More than 1 heaven, more than 1 hell?

  • Thread starter Thread starter DL82
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
D

DL82

Guest
It was a book with origins in Eastern Christianity that got me thinking about this ( forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=229801 )

But I don’t even know for sure what the Western rite of the Catholic Church thinks on this issue.

Is there more than 1 heaven? Is there more than 1 hell?

I don’t mean more than one meaning of the word ‘heaven’, I know it can mean the sky, the realm of God, or the place of our eternal reward. I don’t mean more than one meaning of ‘hell’, again I realise it can mean ‘the bowels of the earth’, ‘the abode of all the dead before Christ’ or ‘the place of eternal damnation’.

I’m talking strictly in the sense that ‘heaven’=‘the place of our eternal reward’/ ‘hell’=‘the place of eternal damnation’.

Is there more than 1 heaven? Is there more than 1 hell? If so, is this Doctrine, Tradition, pious supposition or opinion? If there is more than 1 heaven, how can some be happier than others? Is the joy of the lower heavens imperfect? If there is more than 1 hell, how can anything make the separation from God any better or any worse? Are those in the higher hells allowed some joy in spite of their torment? Can people move between the layers, or is it finally decided at death?

Just curious.

DL
 
There does seem to be a Biblical mention of levels of punishment in Hell and reward in Heaven. Though this neither implies nor denies the existence of different places for these
 
Better be! There are too many members of sect A who are morally certain that no member of sect B or religious background X can possibly attain salvation. This is not to mention the ones who don’t want to be in the same end place as so-and-so. God will have to hide them somewhere!

Matthew
 
Better be! There are too many members of sect A who are morally certain that no member of sect B or religious background X can possibly attain salvation. This is not to mention the ones who don’t want to be in the same end place as so-and-so. God will have to hide them somewhere!
…what? :confused:
No one in Heaven is going to be upset that someone else is in Heaven with them. :ehh:
 
Ive never heard of there being more than one heaven or one hell, in all my years at a catholic school. Im pretty sure the bible has never mentioned this either. This would be a good topic to discuss though and can be very interesting.
 
2Cor.12
[1] It is not expedient for me doubtless to glory. I will come to visions and revelations of the Lord.
[2] I knew a man in Christ above fourteen years ago, (whether in the body, I cannot tell; or whether out of the body, I cannot tell: God knoweth;) such an one caught up to the third heaven.
[3] And I knew such a man, (whether in the body, or out of the body, I cannot tell: God knoweth;)
[4] How that he was caught up into paradise, and heard unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter.
[5] Of such an one will I glory: yet of myself I will not glory, but in mine infirmities.
 
It was a book with origins in Eastern Christianity that got me thinking about this ( forums.catholic-questions.org/showthread.php?t=229801 )

But I don’t even know for sure what the Western rite of the Catholic Church thinks on this issue.

Is there more than 1 heaven? Is there more than 1 hell?

I don’t mean more than one meaning of the word ‘heaven’, I know it can mean the sky, the realm of God, or the place of our eternal reward. I don’t mean more than one meaning of ‘hell’, again I realise it can mean ‘the bowels of the earth’, ‘the abode of all the dead before Christ’ or ‘the place of eternal damnation’.

I’m talking strictly in the sense that ‘heaven’=‘the place of our eternal reward’/ ‘hell’=‘the place of eternal damnation’.

Is there more than 1 heaven? Is there more than 1 hell? If so, is this Doctrine, Tradition, pious supposition or opinion? If there is more than 1 heaven, how can some be happier than others? Is the joy of the lower heavens imperfect? If there is more than 1 hell, how can anything make the separation from God any better or any worse? Are those in the higher hells allowed some joy in spite of their torment? Can people move between the layers, or is it finally decided at death?

Just curious.

DL
I think the answer you are looking for is that there are different levels of the same place. different degrees of reward in heaven and different levels of punishment in hell. Yes even though all of heaven is eternal reward and all of hell is eternal punishment. justice requires that hell have greater and lesser degrees of pain based on the offences against God. you don’t treat a rapist and a petty thief quite the same. although they may both end up in the same place. in heaven those who love God more and give God more of themselves are capable a recieveing more of him. Differing degrees of the same places.
 
