Morality of Organ Transplants

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dan_Daly
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

Dan_Daly

Guest
New thread started from a discussion that came up in the “NFP abuse” thread.
Um, that’s not true. In the slightest. See here.

This is a good article from the National Catholic Bioethics Center.
Your first source is from a Baptist group. Not a good place to go for the Catholic teaching on something.

Your second source actually seems to be arguing for my position. It says:
Given what has been said, the irreversible cessation of cardio-pulmonary functioning (understood as above) is good evidence that death has occurred in a given patient.
If there has been an irreversible cessation of cardio-pulmonary function…that would mean the heart is no longer functioning, and would not be able to function again in the future (the irreversible part). So why transplant a heart that can’t work? In actuallity, the cessation of heart function is CAUSED by the surgeon performing the transplant surgery, and as thus the transplant is the cause of death.

Pax and God Bless.
 
Re: First source - our brothers in Christ have much to offer us. This is an ethical issue for all Christians, not just Catholics. Read the article and consider its points.

Re: second source - obviously you didn’t read the ENTIRE article. From the conclusion:
With these two distinctions in mind, I think it is clear that the persistent functioning of a sub-system requiring artificial life support does not indicate that a person is still alive. To see this clearly consider an example from James Dubois. Dubois has us consider a decapitated patient who arrives in the ER. Miraculously, the ER team succeeds in restoring cardio-pulmonary functioning with intensive life support. Is the decapitated patient a human being? Intuitively, we should say no. To say yes would reduce what it means to be a human being to a pitter-patter of disintegrated biological sub-systems.
By your logic, Dan, it would be immoral to donate the still-beating heart of a decapitated man, because that would be killing him.
 
Re: First source - our brothers in Christ have much to offer us. This is an ethical issue for all Christians, not just Catholics. Read the article and consider its points.

Re: second source - obviously you didn’t read the ENTIRE article. From the conclusion:

By your logic, Dan, it would be immoral to donate the still-beating heart of a decapitated man, because that would be killing him.
Thank you for following me over to the new thread.

I agree, Protestants are not always wrong. The idea that they are, is often a stumbling block for Catholics, myself included. Just because something is believed by some Protestants doesn’t make it true or not true. We must look to see if what our brother Christians are saying agrees with authentic teaching of the Catholic Church. That is the key, Protestants are right- when they agree with the Church.

Did you listen to the podcast I linked to? If not, please do so. I have quickly gone over both articles you provided, but will be happy to give them a more careful reading.

Once you listen to the podcast, let me know how you respond to people “reliably determined to be brain dead” who you argue are candidates for donating vital organs- among other things- sitting up, having children, and…getting better.

I also agree with your logical conclusion given your hypothetical example of a decapitated man. I do not believe removing his heart while it is still beating would be moral. I’d also be curious as to the circumstances which allow this hypothetical situation to occur- how did the man become decapitated? It would seem quite a stretch for him to be accidentaly decapitated…and yet have a surgical team standing by to remove his heart. If you want to talk about removing it after it has stopped, you’d need to explain why you are removing it. Even if someone is dead, we are not permitted to mutilate their corpse for no good reason.

Pax and God bless.
 
Just to follow up to your decapitation hypothetical, as someone who has recently picked up raising chickens at home, I can let you know from personal experience- decapitation does not cause instanteneous death. Death occurs shortly thereafter. When more people were involved in the raising and butchering of their own food, this was far more common knowledge than in today’s factory fed society. It’s where the phrase “running around like a chicken with his head cut off” comes from. Dead chickens can’t run. Headless ones, that are still alive, can.

Pax.
 
If there has been an irreversible cessation of cardio-pulmonary function…that would mean the heart is no longer functioning, and would not be able to function again in the future (the irreversible part). So why transplant a heart that can’t work? In actuallity, the cessation of heart function is CAUSED by the surgeon performing the transplant surgery, and as thus the transplant is the cause of death.
I think you are misunderstanding the physiology here. When a heart stops beating, and a person has died, doctors give it several minutes to make sure it is not going to re-start. If it doesn’t, the person has died and there is a window of a few hours where the heart may be transplanted (it’s not viable for long without a blood supply).

