Mormonism and Protestantism

  • Thread starter Thread starter HailHolyQueen90
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
From the Latter-day Saint perspective, we are not Protestant, and do not consider ourselves as such, primarily because we do not see ourselves as “reforming” the Church (which is what Protestant historically referred to), but rather we see ourselves as a “restoration” of Christ’s ancient Church, by God Himself. A number of other churches can also fall under this “restorationism” branch, such as Church of Christ, Disciples of Christ, Seventh-day Adventist, Jehovah’s Witnesses, etc.

In general, non-Latter-day Saints view us as non-Christian (and therefore not Protestant), since we do not hold to the traditional Trinity doctrine of God. So either way, the answer is that The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is not considered Protestant.
I think this is a very good description. I’d only clarify, Protestants consider their actions against Catholicism as a restoration. Reforming in order to restore. Mormonism is just one more form of Christian primitivism.

From a Catholic perspective, Protestant denominations are fruits of the same vine, but Mormonism is not of the same vine. Mormonism is something other, something that arose from, among other things, American Protestantism.
 
If by CoC you mean Church of Christ you are completely wrong. Both books are man created, uninspired by God. The believe in multiple gods, Jesus and Satan are spirit children of God, that men can become gods, Jesus death was insufficient to atone for our sins, everyone will go to some form of heaven, only LDS who leave the church will go to hell (outer darkness), salvation is based on works, still teach polygamy, still teach that people of color were cursed in a pre-mortal existence, a woman’s salvation is tied to her obedience to her husband, etc… None of these things has any place at a CoC.
The problem is that the church of Christ, and the Community of Christ share initials.

What is being discussed is the Community of Christ, and it shares the same initials as your denomination.
 
SpeSalvi,
Thanks for explaining your previous statements. Sorry I did not provide more details but I simply had very little time this morning to write. Let me make a couple of comments now…
But you’re not going to point out what IS incorrect? Don’t you want to help clarify something if someone’s mistaken? :confused:

Since Janderich is quick to complain but not to explain, I’ll try to clear things up.

Yes, they believe that multiple gods EXIST, but they don’t worship anyone other that the God they call God The Father/Elohim. Agreed.

Yes, they believe Jesus and Satan (along with all of us as well) are spirit children of God and we’re all therefore spirit brothers and sisters as well. Agreed.

Yes, they believe that men can progress to become gods just like God did. Yes, this may be, but it is important to note that it will be a long time after the resurrection and God will always be greater than us.

No, they DO believe that Jesus’ atonement was sufficient to redeem us (the atonement that happened in the Garden of Gethsemane); however they don’t actually put a lot of emphasis on His death because they considered all the work done in the Garden. The atonement and then resurrection is what they focus on. Fine.

No, they do not believe everyone will go to some form of heaven. It’s just pretty difficult to get into Hell- you have to have KNOWN that the LDS church was the true church and deny it anyway. In other words, people like me that have left the LDS church are pretty much the only ones that’ll be there. The murderers, traitors, and other evil people will get to go to the lowest degree of heaven, provided they never heard about the LDS church before their deaths. I believe your statement about who goes to hell (outer darkness) is still too broad and I in no way believe you would be considered one. It is not enough, simply to have left the church. Joseph Smith taught that to become a son of perdition, a person must “have the heavens opened unto him, and know God…He has got to say that the sun does not shine while he sees it; he has got to deny Jesus Christ when the heavens have been opened unto him, and to deny the plan of salvation with his eyes open to the truth of it” (Teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith, p.358). Spencer W. Kimball said, “The sin against the Holy Ghost requires such knowledge that it is manifestly impossible for the rank and file to commit such a sin” (The Miracle of Forgiveness, p.123)" Such an one must desire to put Christ to death anew if he were able.

Salvation in the LDS church is based on works AND grace. Agreed.

They’ve officially condemned polygamy, but believe that it’ll be practiced in Heaven. Example: If a man’s wife dies, he can remarry and be sealed to another woman in the temple because he’s allowed to have more than one wife in Heaven. If a woman’s husband dies, she cannot remarry in the temple because she can’t have more than one husband. However, the church will recognize the civil marriage of two people that have both been previously sealed in the temple without a problem. A man that hasn’t been previously sealed can’t marry a woman that has, though; even civilly. He HAS to be sealed to someone in order to attain the highest level of heaven. One may infer, but there has nothing stating such.

