Modesty poll

  • Thread starter Thread starter 1inICXC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
But according to your logic, based on that sign, men would never be able to wear shorts.

Summer is on the way here, so I’d like to know whether I can wear my shorts again.😉
Actually I do agree with that in general. 🙂 I haven’t worn shorts since I was a child, but many men’s shorts are immodest too and I don’t think they should ever be worn to Mass. Just my opinion, but it’s obvious that’s certainly in the minority so you have my permission to ware whatever you want 😃
 
Hmm, i thought things would be split more evenly for the above or below the knee issue.

It looks like it’s a non-issue then.
I didn’t put a poll about cleavage as there is only one option for that.

Crystalina was also wearing above the knee during one of her recent appearances so I kind of gathered it is acceptable.

Well good, now I have a much larger variety of clothing to chose from, though DH is not a fan of me wearing above the knee.

@ Patricia, you were asking where to find those dresses, over here, in Europe, you find them eveywhere: Debbenhams, Zara, Mango etc. it’s quite frustrating that the one year that high neck dresses are in I am breastfeeding so they are totally written off for me.
 
Actually I do agree with that in general. 🙂 I haven’t worn shorts since I was a child, but many men’s shorts are immodest too and I don’t think they should ever be worn to Mass. Just my opinion, but it’s obvious that’s certainly in the minority so you have my permission to ware whatever you want 😃
Don’t men’s shorts usually go down to the knee, or is that just in Europe? They could be considered immodest for not being dressy enough for church but they definitely don’t show too much
 
I think of “immodest” as showing cleavage, being strapless or thin-strap, having a net panel in the midriff, etc. Dresses slightly above the knee but that aren’t cut low, strapless, etc. are fine with me. And a modest dress is preferable to little shorts or tight pants or sagging/bagging pants.

Some of immodesty is in the attitude of the wearer, too. I’m sure there are women who could wear a floor length dress and be scandalous in it. And, there are modest women who could wear a skirt above the knee and be ladylike wearing it.

🤷
I totally agree with this. Couldn’t have sait it better.
 
Hmm, i thought things would be split more evenly for the above or below the knee issue.

It looks like it’s a non-issue then.
I didn’t put a poll about cleavage as there is only one option for that.

QUOTE]

True but I’d be interested to hear peoples views on bare shoulders, strapless dresses, bra straps showing etc all of which I personally think are un-acceptable.
 
Don’t men’s shorts usually go down to the knee, or is that just in Europe? They could be considered immodest for not being dressy enough for church but they definitely don’t show too much
It depends. Some men’s shorts in the US go to mid-thigh and many knee length shorts are so loose that they are either falling off the hips or the legs are loose enough that you can get an unexpectedly unpleasant view when the wearer sits down and the legs ride up. Most men’s shorts in the US are not like slacks.

Just to clarify, my opinions are not based on an extra inch of showing skin, it about the fact that people then use it as an excuse to keep pushing the boundaries for the sake of fashion or comfort. Above the knee opens the avenue to 3 inches above the knee, etc. A modest skirt at 3 or 4 inches above the knee while standing might not be so modest when it rises 2 inches when you are sitting.
 
True but I’d be interested to hear peoples views on bare shoulders, strapless dresses, bra straps showing etc all of which I personally think are un-acceptable.
I think the setting it is important. None of those would be acceptable for Church and bra straps showing is never acceptable.

On the other hand, a stapless gown that isn’t low cut might be perfectly acceptable and modest for a formal occassion.
 
These are nice men’s shorts. My sons wear shorts like these.

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)
 
Ugly is in the eye of the beholder, to misquote the old proverb. And most men can look at a woman’s body and never see her face, so I would say, no.
Beauty is definitely **not ** in the eye of the beholder. IMO as long as an outfit is decent then whether it inspires lust or not doesn’t make it immodest. If man sins because of a woman’s lower leg then that is on him.
 
Don’t men’s shorts usually go down to the knee, or is that just in Europe? They could be considered immodest for not being dressy enough for church but they definitely don’t show too much
Sure men’s shorts go to the knee. Boys in my area wear shorts below their knees. DS thought his gym shorts were too short, (at his knee) and refused to wear them, opting for the sweat pants instead.
 
I would say things are considered immodest if they are tight, revealing, show excessive cleavage (women), excessive displays of chest hair (men) and/or do not reach the knee area especially in most work places & of course places of worship regardless of height, weight, body type and clothing size.
 
If modest clothing depends on how much lust is produced, does that mean an ugly person can wear what they want while a beautiful person shouldn’t wear anything less than a burka?
This does seem to be the point of this thread. The claim seems to be that anyone attractive is automatically an evil sinner and is personally responsible if however nicely dressed, men think that woman is pretty.

Anyone ugly is off the hook and can show up to Mass naked because the OPs issue isn’t about dress but about female beauty and male attention that comes from it, assumed.

This thread is all about inappropriate boundary issues.

It’s not about women’s attire but about making women responsible for how men react to women around them. Since no one can control anyone else’s feelings, sinful or otherwise, the thread indicates a psychological issue ragarding rage at attractive people and a desire to make them somehow pay for being attractive, perhaps by hoping they will burn in hell because men think they are pretty.

We don’t habitually wear burkha’s in this country, it isn’t the norm and it shouldn’t be required at Church. Are we sure the OP isn’t an Irani Muslim, a 7th Day Adventist or maybe a Hasidic Jew?

Perhaps we could stone women who show their calves at Mass, in big circles of angry jealous women. Oh whoops! Jesus said “let he who is without sin cast the first stone” and in any event, dressing appropriately for church is not a sin, even if the appropriately dressed woman is attractive.

