Multiple marriages prior to protestant baptism but want to become Catholic AND RE-marry---Can I?

  • Thread starter Thread starter TabbyLilac
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
T

TabbyLilac

Guest
Hi there. I will cut right to the chase. I was raised by atheist parents. In my 20s I was married and divorced twice, both times in civil ceremonies. The first one ended when my husband had a vasectomy without my consent right after discovering I was pregnant. He then forced me to have an abortion. It nearly ruined my life and pushed me into a deep depression. We divorced. I fell into drugs to escape the pain of having my child taken from me. I then married the first man who would go out with me who also wanted children (in a civil ceremony). A month into our marriage he became abusive and told me that he had changed his mind and absolutely did not want children. He became a heavy drug abuser and had severe mental health issues. Finally he was admitted to a psychiatric hospital for a few weeks and I used the opportunity to escape and file for divorce. I was at rock bottom and didn’t know how to fix my life, and then one night I broke down and prayed to God to save me and surrendered myself to Jesus. That was 5 years ago. I have been in a serious relationship with a kind, loving, hardworking, honest man for about 4 years. We have a 2-year old and a 5-month old. We both have good jobs and we were baptized together into the Christian faith along with our newborn daughter at the Methodist Church. We work hard to raise our children right and to be good Christians. I have felt the Catholic Church calling to my heart since I was a child and attended Mass occasionally with a Catholic friend of mine. I have always known that I wanted to be Catholic, that I was Catholic in my heart, but after the many terrible sins I committed earlier in my life (drugs, 2 pointless marriages, lying, cursing, etc) that the Catholic Church would never accept me. Recently though the calling to purse becoming Catholic has been almost a physical sensation and I have begun reading and studying and learning all I can about Catholicism.

I understand that a divorced person who wants to become Catholic and re-marry must obtain an annulment from the Church and that there are certain criteria which must be met. I feel that both of my former “marriages” would meet these criteria but I’m not certain.

For one thing, both marriages took place before I had ever been baptized and was not a Christian. I believe both of my ex-husband’s had been baptized as infants but both were atheists by the time I knew them. Also both were civil ceremonies, not religious ceremonies. And both men decided AFTER we were married that they did not want children, despite the fact that I did and that this had been discussed beforehand.

However, I could not find anything specifically addressing whether it was possible to have TWO marriages annulled or whether the church can only annul one previous marriage. I would greatly appreciate any insight into this… there is SO much riding on it for me. My fiance and I have a family together and wish to become Catholics, be married in the Catholic church, and raise our children as Catholics. My fiance has never been married, but I am so afraid that my 2 awful mistakes of marriages will prevent me from being able to receive sacrament and that our marriage would not be recognized by the Catholic Church.

Can anyone answer this for me? Thank you so much for taking the time to read this.
 
…However, I could not find anything specifically addressing whether it was possible to have TWO marriages annulled or whether the church can only annul one previous marriage. I would greatly appreciate any insight into this… …

Can anyone answer this for me? …
Hello,

There is no limit on the number of marriage cases a person can present. You should contact a local parish priest and/or the local Tribunal for practical advice.

Dan
 
I commend you for wanting to have an opportunity to have your marriage recognized in the Catholic church. I truly hope your wishes come true. I wish you nothing but the best!
 
Two things in your favor is that at the time of your first two marriages you we not baptized. The the eyes of the Church you were not Christian at the time of these two marriages. The other thing in your favor is that your first two marriages were civil ceremonies and not religious ceremonies. The Church does not recognize civil ceremonies as a valid wedding.

On a separate note please consider St. Paul of Tarsus. Prior to his conversion St. Paul was the greatest persecutor of the Church. Yet God choose Saul to be an instrument to the Gentile nations. Welcome Home!
 
Thank you! I struggle with feeling as though I’ve sinned too much in my earlier life to be accepted into the Catholic Faith, which I see as the true Church, and that’s why I am so hesitant even now. But after years of knowing in my heart that it was where I wanted to be, I feel like God has just finally given me the extra nudge I needed to step out in faith and overcome my fear of not being good enough. I know that all have sinned and all fall short, but some of us have made a worse mess of it than others and I’m definitely one of them.
 
Thank you William Joseph, your “welcome home” brought tears to my eyes and joy to my heart. St. Paul is an excellent example of God’s incredible grace and forgiveness and I appreciate the reminder…
 
Thank you! I struggle with feeling as though I’ve sinned too much in my earlier life to be accepted into the Catholic Faith, which I see as the true Church, and that’s why I am so hesitant even now. But after years of knowing in my heart that it was where I wanted to be, I feel like God has just finally given me the extra nudge I needed to step out in faith and overcome my fear of not being good enough. I know that all have sinned and all fall short, but some of us have made a worse mess of it than others and I’m definitely one of them.
You are worthy and a child of God. God wants you to be a part of his union and for you to have God be the center of your life, your husband, your children and your marriage. Do not hesitate to convert and get married in the eyes of God. We all have shortcomings and struggle with sinning. Please stay encouraged! I will be praying for you!
 
Two things in your favor is that at the time of your first two marriages you we not baptized. The the eyes of the Church you were not Christian at the time of these two marriages. The other thing in your favor is that your first two marriages were civil ceremonies and not religious ceremonies. The Church does not recognize civil ceremonies as a valid wedding.

