A question for those of you who HAVE seen this film, how faithful is it to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s creation?
Umm…this was my biggest problem with the film.
There were many aspects that they nailed. E.g., the bull pup. I have NEVER seen any Sherlock Holmes film or television show that had the bull pup, even though it’s clearly part of the Canon. It was awesome!
OTOH, more actors have portrayed Sherlock Holmes than any other fictional character (cool, isn’t it?!), so obviously I haven’t seen most of these portrayals, so it’s very likely that other films, television shows, and stage productions HAVE used the bull pup. I have never seen the Ellie Norwood portrayal, and from what I have read, this is the best along with Jeremy Brett. Perhaps this series used the bull pup.
Another Canon aspect that was portrayed was Watson’s gambling problem. Bravo. The Granada television series with Jeremy Brett hinted at the gambling problem. The new movie really emphasized it.
Interestingly, Jude Law made his debut in one of those Granada episodes. He was the stableboy in Shoscombe Olde Place. I think ??? that several other actors in the movie were involved with those Granada episodes, although I haven’t taken the time to look them all up and check.
What really bothered me about this movie was the portrayal of Holmes as a slob in his personal hygiene. Yes, he is definitely a clutterbug, as evidenced by many statements in the Canon about the piles of papers in his rooms, and “the state of his rooms.”
But when it comes to personal hygiene and appearance, Watson describes him as having a “cat-like love of personal cleanliness.”
I really had a difficult time with Holmes portrayed as a slob. Really difficult time.
Also, I think the movie portrayed Holmes and Watson as too “modern.” The characterizations struck me as 2010 men (especially all the wisecracks and sarcasm) lifted into the Victorian Age. That’s just not right, IMO.
One of the things the movie failed to do, IMO, was demonstrate Holmes’ deductive abilities. Yes, he certainly figured out the case (ANY detective, including the people on all the CSI shows on television, would have figured out the case!), but one of the things that makes the Doyle stories so wondrous is that Holmes will not only solve a crime, but in the course of the story, will deduce that a woman in the train station is a professional typist, or a man sitting in a restaurant has recently left his wife. I personally think that more of this “everyday deduction” and less of the spectacular case-related deductions would have made this movie more likeable.
Finally–and I’m not sure if I can explain this–I did not like the portrayal of Holmes as “hyper” in his mind. In the stories, he is described as a “reasoning machine.” He describes to Watson how he carefully and deliberately organizes his brain, ignoring anything (e.g., the Copernican theory of the Solar system) that has nothing to do with his work. The comment about the bridge that Holmes makes early in the film struck me as ridiculous–this doesn’t seem like the type of fact that Holmes would ever bother to remember.
In the film, Holmes appears to be constantly hyper, almost like a child with ADHD. Or perhaps a better word would be “autistic”–he appears unconnected with what’s going on. This is so far from the portrayal in the canon and on the Granada series, in which Holmes is so focused on a case that he doesn’t eat or sleep, and appears positively inhuman, according to Watson.
I also think, along with many critics, that the case in the film is just plain SILLY. Villains taking over the world–utter nonsense. In the stories, Prof. Moriarty, Holmes’ greatest foe, wants MONEY. He never expresses any desire to “rule the world.” That’s the kind of thing that you see on the Saturday morning cartoon shows like Transformers and He-Man, Masters of the Universe. OR in James Bond movies.
I would have liked the film better if they had made it clear that the villain and his group were actually a re-presentation of Aleister Crowley and his occult organization, The Silver Star. Crowley did his evil stuff during the time that Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson were at work in London.
Anyway, I am grateful that the film has once again raised interest in Doyle’s Canon, and I’m sure that many people, especially teenagers, will read the original stories and although many will be bored, there will be some who will become the future Sherlockians and continue the legacy.