Muslims is this true?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Timi_Celcer
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I can’t comment on the most of the hadith in the OP, but I an tell you Shias like me consider Sahih Bukhari as a Sunni book and thus we don’t give much consideration for it.

As for fornicators, the punishment is 100 if there are 4 witnesses who saw the act with their eyes (and I think the witnesses have to be pious…).

As for lying about your faith, Shias say that if your life (or your family) is in danger, you an conceal your faith if you fear harm.
 
As for fornicators, the punishment is 100 if there are 4 witnesses who saw the act with their eyes (and I think the witnesses have to be pious…).
This begs the question, what exactly were all these pious individuals doing in the fornicators’ bedrooms in the first place?
 
This begs the question, what exactly were all these pious individuals doing in the fornicators’ bedrooms in the first place?
Yes.
Which means you have to do it in public to get caught…
 
In response to the original post, it should be noted that the Christian scriptures are filled with commandments forbidding everything from wearing mixed fabrics to boiling goats in milk, and ordering the people of Israel to do things we now consider heinous- – stoning rebellious children, for instance. I would humbly submit that the world which created the Quran and which created the Bible are more removed from us than one another. They are marked by the limitations of the people who made them, just as anything we produce here, even when inspired by God, is marked by our own limitations.

In peace…
 
This begs the question, what exactly were all these pious individuals doing in the fornicators’ bedrooms in the first place?
This ruling is supposed to go right with Jesus’ “let the one without sin throw the first stone”.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top