Morality of satire

  • Thread starter Thread starter Soler
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
S

Soler

Guest
Because satire involves mocking other peoples sins/faults, I am wondering whether or not it is okay to find it amusing. For instance, is it morally acceptable to find the actions of the pigs in George Orwell’s Animal Farm amusing?
 
Wow. I say this with all humility, I’m not trying to be sarcastic, witty, or anything else.

Lighten up!!!

It’s okay to laugh, have fun, enjoy a good yarn or joke. When my buddies and I hang out, we pull no punches. If one doesn’t fire back with a insult, we’re all like, “Wow! What’s your problem?!” When one recently got married, I gave the toast, and boy did I have a field day! He wanted to kill me, and all the guests where howling in laughter. So have fun!

Oscar Wilde is the master of satire and wit, and I read him all the time. One of the funniest writers who ever lived.

Animal Farm is a great book, Orwell is a magnificent writer.

Enjoy your life my friend.
 
The examples you note portray the foibles of humankind, not of an identifiable individual. I think this is the critical distinction. People are funny, but it is wrong to ridicule an individual.
 
I don’t think that satire as a device to make a political point is wrong.

I don’t think that satire as a device to show someone that their view/position is wrong is sinful.

Aren’t public figures are fair game for ridicule, by the way?
 
Perhaps it can be said that certain satire is not wrong…and some is…
 
Thanks for all your replies.
One of the main points that concerns me regarding satire is that it intends, by its very nature, to be witty, and therefore often aims to make people laugh at the sins of others. And is it okay to laugh at evil?
 
To laugh at evil, to disrespect that which does not come from God; an interesting question. I guess it depends on the level of evil. Satirizing vain or ignorant people, ala Saturday Night Live, while it may often be in bad taste, is not unlike what Jesus did with regard to the Pharisees. Satire actually makes fun of the human condition and is therefore self-effacing. It’s cathartic. Satirizing some horrible thing, that is deserving of solemn respect for those who have suffered, like the Holocaust or 9-11, transcends taste and is evil in itself; no laughing matter.
 
Thanks for all your replies.
One of the main points that concerns me regarding satire is that it intends, by its very nature, to be witty, and therefore often aims to make people laugh at the sins of others. And is it okay to laugh at evil?
I have no problem laughing at evil. I’m sure the devil hates being laughed at. 😉 We shouldn’t underestimate the power of humor as a weapon against the evil one. There is no one more serious than the demons.

I think Bookcat is right. Some is good and some is bad. Historically-speaking, satire has been a useful instrument whereby those who are suffering at the hands of their leaders can criticize the powers-that-be in ways that won’t get censored. The history of satire goes back to antiquity.

I can see your dilemma, though. Nowadays, comedians often hide behind “satire” as though it gives them carte blanche to be tactless, offensive, and utter every imagineable profanity. That’s not really satire, though.
 
To laugh at evil, to disrespect that which does not come from God; an interesting question. I guess it depends on the level of evil. Satirizing vain or ignorant people, ala Saturday Night Live, while it may often be in bad taste, is not unlike what Jesus did with regard to the Pharisees. Satire actually makes fun of the human condition and is therefore self-effacing. It’s cathartic. Satirizing some horrible thing, that is deserving of solemn respect for those who have suffered, like the Holocaust or 9-11, transcends taste and is evil in itself; no laughing matter.
I agree.

About 20 years ago, there was a radio duo on Chicago radio, Steve Dahl formerly of Detroit Radio and I forget the other guy’s name. I used to listen to them frequently, although they used to push the bounds of good taste.

I remember one of they saying “time plus tragedy equals comedy”, and to some extent that may have some validity. Some in the sense that some bad things that happen are far too evil for us to accept or comprehend. They were satirizing Jeffrey Dahmer (the killer that stored his victims body parts in his fridge) years ago.

What humor could be found in such an occurance of evil is difficult to grasp, but years later I do understand this as perhaps a very lame attempt at shock humor, perhaps underscored by an attempt to laugh off or deny something as fundamentally evil as Dahmer’s actions.

