MOVIES: Inception

  • Thread starter Thread starter Monica4316
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
This thread made me go and watch it last evening. šŸ˜‰

I think it’s good.

I kept thinking about two things as I was watching it: that the Bourne trilogy has now set a new standard for action scenes in movies, and that Nolan was very much inspired by Andrey Tarkovsky’s film ā€œSolarisā€. The element of the dead wife and having the opportunity to live with her in a dream world was completely taken from there, together with questions about reality and what makes a person real.

I keep wondering about the end. I’d like to think the happy end was real but it seemed a bit too perfect.
 
Every movie has it’s skeptics, and every movie will have at least one person here who will go out of their way to find that it’s somehow anti-Catholic.
If it’s not Catholic, it’s anti-Catholic.[BIBLEDRB]Matthew 12:30[/BIBLEDRB]
 
ā€œIt doesn’t matter because we’ll be together no matter what.ā€
In other words: regardless if we think it is real or not, it does not matter because we can define reality to our liking no matter what. This is existentialism.
The top spinning at the end had implications for us viewers, not for Cobb. Ellen Page’s character was right about Cobb (ā€œHe’ll be fineā€). He respected the importance of what’s real so much. He never lost sight of his goal of getting back to his family, and he turned down the opportunity to live in a joyful but solipsistic dream state. In short, he didn’t need to see the top fall and stop spinning.
Exactly, so it didn’t matter one way or the other what exactly was real or dream as long as they thought it was what they wanted. This is existentialism, viz., wishful thinking. Sartre said in his Existentialism is a Humanism lecture ā€œthat man first of all exists, encounters himself, surges up in the world—and defines himself afterwards,ā€ irrespective of a guiding authority for judging truth. Viz., existentialism denies absolute truth because we apparently invent truth. Pope Pius XII said this of existentialism in Humani Generis:
Such fictitious tenets of evolution which repudiate all that is absolute, firm and immutable, have paved the way for the new erroneous philosophy which, rivaling idealism, immanentism and pragmatism, has assumed the name of existentialism, since it concerns itself only with existence of individual things and neglects all consideration of their immutable essences.
 
In other words: regardless if we think it is real or not, it does not matter because we can define reality to our liking no matter what. This is existentialism.
I can’t remember that part, but I think it was from what Cobb said to convince his wife to leave the dream, which is later regretted. If you look at it in a way, it’s just another one of those ā€œeven if we die we’ll be together in the afterlifeā€ sort of speeches. I think you’re over analyzing.
Exactly, so it didn’t matter one way or the other what exactly was real or dream as long as they thought it was what they wanted. This is existentialism, viz., wishful thinking. Sartre said in his Existentialism is a Humanism lecture ā€œthat man first of all exists, encounters himself, surges up in the world—and defines himself afterwards,ā€ irrespective of a guiding authority for judging truth. Viz., existentialism denies absolute truth because we apparently invent truth. Pope Pius XII said this of existentialism in Humani Generis:
No, it has nothing to do with Cobb. It’s a scene meant for the viewers alone (which is why he’s out playing with his kids, which was his real-life goal that he never lost sight of, even when he could have stayed with his dream wife and kids forever).
 
If it’s not Catholic, it’s anti-Catholic.[BIBLEDRB]Matthew 12:30[/BIBLEDRB]
And then there’s Mark 9:40. ā€œFor he that is not against you, is for you.ā€ These quotes can easily be used out of context.
 
It was absurd, and you’re right: How can someone be woken up with a ā€œkick,ā€ but not by a car chase or gunfire? Um…hello? Wouldn’t the latter be a wee bit more threatening to the psyche than a nudge?
It’s science fiction. There’s a certain amount of willful suspension of disbelief involved. šŸ˜‰

They actually did explain it pretty well. They were so heavily sedated that only a preprogrammed signal (the feeling of falling) would wake them up. Hence the need to create artificial gravity with an elevator, which was, to me, really cool (but I’m a nerd).
 
ā€œIt doesn’t matter because we’ll be together no matter what.ā€

In other words: regardless if we think it is real or not, it does not matter because we can define reality to our liking no matter what. This is existentialism. Exactly, so it didn’t matter one way or the other what exactly was real or dream as long as they thought it was what they wanted. This is existentialism, viz., wishful thinking.
I don’t think the film is advancing the notion that reality doesn’t matter. It matters very, very much to Cobb. His answer to the train riddle was (obviously) wrong, since they were not together no matter what. Cobb is unable to define his own reality, as the crumbling buildings all around him display, and he is also patently unable to bring his dead wife back (despite how much he wants to).