There are traditions that talk about 7 levels of Heaven with the Archangel Michael in the 7th where God sits on his Throne. There is also a part in Corinthians where the Apostle Paul talks about a 3rd heaven.

Dante’s Inferno gives around 7 reigns of Hell. Seperated by the 7 deadly sins I believe. Gluttons would have different punishments than murderers or heretics
 
This idea seems to contradict reason.
  1. Hell is a state of eternal separation from God.
  2. The separation from God in hell is absolute; there can be no joy since God is joy, there can be no good, since God is good,… ad infinitum.
    -Now, if we postulate that there are different levels of hell, then we must also say that there are different levels of separation from God in hell, id est that those who are in hell (at least those in the “upper levels of hell”) are not really absolutely separated from God, rather they are just, oh, far away.
    That’s a twisted view of hell if I ever saw one.
Same goes for heave.
  1. Heaven is a state of absolute knowing God, of being in His Presence and in the glorified state; the Beatific vision.
  2. Such a state means an absolute “closeness” to the Trinity, a partaking in the divine life.
    -So, if we say that there are different levels of heaven, a knowing of God in a state of such absolute blessedness is nor really absolute, but only relative. Thus, we then know God only relatively.
    Don’t you think that such a segregation would contradict God’s plan for man?
    This idea sounds kinda like limbo.
    But, if such an idea were true, then Gods plan for man would be an incomplete one, for if man is created to be in the absolute presence of God, then nothing less that that can fulfill his purpose, his nature. So, those who would be in the “lower levels” of heaven wouldn’t really be in heaven. They would only be “really really really” close to the real deal.
The justice argument, mentioned above, has nothing to do with the idea of levels in heaven and hell.
You either choose God, whether you are a rapist or a petty thief, or you turn you back on him, whether you are a “good person”.

Anything less than an absolute (therefore only one) state, heaven or hell, would render God’s plan for man flawed, I think.

So, God bless.
 
This idea seems to contradict reason.
  1. Hell is a state of eternal separation from God.
  2. The separation from God in hell is absolute; there can be no joy since God is joy, there can be no good, since God is good,… ad infinitum.
    -Now, if we postulate that there are different levels of hell, then we must also say that there are different levels of separation from God in hell, id est that those who are in hell (at least those in the “upper levels of hell”) are not really absolutely separated from God, rather they are just, oh, far away.
    That’s a twisted view of hell if I ever saw one.
Same goes for heave.
  1. Heaven is a state of absolute knowing God, of being in His Presence and in the glorified state; the Beatific vision.
  2. Such a state means an absolute “closeness” to the Trinity, a partaking in the divine life.
    -So, if we say that there are different levels of heaven, a knowing of God in a state of such absolute blessedness is nor really absolute, but only relative. Thus, we then know God only relatively.
    Don’t you think that such a segregation would contradict God’s plan for man?
    This idea sounds kinda like limbo.
    But, if such an idea were true, then Gods plan for man would be an incomplete one, for if man is created to be in the absolute presence of God, then nothing less that that can fulfill his purpose, his nature. So, those who would be in the “lower levels” of heaven wouldn’t really be in heaven. They would only be “really really really” close to the real deal.
The justice argument, mentioned above, has nothing to do with the idea of levels in heaven and hell.
You either choose God, whether you are a rapist or a petty thief, or you turn you back on him, whether you are a “good person”.

Anything less than an absolute (therefore only one) state, heaven or hell, would render God’s plan for man flawed, I think.

