A recent Jewish article seems pertinent to this:
It goes on to highlight the prime offenders Teachers, Parents, and Spouses.
Where does the author get the interpretation that the Torah commands us not to embarrass someone publicly? Is the passage in question really referring to satirical embarrassment or to some other form which may not quite relate to satire? Are there any Scriptural passages (NT or OT) which might actually lend support to the use of satire? If so, how/to what degree would they lend this support?
Isn’t God Himself said, in some places of the OT, to “laugh” at men in his sinful folly, if we are to take Him “laughing” here literally.
And, if the Torah clearly commands us not to embarrass others in public, doesn’t that settle the issue once and for all?
Still, haven’t there even been Catholic satirists in the past…?
I’ve always seen satire as making fun of the actions of individuals or groups of people, humorously calling them out for the ridiculousness that they are. After all, I think, sometimes you’ve got to be a little harsh to get your point across. Isn’t this even supported in some places in Sacred Scripture? Christ wasn’t all sweetness and lollipops all the time, certainly with the Pharisees, at least as far as I (I think, reasonably) interpret his words and likely tone of them, nor was Paul always nicey-nice to those in sin or even in opposition to him, as I recall. Sometimes a little public shame is good, is it not?
Again, though, the Torah thing is a little concerning, though.
As a classicist, I have always found both the satires of Horace and of Juvenal yet funny today. Sure, Horace is a bit milder and Juvenal is, by many, considered much more harsh, though I think even he is mocking more the behaviors of his targets than the targets themselves, or, at least, even if he is mocking his targets with malice, at least, we might read him as simply mocking their behaviors and get enjoyment out of him that way. Both of them, it would seem, are kind of trying to poke society in the ribs a little to get it to “wake up” and take notice of its follies, at least as these satirists see them.
On the Catholic side of the equation, Alexander Pope comes to mind, though, from what I’ve read, some of the theology in his writings was rather questionable and he certainly made enemies.
So, what do you all think with this in mind? Of Horace? Of Juvenal? Of Pope? And, what of the Torah?
Again, particularly as a classicist who enjoys Roman and contemporary satire, I “have a dog in the fight”, if you’ll forgive the metaphor, and I am thus very eager to hear your responses.
Also, could the poster who mentioned that Jesus rather satirized the Jewish leaders of His day elaborate on this?