So, I don’t really understand what you mean by the cessation of heart functioning being caused by the surgeon. When the surgeon removes the heart, the person has already died. The transplant has nothing to do with the cause of death.
 
With charity, I think you misunderstand the situation. If the person the heart is taken from is dead, why is there a need to restrain and sedate them during the removal procedure?

If the heart is dead, how does it come back to life in the recipeint of the transplant? If the heart is alive, how can a dead person have a living heart?

Pax and God bless.
 
With charity, I think you misunderstand the situation. If the person the heart is taken from is dead, why is there a need to restrain and sedate them during the removal procedure?

If the heart is dead, how does it come back to life in the recipeint of the transplant? If the heart is alive, how can a dead person have a living heart?

Pax and God bless.
The heart still has the ability to function in someone else, the donor is dead. When the heart no longer beats, blood is not circulated throughout the body, the lungs do not work, and everything shuts down. It is important to understand that the heart itself is not dead (at least, a healthy heart that is being transplanted), it is its relationship with other body systems that are causing its cease in functioning in that particular person. Maybe the person got into an accident and hemorrhaged too much, maybe the person went into anaphylactic shock and stopped breathing and died, etc. They would not transplant a diseased heart into someone else. The heart can still function, just not in the donor’s body.
 
The heart still has the ability to function in someone else, the donor is dead. When the heart no longer beats, blood is not circulated throughout the body, the lungs do not work, and everything shuts down. It is important to understand that the heart itself is not dead (at least, a healthy heart that is being transplanted), it is its relationship with other body systems that are causing its cease in functioning in that particular person. Maybe the person got into an accident and hemorrhaged too much, maybe the person went into anaphylactic shock and stopped breathing and died, etc. They would not transplant a diseased heart into someone else. The heart can still function, just not in the donor’s body.
If the heart is not dead, as you said, that means it is alive. The only thing that keeps any part of a human body alive is a human soul. So if any part of the body, in this case a heart, is alive, that means the soul is present. Death occurs when the soul leaves the body, so if the soul is present, the person is not dead.

If “death” can occur when some body parts are dead and others are not, who decides which ones and how many are needed for the person to be alive?

We are called to protect the weak and defenseless among us. That includes the dying. “So and so is going to die anyway” goes the argument. Well, we are all going to die anyway. None of us knows the day or the hour. The “brain dead” patient may very well die soon, but so may the doctor about to remove his organs. Nearness of death does not give anyone the authority to kill anyone, including oneself.

The Catholic Church has consistently taught there are three “exceptions” to “Thou Shall Not Kill”:

-Killing in a just war
-Capital Punishment, justly carried out by the state
-Killing in self defense

Killing someone for their organs, even if they are dying and even if the act is carried out with noble intentions, is not on the list.

Pax and God Bless.
 
There can be brain death, while the cardio pulmonary system is kept functioning artificially with a ventilator.

ncbcenter.org/page.aspx?pid=482&storyid1277=32&ncs1277=3
What about Truog and Miller’s comments on brain death? They claim that certain patients who satisfy whole brain death manifest evidence of system-wide functioning (e.g., wound healing, and immunological defense). If so, is brain death good evidence for death? The answer to this question is, “yes,” but to explain why requires making several distinctions. First, there is a distinction between the persistent functioning of a sub-system (e.g., endocrine functioning) of a human being and the persistence of the human being. A human being may be dead and a sub-system may persist. Dead bodies may continue to grow hair, and nails, and some bodies satisfying brain death criteria have certain larger sub-systems which continue to function, albeit under external support. Conversely, a sub-system may be “dead,” or severely impaired as in the cases of kidney failure or ventilator dependent persons who otherwise are fully functioning. Thus such persons are fully alive. Consequently, to argue against brain death as an adequate determination of death, one must argue that in the setting of brain death the human being, not just a sub-system, still exists. Second, there is a distinction between sub-systems functioning because of external life support in a non-integrated manner, and sub-systems functioning autonomously in an integrated manner with other sub-systems. Patients satisfying whole brain death need external life support of some sort, typically ventilator support. Therefore if the organism requires artificial life support due to permanent loss of the organism’s own ability to integrate and regulate vital functions, this is good evidence that the soul has departed that body. In admitting that the body needs external support is just to admit that the body has lost its own resources to maintain vital functioning. This should be taken to be evidence for death, not life.

