Murtha nabs $150M pork

  • Thread starter Thread starter gilliam
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Earmarks/pork are essentially legalized bribery.
Yes, you and Vern are correct. It is a system of legalized bribery. Both parties are complicit.
40.png
MelanieAnne:
Congressmen get special appropriations for companies in their home districts.
Companies like defense contractors…
40.png
MelanieAnne:
In turn, companies in their home districts make campaign contributions to the congressman.
…and make things they try to sell to the Pentagon. You can’t take that out of the mix.
40.png
MelanieAnne:
One big money merry-go-round paid for by the already over-taxed taxpayers. It’s corrupt, it’s immoral and it’s wrong. and unfortunately it goes on all the time.
It’s how the military-industrial complex works. It doesn’t only apply to social welfare programs.
 
Earmarks/pork are essentially legalized bribery. Congressmen get special appropriations for companies in their home districts. In turn, companies in their home districts make campaign contributions to the congressman. One big money merry-go-round paid for by the already over-taxed taxpayers. It’s corrupt, it’s immoral and it’s wrong. and unfortunately it goes on all the time.
By my calculations, the whole tab of those listed “legal” bribes comes to $393.5 million.
 
Companies like defense contractors…
Perhaps. And then there are the billions that go towards all kinds of other stuff completely unrelated. Liking building a bridge to nowhere.

And the stuff that the companies you speak of want to try to sell to the Pentagon is stuff the Pentagon doesn’t WANT, doesn’t NEED, and hasn’t REQUESTED. The stuff the Pentagon actually needs is the subject of a separate spending authorization.
 
Perhaps. And then there are the billions that go towards all kinds of other stuff completely unrelated. Liking building a bridge to nowhere.

And the stuff that the companies you speak of want to try to sell to the Pentagon is stuff the Pentagon doesn’t WANT, doesn’t NEED, and hasn’t REQUESTED. The stuff the Pentagon actually needs is the subject of a separate spending authorization.
Some years back, you may have noticed a commuter plane with twin tail booms – the Shorts Sherpa. This aircraft was phased out by the airlines that owned them, and they could be bought for a song. And someone did buy them, refurbished them, and tried to sell them. No takers.

So he went to his senator, who informed the Air Force they needed a fleet of Shorts Sherpas. The Air Force said they didn’t – they had much better aircraft for short haul missions. They pointed out if they bought the Sherpas, they’d also have to train aircrews and maintenence personnel, buy spare parts, tools and on and on – a huge expense for an aircraft they didn’t need.

When the next appropriations bill passed, the Air Force found itself the proud owner of a fleet of Shorts Sherpas.
 
That’s why we need a Line Item Veto in the Constitution, so we can hold one man – the President – responsible for gross overspending.
Vern, on the one hand I agree that a line item veto would be great for trimming pork, and it’s high time something got done about that; but there can be a legitimate use for riders attached to a bill as well, to force the executive’s hand on an issue. Like crushing a bitter pill into a spoonful of honey, it’s something that occasionally needs to be done, and straight-up veto override isn’t always up to the task.

Forcing the executive to accept or reject a bill as a package deal has its purpose; it’s a check on the president’s power, and that’s not something we need less of – especially right now, when the president is using executive orders as if they were the same thing as a line-item veto.
 
Murtha is a former troop. Looks like he’s doing the best of all to “support the troops”. To call a former troop corrupt without basis is an insult to a man doing more to “support the troops’” than any of these other guys.
My dear MelanieAnne, I am the embodiment of reasonable. In fact, if you look at the definition in the dictionary, there’s a picture of me right over the word. 😉
Our MSM has so messed up the usage of so many words, making them up and changing their usage in incorrect ways. One would think that people who talk for a living would do a better job of using words properly. Two that come to mind when talking about our soldiers and Iraq are deploy/redeploy and troops.

Just talking about the word troops here : It’s morphologically plural, has no singular meaning, and furthermore is semantically plural: troops is definitely referring to some number of soldiers higher than one. It has been used without the ‘s’ but still meaning a group (more than one), i.e. a troop of well-wishers. Still it means a group of more than one.

Murtha is a former soldier/airman/Marine (take your pick) would be the proper way to change that sentence. You could also say Murtha, as one of the troops,…

But, troop, as a singular noun, meaning one person of a group, is not a proper word.
 
When are we, as Catholics, going to accept Libertarian economic principles? This is exactly the type of wasteful government spending our country does not need. Perhaps the voting population will one day get so fed up with paying out a third of their income to the government that we can end this sort of nonsense.

