More chance or no chance?

  • Thread starter Thread starter twinc
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

twinc

Guest
probably a very unwelcome question but I have always wondered whether the mentally --afflicted have more chance or no chance of salvation and under the circumstances can one even be a Christian - are these included in salvation for all mankind - twinc
 
probably a very unwelcome question but I have always wondered whether the mentally --afflicted have more chance or no chance of salvation and under the circumstances can one even be a Christian - are these included in salvation for all mankind - twinc
For a start a Christian is anyone validly baptised with water in the name of the Father, and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit and that applies to everyone, mentally impaired or not.
Beyond the age of reason if a person is mentally impaired to the extent that they do not and will never know right from wrong then they cannot commit a mortal sin. A Catholic dying free from mortal sin is saved.
 
For a start a Christian is anyone validly baptised with water in the name of the Father, and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit and that applies to everyone, mentally impaired or not.
Beyond the age of reason if a person is mentally impaired to the extent that they do not and will never know right from wrong then they cannot commit a mortal sin. A Catholic dying free from mortal sin is saved.
so what was the real question ? - twinc
 
A mentally impaired person has the same culpability as a child with the same mental capacity…so, there is no definite answer to the question in the OP. So the answer would seem to lie in the degree of mental impairment.

It would seem, though, that a person with full mental capacity has more opportunity to willfully sin, and make it much easier to reject tthe Gospel message.
 
A mentally impaired person has the same culpability as a child with the same mental capacity…so, there is no definite answer to the question in the OP. So the answer would seem to lie in the degree of mental impairment.

It would seem, though, that a person with full mental capacity has more opportunity to willfully sin, and make it much easier to reject tthe Gospel message.
so all the clever ones with the answers had better plead insanity without in most cases pleading amiss - twinc
 
They are responsible for their actions, they are sinners and if they do not repent they are doomed as clearly illustrated in the Holy Word. So yes they have a chance, but it depends on a case by case basis, if they haven’t accepted the teachings then they will be doomed for all eternity.
 
probably a very unwelcome question but I have always wondered whether the mentally --afflicted have more chance or no chance of salvation and under the circumstances can one even be a Christian - are these included in salvation for all mankind - twinc
this is my personal opinion as I have heard of saints who have spoken of it but never seen an official church teaching, and I base it on having family members with mental health, developmental delays, personality disorders, cognitive impairment and other disabilities, as well as working with people of all ages with any number of disabilities in preparation for sacraments. It is my opinion that those who cannot respond to catechesis and religious education with full powers of the intellect and will through no fault of their own are under the direct tutelege of the Holy Spirit himself and he takes over their spiritual formation. I think that is one meaning at least of the verse that says he prays for use in unintelligible groanings when we cannot pray for ourselves. It think since they are the least of these that Christ speaks of they are therefore first in the kingdom of heaven.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top