I do not believe the soul is divided up amongst the cells in the body, thus “tieing” it to the body until every last cell has died. Once the body as a whole no longer supports life, the soul leaves it. I do not believe it hangs around till even last cell is dead.
If you are brought into the ER with fatal injuries, they try to revive you multiple times and fail, because the damage to your body as a whole is incompatible with live, there are still good organs, including the heart that when placed in someone else can save their life. They just and moral thing to do is to allow the earthly body that has been left behind by the soul to save another. (provided of course that this is the deceased’s and their families wishes…no manditory donor stuff).
I do believe every and all efforts medically availible should be made to save someone, and I am strongly against unplugging someone to harvest organs or letting someone die who could be saved just to get their organs. I am also against using an embryo to harvest stem cells from. I believe that even person is a unique and special soul…created at conception.
However once your body has died, and cannot be saved…by all means use what can be used to save another. My family has directions to do that with me (whatever they can as I have a heart condition, so no one wants my heart.)
Dan, you did not answer the question about turning down organs since by your explanation all cellular activity must stop before the soul leaves, that pretty much rules out any organ transplant. Since you believe that removeing organs before the soul has left is murder, then I assume you will not accept a organ donation?
Also what about blood. If the soul is in every living cell in the body how does that apply to blood cells in a transfusion.
One more thing, do you have Church doctrine to back up your claims?
Thank you for your thoughtful comments. I will try to answer all the questions you asked.
I would not accept donated organs, if those organs were vital organs without a duplicate which means their removal killed the donor. Some organs, like a kidney, can be donated from a donor who survives the procedure and goes on living (because they have another kidney). That is fine. The same thing goes for blood donation. There are also some tissues which can be donated, after death has actually occured. But as far as organs like heart, which can only be harvested by killing the donor, no I would not accept them, as to do so is to cooperate with the intentional killing of another person.
Yes, I do have Church doctrine to back me up. The Church teaches the soul is what animates the body. Death occur when the soul seperates from the body. So if the body is animated, the soul is present, and the person is not dead.
The Church also teaches that the direct taking of a human life is a violation of the commandment “thous shall not kill” except for: killing in a just war, the death penalty justly carried out by the state, killing in self defense. Those are the only three exceptions. Just as we have no right to commit suicied, we have no right to donate organs if the donation process ends our life, and others have no right to take them if it kills us.
Your comments about being able to “save” someone seem to point towards a sliding scale of death. Someone can be completely beyond the help of medecine, be dying, and still be alive. There is a huge difference between a dying person and a dead one. One is alive, the other is not. Death has nothing to do with medical capabilities. If it did, someone in the US might be alive, but someone in a 3rd world country is “dead”. Or someone is “dead” today, but in 50 years, a person in the exact same condition is now considered alive because of new medical techonolgies.
Death is when the soul leaves the body. The argument that brain function or heart function is the sole determinant of death is easily proven false:
A human being can live their entire life and die…and never even have a brain or a heart, let alone function of either. We have a soul from the moment of our creation. We don’t have a heart. We don’t have a brain. We do have a body and a soul. Every single person has been alive at a time when they had no brain function and no heartbeat. So if human life exists without those things, their absence cannot be the determinant of death.
I hope that answers your questions.
Can you answer my question of why “brain dead” donors need to be sedated and restrained while their organs are removed, if they are really dead?
Pax and God bless.