I think this is a personal issue for the OP, best addressed in therapy and it would probably help if she actually were Catholic, had actually ever been to a Mass to see what people really wear there, and actually knew any of the Church’s doctrine. Then perhaps her fantasies about sexuality in Mass would recede and her posted concepts about going to Mass would be less ignorant.
 
This does seem to be the point of this thread. The claim seems to be that anyone attractive is automatically an evil sinner and is personally responsible if however nicely dressed, men think that woman is pretty.

Anyone ugly is off the hook and can show up to Mass naked because the OPs issue isn’t about dress but about female beauty and male attention that comes from it, assumed.

This thread is all about inappropriate boundary issues.

It’s not about women’s attire but about making women responsible for how men react to women around them. Since no one can control anyone else’s feelings, sinful or otherwise, the thread indicates a psychological issue ragarding rage at attractive people and a desire to make them somehow pay for being attractive, perhaps by hoping they will burn in hell because men think they are pretty.

We don’t habitually wear burkha’s in this country, it isn’t the norm and it shouldn’t be required at Church. Are we sure the OP isn’t an Irani Muslim, a 7th Day Adventist or maybe a Hasidic Jew?

Perhaps we could stone women who show their calves at Mass, in big circles of angry jealous women. Oh whoops! Jesus said “let he who is without sin cast the first stone” and in any event, dressing appropriately for church is not a sin, even if the appropriately dressed woman is attractive.

I think this is a personal issue for the OP, best addressed in therapy and it would probably help if she actually were Catholic, had actually ever been to a Mass to see what people really wear there, and actually knew any of the Church’s doctrine. Then perhaps her fantasies about sexuality in Mass would recede and her posted concepts about going to Mass would be less ignorant.
Wow, ROFLMAO.

While reading this I thought for sure: Troll, but then i see you’re a regular AND Catholic!
God bless you, you did crack me up nonetheless!
 
True but I’d be interested to hear peoples views on bare shoulders, strapless dresses, bra straps showing etc all of which I personally think are un-acceptable.
Susanne, from the responses on here I think everyone would agree with you, I would consider those the obvious ones.

Knowing there are a lot of conservative Catholics on CAF I wanted their opinions on the knee showing or not because it’s less obvious, come to think of it, sleeveless would be another one, I’ve heard some complaints about that one but it’s not as scandalous as showing cleavage or mini-skirts or strapless tops. And then, there would be heels. Shoes can make a world of a difference.

Again, I prefer some sleeve over no sleeve and below the knee rather than above the knee but it’s good to know that either is acceptable.
 
Knees are what I look at all the time, it can be a real deal breaker.:eek:
 
Actually, I find this topic to be, at least so far, one of the more reasonable modesty topics that I have come across on CAF. Usually, they become so polarized that they wind up with people engaging in ridiculous strawman arguments against either moral degenerates who wouldn’t care if a woman walked into Mass naked, or Taliban-wannabes who want all women to walk around in burkas – though no one actually endorses either of these extreme positions!

As for the OP, I think it’s reasonable to say that as a general rule skirts that hit just above the kneecap are modest, but that there may be situations where they aren’t – for example, if a woman spreads her legs wide exposing her underwear, now this may sound ridiculous but as someone who usually wears pants, I do have to be careful whenever I am wearing a skirt and sitting, for example, on a subway car where rows of seats face each other.

Also, I don’t think modesty is just about how much epidermis is exposed to the public. Hope no one minds a Twilight reference but one of the vampire characters, Heidi, has the special power of being extremely seductive and alluring to anyone she meets, and uses this power to lure humans into the vampire compound in Volterra, Italy, where they are killed for their blood by the “Volturi” (a “coven” or group of vampires who live there and act as a kind of vampire Mafia). However, she covers up her body completely when among humans as, due to Twilight vampire mythology, exposed vampire skin sparkles in the sunlight, and would expose her to the humans as, well, non-human. Anyway, Heidi’s description in the books makes it obvious that covering up your skin does not equate to modesty – she is described as “not only the hunter, but the bait”.
 
Susanne, from the responses on here I think everyone would agree with you, I would consider those the obvious ones.
Interesting…

Perhaps not everyone…

My wife’s wedding dress was strapless. I think her bridesmaids wore strapless dresses too, or perhaps spaghetti straps. I certainly don’t think the dresses were scandalous or immodest (although I presume you’ll disagree) and nothing was said by our priest or any family or friends.

I guess in any discussion of modesty there will be disagreements on where to draw the line.
 
We don’t habitually wear burkha’s in this country, it isn’t the norm and it shouldn’t be required at Church. ** Are we sure the OP isn’t an Irani Muslim, a 7th Day Adventist or maybe a Hasidic Jew? **

Perhaps we could stone women who show their calves at Mass, in big circles of angry jealous women. Oh whoops! Jesus said “let he who is without sin cast the first stone” and in any event, dressing appropriately for church is not a sin, even if the appropriately dressed woman is attractive.

I think this is a personal issue for the OP, best addressed in therapy and it would probably help if she actually were Catholic, had actually ever been to a Mass to see what people really wear there, and actually knew any of the Church’s doctrine**. Then perhaps her fantasies about sexuality in Mass** would recede and her posted concepts about going to Mass would be less ignorant.
your sarcasm is uncharitable. Why can’t you take the arguments put forth at face value and not mock them by suggesting that people who desire less revealing attire also desire to stone people who show more skin? Do you really think this is a reasonable response to something you disagree with?

Bolded are your ad hominem arguments – useless, but designed to sting and defame character, but not to actually improve the discourse by offering thoughtful objections.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top