Morality of a morality pill

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pat_OC
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

Pat_OC

Guest
So I am writing an essay/portfolio for a school assignment in ethics where we have to analyse an article about a specific ethical issue written by this utilitarian philosopher called Peter Singer, and long story short, I would like the Catholic perspective on the certain issue.

The issue he raises in this article is a pill that could change someones morality. He puts it like this: people’s moral behaviour differs greatly, for example, some people are incredibly empathetic and will go out of their way to help strangers, and some people are psychopaths. If it is found that this was caused by a difference in brain chemistry, then it would follow that drugs could be used to change this brain chemistry to promote or inhibit tendencies towards certain behaviours, since medication is already used to change people’s mood or behaviour all the time for various mental health conditions. In short, a drug that could make people moral.

Ignoring the multitude of objections I have around Peter Singer’s opinions and philosophy, as well as the feasibility of something like this being a reality, what would the Catholic teaching be around this issue? I already have an idea, but as a loyal but sinful member of the Church and a lover of Jesus, I wanna get this right 🙂

I am aware that altering a person’s brain chemistry, or rather the use of drugs in general is okay for strictly medical reasons - for example, anti-psychotics or anti-depressants, however this proposed morality pill would not classify as being for health reasons. In the churches eyes, would this pill raise issues around free will? If someone’s natural behaviour were to suddenly and radically change due to a drug, would their actions still be considered freely chosen with full knowledge and consent? If so, would it be moral to give it to those who have a high disposition to violent behaviour in order to stop it? My instincts tell me its not the greatest idea… and that even those like psychopaths who lack empathy and are likely to be violent can still make rational decisions to choose what is objectively good. I know this is a very speculative question and kind of broad, but anything that can help shed some light onto the Churches view on something like this would be much appreciated!!

P.S. Catechism quotes would be especially appreciated!
 
There is a similar issue with surgery to restore function. For example, infertility. The Catechism states:
2379 The Gospel shows that physical sterility is not an absolute evil. Spouses who still suffer from infertility after exhausting legitimate medical procedures should unite themselves with the Lord’s Cross, the source of all spiritual fecundity. They can give expression to their generosity by adopting abandoned children or performing demanding services for others.
 
I think we here at CAF should be disinclined to do your homework for you. YOU need to analyze the article. YOU need to build your arguments. YOU need to do your own research.

This is a school assignment. You need to do the thinking here. This is not a crowdsourcing exercise.
 
A morality pill would be a pill of eternal life.

Because sin comes from death (and not merely death from sin). Or more specifically, the fear of death. The need to survive is a double edged sword. It could also urge a man to “get ahead in life” and walk on others, creating a large space for himself… or to indulge in pleasure because he knows life is short. You can’t cure any of this without curing death.

Yet on another note, this is exactly what Christ did. He conquered death, and we are risen in him. He renews us with the Holy Spirit, until the day of Resurrection when our bodies will finally have met our final hope. He is our morality pill, so to speak. But there’s nothing immoral about it! Because it’s not forced and it’s free will to believe in Christ or not.
 
Last edited:
Think about how a morality pill could work. The pill does not know right or wrong. It doesn’t have intentions. It doesn’t make plans. It doesn’t choose. The brain performs all these functions, either with or without the morality pill. The pill only modifies brain function in broad ways, like amplifying one neurological pathway or attenuating another. The person still has to use his available brain function in order to figure out what’s right or wrong, form intentions, make plans, make choices, and actually carry them out. What then is left for the morality pill to do?

I won’t answer the question any further because it’s your homework, and besides, I don’t know all the answers, although I might have some hunches.

Think also about balance. What if a prayer pill caused someone to pray all the time? What if a selflessness pill caused someone to never think of himself? What if an honesty pill caused someone to always tell the truth? How would that work out? What does this have to do with free will and morality? 💥
 
Last edited:
I think we here at CAF should be disinclined to do your homework for you. YOU need to analyze the article. YOU need to build your arguments. YOU need to do your own research.

This is a school assignment. You need to do the thinking here. This is not a crowdsourcing exercise.
You have a good point there, which I didn’t think about. I didn’t mean to get this part of my assignment done for me and I was definitely doing my own research too, I just wanted some opinions to help.
However, you are right, I and I should go and find those opinions in my own research, since I am being graded.
Thanks to everyone who did contribute though, it was much appreciated.
 
Last edited:
Hello.

You might want to consider a person’s ability to make choices as a possible focus for your assignment. For catechism quotes those are freely found on the internet.

Hope your assignment works out well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top