Moral sinners can't receive Eucharist, but don't they need it?

  • Thread starter Thread starter hamburglar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
H

hamburglar

Guest
I understand that a person in a state of mortal sin cannot receive the Eucharist. I have gotten questions from people saying “if the ‘wafer’ is really the Body of Jesus, shouldn’t a sinner benefit from receiving it more than a person in a state of grace?” I don’t know how to address this. And yes, some people I know really do call the Body a “wafer”
 
I understand that a person in a state of mortal sin cannot receive the Eucharist. I have gotten questions from people saying “if the ‘wafer’ is really the Body of Jesus, shouldn’t a sinner benefit from receiving it more than a person in a state of grace?” I don’t know how to address this. And yes, some people I know really do call the Body a “wafer”
We Catholics believe in Transubstantion, which means it is NOT a wafer (except for its accidents) but the Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity. Lutherans and others believe in Consubstantiation, which means it’s both a wafer and the Body of Christ.

As for not being in the state of sanctifying grace, confession works much better than receiving communion. In fact, it is an act of sacrilege (another mortal sin) to receive unless you’re considered worthy enough to receive it.
 
We Catholics believe in Transubstantion, which means it is NOT a wafer (except for its accidents) but the Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity. Lutherans and others believe in Consubstantiation, which means it’s both a wafer and the Body of Christ.

As for not being in the state of sanctifying grace, confession works much better than receiving communion. In fact, it is an act of sacrilege (another mortal sin) to receive unless you’re considered worthy enough to receive it.
I know it’s not a wafer, I was just pointing out that’s what my Protestant friends call it. I also know about sacrilege. I just don’t know how to respond to my friends when they ask me these questions.
 
Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty of profaning the body and blood of the Lord. [28] Let a man examine himself, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup. [29] For any one who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment upon himself. [30] That is why many of you are weak and ill, and some have died.
**1 Corinthians 11:27-30 **
 
Yes, they need it desperately. That’s why they should get to confession ASAP and receive soon after.

Seriously, mortal sin is called “mortal” because it kills the life of Christ in the soul. A person in mortal sin is spiritually dead. The Holy Eucharist is the heavenly food of the soul, but food cannot nourish or in any other way help a dead person. The soul must first be brought back to life through confession. Only the living eat.

Betsy
 
I know it’s not a wafer, I was just pointing out that’s what my Protestant friends call it. I also know about sacrilege. I just don’t know how to respond to my friends when they ask me these questions.
It’s difficult to respond to those who insist it’s still a wafer. But we refer to all the atomic particles that comprise the Hosts as “accidents” rather than “substances.”
 
Personally, we ALL need the Eucharist. It is the bread of life, the bread for our journey. No one needs it any more than the other…but the believer the one who receives it worthily understands the power of it…and savors and hungers for it.

The sinners need our prayers more so that they can be reconciled to the church and the gifts promised by this reunion.
 
Yes, they need it desperately. That’s why they should get to confession ASAP and receive soon after.

Seriously, mortal sin is called “mortal” because it kills the life of Christ in the soul. A person in mortal sin is spiritually dead. The Holy Eucharist is the heavenly food of the soul, but food cannot nourish or in any other way help a dead person. The soul must first be brought back to life through confession. Only the living eat.

Betsy
Excellent answer!
 
Yes, they need it desperately. That’s why they should get to confession ASAP and receive soon after.

Seriously, mortal sin is called “mortal” because it kills the life of Christ in the soul. A person in mortal sin is spiritually dead. The Holy Eucharist is the heavenly food of the soul, but food cannot nourish or in any other way help a dead person. The soul must first be brought back to life through confession. Only the living eat.

Betsy
This is indeed a wonderful answer - one dead in sin can not be nourished. I will have to try and remember that one.

Brenda V.
 
