Morality of corporal punishment

  • Thread starter Thread starter Spyridon
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Spyridon

Guest
Is it morally acceptable to use corporal punishment on children ages 5-10?
  • Yes, it is morally acceptable to use corporal punishment
  • No, corporal punishment is intrinsically wrong and akin to abuse
  • Other
0 voters
 
Last edited:
I would suggest that anyone who can’t tell the difference between corporal punishment and abuse abstain from utilizing corporal punishment and stick to “time outs”
 
I would also add that corporal punishment is one of a number of options of punishments. Which one gets used depends on the circumstance and the child (shaming worked best when I was young…spanking on me had no effect. Contrast that with my brother…one whack on his backside got instant results)
 
Corporal punishment should be an entirely symbolic act in those ages.

It’s the perception of corporal and perception of punishment, put together. That said the pain caused shouldn’t be physical or psychological, only purely that of conscience.
 
Last edited:
Other. Too broad a topic; question needs to be narrowed. The morality of CP would be dependent on the moral compass of the person administering it.

Edited to say. Suggest a poll that is more expansive, with questions of a more personal/situational nature.
 
Last edited:
CP can be anything from a light spanking to a full-on switching…
 
A belt across the rump
I believe in punishment because it is biblical - spare the rod and spoil the child (paraphrase). However, the amount of pain inflicted must not be excessive. It must be reasonable for the child of that age to know it is a punishment. Too little would make a mockery of it but too much is abusive.

I would avoid things like belt - an impression of a whip invariably comes with it. Be careful not to make it like a torture, even with symbolism. It is not to humiliate.

A simple cane would do the job. It is done not out of anger because when you are angry you may be unable to control the force you are going to give. The child has to know the reason for the punishment, so you need to tell him/her. You do it because he/she has done wrong and because you love him/her.

After the punishment is done, always reaffirm the child - hug and words of affirmation. It hurts you as much at it does to him/her.

Caning probably may be done once or twice in the child’s lifetime. If it is done properly with the proper spirit (love) and good parenting, by the time the child reach ten, it may not be done anymore. There may be other ways to discipline him/her.

God bless.
 
Last edited:
I was a notoriously stubborn child. Even physical punishment didn’t phase me. The only thing I took serious was when my parents took my books away from me lol
 
St. John Bosco:
Force, indeed, punishes guilt but does not heal the guilty….In the case of some boys, a reproachful look is more effective than a slap in the face would be. Praise of work well done and blame in the case of carelessness are already a great reward or punishment. A reproachful or severe look often serves as an excellent means of moral restraint over the young. By it the guilty person is moved to consider his own fault, to feel ashamed, and finally to repent and turn over a new leaf. Never, except in very extreme cases, expose the culprit publicly to shame. Except in very rare cases, corrections and punishments should be given privately and in the absence of companions; and the greatest prudence and patience should be used to bring the pupil to see his fault, with the aid of reason and religion. To strike a child in any way…must be absolutely avoided…[these punishments] greatly irritate the child and degrade the [parent].
 
We owe the end of the use of physical violence against children to enlightenment values and he consequent understanding of human rights that flows from them. It’s banning in many countries shows the weakening of religious influence. Most religions, including the Catholic Church, have traditionally upheld this terrible practice. If you would not physically attack an adult behaving in the same way, don’t even think for an instant that it could be acceptable to do it to a child.
 
Although if scripture was divinely inspired you would have thought God might have said ‘don’t do this awful thing’ rather than ‘do this awful thing’.
 
I was never hit as a child, not even spanked.

I heard someone explain it really well, a mother of seven and it was “Let them have consequences”.

They break their tablet? They don’t get a new one.
They through a tantrum? Well, why?
They don’t eat their dinner or at least try? No, dessert.
You didn’t have a good report card, but tried? Okay, you still get to go on that weekend trip.
If you didn’t get a good report card, you need to study more—so no weekend trip.

If things have a routine, consequences are easy to deal with. Punishments are excessive.
 
Defining terms would be good here. “Spanking” does not necessarily equate to “physical violence”. If you believe all spanking is “physical violence”, then we disagree.

When my son was 3, the best way to get across that he should not stick his finger in a light socket was a whack on his rear end, not “enlightenment values”. When my son was 5 and decided to jump out of our car at the gas station to run inside, almost getting hit by a car, the best way to get across to him how much of a bad idea that was, was to explain to him what he did was dangerous and underscore that teaching with a whack on his rear end, as opposed to a “time out”, or discussion about “values”.

Today, my boys (25 and 23 yrs old) are well adjusted, healthy, smart, well-educated, loving children who have told me they thought how I raised them was why they are who they are today. I’ll put the way I raised my kids and how they turned out against anybody else’s approach.

Regarding your last statement: “If you would not physically attack an adult behaving in the same way, don’t even think for an instant that it could be acceptable to do it to a child”. If you don’t see the difference between reasoning with an adult and reasoning with a 3 yr old, then we will never agree on this topic. Also, as I stated above, if you can’t tell the difference between corporal punishment and a “physical attack / physical violence”, then you are definitely a person that should stick to “time outs” and never spank your kids.
 
Corporal punishment was a recognized educational tool for a long period of time. It wasn’t “vengeance” or assault or anything else. Of course its moral.
 
A vague hypothetical is not good fodder for firm moral evaluation.

Is it moral for me to shoot a person?
 
Last edited:
I have never seen corporal punishment used by a parent when they were not using it while in a fit of rage.

The few who use it wisely are rare.

I think when done improperly as most are, it causes more harm than good.

Jim
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top