H Horatius Guest Jan 1, 2013 #41 Sarcelle said: Horatius;10170810: Would you wish a Hindu a happy birthday of the monkey god Hanuman? Would you wish a Wiccan a happy Samhain? Would you wish a Lutheran a happy Reformation Day? Click to expand... Well, if the Pope issued a judgement saying that Catholics were forbidden from doing the above, then it would be a big deal too. Click to expand... This is a Tu quoque argument. Would it be fair for the pope to be criticized for this? I notice that none of you Chicken Littles have answered my questions. They weren’t rhetorical.
Sarcelle said: Horatius;10170810: Would you wish a Hindu a happy birthday of the monkey god Hanuman? Would you wish a Wiccan a happy Samhain? Would you wish a Lutheran a happy Reformation Day? Click to expand... Well, if the Pope issued a judgement saying that Catholics were forbidden from doing the above, then it would be a big deal too. Click to expand... This is a Tu quoque argument. Would it be fair for the pope to be criticized for this? I notice that none of you Chicken Littles have answered my questions. They weren’t rhetorical.