I interpreted the tension in the final scene to be for us as well–it’s not that it doesn’t matter whether the top fell. It matters! We don’t know whether to be happy that Cobb has found reality, or mourn that he is still trapped, but there is a serious difference between the two states, and one is clearly preferable to the other.
 
If it’s not Catholic, it’s anti-Catholic.[BIBLEDRB]Matthew 12:30[/BIBLEDRB]
Way to equivocate and rip our Lord’s words out of any possible context.

It’s stupid to suggest or imply that a movie has to be either ā€œCatholicā€ or ā€œanti-Catholic.ā€ A movie can have really good, healthy themes that are very philosophically and spiritually compatible with Catholicism, without actually having anything to do with our faith in its explicit plot. And don’t forget about that other poster’s pointing out Mark 9:40. Inception isn’t against what we believe, therefore - by your logic - Mark 9:40 proves that it’s actually for Christ.
In other words: regardless if we think it is real or not, it does not matter because we can define reality to our liking no matter what. This is existentialism.
And the movie was solidly against it. The line to which you were responding was precisely the one that was portrayed in the movie as having disastrous consequences.

It did matter if the train was going to take them where they wanted to go - Cobb was wrong to teach his wife that it didn’t, and that little existential ā€œshortcutā€ eventually cost him his wife’s life.
Exactly, so it didn’t matter one way or the other what exactly was real or dream as long as they thought it was what they wanted. This is existentialism, viz., wishful thinking.
What is wrong with you? Did you actually watch this movie? Did you completely miss how its themes bluntly rejected the notion that ā€œit doesn’t matter what exactly is real as long as it is what we wantā€ by its portrayal of Cobb’s decision not to live in the solipsistic dream limbo? Cobb explicitly pointed out what a profound difference it made that the dream limbo’s simulation of his wife wasn’t really her, but only his subconscious’ projection of her.

Your posts in this thread make me sick, Geremia. If what you were saying made a lick of sense, my disagreement wouldn’t be so passionate, but your examples are so completely extrinsic to anything in the movie, that I’m forced against my will to conclude that you’re just looking for corruption - for relativism, existentialism, etc.

Disgusting.

Let this reply from a completely different poster sink in, Geremia, and especially note the part I bolded:
I don’t think the film is advancing the notion that reality doesn’t matter. It matters very, very much to Cobb. His answer to the train riddle was (obviously) wrong, since they were not together no matter what. Cobb is unable to define his own reality, as the crumbling buildings all around him display, and he is also patently unable to bring his dead wife back (despite how much he wants to).
 
Way to equivocate and rip our Lord’s words out of any possible context.
Really? How have I done that?
It’s stupid to suggest or imply that a movie has to be either ā€œCatholicā€ or ā€œanti-Catholic.ā€
The Index must have been stupid, too?
A movie can have really good, healthy themes that are very philosophically and spiritually compatible with Catholicism, without actually having anything to do with our faith in its explicit plot. And don’t forget about that other poster’s pointing out Mark 9:40. Inception isn’t against what we believe, therefore - by your logic - Mark 9:40 proves that it’s actually for Christ.
What does Mark 9:40 have to do with this?
And the movie was solidly against it. The line to which you were responding was precisely the one that was portrayed in the movie as having disastrous consequences.

It did matter if the train was going to take them where they wanted to go - Cobb was wrong to teach his wife that it didn’t, and that little existential ā€œshortcutā€ eventually cost him his wife’s life.
And you support this by saying that the end scene was just there for no reason, no? The end scene, even visually with its blurred focus, was clearly dream-like. If it was not intended to be, why was it left doubtful; why did not the top definitively topple? The only certainty is doubt; this is skepticism.
your examples are so completely extrinsic to anything in the movie, that I’m forced against my will to conclude that you’re just looking for corruption - for relativism, existentialism, etc.
There were good parts such as the importance of fatherhood and the desire to return to reality, but they were not what the movie was primarily about. If they were, we would have seen more character development between father and children and father and wife, which was sorely lacking.

Overall, no reason can come of irrationality or absurdity.

Also, this movie would have definitely been on the Index due to its black magic scenes with the pharmacist. Number IX of the Council of Trent’s Rules on Prohibited Books:All books and writings dealing with geomancy, hydromancy, aeromancy, pyromancy, oneiromancy, chiromancy, necromancy, or with sortilege, mixing of poisons, augury, auspices, sorcery, magic arts, are absolutely repudiated.
 
