Mortal sin or just overreacting?

  • Thread starter Thread starter PiousTemplar
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
P

PiousTemplar

Guest
On facebook I often join groups like ‘Ex Catholics saved by Christ’ to evangelise the faith. Today I was arguing with two non-denominational Christians who don’t believe tha apostles creed. It felt like I was getting nowhere and they were not listening or even considering the Catholic point of view. From then on I was far from ‘charitable’ to them when arguing. I was saying things like ‘Faith alone is a lie from the pit of hell’ rather than a more charitable ‘Faith alone is false’. I got really emotional and was really annoyed and angry. They often mock the Eucharist and call the Catholic Church unbiblical and diabolical. I was saying things like ‘Open your eyes, your interpretation IS FALSE’ and ‘You are a lier and a deceiver!’

I feel really bad. Can I still receive Holy Communion? I just got back from confession so It will be weird going again to confess 1 or 2 sins!
 
Did you believe it was a mortal sin at the time? Did you tell yourself, more or less, “I know this is a serious offense against God, but I choose to do it anyway.” I doubt it. From what you’ve related, you did not blaspheme and you did not wish or express serious harm to anybody. It sounds like you got a bit passionate, that’s all.
 
Did you believe it was a mortal sin at the time? Did you tell yourself, more or less, “I know this is a serious offense against God, but I choose to do it anyway.” I doubt it. From what you’ve related, you did not blaspheme and you did not wish or express serious harm to anybody. It sounds like you got a bit passionate, that’s all.
Are you sure my friend? I prayed once during the argument ‘Lord help me with this’. I didn’t want to offend God just preach the truth. I think I just changed by accident from arguing the truth to evangelise to just arguing to win. I hope I didnt mortal sin.
 
From what I gather you didn’t commit a mortal sin, you were defending the faith which is a very good thing, perhaps in future you should do it more charitably but you learnt your lesson, I would if you knew it wasn’t right and still did it, consider it a venial sin and if you did it unintentionally it is either an imperfection or venial sin. Yes you can receive the eucharist, mortal sin has to be something very grievious and deliberate, just either say a sincere act of contrition beforehand and you can even mention it in your next confession. Trust in God’s mercy and don’t let the devil deceive you, scrupulosity is from the devil and I suffer from it myself. The devil will do anything he can to disturb your peace, true contrition is a peaceful and tranquil sorrow as Padre Pio said. God Bless you:thumbsup:
 
From what I gather you didn’t commit a mortal sin, you were defending the faith which is a very good thing, perhaps in future you should do it more charitably but you learnt your lesson, I would if you knew it wasn’t right and still did it, consider it a venial sin and if you did it unintentionally it is either an imperfection or venial sin. Yes you can receive the eucharist, mortal sin has to be something very grievious and deliberate, just either say a sincere act of contrition beforehand and you can even mention it in your next confession. Trust in God’s mercy and don’t let the devil deceive you, scrupulosity is from the devil and I suffer from it myself. The devil will do anything he can to disturb your peace, true contrition is a peaceful and tranquil sorrow as Padre Pio said. God Bless you:thumbsup:
Thankyou my friend! Off to Mass now!
 
To quote someone, (Thomas Aquinas?)- “Faith without charity is cruelty”.
Mortal sin? - I really doubt it- venial sin?- probably.
It’s easy to get carried away in the face of stubborn stupidity and express frustration and anger but it doesn’t win hearts and minds. If you can patiently state your position from a stance of love your ideas will be a lot more effective.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top