I am not, in principle, opposed to smart legislative decisions in regards to directing capital / tax dollars towards legitimate causes. But constitutional principles have been neglected to the n-th degree in this country. By that I mean that “pork” monies, like the ones all our federal legislators obtain, are essentially contributing to causes that are supposed to be left to local and state governing bodies.

So what happens is what has gradually taken place in this nation for almost a century: the end of federalism.

Sometimes governments need to act. Local, state, and federal governments can all be appropriate governing bodies - but in different aspects. Local governments are better equipped to deal with matters that are region-specific. Federal policy-makers should focus on the legislative needs and priorities of America as a whole.

But that is not what we have today. What we have today is a dependent union of fifty states - and representative politicians - trying to position themselves on the federal nipple.

We need to embrace federalism again today if we are even to hope for effective government. And that does not even address what we need to do about entitlement spending.
 
Vern, on the one hand I agree that a line item veto would be great for trimming pork, and it’s high time something got done about that; but there can be a legitimate use for riders attached to a bill as well, to force the executive’s hand on an issue. Like crushing a bitter pill into a spoonful of honey, it’s something that occasionally needs to be done, and straight-up veto override isn’t always up to the task.

Forcing the executive to accept or reject a bill as a package deal has its purpose; it’s a check on the president’s power, and that’s not something we need less of – especially right now, when the president is using executive orders as if they were the same thing as a line-item veto.
Many states have line item vetos in their constitutions and we can see how they work – and pick the best. The congress can always over-ride a line item veto – but the beauty of it is that the over-ride must pass on its own merits.

If the majority of Representatives and Senators don’t think a billion dollars for a doll museum in Pickleville is worth it, it won’t pass.
 
When are we, as Catholics, going to accept Libertarian economic principles? This is exactly the type of wasteful government spending our country does not need. Perhaps the voting population will one day get so fed up with paying out a third of their income to the government that we can end this sort of nonsense.

I am not, in principle, opposed to smart legislative decisions in regards to directing capital / tax dollars towards legitimate causes. But constitutional principles have been neglected to the n-th degree in this country. By that I mean that “pork” monies, like the ones all our federal legislators obtain, are essentially contributing to causes that are supposed to be left to local and state governing bodies.

So what happens is what has gradually taken place in this nation for almost a century: the end of federalism.

Sometimes governments need to act. Local, state, and federal governments can all be appropriate governing bodies - but in different aspects. Local governments are better equipped to deal with matters that are region-specific. Federal policy-makers should focus on the legislative needs and priorities of America as a whole.

But that is not what we have today. What we have today is a dependent union of fifty states - and representative politicians - trying to position themselves on the federal nipple.

We need to embrace federalism again today if we are even to hope for effective government. And that does not even address what we need to do about entitlement spending.
I want to know how it got to be that our elected representatives can get away with this stuff and we have absolutely no recourse!
I watched a ‘youtube’ (first-timer there, honest 🙂 last night and some veterans were asking their Senator to view a video. He ignored them all they way out of the building and into his waiting car. He wouldn’t even give them the courtesy of any kind of a response. Who the heck does he think writes his huge, overblown paycheck? He works for these people.
 
I want to know how it got to be that our elected representatives can get away with this stuff and we have absolutely no recourse!
I watched a ‘youtube’ (first-timer there, honest 🙂 last night and some veterans were asking their Senator to view a video. He ignored them all they way out of the building and into his waiting car. He wouldn’t even give them the courtesy of any kind of a response. Who the heck does he think writes his huge, overblown paycheck? He works for these people.
Sad scenario, no? These folks in DC don’t care what their constituents think obviously. And the reason they don’t is because they depend on the ignorance (lack of knowledge) of their constituents and the propensity of voters to re-elect the incumbents. I wager that more than 60% of the constituents do not have a clue what their representatives (Senate and House) are doing and really don’t care. They are too busy doing their everyday things and it is just too much trouble to keep tabs on the Congress. Then, lo and behold, one day they wake up a are astonished at what has been passed. Case in point–the bill ostensibly passed yesterday giving benefits to illegal aliens who are working here. Only bright note here is that the bill was in the House and has not reached the Senate yet.

Personally, I would love to totally clean house in the Congress, throw out the bad, and the good, and start all over. Surely we can do better than this. But not before the electorate wakes up and smells the putridity emanating from the District.
 
I want to know how it got to be that our elected representatives can get away with this stuff and we have absolutely no recourse!
We do have recourse. We can vote them out. Less than half of all eligible voters do not vote. Those that run for office know this and behave accordingly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top