Another disturbing problem is that *Inception *says murder can be justified as long as the person you are killing is someone’s ā€œprojection,ā€ and since the movie never defines what is reality, anything can be a ā€œprojectionā€ if one thinks it is. Di Caprio’s character snipes men in the snow scene to the architect girl’s surprise; he justifies this by saying they are just another man’s projection. Maybe unborn humans are just our projection, too? If you deceive yourself into thinking so, then maybe they will be just mere ā€œprojections.ā€ Anything goes and there is no objective morality, then. This movie represents well our culture of death.
 
I interpreted the tension in the final scene to be for us as well–it’s not that it doesn’t matter whether the top fell. It matters! We don’t know whether to be happy that Cobb has found reality, or mourn that he is still trapped, but there is a serious difference between the two states, and one is clearly preferable to the other.
By the way, I have an update on that. I’ve heard from several people who stayed to the end of the credits that the top does in fact fall. Which settles it once and for all, he’s in reality at the end. So whether or not it did is now a moot point, because it in fact did. So all arguments with whether the top toppled as it’s basis are now also proven wrong.
Will Geremia now change his mind? No, he’ll find some other inconsequential thread to pull on.

Sheash, no one has faith anymore šŸ˜›
 
My wife and I saw ā€œInceptionā€ yesterday. Not only was it almost three hours long, we came out trying to come up with our own conclusion at the end. The ending can be somewhat confusing if you don’t pay attention to the layers throughout the movie. It had good special FX and the story line was genuine. I enjoy the way that Christopher Nolan challenges the audience to think about his films (ā€œInceptionā€, ā€œThe Prestigeā€, and ā€œMementoā€) and perceive them in various ways. Overall I recommend seeing ā€œInceptionā€ because of the unique storyline, the quality of the film and the fact that it is not another remake . I love this director and I am glad that he can diversify his movie making talents with the like of these films and the Batman: Begins series.
 
Another disturbing problem is that *Inception *says murder can be justified as long as the person you are killing is someone’s ā€œprojection,ā€ and since the movie never defines what is reality, anything can be a ā€œprojectionā€ if one thinks it is. Di Caprio’s character snipes men in the snow scene to the architect girl’s surprise; he justifies this by saying they are just another man’s projection. Maybe unborn humans are just our projection, too? If you deceive yourself into thinking so, then maybe they will be just mere ā€œprojections.ā€ Anything goes and there is no objective morality, then. This movie represents well our culture of death.
Contrary to the plot of the movie, you’re claiming the human shaped ā€œprojectionsā€ of a character’s subconscious are actually people. Can you give any rationale for that claim?
 
My Mark 9:40 says:[bibledrb]Mark 9:40[/bibledrb]
My mistake. In most translations - including the NAB - Mark 9:40 reads, ā€œFor whoever is not against us is for usā€ (that’s the NAB). I think it’s verse 39 in the Douay-Rheims.

I wouldn’t have known that the Douay-Rheims is slightly different, because I don’t use that translation.
Really? How have I done that?
By interpreting it to mean that what isn’t Catholic must be anti-Catholic:
If it’s not Catholic, it’s anti-Catholic.
But perhaps you simply meant ā€œCatholicā€ to mean ā€œmorally, spiritually, and philosophically compatible with Catholicism.ā€ Quite a stretch, but I’ll just give you the benefit of the doubt on this.
The Index must have been stupid, too?
The Index included every book in existence that was written by a non-Catholic? Oh, wait, of course not. :rolleyes:

Let me repeat: A movie can thematically be very philosophically, morally and spiritually compatible with Catholicism, without actually having anything to do with our faith in its explicit plot.
And you support this by saying that the end scene was just there for no reason, no?
And you support this by saying that the end scene must be interpreted in a way that completely goes against everything else in the movie?
The end scene, even visually with its blurred focus, was clearly dream-like. If it was not intended to be, why was it left doubtful; why did not the top definitively topple? The only certainty is doubt; this is skepticism.
If we had been shown two seconds more, we would have been certain whether Cobb’s reunion with his kids was in reality or was in a dream. That’s far from skepticism, Geremia. What’s to stop Cobb from walking back into the room and seeing if the top is still spinning?

If you must know, I think the ending was a warning against complacency for us viewers: i.e. ā€œDon’t think that just because you’ve seen this happy ending that you can get sloppy - you always have to be attentive to what’s real and what’s not, what’s true and what’s not.ā€

The uncertainty obviously can’t apply to Cobb, since he can easily walk back in the room and look at the top. Furthermore, to interpret it to mean that ā€œthe only certainty is doubtā€ goes against the rest of the movie, which always maintained the importance of the difference between reality and dreaming, which solidly rejected the kind of solipsistic existence Cobb was offered in both its plot and its imagery, and which never implied that one cannot ultimately tell what’s real and what’s not, but rather assumed that one always can.