They don’t believe that people of color were CURSED in the premortal existence. As it was explained to me in my Laurel class, people of color were the spirits that didn’t want the responsibility of holding the priesthood because of it’s power. They asked to be turned a darker color so they didn’t have to deal with that responsibility. By the late 1970’s, all the spirits that didn’t want that responsibility had come to earth already, and so that ban was rescinded. This is definitely not doctrine. There may have been a few statements by church leaders but there is certainly nothing official.

A woman’s salvation isn’t necessarily tied to obedience to her husband (officially), but if a woman doesn’t get sealed to someone she can’t attain the highest degree of heaven. It is also traditionally a lot harder for a woman to successfully request to get her sealing broken than it is for a man. I agree a woman’s salvation is not tied to her husband. I also agree that a woman must at some point be sealed to a husband. (By the way, the reverse holds for a man). However, marriage and sealing may not happen during this life. That opportunity may yet come after death but before the resurrection. I have never heard that it is more difficult for a woman to get a sealing cancellation. It is difficult for either party.

There ya go. Janderich, next time you want to refute something please explain. Don’t just play the victim.
 
If you’re going to post a response, then please pay attention.
Notice the first part of my repsonse “If.” Nice link, but that poster is wrong too, Mormons aren’t Protestant and aren’t Christian. Joseph Smith reported in his first vision that he was told all Christian churches and denominations had fallen into apostasy and God was offended at their worship. To my knowledge, none of these denominations have changed in the last 190 years, so Mormons must hold they are still in apostasy. Why would Mormons want to be part of a group that offends God on a weekly basis?
 
Notice the first part of my repsonse “If.” Nice link, but that poster is wrong too, Mormons aren’t Protestant and aren’t Christian. Joseph Smith reported in his first vision that he was told all Christian churches and denominations had fallen into apostasy and God was offended at their worship. To my knowledge, none of these denominations have changed in the last 190 years, so Mormons must hold they are still in apostasy. Why would Mormons want to be part of a group that offends God on a weekly basis?
Again Steve, the founder of your denomination taught close to the same thing, the apostacy/restoration dichotomy.

Smith got his total apostacy theory from the campbellites, and one of the early mormon leaders was originally a follower of Campbell and Stone he nearly became the 2nd mormon prophet, but was beaten out by Brigham Young.

The similarities are amazing between the two. Both teach apostacy/restoration, communion each sunday, and beleivers baptism by submersion. And both have a lay leadership.
 
Would the LDS Church be considered Protestant?

How would you explain the Mormon Church when it comes to Orthodoxy, Catholicism and Protestantism?
Most Protestants will deny to their tomb that Mormons are Protestants. Protestant thought gave birth to Mormon thought. I recall that Joseph Smith had attended a Presbyterian church and his family a congregational church of some sort. The parents of Joseph Smith attended some form of Protestant church and Joseph decided that everyone was wrong.

Mormonism has no relationship to Orthodoxy, Catholicism or Protestant thought. It is a mutation.
 
You know nothing about protestantism OR Mormonism, I wouldn’t expect you too! Unless your a convert from either your in no position to judge the beliefs and practices of other Churches.

**Your opinions are all based on outside observations and stereotypes. Wow. All the judgement here.

Unless you’ve been mormon or protestant, You have no right to tell them or me what is wrong and what is right. **
Do you see me telling Catholics here that their faith is wrong?! :mad:
Mi,

What you are suggesting here is the difference between Rationalism and Empiricism. Your line of thinking would equate to the only way to know that Homosexuality is wrong is to have been one. Do you agree with this?
 
If by “Christian” you mean one that believes in Jesus Christ as Savior and Redeemer then we most definitely are Christian.

However, if you define “Christian” as one who must believe in the Trinity and the Bible alone as scripture then we definitely are not, and we do not claim to be.

The problem occurs when people try and lump these two statements together. This simply causes confusion, and I am afraid many are happy with it that way.
Jan,

No. I would say someone Baptized in the Name of the Father without a body, Son with a Body and not the brother of Satan, and the Holy Spirit is a Christian.
 
If by “Christian” you mean one that believes in Jesus Christ as Savior and Redeemer then we most definitely are Christian.

However, if you define “Christian” as one who must believe in the Trinity and the Bible alone as scripture then we definitely are not, and we do not claim to be.

The problem occurs when people try and lump these two statements together. This simply causes confusion, and I am afraid many are happy with it that way.
If comes a man tomorrow whose name would be Jesus and I think he is my saviour because I feel he is my saviour would make me Christian too then.
Your Christ from which you take the denomination of christians is described as another person by mormonisms. Many of his saying are not even taken in consideration with the exuse of the bad translation and so on.