With these two distinctions in mind, I think it is clear that the persistent functioning of a sub-system requiring artificial life support does not indicate that a person is still alive. To see this clearly consider an example from James Dubois. Dubois has us consider a decapitated patient who arrives in the ER. Miraculously, the ER team succeeds in restoring cardio-pulmonary functioning with intensive life support. Is the decapitated patient a human being? Intuitively, we should say no. To say yes would reduce what it means to be a human being to a pitter-patter of disintegrated biological sub-systems.
 
If the heart is not dead, as you said, that means it is alive. The only thing that keeps any part of a human body alive is a human soul. So if any part of the body, in this case a heart, is alive, that means the soul is present. Death occurs when the soul leaves the body, so if the soul is present, the person is not dead.
When someone’s heart stops, it either starts again or it doesn’t. If it doesn’t after a certain amount of time, the person has died. Period. The heart is still viable and can be used for someone else, if it is healthy. But the *person *has died.

I’m very confused about what your point is. Is your issue with the medical determination of when death occurs? By your definition, a person isn’t actually dead until at least 24 hours after they have actually died, because skin cells still live on for about this long. Is this what you believe?
 
Dan,

I think you are misundertanding how living tissue works. A body as a whole can be dead, essentially there is too much cumlative damage or failure that is irreversable for the body as a whole to survive. This damage maybe isolated to a certain system or area of the body. Other areas are OK, but because one area is damaged the body as a whole cannot live, however the OK areas, which are not alive in the sense of possessing a soul, or being a complete person, or able to now or later survive on their own, are still viable if placed into another body before they start to decay.

Example:
You get your head chopped off. The damage to your spinal column and spine are to great to be fixed, and the damage to your body as a whole is too great for it to go on living. However, your eyes, skin, heart, lungs, kidneys etc. are undamaged. They are not alive in the sense of being to survive now or ever on their own, they are not a whole person any longer, and because your body as a whole has died your soul has left and is on to it’s final destination. All those OK organs can if transplanted soon enough survive in another person. Why not donate them and say another’s life.

Side note: Dan if you believe that all post mortem organ donations are bad, then I would expect that you have documents stating you do not want to recieve a donated organ should you need one correct?
 
ncbcenter.org/page.aspx?pid=436#8

This page covers the concerns the criteria for determining brain death and the morality of organ transplants when the donor has been medically declared “brain dead”. It’s written in a way that it can be understood by those who are not medical professionals or who have a limited knowledge of anatomy and physiology.
 
Dan,

I think you are misundertanding how living tissue works. A body as a whole can be dead, essentially there is too much cumlative damage or failure that is irreversable for the body as a whole to survive. This damage maybe isolated to a certain system or area of the body. Other areas are OK, but because one area is damaged the body as a whole cannot live, however the OK areas, which are not alive in the sense of possessing a soul, or being a complete person, or able to now or later survive on their own, are still viable if placed into another body before they start to decay.

Example:
You get your head chopped off. The damage to your spinal column and spine are to great to be fixed, and the damage to your body as a whole is too great for it to go on living. However, your eyes, skin, heart, lungs, kidneys etc. are undamaged. They are not alive in the sense of being to survive now or ever on their own, they are not a whole person any longer, and because your body as a whole has died your soul has left and is on to it’s final destination. All those OK organs can if transplanted soon enough survive in another person. Why not donate them and say another’s life.

