Most scientists 'can't replicate studies by their peers'

  • Thread starter Thread starter ucfengr
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
The basic premise of the method is to question and test. When politics gets in the fold you are told not to question or test!

Science is not black and white. People who make it thier god try to shape it into a final authority. In reality, it is messy, and hard to understand.
It’s hardly settled. In any field.
Right on the money. 👍👍
 
Maybe the headline should have been, “Most scientists are not really good at science.”

The other stories that day could have read,

“Most investment professionals deliver below average investment returns.”

“Colleges of Education show lowest student test scores.”

“Most politicians stretch the truth in campaign speeches.”

“Most journalists have a personal bias in their reporting.”

I do not see this story as real news.
 
As mentioned by a previous poster, much of the replication concerns have been in the medical and social sciences. Here is an interesting article from Nature that gives a more nuanced understanding of where people see problems and possible corrective mechanisms.

nature.com/news/how-scientists-fool-themselves-and-how-they-can-stop-1.18517

Scientists are a very reflective group, in my experience. The Nature article above highlights this. They also take peer review very seriously. But the volume and highly specialized nature of most research being published can make that job challenging.

Climate science suffers more unique challenges because it has to rely heavily on models which will never be perfect. However, the old line “all models are wrong, some are useful” is where climate science lives. Most people in that field believe the models have reached the fidelity to be useful in informing decisions, which is what I understand “settled science” to mean.
 
As mentioned by a previous poster, much of the replication concerns have been in the medical and social sciences. Here is an interesting article from Nature that gives a more nuanced understanding of where people see problems and possible corrective mechanisms.

nature.com/news/how-scientists-fool-themselves-and-how-they-can-stop-1.18517

Scientists are a very reflective group, in my experience. The Nature article above highlights this. They also take peer review very seriously. But the volume and highly specialized nature of most research being published can make that job challenging.

Climate science suffers more unique challenges because it has to rely heavily on models which will never be perfect. However, the old line “all models are wrong, some are useful” is where climate science lives. Most people in that field believe the models have reached the fidelity to be useful in informing decisions, which is what I understand “settled science” to mean.
👍

Those using models call their models “skilled” if they are able to come somewhat close in predicting observations – going backwards over actual observations, then going forward in time and waiting to see how they do.

They are constantly “tweaking” their models as new data and theory come in, so in general models improve over time, esp with greater super-computer power.

Climate scientists talk frankly about “known knowns,” “known unknowns,” and “unknown unknowns.” Some of the “known unknowns” is whether there might be some volcanos at a certain point in the future, or a deep solar minimum or strong el nino. But I think a “known unknown” would also be positive feedbacks that are hard to quantify and put into computer models, like carbon release from melting ocean clathrates and permafrost, which could spiral the warming up a lot higher than if this were not an issue. I did ask the climate scientist if that was in their models, and they said “no.”

Contrary to denialist claims that climate scientists are out to take over the world and oppress everyone, they are an intelligent, very well educated, hard-working group, striving to be as accurate and honest as possible, bec the competition among them is stiff…and now their work is under a public microscope.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top