I repeat again here. Mormons are capable of the most deep blaphemy of chrstianity. First of all the use of Jesus figure as they want pictured by J.Smith, and we don’t have to talk about The Holy Father and Who for mormon He is and has been…

Nobody can ever say mormon faith is wrong. No, mormon faith is right in what they think to be right. But what they think is right is extremely insulting to Christianity I would add for a christian is just plain devilish.
 
If comes a man tomorrow whose name would be Jesus and I think he is my saviour because I feel he is my saviour would make me Christian too then.
Your Christ from which you take the denomination of christians is described as another person by mormonisms. Many of his saying are not even taken in consideration with the exuse of the bad translation and so on.

I repeat again here. Mormons are capable of the most deep blaphemy of chrstianity. First of all the use of Jesus figure as they want pictured by J.Smith, and we don’t have to talk about The Holy Father and Who for mormon He is and has been…

Nobody can ever say mormon faith is wrong. No, mormon faith is right in what they think to be right. But what they think is right is extremely insulting to Christianity I would add for a christian is just plain devilish.
Would it be fair to say that as you write what they think would be considered anathema?
 
If comes a man tomorrow whose name would be Jesus and I think he is my saviour because I feel he is my saviour would make me Christian too then.
Your Christ from which you take the denomination of christians is described as another person by mormonisms. Many of his saying are not even taken in consideration with the exuse of the bad translation and so on.

I repeat again here. Mormons are capable of the most deep blaphemy of chrstianity. First of all the use of Jesus figure as they want pictured by J.Smith, and we don’t have to talk about The Holy Father and Who for mormon He is and has been…

Nobody can ever say mormon faith is wrong. No, mormon faith is right in what they think to be right. But what they think is right is extremely insulting to Christianity I would add for a christian is just plain devilish.
I agree it is extremely insulting to Christianity and what they believe and proclaim is blasphemy.

Anyone who believes that Jesus is just A god and deny that He is the Creator but claim that he was God’s first creation and that we too can eventually become a god is not a Christian but a part of a cult.
 
I agree it is extremely insulting to Christianity and what they believe and proclaim is blasphemy.

Anyone who believes that Jesus is just A god and deny that He is the Creator but claim that he was God’s first creation and that we too can eventually become a god is not a Christian but a part of a cult.
Then it would be fair to say you would agree with anathema.
 
Would it be fair to say that as you write what they think would be considered anathema?
Anathema is everything coming from you, from the inside of yourself, expecially making you feel good and maybe others too, but going subtle or openly against the Person you affirm is your guide.
When you confound for your own confort and gain of any gain, expeciallym emotional gain, you don’t have the courage to refute the truth but you change it. whenever you, and your world, your family, your heart, your feeling of being a good person are directly linked with God’s Will. This is anathema.

What they, mormon consider anathema? Whatever doesn’t make them feel well.
In this attitude the join rational satanism.
 
From the Latter-day Saint perspective, we are not Protestant, and do not consider ourselves as such, primarily because we do not see ourselves as “reforming” the Church (which is what Protestant historically referred to), but rather we see ourselves as a “restoration” of Christ’s ancient Church, by God Himself. A number of other churches can also fall under this “restorationism” branch, such as Church of Christ, Disciples of Christ, Seventh-day Adventist, Jehovah’s Witnesses, etc.

In general, non-Latter-day Saints view us as non-Christian (and therefore not Protestant), since we do not hold to the traditional Trinity doctrine of God. So either way, the answer is that The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is not considered Protestant.
It is not just that. It is because you believe in a different God, a different Christ, and a very weak and dishonest Christ.
 
Anathema is everything coming from you, from the inside of yourself, expecially making you feel good and maybe others too, but going subtle or openly against the Person you affirm is your guide.
When you confound for your own confort and gain of any gain, expeciallym emotional gain, you don’t have the courage to refute the truth but you change it. whenever you, and your world, your family, your heart, your feeling of being a good person are directly linked with God’s Will. This is anathema.

What they, mormon consider anathema? Whatever doesn’t make them feel well.
In this attitude the join rational satanism.
I am not understanding your notion of Anathema as it regards feelings and guides. You are saying that if it does not make them feel well then they are anathema. They do have a burning in their bosom as a sign of faith. I am not sure how that makes them feel.

a·nath·e·ma   /əˈnæθəmə/ Show Spelled[uh-nath-uh-muh] noun, plural -mas.
  1. a person or thing detested or loathed: That subject is anathema to him.
  2. a person or thing accursed or consigned to damnation or destruction.
  3. a formal ecclesiastical curse involving excommunication.
  4. any imprecation of divine punishment.
  5. a curse; execration.
 
