Muslim Incorruptibles?

  • Thread starter Thread starter lukpet
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
L

lukpet

Guest
I have read many comments from muslims which have witnessed, or at least someone from their familiy has, that a body of a muslim was fresh after months, or was even still bleeding.
Examples:
https://www.quora.com/Is-it-true-that-the-bodies-of-martyred-Muslims-don-t-decay-when-they-re-buried

https://www.quora.com/I-get-message...esh-intact-in-graves-Who-has-seen-such-a-body

These people seem to be very serious. How would you explain it? Do you think it is fake, or is it somehow scientifically possible or is it possible that the devil makes such miracles in order to trick the people? Thank you for your answers, I have really struggled with this today.
 
Why do you assume Muslims can’t be good, holy people too? They have truth, they believe in the Abrahamic God but they don’t have the fullness of the faith. If a miracle happens, it’s from God.

With that being said, not all accounts of a miracle happening actually happen. This is true in our church as well.

Bokbok
 
Yep, and why wouldn’t God be able to perform miracles outside the Christian religion? I think there are many good, holy Muslims that try to do the will of God. I know personally some not good, holy Muslims, that are rather indifferent about God. Muslims have quite a few things in their religion that are quite correct, but they’re missing the one thing that is the most important. I think, that being said, that just because someone alleges a miracle happened, does not make it so. that is not to say, I believe that the people who claim it happened are lying, I very much believe in miracles. But I believe that Miracles are rare for a reason. Part of that reason is, they would cease to be Miracles if they were not rare.
 
We should consider what purpose God would have in preserving the body of a non-Catholic. It’s certainly a miraculous thing for someone’s body to avoid corruption, but God wouldn’t do this in order to lead people to Islam or keep current Muslims where they are.

It would help to look at their personal lives and see if there’s a chance they had secretly become Christian, or if perhaps they had been exploring it and converted (privately or publicly) before their death.

We could also perhaps look at this as the gospels do. We can see ourselves as the Jews, who Jesus desired to spread His message to first, and these Muslims as Gentiles, who God also speaks to and is willing to work miracles for.
 
Last edited:
It’s impossible because it’s not divine they don’t believe in the one true God
 
That is this 19th century priest’s opinion, not dogmatic fact. In the Gospel we see those who are not among Christ’s disciples casting out demons and doing so effectively. The apostles, in fact, complained to Christ about this and Christ rebuked them. God, in his mercy and love, working a miracle through a material heretic is not validating the heresy!
This sounds a lot like Donatism, but applied to miracles rather than the sacraments. By the logic present above, is not God confirming heresy / schism when He allows the Eucharist to be confected by a heretical or schismatic priest? Yet we know that happens.
 
Disagrees with what say ing miracles can happen in Muslim religion s or Buddhism or what ever
 
Last edited:
Wrong wrong my friend they don’t believe in our Lord Jesus He is the one true God one and only one read the 1st commandment t
 
Last edited:
How would you explain the people claiming this? Do you think they are lying because it is practically imposslible scientifically that a dead body is fresh and bleeds after a month. Or that one that claims that it happened in their family that after several months the body was like at the beginning.
 
Okay, so it is possible that the devil performs miracles in order to decieve people into heresies and apostasy?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top