Yes, interesting question to consider true evil as a matter for satire. On one hand, it perhaps can make evil less threatening, which could be good or bad. On the other, it reinforces our triumph over evil that we have (though rarely addressing the source of our victory, Jesus Christ).
 
I remember one of they saying “time plus tragedy equals comedy”, and to some extent that may have some validity.
That is an interesting theory. I wonder if it holds true. At present, it seems incomprehensible for someone to make jokes about the Holocaust or 9/11. But those events are still so recent. Could there ever be a time when it wouldn’t be wildly inappropriate? I can’t imagine.

Yet, you have people like Mel Brooks joking about the Spanish Inquisition in one of his movies. I’m sure it was no laughing matter at the time. However, now that we are so far removed from both the victims and the perpetrators, not many would be offended.

I came across this article written by a journalist who followed around a Catholic priest (Fr. Frechette) in Haiti following the earthquake. Fr. Frechette is from Connecticut, but he has been serving in Haiti for over 20 years. (Warning: this article is a little raw in places)
He knows it, too, and figures that second only to his faith in a God that orders the universe even amidst the apparent chaos, humor is his salvation. He tells me he read somewhere that a normal reaction to a normal thing is normal, and an abnormal reaction to an abnormal thing is normal. But a normal reaction to an abnormal thing is abnormal. Even so, there’s a “hierarchy of maturity,” he says. You can become a “psychological fetus,” upon witnessing horrors like Haiti’s, which makes you a burden to everybody, as the problem becomes comforting you. You can become angry, blaming everyone or everything. But the most productive abnormal reaction, he says, is to find laughter. He does that, he reasons, and it keeps him moving. And he always has to keep moving.
The “humor” that Fr. Frechette makes use of is not satire, but I thought it was interesting nonetheless. Sometimes, when faced with such profound evil, all you can do is laugh to keep from crying.
 
Satire most often ridicules not an individual’s sins but rather a faulty belief, principle, or set of beliefs.

If a system or position is ridiculous, then by definition ridicule is warranted.

Furthermore, as others have pointed out, even if it is an individual being ridiculed directly - and not a belief system - that character may not exist.

That said, there is satire in which real individuals are attacked. For example: JibJab’s “He’s Barack Obama” superhero parody.

I don’t think that video, as an example, is sinful, because it’s not mean-spirited nor personal. If some satire is wrong, it’s not because of the object of the act of satire is immoral, but rather because it is done cruelly.

Finally, and perhaps most importantly, I think it is absolutely okay to laugh at evil. One of the most powerful abilities of good comedy is to totally ruin the glorification of evil by portraying it as ridiculous.
 
Yet, you have people like Mel Brooks joking about the Spanish Inquisition in one of his movies. I’m sure it was no laughing matter at the time. However, now that we are so far removed from both the victims and the perpetrators, not many would be offended.
You hit on an interesting point. Mel Brooks is a Jew, and Jews were among the primary targets of the Spanish Inquisition. Brooks isn’t so much justified by time as he is by circumstance. Through satire he calls attention to prejudice, which is an eternal condition of man. By parodying the ugliness of prejudice in it’s most extreme form, he reveals the absurdity of it’s less virulent variety. As a Jew he can do that, because he has experienced prejudice.
 
A recent Jewish article seems pertinent to this:
Our society thrives on embarrassing others. It’s time to stop. Imagine what the world would look like if the news media and popular culture would carefully observed the Torah’s commandment not to embarrass someone else in public. Our Sages actually compare it to murder, noting that when someone is embarrassed all the blood drains from their face.
Many of the daytime talk shows and reality TV would be gone. Even American Idol would cease. The Star and The National Enquirer, People magazine and US would likely fold. Airwaves would go silent and newspapers would shrink even further than they have already. . . .
It goes on to highlight the prime offenders Teachers, Parents, and Spouses.
 