So, God bless.
ah then what of the talk in the bible about being least in heaven. indeed everything we know about heaven and hell tells us that we A don’t understand entirely what either one is heaven is greater and hell is worse then humanity can entirely understand.
B there are differing states. some lower some higher. different saints have told us this. there are different places in heaven and hell. we don’t entirely understand how that is but we do know that they are there. greater sinners suffer more and greater saints have greater joy. and no there is no jeaoulsy because each has there personal potential of joy. that is they are filled with God love to there individual ability to receive him. Some get more some get less but all are filled to there capacity to receive God. hope this helps.
 
ah then what of the talk in the bible about being least in heaven. indeed everything we know about heaven and hell tells us that we A don’t understand entirely what either one is heaven is greater and hell is worse then humanity can entirely understand.
B there are differing states. some lower some higher. different saints have told us this. there are different places in heaven and hell. we don’t entirely understand how that is but we do know that they are there. greater sinners suffer more and greater saints have greater joy. and no there is no jeaoulsy because each has there personal potential of joy. that is they are filled with God love to there individual ability to receive him. Some get more some get less but all are filled to there capacity to receive God. hope this helps.
Sure, I never proposed to understand the mystery of Heaven, only offered an opinion that maybe, like many other things in the Bible, the talk on the multitude of heavens should be taken not literally as in states of being as we know them on earth, or should be taken fully symbolically, as many things in the Apocalypse are. The idea of a multitude of different states of heaven, as it was presented, seems to me to be incompatible with God’s plan.
But, as always, I’m open to being wrong. I would really like to hear the opinion of SeekingCatholic, BlainerTog or Sarpedon on this one.
 
Sure, I never proposed to understand the mystery of Heaven, only offered an opinion that maybe, like many other things in the Bible, the talk on the multitude of heavens should be taken not literally as in states of being as we know them on earth, or should be taken fully symbolically, as many things in the Apocalypse are. The idea of a multitude of different states of heaven, as it was presented, seems to me to be incompatible with God’s plan.
But, as always, I’m open to being wrong. I would really like to hear the opinion of SeekingCatholic, BlainerTog or Sarpedon on this one.
a lot of the informaiton we have on heaven comes from extra biblical sources. some approved saints have spoken at length about heaven hell and purgatory. some saints were shown heaven and hell. I however think we take the bible literally much more often then we do not take it literally. but even if we don’t take it entirly literally. it does seem to suggest a class structure in heaven. Our Lady has attained a higher state of grace then we will. She has a special place in heaven. already there is one human who is set aside. been given higher grace then the rest. we know that a priest is a priest FOREVER. we don’t know the purpose he serves in heaven, but we know he is still a priest. with that distinct title. there are different level of grace in heaven. just as there are different people in heaven. all of them are totally fulfilled and full to the top with Gods grace. But they all have different potential for receiving Gods grace.
 
Didn’t Jesus say that it would be more tolerable for Sodom and Gomarrah then for Jerusalem on the day of judgement?

That would seem to me to indicate differing levels of punishment.

I would have to agree that there are different amounts of joy and happiness, after all St. Paul said that there are different levels of heaven.
 
a lot of the informaiton we have on heaven comes from extra biblical sources. some approved saints have spoken at length about heaven hell and purgatory. some saints were shown heaven and hell. I however think we take the bible literally much more often then we do not take it literally. but even if we don’t take it entirly literally. it does seem to suggest a class structure in heaven. Our Lady has attained a higher state of grace then we will. She has a special place in heaven. already there is one human who is set aside. been given higher grace then the rest. we know that a priest is a priest FOREVER. we don’t know the purpose he serves in heaven, but we know he is still a priest. with that distinct title. there are different level of grace in heaven. just as there are different people in heaven. all of them are totally fulfilled and full to the top with Gods grace. But they all have different potential for receiving Gods grace.
Sure, I agree good information can come from extra-biblical sources, but that doesn’t mean that every vision of heaven or hell had by a saint is valid as literal theology. Take the visions the children in Fatima had - they saw hell as a place engulfed in fire and brimstone, which would indicate a very simplistic view if it would be taken as an objective literal fact, without looking at the subjective way the human mind might experience a vision of a state that is beyond the normal human sensory data. We must, and I think every respectable theologian would agree here, when dealing with personal revelations and visions of such a type, take into account the way people experience such phenomena - the subjective factors, the limit of the unglorified human mind to understand a state of eternal happiness/separation, the way the vision is granted and the general context of the revelation.

That said, I want to tackle the levels of heaven/hell a bit more.

Now, what you seem to imply in the context of levels of heaven is that every person will get all the love they can receive, and the amount of love or joy or whatever the receive is, in fact, the measure of the level of heaven they are in. Correct?