You are paranoid, Geremia, and your reactionary, quasi-fundamentalist attitude of withdrawal when it comes to matters of popular culture is a terrible attitude for Catholics to have. Maybe it would be appropriate for Manicheans. 🤷
There were good parts such as the importance of fatherhood and the desire to return to reality, but they were not what the movie was primarily about. If they were, we would have seen more character development between father and children and father and wife, which was sorely lacking.
There sure was a lot about his relationship with his wife, and it all factored into the theme of the importance of ā€œreturning to reality,ā€ as you actually quite aptly put it.
Also, this movie would have definitely been on the Index due to its black magic scenes with the pharmacist.
Oh, hey, since you’ve just arrived here in your time machine, you should know that Pope Paul VI abolished the Index in June of 1966.
Another disturbing problem is that *Inception *says murder can be justified as long as the person you are killing is someone’s ā€œprojection,ā€ and since the movie never defines what is reality, anything can be a ā€œprojectionā€ if one thinks it is.
If you didn’t have so many posts, I’d be sure your posts were those of a troll. If you’re helping some kind of psychology or philosophy student with a research project on how people react when inundated with shameless absurdity, please PM me and spare me further grief. As much as I’m beginning to suspect that the joke’s on me (and you sure got me, if this is all a joke! :)), I’m nonetheless going to take the bait once again and take you seriously:

Inception does not justify murder ā€œas long as the person you are killing is someone’s ā€˜projection’.ā€ That statement makes no sense, since in the case of what Inception portrayed, there is no ā€œperson you are killingā€ at all. The projections of the rich young guy’s subconscious are not persons in any sense of the word. There’s not even a human being there, which is why your comparison with the unborn makes absolutely no sense.

The basic biology involved proves that at the very least, an abortion kills a living homo sapien. No one and nothing was being killed by Cobb’s gunshots. The only persons involved were all sleeping peacefully on an airplane, remember?
By the way, I have an update on that. I’ve heard from several people who stayed to the end of the credits that the top does in fact fall. Which settles it once and for all, he’s in reality at the end. Sheesh, no one has faith anymore šŸ˜›
Really? I thought I remembered staying to the end credits, and I don’t remember that at all. Maybe I ducked out before it, but then I found this youtube video which also reinforced how I remembered it.

Am I nevertheless missing something, curlycool? What did you friends say exactly?
 
I don’t know what movie you were watching! It was SO much more complex than ESotSM (and I really like that movie). Did you not realize HIGHLIGHT FOR SPOILER:AWESOME MOVIE!
SPOILERS. Scroll past if he you haven’t seen the movie.

:IMDB has two sets of actors for the kids: Phillipa 3 years and 5 years and James 20 months and 3 years. Also, the kids are wearing different clothes. Finally, in the scenes in his dream, Cobb is wearing a wedding ring. In the final scene, Cobb is not wearing a wedding ring.
 
Really? I thought I remembered staying to the end credits, and I don’t remember that at all. Maybe I ducked out before it, but then I found this youtube video which also reinforced how I remembered it.

Am I nevertheless missing something, curlycool? What did you friends say exactly?
Hmm, maybe. I heard it second hand from someone. I’ve been trying to check online, but I can’t seem to get anything conclusive. There’s a second rumour that at the end of the credits you hear the top fall, but obviously we can’t confirm that. I’ll have to see it again, which I was planning to do because the movie is so good.

Although something conclusive I have heard that makes a lot more sense is that at the end, Leo is not wearing a wedding ring. Apparently (again, I can’t confirm from here) he always wears a wedding ring in ā€œdreamlandā€ and never in the real world.

It just doesn’t fit with the rest of the story either. If he was in ā€œdreamlandā€, then he has the ability to shape his world, but the scene before he lets go of the memory of his long dead wife and she is completely absent at the end. It’s a bit contradictory to say that he accepts the reality that is wife is dead, but still chooses to live in a fantasy. Like, if you’re going to live in a fantasy world, why not go all the way?

The only way you really could argue it is if you say that the whole thing is a dream. Which would require ignoring the fact that it doesn’t follow the established rules of dreaming. Unless you want to argue that the rules are different, but at that point you’ve pretty much usurped the entire movie as it is (and that is best left to badly written fan fiction).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top