The book is actually very accurate. It describes the Dark Night exactly as Catholic Theology teaches it. There is no feeling of love, light, joy, charity, hope or the presence of God. God seems to have abandoned you or non existent. That’s what the Dark Night it. It is necessary for the soul to go through this to achieve union with the soul of Christ.
St. Teresa of Avila experienced it for about 20 years. St. Francis of Assisi did not come out of it until he was on his death bed. St. Catherine of Siena went through it for an undetermined period of time. St. Faustina and St. Therese experienced it less time, because they died younger than the rest.
This experience does not mean that the person is not a saint. It’s just the opposite. It only happens to those who are saints. God allowed it to happen to them because he knew the outcome. He knew they would not buckle.
The author gets it spot on. Mother Teresa was able to smile, despite it all because she traveled on intellect. The intellect takes over. You smile, you pray and you do what you have to do, because you KNOW that God is near . . . however, you FEEL worse than being in hell. Even in hell, those poor souls have feelings. The mystic does not always feel.
Sometimes, with the Dark Night of the Soul, the mystic will also experience a Dark Night of the Senses. St. John of the Cross explains this for us. You may want to read him. However, I warn you. His writings are very frightening, because he draws you into his experience of darkness. However, it must be remembered that while he wrote these things, he was happy. His mind told him that he had every reason to be happy.
The same is true about Mother Teresa. Mother smiled, because she knew that her suffering, her lack of faith, charity, and her feelings of hopelessness pleased Christ and atoned for his suffering. She agrees to be the “saint of darkness” as she calls herself. The height of sanctity is the willingness to spend eternity in darkness if it pleases God. This is the power of Mother Teresa’s testimony.
When she had nothing else to give, she surrendered to God even the possibility of seeing him, as long as it pleased him. What is powerful about her book is that she teaches us to let go of what we feel and what we believe and hang on to what we know.
She is very joyful. She wills herself to smile for Jesus, regardless of her feelings and thoughts. What she teaches us is that we’re not as important as we believe. We hang on to our thoughts, our ideas, our opinions and our feelings. Mother teaches us that true holiness is acheived through total poverty. Total poverty is to have nothing material and nothing emotional, only knowledge. It’s not academic knowledge, it’s spiritual knowledge. It’s the kind of knowledge that Christ and the Blessed Mother had. It’s the knowledge that St. Joseph had. Mother teaches us that love is a choice, not a feeling.
Pio experienced it, but his was combined with physical torture. God allowed Satan to physically torture him. Mother Teresa did not have this experience.
If you read Mother Teresa’s writings very carefully, the one thing that she never doubts is God’s mercy. She knows that what she is experiencing is not because God does not love her, but because he is merciful. She is being blessed with the rare opportunity to share in the darkness of the cross.
I would suggest that you read it again, but put aside all feelings. Read it coldly and logically. Apply the principles of assetical theology to it and you’ll see that it describes a life of faith that is beyond anything that any of us can can do on our own and that it’s God at work and Mother is a willing victim.
Fraternally,
Br. JR, OSF