Side note: Dan if you believe that all post mortem organ donations are bad, then I would expect that you have documents stating you do not want to recieve a donated organ should you need one correct?
I appreciate the comments. With charity, I’d suggest that you misunderstand how the soul works. The soul is what animates the body. A body can’t be living if a soul is not present.

Yes, if your head is chopped off you can not survive, FOR LONG. You would be dying not dead. There is a big difference between the two.

I don’t know why you think I am against all post-mortem organ donations. I haven’t said I’m against any post-mortem donations. I’m against PRE-mortem donations that actually cause death. It’s simply a case of our society calling people who aren’t dead, “dead”, and hence there is confusion on people’s part on when exactly pre and post mortem are.

If brain function and/or heart beat are the defining criteria for human life, and their ceasing is the defining of criteria for human death…

How can a human being, exist, live, and die, all with never even having a brain or a heart? All of us were human before we had brains. All of us human before we had hearts. We had a body (a very small one to be sure) and a soul. We were human from the moment of conception. So the argument that a human being can’t be alive without a heart beat or brain waves falls flat on its face because every single person was alive without a heart beat or brain waves.

Pax
 
When someone’s heart stops, it either starts again or it doesn’t. If it doesn’t after a certain amount of time, the person has died. Period. The heart is still viable and can be used for someone else, if it is healthy. But the *person *has died.

I’m very confused about what your point is. Is your issue with the medical determination of when death occurs? By your definition, a person isn’t actually dead until at least 24 hours after they have actually died, because skin cells still live on for about this long. Is this what you believe?
“at least 24 hours after they actually died” is a very unclear statement for me to respond to, as I’m not sure how you are defining “actually died”.

How long it takes someone to die varies in every case, both based on the person and the method of death. Someone can linger on death’s doorstep for days or weeks, or they could be incinerated in napalm in a brief moment.

Pax
 
I do not believe the soul is divided up amongst the cells in the body, thus “tieing” it to the body until every last cell has died. Once the body as a whole no longer supports life, the soul leaves it. I do not believe it hangs around till even last cell is dead.

If you are brought into the ER with fatal injuries, they try to revive you multiple times and fail, because the damage to your body as a whole is incompatible with live, there are still good organs, including the heart that when placed in someone else can save their life. They just and moral thing to do is to allow the earthly body that has been left behind by the soul to save another. (provided of course that this is the deceased’s and their families wishes…no manditory donor stuff).

I do believe every and all efforts medically availible should be made to save someone, and I am strongly against unplugging someone to harvest organs or letting someone die who could be saved just to get their organs. I am also against using an embryo to harvest stem cells from. I believe that even person is a unique and special soul…created at conception.

However once your body has died, and cannot be saved…by all means use what can be used to save another. My family has directions to do that with me (whatever they can as I have a heart condition, so no one wants my heart.)

Dan, you did not answer the question about turning down organs since by your explanation all cellular activity must stop before the soul leaves, that pretty much rules out any organ transplant. Since you believe that removeing organs before the soul has left is murder, then I assume you will not accept a organ donation?

Also what about blood. If the soul is in every living cell in the body how does that apply to blood cells in a transfusion.

One more thing, do you have Church doctrine to back up your claims?
 
I do not believe the soul is divided up amongst the cells in the body, thus “tieing” it to the body until every last cell has died. Once the body as a whole no longer supports life, the soul leaves it. I do not believe it hangs around till even last cell is dead.

If you are brought into the ER with fatal injuries, they try to revive you multiple times and fail, because the damage to your body as a whole is incompatible with live, there are still good organs, including the heart that when placed in someone else can save their life. They just and moral thing to do is to allow the earthly body that has been left behind by the soul to save another. (provided of course that this is the deceased’s and their families wishes…no manditory donor stuff).

I do believe every and all efforts medically availible should be made to save someone, and I am strongly against unplugging someone to harvest organs or letting someone die who could be saved just to get their organs. I am also against using an embryo to harvest stem cells from. I believe that even person is a unique and special soul…created at conception.

