L
lynnvinc
Guest
What is CAF and aren’t we discussing this issue?Where does the article mention social media?
What is CAF and aren’t we discussing this issue?Where does the article mention social media?
Right on the money.The basic premise of the method is to question and test. When politics gets in the fold you are told not to question or test!
Science is not black and white. People who make it thier god try to shape it into a final authority. In reality, it is messy, and hard to understand.
It’s hardly settled. In any field.
As mentioned by a previous poster, much of the replication concerns have been in the medical and social sciences. Here is an interesting article from Nature that gives a more nuanced understanding of where people see problems and possible corrective mechanisms.
nature.com/news/how-scientists-fool-themselves-and-how-they-can-stop-1.18517
Scientists are a very reflective group, in my experience. The Nature article above highlights this. They also take peer review very seriously. But the volume and highly specialized nature of most research being published can make that job challenging.
Climate science suffers more unique challenges because it has to rely heavily on models which will never be perfect. However, the old line “all models are wrong, some are useful” is where climate science lives. Most people in that field believe the models have reached the fidelity to be useful in informing decisions, which is what I understand “settled science” to mean.