Morality question

  • Thread starter Thread starter newbiefound
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
N

newbiefound

Guest
The other day I was at an abortion referral place that hands out contraception and someone yelled out “WOOO ABORTION YEAAAH” as they were driving by and impulsively I said yelled “Fool” not like a scream or anything but definitely a yell. I was surprised that it came out. Everyone reprimanded me for it and told me that I should stay quiet and just pray. But I told them that zeal is a good thing and that anger isn’t bad if it’s directed at something evil.
 
The other day I was at an abortion referral place that hands out contraception and someone yelled out “WOOO ABORTION YEAAAH” as they were driving by and impulsively I said yelled “Fool” not like a scream or anything but definitely a yell. I was surprised that it came out. Everyone reprimanded me for it and told me that I should stay quiet and just pray. But I told them that zeal is a good thing and that anger isn’t bad if it’s directed at something evil.
I would suspect that the person who hollered out did so to try and arouse an emotion in one of the protesters, which worked. I would guess that those who reprimanded you did so that you would not lower yourself to the same level of the knucklehead in the car whose gutless drive-by-announcement reflected absolute ignorance and immaturity.
 
I don’t mean to stray from the topic, but can someone please explain to me what good it does to protest outside of abortion clinics and places in which people go to obtain contraception? I do acknowledge that we have the right as U.S. citizens to peacefully protest, but it doesn’t stop the people from going in. Whenever I see media coverage about these demonstrations, the impression that I get is that those people are nuts. (I know not all of the protests aren’t as rash and disturbing, but the ones that are make Catholics look really bad). Wouldn’t it do so much more good to find a less dramatic way to push for the cause? I am pro-life, I just think that there must be a more productive way than picket in front of these places.
 
The other day I was at an abortion referral place that hands out contraception and someone yelled out “WOOO ABORTION YEAAAH” as they were driving by and impulsively I said yelled “Fool” not like a scream or anything but definitely a yell. I was surprised that it came out. Everyone reprimanded me for it and told me that I should stay quiet and just pray. But I told them that zeal is a good thing and that anger isn’t bad if it’s directed at something evil.
Pax tecum!

Well, the person was a fool to yell something stupid like that out. I don’t think you did anything wrong.

In Christ,
Rand
 
I don’t mean to stray from the topic, but can someone please explain to me what good it does to protest outside of abortion clinics and places in which people go to obtain contraception? I do acknowledge that we have the right as U.S. citizens to peacefully protest, but it doesn’t stop the people from going in. Whenever I see media coverage about these demonstrations, the impression that I get is that those people are nuts. (I know not all of the protests aren’t as rash and disturbing, but the ones that are make Catholics look really bad). Wouldn’t it do so much more good to find a less dramatic way to push for the cause? I am pro-life, I just think that there must be a more productive way than picket in front of these places.
It’s extremely productive when peaceful demonstrators, particularly those “armed” with the Rosary, encounter women who are willing to reconsider having an abortion. I have a number of friends who regularly pray and counsel young women approaching a local abortuary; by God’s grace they have been able to help these mothers see the beauty of the child they are carrying and have followed through after the change-of-heart with seeing that they receive proper medical care and other necessities during the pregnancies and after.
 
It’s extremely productive when peaceful demonstrators, particularly those “armed” with the Rosary, encounter women who are willing to reconsider having an abortion. I have a number of friends who regularly pray and counsel young women approaching a local abortuary; by God’s grace they have been able to help these mothers see the beauty of the child they are carrying and have followed through after the change-of-heart with seeing that they receive proper medical care and other necessities during the pregnancies and after.
No offense to anyone, but I guess I would actually have to see that to believe it. The only experiences I have seen are negative, such as name-calling, throwing things…etc. I think that the stigma of picketing is automatically viewed by people as negative and annoying. Maybe if there was only a couple of women and a table set up with a sign and some reading material, it would make for a calmer approach to couseling the women who are willing to accept. I had a friend who “tricked” me into giving her a ride to an abortion clinic a few years ago. I was up in arms over the whole situation, and no longer talk to her. But the demonstrators that approached her after I told her to get out of my car seemed anything but spiritual, God-fearing people.