I agree it is extremely insulting to Christianity and what they believe and proclaim is blasphemy.

Anyone who believes that Jesus is just A god and deny that He is the Creator but claim that he was God’s first creation and that we too can eventually become a god is not a Christian but a part of a cult.
Members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, while rejecting the traditional doctrine of the Trinity, believe that Jesus Christ is the divine Son of God, our Lord and Savior, one of the members of the Godhead, and most certainly is the Creator. Latter-day Saints believe that through the atoning sacrifice of our Savior Jesus Christ, we can become heirs of God and joint heirs with Christ (Romans 8:17), participating in the same life that God lives, becoming gods. Members of The Church of Jesus Christ do not believe that we become gods through any power of our own, but that it is only by God’s grace, and our accepting of His grace, demonstrated by continuous faith in Jesus Christ, continuous repentance, and following the Lord’s commandments.

For further understanding of the Latter-day Saint belief, perhaps these links will be helpful:
jefflindsay.com/LDSFAQ/FQ_Relationships.shtml
jefflindsay.com/LDSFAQ/FQ_theosis.shtml
 
Members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, while rejecting the traditional doctrine of the Trinity, believe that Jesus Christ is the divine Son of God, our Lord and Savior, one of the members of the Godhead, and most certainly is the Creator. Latter-day Saints believe that through the atoning sacrifice of our Savior Jesus Christ, we can become heirs of God and joint heirs with Christ (Romans 8:17), participating in the same life that God lives, becoming gods. Members of The Church of Jesus Christ do not believe that we become gods through any power of our own, but that it is only by God’s grace, and our accepting of His grace, demonstrated by continuous faith in Jesus Christ, continuous repentance, and following the Lord’s commandments.

For further understanding of the Latter-day Saint belief, perhaps these links will be helpful:
jefflindsay.com/LDSFAQ/FQ_Relationships.shtml
jefflindsay.com/LDSFAQ/FQ_theosis.shtml
I don’t think you are understanding, Mormons believe Jesus Christ is both creator and created. A God among gods. You’ve taken HIs name and use it in false teachings, which Jeff Lindsay only underlines in bold red.
 
I don’t think you are understanding, Mormons believe Jesus Christ is both creator and created. A God among gods. You’ve taken HIs name and use it in false teachings, which Jeff Lindsay only underlines in bold red.
The first article I linked to addresses the Latter-day Saint understanding of this issue, hence why I linked to it.
 
Members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, while rejecting the traditional doctrine of the Trinity, believe that Jesus Christ is the divine Son of God, our Lord and Savior, one of the members of the Godhead, and most certainly is the Creator. Latter-day Saints believe that through the atoning sacrifice of our Savior Jesus Christ, we can become heirs of God and joint heirs with Christ (Romans 8:17), participating in the same life that God lives, becoming gods. Members of The Church of Jesus Christ do not believe that we become gods through any power of our own, but that it is only by God’s grace, and our accepting of His grace, demonstrated by continuous faith in Jesus Christ, continuous repentance, and following the Lord’s commandments.
(For Mormon theology, I’m using this site (and subsequent links) for my source.)
(For orthodox Christian theology, I’m quoting the Nicene Creed.)

The Church of Jesus Christ of the Latter-day Saints use the words found in the language of Catholics(/Orthodox/Protestants), but define the words differently. It’s one thing to maintain those words for themselves during worship, because they understand their own definitions of the words. The problem, however, lies in when they use those words to communicate with orthodox Christianity, knowing that their will be a language barrier, allowing us to believe that Mormon theology at face value is only an extension of orthodox Christian theology, when it is in fact radically (meaning “to the roots”) different. That’s called deception. I don’t like being deceived.

