Multiple Choice Penance?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Elzee
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

Elzee

Guest
At our Reconciliation Services, the priest assigns a ‘general penance’ for everyone. This can vary from picking your penance form a list of 5 or 6 listed on a sheet of paper handed out to everyone (the choices may be writing an anonymous letter to someone in prison, a community service project, praying for the unemployed, etc.) or just a general ‘everyone say an Our Father’.
Do other parishes do this? Is this a common practice for Reconciliation Services?
 
Penances without individual confession I believe is invalid. General absolution is not allowed except for the following in Canon Law:
Can. 961 §1 General absolution, without prior individual confession, cannot be given to a number of penitents together, unless:

1° danger of death threatens and there is not time for the priest or priests to hear the confessions of the individual penitents;

2° there exists a grave necessity, that is, given the number of penitents, there are not enough confessors available properly to hear the individual confessions within an appropriate time, so that without fault of their own the penitents are deprived of the sacramental grace or of holy communion for a lengthy period of time. A sufficient necessity is not, however, considered to exist when confessors cannot be available merely because of a great gathering of penitents, such as can occur on some major feastday or pilgrimage.

§2 It is for the diocesan Bishop to judge whether the conditions required in §1, n. 2 are present; mindful of the criteria agreed with the other members of the Episcopal Conference, he can determine the cases of such necessity.

Can. 962 §1 For a member of Christ’s faithful to benefit validly from a sacramental absolution given to a number of people simultaneously, it is required not only that he or she be properly disposed, but be also at the same time personally resolved to confess in due time each of the grave sins which cannot for the moment be thus confessed.

§2 Christ’s faithful are to be instructed about the requirements set out in §1, as far as possible even on the occasion of general absolution being received. An exhortation that each person should make an act of contrition is to precede a general absolution, even in the case of danger of death if there is time.

Can. 963 Without prejudice to the obligation mentioned in can. 989, a person whose grave sins are forgiven by a general absolution, is as soon as possible, when the opportunity occurs, to make an individual confession before receiving another general absolution, unless a just reason intervenes.
All the Reconciliation services I have gobe to have had individual confessions afterwards. No general absolution was given during the service.

I would talk to the priest about this. If you do not get any satisfaction there, you may have to go to the bishop.

PF
 
Try to listen carefully to see if the priest mentions anything about grave or mortal sins requiring individual confession. If you don’t hear it, ask the priest off to the side if individual confession is required for serious sin. If he says “no”, then, ask the Holy Spirit for the courgae to tell him that you believe he is violating the directives above. If he says, “so what”, let him know that you have an obligation to report it to the local bishop and if he does nothing, right to the Congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith.

This is hard, but ponder the number of souls that believe errantly that they are receiving absolution and it cannot be given in such a context. There are extreme circumstances when general absolution can take the place of individual confession and trust me, the ordinary American parish is not engaged in anything that would enable it. Think war, major disaster where no privacy or there aren’t enough priests to get through the masses, etc.
 
I"m sorry - I guess I wasn’t very clear. We do have individual confessions at our Reconciliation services …it’s just that the priest doesn’t give individual penances. Before the individual confessions we are told to ‘pick’ from the things I cited in my first post after we are done with our individual confession. (So, the priest does not assign a penance after the individual confesses -we go back to the pew and ‘pick’ our penance from a list prepared ahead of time). Sorry for my poor wording!
 
Gotcha. Not sure how that works. It just seems that it would be easier to give out penances individually in individual confession. What is the big deal? It would take what - 15 seconds?
 
Still do not like the idea. It is human nature to go with the easiest path possible. The penance should fit the sin(s).

The following thread has some unique penances:
Stiffest Penance?
PF
 
40.png
WanderAimlessly:
Still do not like the idea. It is human nature to go with the easiest path possible. The penance should fit the sin(s).

The following thread has some unique penances:Stiffest Penance?
PF
I too am not very accepting of this idea. I think it is better to have the priest suggest what we should do for penance based on the how serious our sins our. Perhaps the priest is hoping that the penitent will feel remorse at choose a tough penance according to their sins. I dunno. I would rather the priest assign penance for me.

matt
 
I have a feeling it’s to save time, but we usually only have about 70 people at our Reconciliation Services (out of a parish of about 3000), and there are always about 6 priests there (they come in from surrounding parishes), so I can’t imagine time is that big a deal…
This set-up isn’t my preference either. I was just curious if other priests did this. I’ve never asked our pastor why he does it.
 
The practice may not be the most desirable, but it is legitimate from what I understand in speaking with some priests who don’t mess around too much. The priest can still assign additional pennance to individual penitents during private confession. I think it would be preferable, however, if he actually assigned one option for everybody rather than saying “pick one from the list”.
 
40.png
Elzee:
I have a feeling it’s to save time, but we usually only have about 70 people at our Reconciliation Services (out of a parish of about 3000), and there are always about 6 priests there (they come in from surrounding parishes), so I can’t imagine time is that big a deal…
This set-up isn’t my preference either. I was just curious if other priests did this. I’ve never asked our pastor why he does it.
I’ve seen it done. Its stupid.
I think the preist being ‘In Persona Christi’ should give the penance. I don’t care if he picks one of 5 options he likes to give. It shouldn’t be up to us.

By the way …the last time I went my priest assigned a nice stiff penance (ignoring the multiple choice nonesense). I thanked him for not having me do the Multiple Choide. He said…he never does.

God Bless Him
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top