LOVED IT. It is a movie about revenge, and it’s actually a “western” set in Nazi-occupied France. There’s a scene where Aldo Raines (the Brad Pitt character) tells one of the Gestapo to keep his uniform on, so they can clearly identify the villains: just like the black hat/white hat thing in the old westerns. What’s wrong with re-imagining history or fantasizing about the “what-if’s”?
Also, keep in mind that this is a predominantly foreign film (most of it’s subtitled in French and German) with a predominantly foreign cast and comparatively less violence than other QT movies. It’s much more talky and provocative. It’s really not an action movie. It’s not a splatter fest. It’s a talky, chatty, dialogue-driven movie a lot of people will find really, really, really boring if they’re not paying attention.
And, not to spoil the ending (see my other post), but the film’s ending raises serious questions about the chief villain’s intents and motivations. As for feeling sympathetic towards the villains getting their just desserts, bopping them with baseball bats and scalping swastikas into their foreheads is kid gloves compared to herding Jews into gas chambers - so, no, I don’t feel remotely “sympathetic” or sorry for them at all, if that’s what you’re suggesting. “Judgment at Nuremberg” this was not. No Marlene Dietrich whining about how she was only following orders.
If you haven’t seen the movie (gee, there’s something I never would have guessed), then I’m not quite sure how any of my perspective on the matter would make a difference, since it sounds like you have already concluded it’s trashy and has no socially redeeming value whatsoever. You’re certainly entitled to that conclusion, and it’s not my place to try to persuade you otherwise.