On a separate note please consider St. Paul of Tarsus. Prior to his conversion St. Paul was the greatest persecutor of the Church. Yet God choose Saul to be an instrument to the Gentile nations. Welcome Home!
Quick correction - the church does consider the civil marriages of non-christians to be valid. However in this case there are a number of other issues that would lead one to suspect invalidity. There is also pauline privilege to consider.
 
Praying for you Tabby. I really do think God is calling to you. I’m sorry for the rough start to your life… don’t forget we are all sinners. I really understand the emotional crying out to God to help you get it all straightened out. I did that about 10 years into my marriage and by gollys and by God’s help He led me to a stronger faith in him and stronger belief in the church Jesus made for us… Sincerely…

Our Father
Hail Mary
Glory be
 
The other thing in your favor is that your first two marriages were civil ceremonies and not religious ceremonies. The Church does not recognize civil ceremonies as a valid wedding.
This is not accurate. The Church recognizes civil ceremonies as valid, unless one of the parties was a baptized Catholic and there was no dispensation to marry outside the Church.
 
Thank you! I struggle with feeling as though I’ve sinned too much in my earlier life to be accepted into the Catholic Faith, which I see as the true Church, and that’s why I am so hesitant even now. But after years of knowing in my heart that it was where I wanted to be, I feel like God has just finally given me the extra nudge I needed to step out in faith and overcome my fear of not being good enough. I know that all have sinned and all fall short, but some of us have made a worse mess of it than others and I’m definitely one of them.
TabbyLiliac, Another Saint who is a great example of God’s great Grace is St. Augustine. There is a reason why St. Augustine’s biography is titled Confessions. Actually, St Paul does not look so bad when compared to St. Augustine. Yet it was through St. Augustine that the Church Doctrine of the Trinity was firmly established. God would not be calling you home to the Catholic Church if He was not going to provide you with the means to live as a Catholic Christian.
 
Is the fact that both men were abusive and both were dishonest about their intention to have children in favor of annulment? Maybe I’ve misunderstood the grounds for annulment…
 
Thank you William… you are right. I have never felt more sure of anything than that I’m being called to the Catholic Church by God. I can’t even explain how it felt, after years of feeling drawn there but now knowing how or when, to have a feeling so strong and sudden that it stopped me in my tracks as I was just going about my day. And I knew exactly what I was being told to do. He will provide a way for me… I am grateful for the information and encouragement you’ve give me here today, I will remember St. Paul and St. Augustine. :):)🙂
 
Dear TabbyLilac, thanks be to God that you are listening to His call for you to become a member of the Catholic Church. Please do not worry about whether or not you think that you have grounds for an annulment. Make an appointment to discuss your situation with the local Catholic pastor or call the marriage tribunal in your diocese for the name of someone who can help you to navigate this process. There may be grounds that you are not aware of. You do not have to determine grounds yourself. The local pastor or tribunal representative will help you. When you explain your situation to them, they will advise you on how to proceed. They want to help you to follow the Lord’s will for your life, and will not judge you in any way. Don’t be afraid to make that first call!
 
Thank you Marysann… you are right I think I am trying to figure it out myself and I should just trust in God. My tendency is to want to hide who I used to be because I am ashamed of it, but the truth is that it a testimony to the greatness of God that someone who was as lost in the darkness as I was has come as far as I have. Truly it serves to illustrate God’s power and forgiveness. I will reach out to my local Church and arrange a meeting… thank you for your encouragement!

I almost feel silly saying this, but since I made the decision to become Catholic I have felt almost giddy with joy, and I find that I can’t stop feeling happy and peaceful no matter what is going on around me. I never knew what people really meant when they spoke about feeling God’s love or feeling overcome with love for God, but I do now… suddenly God has become everything, and that’s why I’m so certain that I’m right to follow this feeling. I am so grateful to have found the Catholic Church in all it’s truth and beauty. Maybe that sounds a little extreme, but that’s just how I feel now… like I’ve finally come home, and I didn’t know I wasn’t home until I finally was.🙂
 
Tabby… there is good news. There is nothing that you could have done in your past that God will not forgive. There is also nothing in your past that can keep you out of the church.

With regards to your former marriages each one would have to be looked at individually. What a tribunal would be looking for is if the marriages were valid. By what you have written in your OP I believe you have a strong case for each marriage to be declared invalid.

Basically what the tribunal will need to discover if there were any impediments to the marriage. On such impediment would be if one or both of you were not open to life or if there was sufficient malice or hidden intent with this. To me your first husband was dead set against children and did not inform you of this fact. YOur second husband and yourself for that matter were not in a right state of mind to agree to marriage.

Your first step is to go see a the Pastor of your parish. He will help you to start what may be a long and emotional road.

not to worry though I truly believe that the harder and more emotional this road is (if put to proper use) will reward you with a prize beyond your wildest dreams - for both you and your husband.

Peace!👍
 
Thank you for the hope and encouragement, ProdigalSun!! I am feeling much more hopeful after reading many of these responses and am much less afraid of what the Catholic priest/pastor will think of me (by the way, how DO you refer to him, as a Pastor or a Priest?). Thanks!!!🙂
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top