continued from my previous post.
OK, here’s the Catholic Catechism answering the question in its usual abstract and vague way:
1735 Imputability and responsibility for an action can be diminished or even nullified by ignorance, inadvertence, duress, fear, habit, inordinate attachments, and other psychological or social factors.
So, the short answer to one of your situations is, your guilt and responsibility for lying is diminished or even nullified because of duress.
Somebody’s life is at stake, so you lie to save it.
So, lying to the Nazis to save a life is not wrong.
Lying under oath in a courtroom, where the defendant’s life is at stake is another matter.
You have sworn to tell the truth and you must. Although, you might lie out of fear for your life, if you believe it to be threatened.
St Paul tells us, stop sinning…God is not mocked.
In addition to duress, lying to the Nazis is not a sin because of social factors (which are too numerous to mention in paragraph 1735).
1735 is part of a discussion of human freedom. When the Nazis are hunting for Jews in your house, you are not operating under perfect freedom, but, in fact, under no freedom at all.
In the Old Testament, there is scriptural validation for 1735. There is described how a man takes a married slave woman out of lust and commits adultery with her. He is guilty of adultery but she is not, because she does not have freedom.
I have asked many priests and the “ask an apologist” thread for a full discussion of 1735, and no one wants to answer me. IF 1735 is valid (and it is part of the Catechism – the deposit of faith – you MUST believe it) then it mean that you don’t have to confess an action under those terms, even if otherwise it would be considered a mortal sin.
1735 is really about the mercy of God and his judgment. It’s not just legalistic mumbo jumbo. It is for this reason that any of us should not pass judgment (at all, in the first place) of anybody, if we want God’s mercy to take full effect.
The Catechism describes homosexual conduct as “grave matter” but it does not come right out and condemn it as mortal sin – because, in general, of the considerations in 1735. Does a same-sex-attracted person really have complete freedom to avoid this “disordered” conduct? Most homosexuals would say not. Most homosexuals would say that they would prefer to not be that way (watch some “coming out” videos on
youtube.com).
Suicide is self-murder. That would be a mortal sin. But, Fr. Ron Rohlheiser has written in national publications about suicide is a disease and we shouldn’t judge the suicide. And, that the Church’s attitude (towards funerals, for example) has changed.
We have to tread very lightly and withhold judgment. Let God decide.
I tried to pose the question about the meaning of 1735 to Fr. Mitch Pacwa on his EWTN Live program. Lo and behold, I got an answer written by a third person that the question was TOO COMPLICATED to discuss on TV. Imagine that! That one sentence is too complicated to discuss on TV.