The Catechism says:
1395 By the same charity that it enkindles in us, the Eucharist preserves us from future mortal sins. The more we share the life of Christ and progress in his friendship, the more difficult it is to break away from him by mortal sin. The Eucharist is not ordered to the forgiveness of mortal sins - that is proper to the sacrament of Reconciliation. The Eucharist is properly the sacrament of those who are in full communion with the Church.
 
God saw it necessary for the Mary to be pure and free from all sin before he conceived in her body… why should we think we should be anything less when we receive him into our bodies?
 
Yes, they need it desperately. That’s why they should get to confession ASAP and receive soon after.

Seriously, mortal sin is called “mortal” because it kills the life of Christ in the soul. A person in mortal sin is spiritually dead. The Holy Eucharist is the heavenly food of the soul, but food cannot nourish or in any other way help a dead person. The soul must first be brought back to life through confession. Only the living eat.

Betsy
and, how can Confession help Protestants? They can’t even receive that Sacrament from the Church…

hamburglar is trying to figure out how to tell her Protestant friends why the Church doesn’t allow everyone to take the Precious Body and Blood…and it’s difficult, do you just say…because the Church says so?
 
and, how can Confession help Protestants? They can’t even receive that Sacrament from the Church…
They can and should if they intend to come into full communion with the Catholic Church.
hamburglar is trying to figure out how to tell her Protestant friends why the Church doesn’t allow everyone to take the Precious Body and Blood…and it’s difficult, do you just say…because the Church says so?
Maybe because–as the Catechism says–the Eucharist is the sacrament of one’s full communion with the Church. That’s why it’s called “Holy Communion” after all. You’ve got to be in communion to receive Communion.
 
You’ve got to be in communion to receive Communion.
That right there is the answer for her Protestant friends.

However, I still think everyone is kinda missing her point in her friends asking these questions. Outside looking into the Catholic Church, it’s really hard to understand it all.
 
Great answers. But I would like to just clear up something: I am a “him” not a “her” 🙂
 
Yes my friend. As your question suggests, sinners do benefit by the reception of Holy Communion. I am a sinner and yet I receive communion as often as possible and the benefits to me can never be measured.

I believe Holy Mass is a reliving of Christ’s suffering and His death on the cross. During His excruciating and freely accepted torment, the sins of mankind, from the beginning of time until the end of time, were carried by Jesus and laid at His Fathers feet.

These sins, all of them, were atoned for. How does the verse go? By His suffering and death our death was destroyed. And then the glorious promise of our salvation; Christ rose from the dead after three days and our life, eternal life, was assured.

We are sons and daughters of Adam. Jesus Christ knows that we are in a life and death struggle with Satan. Just as Jesus was tempted by him on the moutain top, so also we will be tempted. We will fall into sin, sometimes into grave sin. There is no doubt about it and no one is exempt.

Jesus in His divine mercy and love instituted the sacrament of reconciliation. He gave the apostles, and through Peter, all Priests the ability to bring God’s
forgiveness to mankind.

Hamburglar,my friend,you have a tough job. Your friends are very good people and have a healthy interest in the workings of salvation. I have friends like that. I believe under certain circumstances they will be saved, even if they do not belong to the Catholic Church. Here is the hard part.

Our Pope, recently, left no doubt that Christ subsists only in the Catholic Church. Only in the Catholic Church may sins be forgiven in the sacramental sense. And only in the Catholic Church is Christ’s Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity present.

And so I bring my sinful self to Mass and trust that God will forgive all my sins as I participate in the Sacrifice. But if I have sinned gravely, a mortal sin, if you will, I know, as has been stated so elegantly in these threads, the reception of the Body and Blood of Christ will lead to my condemnation.

Given everything that has lead up to the institution of the Sacrement of Holy Eucharist it only makes sense to me. I have been defeated by Satan. My life has been sucked out of me. My soul lingers in a very dangerous place since union with God is impossible. I left Him. The good news is that God never left me. He loves me no less in my condition. People may be praying for me. A full life in communion with God is always in reach. All it takes is a trip to the confessional.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top