Thanks for the insight though 😃
 
No offense to anyone, but I guess I would actually have to see that to believe it. The only experiences I have seen are negative, such as name-calling, throwing things…etc. I think that the stigma of picketing is automatically viewed by people as negative and annoying. Maybe if there was only a couple of women and a table set up with a sign and some reading material, it would make for a calmer approach to couseling the women who are willing to accept. I had a friend who “tricked” me into giving her a ride to an abortion clinic a few years ago. I was up in arms over the whole situation, and no longer talk to her. But the demonstrators that approached her after I told her to get out of my car seemed anything but spiritual, God-fearing people.

Thanks for the insight though 😃
It is, of course, “negative and annoying” to those who are having their “choice” so visibly questioned, but moreso to the providers who have a vested interest in seeing that no one is dissuaded from using their services. But I want to reiterate that all the Catholics I know who faithfully bring a pro-life presence to those places of death do so in a very loving, prayerful manner and have met with much success in turning women aside from the killing of their babies (and of their own souls). Such a result is well-worth whatever criticism is leveled at their activity.
 
Picketing is another form of parading. Catholics should never be reluctant to parade their values before a godless society. How else are we to get the word out, since the media and academia
have effectively stifled the Catholic point of view?
 
I don’t mean to stray from the topic, but can someone please explain to me what good it does to protest outside of abortion clinics and places in which people go to obtain contraception? I do acknowledge that we have the right as U.S. citizens to peacefully protest, but it doesn’t stop the people from going in. Whenever I see media coverage about these demonstrations, the impression that I get is that those people are nuts. (I know not all of the protests aren’t as rash and disturbing, but the ones that are make Catholics look really bad). Wouldn’t it do so much more good to find a less dramatic way to push for the cause? I am pro-life, I just think that there must be a more productive way than picket in front of these places.
Prayer, esp. the Rosary, is the most powerful weapon we have! 🙂 I’ve been praying in front of abortion clinics since I was an early teen. My first experience brought me to tears the entire time, because I was adopted and my birthmom had only been 17 yrs old when she had me. The thought that she could have chosen this, but instead chose to give me life and offer me to a loving family made me even sadder for these poor women. The security guard in front of the abortion clinic was very shaken up by my tears, as he kept looking at me the whole time we were there. That was witness enough - to make him think.

I have prayed off and on and I know that where I went to school, there have been 3 abortion clinics shut down in the area (one has to travel almost an hour to go to one from where my school is) due to this peaceful prayer. Plus, we’re there also to support the sidewalk counselors who approach these women with pamphlets, not shoving them in their faces, but I can say that I highly doubt a woman would go to a table that was set up. Her goal is to get in there, and if it’s not her goal, it’s her parents’ or her boyfriend’s. We’ve had quite a few turnarounds just through this, and one life saved is worth all this :). And of course, the media will take the exceptions and blow them out of proportion - after all they do have an agenda in mind. 😦
 
The other day I was at an abortion referral place that hands out contraception and someone yelled out “WOOO ABORTION YEAAAH” as they were driving by and impulsively I said yelled “Fool” not like a scream or anything but definitely a yell. I was surprised that it came out. Everyone reprimanded me for it and told me that I should stay quiet and just pray. But I told them that zeal is a good thing and that anger isn’t bad if it’s directed at something evil.
Isn’t that simply a short form of saying , “Your being foolish.”

Just a thought.

AndyF
 
Matthew 5:22
But I say unto you, That whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment: and whosoever shall say to his brother, Raca, shall be in danger of the council: but whosoever shall say, Thou fool, shall be in danger of hell fire.
 
Matthew 5:22
But I say unto you, That whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment: and whosoever shall say to his brother, Raca, shall be in danger of the council: but whosoever shall say, Thou fool, shall be in danger of hell fire.
NAB reads…

22 “What I say to you is; everyone who grows angry with his brother shall be liable to judgement; and any man who uses abusive language toward his brother shall be answerable to the Sanhedrin, and if he holds him in contempt he risks the fires of Gehenna.”

You have the context right and it IS anger, and not correctional. Thanks for bringing that to light.

AndyF
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top