MUSIC: Chanticleer

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cracker_Mom
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Counter tenors? I don’t have full range but, indeed, I am perfectly capable of singing counter tenor (with no, ahem, modifications). We have two women in our choir who sing tenor. The vocal range of human beings extends across the spectrums.
Yes, it is pretty amazing. You’re two female choir members are probably contraltos (think Kathleen Ferrier, Marian Anderson and Ewa Podles. All voices, if they have good technique, are trained to have between 2 1/2 to 3 octaves, although, they will have their strengths in certain areas of the voice - which is why they have soprano, mezzo, alto, contralto, counter-tenor, tenor, baritone, bass-baritone, bass, etc.

It’s funny, as much as I have performed with and seen countertenors, I still get “disconcerted” when I watch them sing. I have to close my eyes. But the majority of countertenors sing early music, and really not much past the 18th century. So you don’t hear much singing Rossini arias or any of the bel cantor repertoire. Some countertenors just sound like guys who sing in falsetto. Others literally sound like women. It makes me wonder what the Castrati really sounded like. There is only one recording of one, but the guy was so old and not in his prime, so we really can’t tell.

One time I sang Handel’s “Ombra mai fu” for a masterclass (I’m a mezzo) and the counter-tenor said to me, “Hey! That’s MY aria.” We had a fun competitive banter with each other.

Here is Andreas Scholl - one of the more popular countertenors of this time:

youtube.com/watch?v=6yGFtA3E-ys

And here he is singing alto in Buxtehude’s Membra Jesu Nostri “Ad faciem”

youtube.com/watch?v=xkylqyHdBwQ&feature=related
 
Just had to add the Chanticleer version of Biebl’s “Ave Maria”.

Beautiful. I usually prefer mixed choirs as I don’t really like adult men singing the high soprano line in any music, but the all-male choir for this works.

youtube.com/watch?v=dVBsNUXg_YM
 
I was an instrumentalist back in the '60s when I was a music major in college, so I’m not sure what the dif is between a guy singing falsetto and a counter-tenor. However, in the '90s when I was singing bass in the Faith Baptist Church choir and tenor in the Knights of Harmony I had (on a good day) a 3-octave range, bracketing E-flats. As far a barbershop tenors are concerned, I was told that most good barbershop tenors are actually basses singing falsetto.

I would have liked ot have had a crack at singing some Early Music. Not much chance of that around here.

DaveBj
 
In the spirit of PDQ Bach, I would call myself a bargain counter tenor 😃 I can sing into the mid alto range without straining. I don’t think this is falsetto.

Nor do I think that Chanticleer’s counter tenors were singing in falsetto. In an intimate adudtorium they project a wall of sound which is quite amazing. There was nothing of falsetto in their counter tenors.
 
I think this description of a countertenor is helpful in understanding how the voice is used. Most countertenors use a falsetto or head voice, but they do come in all shapes and sizes, so it’s not “one size fits all” type of voice - basically like almost all voice types. I got this from Wikipedia, but my opera/music text books pretty much describe it in the same way.:

"A trained countertenor will typically have a vocal centre similar in placement to that of a contralto or mezzo-soprano.[12] Peter Giles, a professional countertenor and noted author on the subject, defines the countertenor as a musical part rather than as a vocal style or mechanism. In modern usage, the term “countertenor” is essentially equivalent to the medieval term contratenor altus (see above). In this way, a countertenor singer can be operationally defined as a man who sings the countertenor part, whatever vocal style or mechanism is employed.[13] The countertenor range is generally equivalent to an alto range, extending from approximately G or A3 to E5 or perhaps F5. In actual practice, it is generally acknowledged that a majority of countertenors sing with a falsetto vocal production for at least the upper half of this range, although most use some form of “chest voice” (akin to the range of their speaking voice) for the lower notes. The most difficult challenge for such a singer is managing the lower middle range, for there are normally a few notes (around Bflat3) that can be sung with either vocal mechanism, and the transition between registers must somehow be blended or smoothly managed.[14]

In response to the (in his view) pejorative connotation of the term falsetto, Giles refuses to use it, calling the upper register “head voice.”[15] Many voice experts would disagree with this choice of terminology, reserving the designation “head voice” for the high damped register accompanied by a relatively low larynx that is typical of modern high operatic tenor voice production. The latter type of head voice is, in terms of the vocal cord vibration, actually more similar to “chest voice” than to falsetto, since it uses the same “speaking voice” production (referred to as “modal” by voice scientists), and this is reflected in the timbre.[16]

Other authorities would prefer to restrict use of the term countertenor to singers employing little or no falsetto, equating it with haute-contre and the Italian term tenor altino.[17] Russell Oberlin was himself a countertenor of this type, noted for his ability to sing alto and/or countertenor parts extending above C5 (the notorious “tenor high C” popularized by Italian opera) while still employing modal voice (many high tenors, particularly those who specialise in the bel canto repertoire of Rossini, Bellini, Donizetti, and their contemporaries can also do this, but generally use a more robust voice production). Some writers insist that this can only be accomplished physically by a man in possession of vocal cords considerably shorter than average,[18] and that such a singer would therefore possess an unusually high speaking voice (a falsettist countertenor normally speaks as a baritone or bass). Like the haute-contre, these tenorial countertenors have a lower range and tessitura than their falsettist counterparts, perhaps from D3 to D5. Those authorities who hold that only non-falsettists are “real” countertenors would prefer the phrase “male alto” for the more common falsettist type.[19]

Some falsettist countertenors have a much higher range, approaching that of a coloratura soprano. These are usually called sopranists or simply “male sopranos”. [20] There are in addition a few rare adult male singers who, for hormonal or other physical reasons, did not undergo the voice-change associated with male puberty, and are referred to as endocrinological castratos.[21]"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top