Points where we can agree:
  • “believe that Jesus Christ is …] our Lord and Savior”
  • “believe that through the atoning sacrifice of our Savior Jesus Christ, we can become heirs of God and joint heirs with Christ”
  • “do not believe that we [are saved] through any power of our own, but that it is only by God’s grace, and our accepting of His grace, demonstrated by continuous faith in Jesus Christ, continuous repentance, and following the Lord’s commandments”
“One of the members of the Godhead.”
To orthodox Christianity: Christ is the Only Begotten Son of God, a member of the Godhead, born of the Father before all ages God from God, Light from Light, true God from true God, begotten, not made, consubstantial (one in Being, distinct Person, but of same essence) with the Father.
To Mormon theology: Christ is not with one substance with the Father but a separate Being, born of the Father and our Heavenly Mother (not the Virgin Mary of orthodox Christianity).
“most certainly is the Creator”
To orthodox Christianity: Christ, by being consubstantial with the Father, was most certainly the Creator. As the Father is maker of heaven and earth, of all things visible and invisible, it was through Christ that all things were made.
To Mormon theology: Christ, by being a separate being from the Father, was the Creator of Earth. However, this Creation is NOT by the Father and through Son as in orthodoxy, but instead the Creator under the guidance of the Father, so that Christ is the “Jehovah” of the Old Testament, the Messiah of the New.
“participating in the same life that God lives, becoming gods”
To orthodox Christianity: As God said on Mount Sinai: “I AM the Lord, your God. Thou shall not have other gods besides me.” Therefore, when the Psalms say we will be made “little less than the gods,” the Prophets of the Old Testament say we will “become gods,” Christ says that we will “become gods,” and St Athanasius writing that “God became man so that men might become gods,” we mean that through Christ’s Incarnation (God becoming man in the flesh), by partaking in the Covenant Christ established, we the partake in the Divine Nature of God, having our bodies glorified and made perfect after the Resurrection, so that we can forever worship perfectly in the Heavenly Liturgy of the Book of St John’s Revelations (or Apocalypse) for all Eternity.
To Mormon theology: After partaking in the Covenant established by Christ, those who are worthy to obtain the highest degree (out of three) within the Celestial Kingdom (the highest of the three Kingdoms of Glory) where, if not married on Earth in a Temple, then given an opportunity to have a Temple Marriage, a man becomes the lord of his own kingdom, much like the Heavenly Father and Mother is the lord and mother of their own kingdom, not necessarily “earth-like,” but most certainly his own newly established kingdom.
 
Members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, while rejecting the traditional doctrine of the Trinity, believe that Jesus Christ is the divine Son of God, our Lord and Savior, one of the members of the Godhead, and most certainly is the Creator. Latter-day Saints believe that through the atoning sacrifice of our Savior Jesus Christ, we can become heirs of God and joint heirs with Christ (Romans 8:17), participating in the same life that God lives, becoming gods. Members of The Church of Jesus Christ do not believe that we become gods through any power of our own, but that it is only by God’s grace, and our accepting of His grace, demonstrated by continuous faith in Jesus Christ, continuous repentance, and following the Lord’s commandments.

For further understanding of the Latter-day Saint belief, perhaps these links will be helpful:
jefflindsay.com/LDSFAQ/FQ_Relationships.shtml
jefflindsay.com/LDSFAQ/FQ_theosis.shtml
You don’t even understand what you are talking about and your insult to Christianity and how you do it. And you are deeply unwilling not to want to understand why. We would just like you and mormons understand why. Your wrongness is in the relativism of divinity while Christianity rely in absolutisms.

…believe that Jesus Christ is the divine Son of God
…relative to chair. The Son of God is not relative to the chair. He is the Word (as St.John said. I know he was not inspired as Joseph Smith, but he knew personally Jesus)

…and most certainly is the Creator.
relative to our world. Is a creator is not the Creator.

**…that through the atoning sacrifice **
His sacrify is completely redemensionato to a much lesser degree. He sacrified Himself just to save human from a lesser degree of exaltation. From mormon sin is relative and not absolute. He made human going and will make humans downgrading from a 5 stars hotel to a trhree stars one.

…becoming gods this is the only point where mormonism became more absolute then Christianity. In Christianity the unity in the Son with God makes us Gods. There is no place for being gods separated from God. In separation from God we are in the same state that we are now. The fall.

*Members of The Church of Jesus Christ do not believe that we become gods through any power of our own, but that it is only by God’s grace, and our accepting of His grace, demonstrated by continuous faith in Jesus Christ, continuous repentance, and following the Lord’s commandments. *As you see from your writing: you first state only and then you add other things. It is strange. Only is only.

If you do, mormons do everything, but everything Joeph Smith told you to do do you still need God’s Grace or is automatic. If it is automatic you don’t need His Grace.

If I have to talk mormonishcally, since Grace is also relativized, I would better state:
Grace is given if you hearn it.
It is a strange concept of Grace. It is more a reward.
Grace is what you get behond you beeing worthed or not. Jesus come as an act of Grace.
Infact He came for the unworthied sinners.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top