My Mark 9:40 says:[bibledrb]Mark 9:40[/bibledrb]
My mistake. In most translations - including the NAB - Mark 9:40 reads, āFor whoever is not against us is for usā (thatās the NAB). I think itās verse 39 in the Douay-Rheims.
I wouldnāt have known that the Douay-Rheims is slightly different, because I donāt use that translation.
Really? How have I done that?
By interpreting it to mean that what isnāt Catholic must be anti-Catholic:
If itās not Catholic, itās anti-Catholic.
But perhaps you simply meant āCatholicā to mean āmorally, spiritually, and philosophically compatible with Catholicism.ā Quite a stretch, but Iāll just give you the benefit of the doubt on this.
The Index must have been stupid, too?
The
Index included every book in existence that was written by a non-Catholic? Oh, wait, of course not.
Let me repeat:
A movie can thematically be very philosophically, morally and spiritually compatible with Catholicism, without actually having anything to do with our faith in its explicit plot.
And you support this by saying that the end scene was just there for no reason, no?
And you support this by saying that the end scene
must be interpreted in a way that
completely goes against everything else in the movie?
The end scene, even visually with its blurred focus, was clearly dream-like. If it was not intended to be, why was it left doubtful; why did not the top definitively topple? The only certainty is doubt; this is skepticism.
If we had been shown two seconds more, we would have been certain whether Cobbās reunion with his kids was in reality or was in a dream. Thatās
far from skepticism, Geremia. Whatās to stop Cobb from walking back into the room and seeing if the top is still spinning?
If you must know, I think the ending was a warning against complacency for us viewers: i.e. āDonāt think that just because youāve seen this happy ending that you can get sloppy - you
always have to be attentive to whatās real and whatās not, whatās true and whatās not.ā
The uncertainty obviously canāt apply to Cobb, since he can easily walk back in the room and look at the top. Furthermore, to interpret it to mean that āthe only certainty is doubtā goes against the rest of the movie, which always maintained the importance of the difference between reality and dreaming, which solidly rejected the kind of solipsistic existence Cobb was offered in both its plot and its imagery, and which never implied that one cannot ultimately tell whatās real and whatās not, but rather assumed that one always can.
You are paranoid, Geremia, and your reactionary, quasi-fundamentalist attitude of withdrawal when it comes to matters of popular culture is a terrible attitude for Catholics to have. Maybe it would be appropriate for Manicheans.
There were good parts such as the importance of fatherhood and the desire to return to reality, but they were not what the movie was primarily about. If they were, we would have seen more character development between father and children and father and wife, which was sorely lacking.
There sure was a lot about his relationship with his wife, and it all factored into the theme of the importance of āreturning to reality,ā as you actually quite aptly put it.
Also, this movie would have definitely been on the Index due to its black magic scenes with the pharmacist.
Oh, hey, since youāve just arrived here in your time machine, you should know that Pope Paul VI abolished the Index in June of 1966.
Another disturbing problem is that *Inception *says murder can be justified as long as the person you are killing is someoneās āprojection,ā and since the movie never defines what is reality, anything can be a āprojectionā if one thinks it is.
If you didnāt have so many posts, Iād be
sure your posts were those of a troll. If youāre helping some kind of psychology or philosophy student with a research project on how people react when inundated with shameless absurdity, please PM me and spare me further grief. As much as Iām beginning to suspect that the jokeās on me (and you sure got me, if this is all a joke!

), Iām nonetheless going to take the bait once again and take you seriously:
Inception does not justify murder āas long as the person you are killing is someoneās āprojectionā.ā That statement makes no sense, since in the case of what
Inception portrayed, there
is no āperson you are killingā at all. The projections of the rich young guyās subconscious are not persons in any sense of the word. Thereās not even a human being there, which is why your comparison with the unborn makes absolutely no sense.
The basic biology involved proves that at the very least, an abortion kills a living homo sapien.
No one and nothing was being killed by Cobbās gunshots. The only persons involved were all sleeping peacefully on an airplane, remember?
By the way, I have an update on that. Iāve heard from several people who stayed to the end of the credits that the top does in fact fall. Which settles it once and for all, heās in reality at the end. Sheesh, no one has faith anymore
Really? I thought I remembered staying to the end credits, and I donāt remember that at all. Maybe I ducked out before it, but then I found
this youtube video which also reinforced how I remembered it.
Am I nevertheless missing something, curlycool? What did you friends say exactly?