But heaven is much more than just absorbing love from God. Heaven is a state of eternal closeness to God. So, how can one be perfectly close to God, yet be farther away than the other guy who’s in a grater level of heaven?
Also, being fulfilled with love is a subjective thing, as well as an objective reality - if God would chose to form such a structure of heaven wherein all of the people would be subjectively filled with as much love they can, but only some would be objectively filled with all the glorified man can - and that is absolute love in the strict sense - then we necessarily arrive at the conclusion that the “real” heaven - id est the subjectively and objectively perfect state of being - is reserved only for a few; the others get a “very close deal, but not the real thing”, since they are voided of a necessary dimension of eternal bliss.
But, how can you, at the same time be “absolutely close to God, to the extent of seeing Him, the Trinity in the beatific vision” and “yet not quite close as you can get.”
It’s logical mumbo-jumbo.

Also, I do not dismiss the passages in the Bible on “being the last in heaven”, rather, I believe that, like many, MANY things in the Bible it requires deeper study.
I can think of at least two ways it may be explained other than the rather simple “multitude of heavens” idea - one being that Jesus spoke relatively to value of the mans deeds in the light of the judgment wherein he would be placed in the state of heaven or hell, so his deeds would be qualified as “the least in the kingdom of heaven”, but not necessarily meaning that he himself would be granted entrance only the the firs floor of the heavenly skyscraper.
But, I’m sure there are far better theological explanations than this one, so I’ll leave that to the theologians, or at least wait till I get my doctorate 🙂

Also, I realize your statement concerning grace. But, if heaven is the state of absolute, glorified closeness to God, then the degrees or, ah, statuses of someone in heaven can only be viewed relatively to his/her position/role in the body of Christ.
Maybe there are differences in the roles of the faithful, just like there are in the Church Militant, but I would be very hesitant to say that the faithful will be granted different degrees of “being close to God”, based on their position, because of the reasons I gave above.
So, this would allow the Blessed Mother to be in a special position of the Mediatrix, and to be full of grace and so forth, but still retaining the single heaven view, since the Mother as well as the sons are in the same state of absolute vicinity to the Trinity, partaking in the same divine life.

Also, just to note, it seems that this view of “I’ve done better so I get a better place” is very close to pelagianism - we work our way into heaven and get the place we deserve.
That’s plain wrong.
If we were to get the place of higher glory, id est higher happiness in the sense of being objectively closer to God, based on the sum total of our works and faith then that would negate the necessity of God’s mercy for our salvation.
Don’t get me wrong, I know the deal with justification, but this is getting a place in heaven based on merit.
I think that can’t logically hold watter.

Anyway, God bless.
 
In the parables about the kingdom of heaven Jesus tells us the rewards will vary (Luke 19:11-27 - some given charge of 10 cities, some 5).
 
In the parables about the kingdom of heaven Jesus tells us the rewards will vary (Luke 19:11-27 - some given charge of 10 cities, some 5).
I’ve given an example above of how such parables (notice the literary figure our Lord uses, a parable - something that conveys the core meaning of his teaching, but is not to be taken literally to the extent of a historical event) can be reconciled with the oneness of heaven.

God bless.
 
Also, just to note, it seems that this view of “I’ve done better so I get a better place” is very close to pelagianism - we work our way into heaven and get the place we deserve.
That’s plain wrong.
If we were to get the place of higher glory, id est higher happiness in the sense of being objectively closer to God, based on the sum total of our works and faith then that would negate the necessity of God’s mercy for our salvation.
Don’t get me wrong, I know the deal with justification, but this is getting a place in heaven based on merit.
I think that can’t logically hold watter.

Anyway, God bless.
No you are not getting what I am saying. I said that every human has a different potential to receive grace. It has nothing to do with how close we stand to God or God not being as nice to some of us because he wants to. cotton burns a lot better then a brick. cotton burns when it even gets close to the fire. you could throw the brick in and It might not get started. All the sacraments depend on the disposition of those receiving them. Why do you think heaven would be different.

