Muslims Opinion About This ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter rad
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi there. 🙂

First of all, it doesn’t really signify anything to Islam. It doesn’t mean that the Pope converted, or that he canonized the Qur’an. For sure, Muslims do not need the approval of another faith for their scripture–and in fact it would actually insult the nobility of the Qur’an if it were “canonized” as Christian scripture. It certainly doesn’t suggest to Muslims at all that Christians either accept the Qur’an as truth or scripture for them.

It was simply a very nice gesture to demonstrate to Catholics and to Muslims a kind of tolerance. You might not know this, but Muslims in general treat the Bible with respect just like they do with the Qur’an. In fact, it is even strange to me since I don’t even see the Bible that way, but for example–they would put the Bible on the highest shelf, and would not put anything (except for another Bible or a Qur’an) on top of it. They wouldn’t put it under their chair, take it in to the bathroom, or anything like that. Even though they don’t consider it the same way they do the Qur’an, they still respect it.

And Muslims often do kiss the Qur’an just as an etiquette for them. I don’t do it personally but I do try to handle my mushaf (Arabic Qur’an) with care. I try more to respect it by following the teachings inside it. So I think the Pope kissing it is just a nice gesture, and nothing more.

Did he get Paradise for doing that? I’m not sure why anyone would ever suggest that, there is no teaching in Islam that just kissing the Qur’an forgives sins or anything like that… but surely, God Almighty only knows who will enter the Garden, and who will enter the Fire.
I want to thank you for you wonderful reply…it clears a lot up for me in my misunderstanding…
Now hamba mentioned in one of his posts that heaven is the same for christians and muslims and jews for all people as well as hell…now do chistians jews and others that achieved salvation receive the 72 virgins as well, or is that only for the mayrters that died for the defense of the islamic faith…i thank you in advance …rad
 
Since the late John Paul 11 kissed the Quran ,What Does it signify to islam, does it mean to you that he converted secretly ,and that he cannonized your scripture as true, and catholic christians can accept it now as part of their cannon…and according to islamic belief…
Did the Late Pope John Paul 11 receive islamic heaven and all it has to offer by this action as a reward…

This has been on my mind For quite a long time,hope some muslims here can answer this for me…
Respect. It means respect of another’s holy book. Because it is dear to them, good manner would dictate you to show respect, especially if you were a guest to the person’s house. Pope John Paul 2 did not commit sin for that nor he would go to hell for that. In fact I respect him for that for showing respect to others eventhough he may not agree with them.

Different cultures show respect in different ways. Some bow, some kiss; it doesn’t matter. We do kiss the Bible. The priests kiss the Bible. It does not mean we worship it; only in this case we believe in it.

Do not read too much in Pope John Paul 2 kissing that Quran other than just a respect for his hosts. Maybe Muslims would not kiss the Bible had they be in Pope John Paul 2 situation. But then again, it’s just a difference in culture. No problem. I am sure Muslim leaders would do the same - showing respect in their own way and withim the limit of their decorum. It was heartwarming to see those Muslim leaders attending the funeral mass of the late Pope.
 
Hi there. 🙂

First of all, it doesn’t really signify anything to Islam. It doesn’t mean that the Pope converted, or that he canonized the Qur’an. For sure, Muslims do not need the approval of another faith for their scripture–and in fact it would actually insult the nobility of the Qur’an if it were “canonized” as Christian scripture. It certainly doesn’t suggest to Muslims at all that Christians either accept the Qur’an as truth or scripture for them.

It was simply a very nice gesture to demonstrate to Catholics and to Muslims a kind of tolerance. You might not know this, but Muslims in general treat the Bible with respect just like they do with the Qur’an. In fact, it is even strange to me since I don’t even see the Bible that way, but for example–they would put the Bible on the highest shelf, and would not put anything (except for another Bible or a Qur’an) on top of it. They wouldn’t put it under their chair, take it in to the bathroom, or anything like that. Even though they don’t consider it the same way they do the Qur’an, they still respect it.

And Muslims often do kiss the Qur’an just as an etiquette for them. I don’t do it personally but I do try to handle my mushaf (Arabic Qur’an) with care. I try more to respect it by following the teachings inside it. So I think the Pope kissing it is just a nice gesture, and nothing more.

