peter’s poster, the woman’s legs are exposed below the knee. If the picture showed the woman in an ankle-length dress, I would think that would be the minimum mandatory requirement.

I feel that skirts/dresses that come to the knee are usually modest enough. I say “usually” because there is always going to be someone out there (Hollywood is an example) who can ruin a modest dress length for the rest of us.

I voted no and I’m a woman, too.
 
I think if a man can’t control his lust over a woman’s knees - he has bigger problems than her immodesty. Sorry just figured I would make the argument from absurdity.
 
Said ‘no/male.’ Unless of course you are in Saudi or certain Haredi neighbourhoods in Israel.
 
There are too many different types of shapes and figures, and to say “x looks okay on one woman, but should be banned for others” is just silly.

Every woman should be modest with her figure, and for some that means she can get away with shorter skirts and tops, whereas for others, it means longer, looser clothing. Its an individual choice made with individual knowledge of their individual body type.

Granted, there are some clothing choices that will always be immodest. ie. bikinis. Recent study out said that the part of the man’s brain that fires up when he sees a lady in one, is the part associated with tool use - a guy isn’t even seeing a woman in a bikini as a person, but as a tool!!
 
But even on the St. Peter’s poster, the woman’s legs are exposed below the knee. If the picture showed the woman in an ankle-length dress, I would think that would be the minimum mandatory requirement.

I feel that skirts/dresses that come to the knee are usually modest enough. I say “usually” because there is always going to be someone out there (Hollywood is an example) who can ruin a modest dress length for the rest of us…
I am fine with dresses and skirts from the bottom of the knee down. It’s when people say above the knee we get in trouble as 1 inch becomes 2 inches becomes 5. The knee is a good demarcation.
 
I think that sign sums it up nicely.

Also, though, how clothing fits is as important as the actual dimensions of the clothing. A size 12+ woman can very easily wear a knee-length skirt if it is cut correctly and isn’t clinging on for dear life.
 
I think if a man can’t control his lust over a woman’s knees - he has bigger problems than her immodesty. Sorry just figured I would make the argument from absurdity.
:rotfl:

At my Catholic high school, the rule on skirts is that they can be no more than 3 inches above the knee. (Of course, half the girls break that rule, which I find rather irritating.) When actually worn it seems modest enough, at least for the setting.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top