A recent Jewish article seems pertinent to this:

It goes on to highlight the prime offenders Teachers, Parents, and Spouses.
Where does the author get the interpretation that the Torah commands us not to embarrass someone publicly? Is the passage in question really referring to satirical embarrassment or to some other form which may not quite relate to satire? Are there any Scriptural passages (NT or OT) which might actually lend support to the use of satire? If so, how/to what degree would they lend this support?

Isn’t God Himself said, in some places of the OT, to “laugh” at men in his sinful folly, if we are to take Him “laughing” here literally.

And, if the Torah clearly commands us not to embarrass others in public, doesn’t that settle the issue once and for all?

Still, haven’t there even been Catholic satirists in the past…?

I’ve always seen satire as making fun of the actions of individuals or groups of people, humorously calling them out for the ridiculousness that they are. After all, I think, sometimes you’ve got to be a little harsh to get your point across. Isn’t this even supported in some places in Sacred Scripture? Christ wasn’t all sweetness and lollipops all the time, certainly with the Pharisees, at least as far as I (I think, reasonably) interpret his words and likely tone of them, nor was Paul always nicey-nice to those in sin or even in opposition to him, as I recall. Sometimes a little public shame is good, is it not?

Again, though, the Torah thing is a little concerning, though.

As a classicist, I have always found both the satires of Horace and of Juvenal yet funny today. Sure, Horace is a bit milder and Juvenal is, by many, considered much more harsh, though I think even he is mocking more the behaviors of his targets than the targets themselves, or, at least, even if he is mocking his targets with malice, at least, we might read him as simply mocking their behaviors and get enjoyment out of him that way. Both of them, it would seem, are kind of trying to poke society in the ribs a little to get it to “wake up” and take notice of its follies, at least as these satirists see them.

On the Catholic side of the equation, Alexander Pope comes to mind, though, from what I’ve read, some of the theology in his writings was rather questionable and he certainly made enemies.

So, what do you all think with this in mind? Of Horace? Of Juvenal? Of Pope? And, what of the Torah?

Again, particularly as a classicist who enjoys Roman and contemporary satire, I “have a dog in the fight”, if you’ll forgive the metaphor, and I am thus very eager to hear your responses.

Also, could the poster who mentioned that Jesus rather satirized the Jewish leaders of His day elaborate on this?
 
(Sorry for posting another reply. 20-minute editing time expired!)

I was just thinking that, perhaps the Torah passage was speaking of maliciously damaging the person’s reputation because you have some hatred toward him/her? As I argued before, it would seem that satire’s main intent is to mock the ridiculousness of a particular behavior of a person or group rather than to personally (in an “ad hominem” way) attack anyone.

Then again, sometimes satire appears to be used to rant (for lack of a better word) about the ills of society, thus expressing an author’s own disdain for them. Being angry about society’s ills, last I checked, was not a sin, and expressing that anger before others can sometimes motivate even them to do something about it or at least to commiserate with the author and to keep their own behavior from falling into what he/she criticizes because he/she sees the ills in it. Such is much of the character of Juvenalian satire. I think much of this really comes down to intent/motivation?

Honestly, I think this topic needs much greater fleshing out. Anyone?

And what about Colbert…? 😉
 
Also, I now recall that Paul somewhere, when criticizing those who would wish to impose circumcision on the Christians, basically asked rhetorically why they did not go all the way and castrate (can I say that on here?) themselves. I mean, that’s pretty biting, don’t you think? And, somehow, I think there may be other Pauline examples that are not now coming to my mind.

Also, I do recall Church Fathers who were not always sugar and spice at least when it came to attacking opposition.

Ah! And, this brings up yet another point: Can Christian satirists morally attack other Christians, if they believe those Christians are sinning or acting in some very foolish manner? Ifso, what would be the limits to this, if any? Should their satire be simply, as it were, a little tap on the shoulder saying, “Hey, this is ridiculous. You might want to look at this!” Or, are we permitted to be more biting, depending on the circumstances of the particular case?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top