As for you interesting notion that I am a pelagian or even bordering on it. lets talk about the 200+ places where Jesus Christ speaks with his own mouth in the bible about exactly what it will take for you to get to heaven. every time he talks about what you do with the grace you are given. you can’t bury it in the back yard he says you must do something with it. and you will be judged on what you have done with what you had. implying that outcomes of that judgement will vary. else it would be a rubber stamp. no I stand by my first argument. perhaps I was unclear? okay now I am more clear. peace have a nice day. I look forward to your rebuttal.
 
I’ve given an example above of how such parables (notice the literary figure our Lord uses, a parable - something that conveys the core meaning of his teaching, but is not to be taken literally to the extent of a historical event) can be reconciled with the oneness of heaven.

God bless.
The following is from Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma:

The degree of perfection of the beatific vision granted to the just is proportioned to each one’s merits. (De fide)

The Decretum pro Graecis of the Union Council of Florence (1439) declared: The souls of the just “clearly behold the Triune and One God as He is, but corresponding to the difference of their merits, the one more perfectly than the other.” The council of Trent defined that the justified person merits an increase of the heavenly glory by good works. D 842

Opposed to the teaching of the Church is the teaching of Jovinian, who, influenced by the Stoics, taught that all virtues are of equal grade; opposed to it also is Luter’s doctrine of the external imputation of Christ’s justice. Both give rise to equality in the beatific vision.

Christ promised: “He (the Son of Man) will render to every one according to his works” (Mt 16:27). St. Paul teaches: “And every man shall receive his own reward, according to his own labour” (1 Cor. 3:8). “He who soweth sparingly shall also reap sparingly: and he that soweth in blessings shall also reap blessings” (2 Cor. 9:6). Cf. 1 Cor. 15:41 et seq.

The Fathers are fond of appealing to the words of Jesus concerning the many mansions in the Father’s House (John 14:2). Tertullian remarks: “Why are there many mansions in the Father’s house, if not on account of the difference of the merits?” (Scorp. 6). St. Augustine sees in the one penny which all the workers in the vineyard uniformly receive for varying durations of work (Mt. 20:1-16), an indication of eternal life, which is for all similarly of eternal duration; in the many mansions in the house of the Father (John 14:2) he sees a symbol of the various grades of remuneration in the one eternal life. To the objection that inequality gives rise to envy, he answers: “There will be no envy on account of the unequal glory, since the unity of love will reign in all” (In Ioan., tr. 67:2). Cf. St. Jerome, Adv. Iovin. II 18-34. S. th. I 12, 6.

Regarding Hell:
The punishment of the damned is proportioned to each one’s guilt. (Sent. Communis.)

The Union Councils of Lyons and of Florence declared that the souls of the damned are punished with unequal punishments (poenis tamen disparibus puniendas). D 464 693. This is probably intended to assert not merely a specific difference in the punishment of original sin (poena damni) and of personal sins (poena damni and poena sensus), but also a difference in the degree of punishment for personal sins.

Jesus threatens the inhabitants of Corazain and Bethsaida, on account of their slowness to repent, with a stricter judgment than the dwellers in Tyre and Sidon (Mt 11:22). The Scribes are to be subject to a particularly strict judgment (Luke 20:47).

St. Augustine teaches: “In their wretchedness the lot of some of the damned will be more tolerable than that of others” (Enchir. III). Justice demands that the punishment be commensurate with the guilt.

So far, have been unable to find anything in the Catechism that talks about degrees of merit in heaven. Seems to be very little about heaven and hell in the Catechism.

Nita
 
No you are not getting what I am saying. I said that every human has a different potential to receive grace. It has nothing to do with how close we stand to God or God not being as nice to some of us because he wants to. cotton burns a lot better then a brick. cotton burns when it even gets close to the fire. you could throw the brick in and It might not get started. All the sacraments depend on the disposition of those receiving them. Why do you think heaven would be different.