However once your body has died, and cannot be saved…by all means use what can be used to save another. My family has directions to do that with me (whatever they can as I have a heart condition, so no one wants my heart.)

Dan, you did not answer the question about turning down organs since by your explanation all cellular activity must stop before the soul leaves, that pretty much rules out any organ transplant. Since you believe that removeing organs before the soul has left is murder, then I assume you will not accept a organ donation?

Also what about blood. If the soul is in every living cell in the body how does that apply to blood cells in a transfusion.

One more thing, do you have Church doctrine to back up your claims?
Thank you for your thoughtful comments. I will try to answer all the questions you asked.

I would not accept donated organs, if those organs were vital organs without a duplicate which means their removal killed the donor. Some organs, like a kidney, can be donated from a donor who survives the procedure and goes on living (because they have another kidney). That is fine. The same thing goes for blood donation. There are also some tissues which can be donated, after death has actually occured. But as far as organs like heart, which can only be harvested by killing the donor, no I would not accept them, as to do so is to cooperate with the intentional killing of another person.

Yes, I do have Church doctrine to back me up. The Church teaches the soul is what animates the body. Death occur when the soul seperates from the body. So if the body is animated, the soul is present, and the person is not dead.

The Church also teaches that the direct taking of a human life is a violation of the commandment “thous shall not kill” except for: killing in a just war, the death penalty justly carried out by the state, killing in self defense. Those are the only three exceptions. Just as we have no right to commit suicied, we have no right to donate organs if the donation process ends our life, and others have no right to take them if it kills us.

Your comments about being able to “save” someone seem to point towards a sliding scale of death. Someone can be completely beyond the help of medecine, be dying, and still be alive. There is a huge difference between a dying person and a dead one. One is alive, the other is not. Death has nothing to do with medical capabilities. If it did, someone in the US might be alive, but someone in a 3rd world country is “dead”. Or someone is “dead” today, but in 50 years, a person in the exact same condition is now considered alive because of new medical techonolgies.

Death is when the soul leaves the body. The argument that brain function or heart function is the sole determinant of death is easily proven false:

A human being can live their entire life and die…and never even have a brain or a heart, let alone function of either. We have a soul from the moment of our creation. We don’t have a heart. We don’t have a brain. We do have a body and a soul. Every single person has been alive at a time when they had no brain function and no heartbeat. So if human life exists without those things, their absence cannot be the determinant of death.

I hope that answers your questions.

Can you answer my question of why “brain dead” donors need to be sedated and restrained while their organs are removed, if they are really dead?

Pax and God bless.
 
Can you answer my question of why “brain dead” donors need to be sedated and restrained while their organs are removed, if they are really dead?
It depends on various individual circumstances, but anesthesia is usually given to keep the organs perfused (with blood) and maintain blood pressure. Muscle relaxants also make it easier to make an incision. It has nothing to do with what I think you are assuming, which is that they are somehow still “alive”.

It’s important to understand that the brain dead patient is on a ventilator, which ensures that the blood is receiving oxygen, and as long as the heart is receiving oxygen, it can beat. That patient is not actually breathing. When the ventilator is removed, everything shuts down.

The bottom line is that the Catholic Church recognizes both neurological and cardiopulmonary criteria as sufficient proof of death. Some posters have pointed out some good articles which would be beneficial to read, and I would suggest familiarizing yourself more with some of the medical terminology. You seem to be promoting a viewpoint that is not supported by the Church, and have yet to provide any church documentation supporting your views.
 
The truth is no one knows for a certainty when death occurs. Scientists are finding out that death is more of a gradual process,rather than reaching some arbitrary point, set by lack of vital signs, as in brain death. I used to be really into the nature of consciousness, so I read a lot on the subject.

I don’t have time now to link to articles, but here is one.

I don’t know if this was already quoted in the thread previous to this one.
 
i see nothing wrong with an organ transplant. if a church is shutting down, and has an organ, and theres another one that needs an organ, there is absoultely no problem with moving it from church A to church B.

😃
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top