Did he get Paradise for doing that? I’m not sure why anyone would ever suggest that, there is no teaching in Islam that just kissing the Qur’an forgives sins or anything like that… but surely, God Almighty only knows who will enter the Garden, and who will enter the Fire.
This is a very mature and balanced comment that I see on this subject for a very long time. Thank you very much. I think you said it better than me, and we are of different religions! Praise God that we can see it the same way. 👍
 
Since the late John Paul 11 kissed the Quran ,What Does it signify to islam, does it mean to you that he converted secretly ,and that he cannonized your scripture as true,
Sorry to say that, but if that was true, then to me it means that he didn’t implement what the Bible described about other religions:

(2 John 1:9):
“Anyone who runs ahead and does not continue in the teaching of Christ does not have God; whoever continues in the teaching has both the Father and the Son.”
 
Since the late John Paul 11 kissed the Quran ,What Does it signify to islam, does it mean to you that he converted secretly ,and that he cannonized your scripture as true, and catholic christians can accept it now as part of their cannon…and according to islamic belief…
Did the Late Pope John Paul 11 receive islamic heaven and all it has to offer by this action as a reward…

This has been on my mind For quite a long time,hope some muslims here can answer this for me…
The Pope above is a Christian. He just kissed the Quran out of trying to be friendly. Muslims understand that . We respect him for doing so , and actually he was a respected person in the Islamic world and by islamic scholars for his outreach in General.

He is a Christian and he never advocated Islam , not that we Muslims care .

meedo
 
hahah so the pope is a pagan for praying before a statue of the virign mary? yet you muslims kiss the black stone which comes straight from arab paganism and was considered to be the supreme rock god of the kaaba😃
 
The pope did it out of respect, that’s all. Why bash him about it? I’d like to see some Muslim scholar (are there any?) kiss a Catholic bible, you know that ain’t gonna happen anytime soon…
 
Islam teaches that believers and unbelievers will have different fates that await them in the Hereafter… and so, if anyone does not believe in the Truth of Islam, then is there any reason at all why they would want to know the rewards that is promised for the believers in Paradise?

Anyhow, here is a desription of what awaits the believers in Paradise.

The Qur’an and Sunnah are full of references to Paradise and the great reward that is in store for those who believe and do righteousness in this life. The reward for goodness is eternal goodness, and the reward for evil is torment and despair.

Rewards for males and females, although different according to their inherent nature that Allah has created them with, are equally gratifying. No one will feel any resentment towards others, nor envy. Peace is the state in which all will exist forever, regardless of any differences they may have had in this life.

The Qur’an says what means:

{If any do deeds of righteousness—be they male or female—and have faith, they will enter Heaven, and not the least injustice will be done to them.} (An-Nisaa’ 4:124)

They will wear the finest clothing and live in the best of surroundings. It was narrated by Imam Muslim that Abu Bakr ibn `Abdullah ibn Qais reported on the authority of his father that Allah’s Messenger (may peace be upon him) said that in Paradise there would be for a believer a tent of a single hollowed pearl the breadth of which would be sixty miles. It would be meant for a believer, and the believers would go around it and none would be able to see the others.

In the same regards, Allah says in His glorious Book what means:

{Allah will admit those who believe and work righteous deeds, to Gardens beneath which rivers flow: they shall be adorned therein with bracelets of gold and pearls; and their garments there will be of silk.} … (Al-Hajj 22:23)

He also says what means:

{[Other] faces that Day will be joyful, pleased with their striving, in a Garden on high, where they shall hear no [word] of vanity: Therein will be a bubbling spring: Therein will be thrones [of dignity], raised on high, goblets placed [ready], and cushions set in rows, and rich carpets [all] spread out.} … (Al-Ghashiyah 88:8-16)

Trees bearing fruits of all kinds, and of types we have not seen or imagined, will be there for those who strived to do their best in this life. The trees will bend their branches down for believers to reach them! All we need to do is to long for a particular one. Rivers of wine that does not intoxicate, rivers of honey, the purest of waters, and milk are all waiting for believers to enjoy.