As for you interesting notion that I am a pelagian or even bordering on it. lets talk about the 200+ places where Jesus Christ speaks with his own mouth in the bible about exactly what it will take for you to get to heaven. every time he talks about what you do with the grace you are given. you can’t bury it in the back yard he says you must do something with it. and you will be judged on what you have done with what you had. implying that outcomes of that judgement will vary. else it would be a rubber stamp. no I stand by my first argument. perhaps I was unclear? okay now I am more clear. peace have a nice day. I look forward to your rebuttal.
Uh, brother, I’m very sorry if I offended you in any way. I didn’t say you were pelagian, only that the idea had a similar ring to it.
If I have said something which has upset you, I apologize, that’s the last thing I wanted to do.

Now, concerning the different people having different potential to receive grace.
The cotton/brick analogy sounds nice, but were talking about spiritual grace here. Do you think that the human soul, each one made in the image of God, and the glorified human body have different grace absorbing properties?

Now, you misunderstood me on the second part - of course works have to do with getting to heaven. I am not a protestant to believe sola fide, but - BUT, what I was saying is that if you postulate that man can do something to EARN his salvation BY HIS OWN MERIT, or to earn a greater place in the sense of somehow shearing to a greater extent in the divine life then others, then and only then one can find elements of pelagianism in such a view.

Tell me this - do you think that the good thief, whom the Lord promised a place by his side personally, had a lesser potential to absorb grace because he lacked the time for doing whatever needs doing to get the grater potential to absorb grace?

I really want to continue this in the spirit of charity.
 
The following is from Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma:

The degree of perfection of the beatific vision granted to the just is proportioned to each one’s merits. (De fide)

The Decretum pro Graecis of the Union Council of Florence (1439) declared: The souls of the just “clearly behold the Triune and One God as He is, but corresponding to the difference of their merits, the one more perfectly than the other.” The council of Trent defined that the justified person merits an increase of the heavenly glory by good works. D 842

Opposed to the teaching of the Church is the teaching of Jovinian, who, influenced by the Stoics, taught that all virtues are of equal grade; opposed to it also is Luter’s doctrine of the external imputation of Christ’s justice. Both give rise to equality in the beatific vision.

Christ promised: “He (the Son of Man) will render to every one according to his works” (Mt 16:27). St. Paul teaches: “And every man shall receive his own reward, according to his own labour” (1 Cor. 3:8). “He who soweth sparingly shall also reap sparingly: and he that soweth in blessings shall also reap blessings” (2 Cor. 9:6). Cf. 1 Cor. 15:41 et seq.

The Fathers are fond of appealing to the words of Jesus concerning the many mansions in the Father’s House (John 14:2). Tertullian remarks: “Why are there many mansions in the Father’s house, if not on account of the difference of the merits?” (Scorp. 6). St. Augustine sees in the one penny which all the workers in the vineyard uniformly receive for varying durations of work (Mt. 20:1-16), an indication of eternal life, which is for all similarly of eternal duration; in the many mansions in the house of the Father (John 14:2) he sees a symbol of the various grades of remuneration in the one eternal life. To the objection that inequality gives rise to envy, he answers: “There will be no envy on account of the unequal glory, since the unity of love will reign in all” (In Ioan., tr. 67:2). Cf. St. Jerome, Adv. Iovin. II 18-34. S. th. I 12, 6.

Regarding Hell:
The punishment of the damned is proportioned to each one’s guilt. (Sent. Communis.)

The Union Councils of Lyons and of Florence declared that the souls of the damned are punished with unequal punishments (poenis tamen disparibus puniendas). D 464 693. This is probably intended to assert not merely a specific difference in the punishment of original sin (poena damni) and of personal sins (poena damni and poena sensus), but also a difference in the degree of punishment for personal sins.

Jesus threatens the inhabitants of Corazain and Bethsaida, on account of their slowness to repent, with a stricter judgment than the dwellers in Tyre and Sidon (Mt 11:22). The Scribes are to be subject to a particularly strict judgment (Luke 20:47).

St. Augustine teaches: “In their wretchedness the lot of some of the damned will be more tolerable than that of others” (Enchir. III). Justice demands that the punishment be commensurate with the guilt.

So far, have been unable to find anything in the Catechism that talks about degrees of merit in heaven. Seems to be very little about heaven and hell in the Catechism.

Nita
Sure, I’m open to being wrong - I only seek an understanding of the truth.

A lack of data in the Catechism I also find confusing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top