Moral questions concerning Instagram

Status
Not open for further replies.

Guest1

New member
  1. Do you think it’s wrong for me if I take a video Someone posted of The Passion of the Christ for example like a scene from The Passion of the Christ and repost it on Instagram?
  2. do you think it’s okay to repost other people’s Instagram pictures such as pictures of Jesus or religious ones without asking? Or without giving credit?
  3. Do you think it’s wrong if I repost a bit of a Catholic song off of YouTube and put it on Instagram?
  4. What if I take videos on YouTube religious ones to make music videos and post it on Instagram?
 
Last edited:
  1. “Fair use” is a clip under 30 seconds broken up with comentary added. So if it meets this crieria, than yes, you’re all set
  2. Without asking? Sure. Without giving credit? That’s kinda scummy.
  3. Again, under 30 seconds with your own commentary? Sure
  4. That’s iffier…are the YouTube uploaders even the legitimate music owners? Do you have their approval to use their songs and repost?
 
Personally, our priests advise us against instigram, Snapchat. Facebook.

Would copyright be an issue?
 
Do you think it’s wrong for me if I take a video Someone posted of The Passion of the Christ for example like a scene from The Passion of the Christ and repost it on Instagram?

do you think it’s okay to repost other people’s Instagram pictures such as pictures of Jesus or religious ones without asking? Or without giving credit?

Do you think it’s wrong if I repost a bit of a Catholic song off of YouTube and put it on Instagram?

What if I take videos on YouTube religious ones to make music videos and post it on Instagram?
The short answer is that if you have created an image, video, music, etc., you can use it in any way you like. If someone else created it, it is covered by copyright law.

Materials covered by copyright law may be used, subject to fair use guidelines.

What is fair use? It varies. These are the four factors to consider:
  1. Purpose and character of the use. Using someone else’s material for commercial gain is not likely to be fair use. Using it in a classroom may be.
  2. Nature of the copyrighted work. It is more likely to be fair use if you are citing a news article or other factual material. Using creative work – a movie, a song, etc. – is less likely to be fair use.
  3. Amount of the portion used compared to the copyrighted work as a whole. Using a large portion of a work is less likely to be fair use.
  4. Effect on the potential market for the copyrighted work. If someone is less likely to buy the copyrighted work because of your use of it, your use is less likely to be covered by fair use.
If these guidelines seem somewhat vague, they are. Lawyers make big bucks defending the rights of copyright holders.

In short, if you didn’t create the work you have no absolute right to use it. You may be able to use it consistent with fair use. The easiest way to be sure is to ask the copyright owner if you may repost the work. They may say yes, they may say no, or they may have conditions such as linking to their original site. Both morally and legally you should respect their intellectual property.
 
Last edited:
40.png
Guest1:
Do you think it’s wrong for me if I take a video Someone posted of The Passion of the Christ for example like a scene from The Passion of the Christ and repost it on Instagram?

do you think it’s okay to repost other people’s Instagram pictures such as pictures of Jesus or religious ones without asking? Or without giving credit?

Do you think it’s wrong if I repost a bit of a Catholic song off of YouTube and put it on Instagram?

What if I take videos on YouTube religious ones to make music videos and post it on Instagram?
The short answer is that if you have created an image, video, music, etc., you can use it in any way you like. If someone else created it, it is covered by copyright law.

Materials covered by copyright law may be used, subject to fair use guidelines.

What is fair use? It varies. These are the four factors to consider:
  1. Purpose and character of the use. Using someone else’s material for commercial gain is not likely to be fair use. Using it in a classroom may be.
  2. Nature of the copyrighted work. It is more likely to be fair use if you are citing a news article or other factual material. Using creative work – a movie, a song, etc. – is less likely to be fair use.
  3. Amount of the portion used compared to the copyrighted work as a whole. Using a large portion of a work is less likely to be fair use.
  4. Effect on the potential market for the copyrighted work. If someone is less likely to buy the copyrighted work because of your use of it, your use is less likely to be covered by fair use.
In short, if you didn’t create the work you have no absolute right to use it. You may be able to use it consistent with fair use. The easiest way to be sure is to ask the copyright owner if you may repost the work. They may say yes, they may say no, or they may have conditions such as linking to their original site. Both morally and legally you should respect their intellectual property.
Fair use includes commercial ventures. This is why youtubers can have “react” channels
 
Fair use includes commercial ventures. This is why youtubers can have “react” channels
And copyright holders file suit after suit against people infringing on their copyrights on YouTube.

Just be aware that fair use is not always clearly defined and if you use someone else’s work without permission you may be infringing. You can defend yourself by claiming fair use, but lawsuits are expensive!
 
40.png
Xanthippe_Voorhees:
Fair use includes commercial ventures. This is why youtubers can have “react” channels
And copyright holders file suit after suit against people infringing on their copyrights on YouTube.

Just be aware that fair use is not always clearly defined and if you use someone else’s work without permission you may be infringing. You can defend yourself by claiming fair use, but lawsuits are expensive!
Yes, when they violate copyright law. But fair use is extremely flexible when it comes to commercial activity. There must be a value-add, but fair use very much applies to commercial use.

(in US copyright law) the doctrine that brief excerpts of copyright material may, under certain circumstances, be quoted verbatim for purposes such as criticism, news reporting, teaching, and research, without the need for permission from or payment to the copyright holder.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top