Eternal youth will be the state of existence for those who inhabit Paradise. The food of Paradise is so pure that their bodies will not produce any wastes, only sweat whose fragrance is musk.

But just as the best things in this life do not come easy, neither does the reward of Paradise come cheap. It does requires great effort to live a righteous life in Islam and invite others to it as well. Believers must struggle with their utmost effort to achieve excellence in everything they do and in every relationship they have so that they can achieve the utmost in rewards i.e. Paradise.

The Qur’an says what means:

{Be quick in the race for forgiveness from your Lord, and for a Garden whose width is that [of the whole] of the heavens and of the earth, prepared for the righteous.} … (Aal `Imran 3:133)

The Prophet (peace be upon him) clearly stated in his description of Paradise that in it there is “what an eye has not seen, what en ear has not heard and what has not crossed the heart of a human.” All the physical descriptions of Paradise mentioned in the Qur’an and Sunnah are merely but examples of what Allah has promised His righteous believers. Yet, the ability of Allah to create and prepare for them is much more. He has created all the beauty in existence out of nothing, simply by His own will.

This hadith of the Prophet (pbuh) really explains that these physical promises are just a small simple part of what God can provide those whom He elevates to enter His Paradise. What is available in Paradise is beyond our imagination; we need to remember that God is capable of creating what is beyond our imagination.

Also, the hadith states that there will be what not had crossed the ‘heart’ of humans. It does not say the ‘mind’, but the ‘heart’. The heart longs more and dreams more than the logical mind. The mind might have limits in its dreams. It is limited by logic and by what is ‘possible’. As for the heart, it only longs and dreams of what it wants and loves, whether it is logical or not.

What can explain this more is a verse which says what means:

{They shall have what they will of their Lord’s bounty. That is the reward of the good-doers.} … (Az-Zumar 39:34)

The situation there is completely different. Here we get what we strive for. But there, we get what we will. So, we simply need to will. A person might will to eat a piece of fruit, while another might will to meet with God!

However, the most important promise of all in Paradise is → encountering our Creator!

It would be such a loss to come to this life not knowing Who brought one here. It would be an even greater loss never to encounter Him. It is the loss of people of Hellfire that they are prohibited from encountering Him and it is the blessing of people of Paradise to encounter Him.
 
The only paradise we will see is the Heaven of Jesus Christ who will be seateth at the right hand of the Father.
 
I read somewhere, maybe on This forum a while back ,that the late Pope John Paul 11,actually didn’t kiss the Quran, but was sniffing It to see if it had a Genuine leather cover…who knows anything can be possable…
 
I read somewhere, maybe on This forum a while back ,that the late Pope John 11,actually didn’t kiss the Quran, but was sniffing It to see if it had a Genuine leather cover…who knows anything can be possable…
:rotfl: :rotfl: :rotfl:
 
I read somewhere, maybe on This forum a while back ,that the late Pope John Paul 11,actually didn’t kiss the Quran, but was sniffing It to see if it had a Genuine leather cover…who knows anything can be possable…
😃 Hvala for your sense of humour.
 
😃 Hvala for your sense of humour.
Hello Brate ! sta ima novo …im keeping up with your posts, their really informative ,lot’s of things i didn’t know about Islam …interesting i must say…Mir Boziji…
 
😃 Hvala for your sense of humour.
Hello Brate ! sta ima novo …im keeping up with your posts, their really informative ,lot’s of things i didn’t know about Islam …interesting i must say…Mir Boziji…😛
 
Hello Brate ! sta ima novo …im keeping up with your posts, their really informative ,lot’s of things i didn’t know about Islam …interesting i must say…Mir Boziji…😛
Thanks Brate! I also go to the Orthodox forum from time to time. Peace and blessings! pozdrav. 😉
 
I want to thank you for you wonderful reply…it clears a lot up for me in my misunderstanding…
Now hamba mentioned in one of his posts that heaven is the same for christians and muslims and jews for all people as well as hell…now do chistians jews and others that achieved salvation receive the 72 virgins as well, or is that only for the mayrters that died for the defense of the islamic faith…i thank you in advance …rad
Personally, I’m not aware of an authentic teaching of Islam about 72 virgins. Are you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top