Mortal sin?

[mymamamary]

Would it be a mortal sin to trade a blessed rosary for another rosary that,isnt blessed drom the jewlery store? I don’t know if it would be simony because, obviously
y the jewler would want to sell the blessed one, asto them its just jewlery. am I morally allowed to.do this or is it.a mortal.sin?

 

[Bookcat]

Not needed to get into the question of mortal sin here.

But one ought not trade “return” a blessed rosary to a store.

One can give it away and buy another if one wishes but after it is blessed it ought not be returned.

 

[mymamamary]

Is it mortal though? Ought not abd cannot morally r two different things

 

[LJN21]

Why are you so obsessed with mortal sin? This is not healthy. You need to stop soliciting advice on a forum and talk to your spiritual director. Take the advice he gives you and don’t go shopping for the answers you want to hear. You might want to mention how many times you come here for advise on whats a mortal sin or not. This is the second post I can see in two days on the subject by you.