Muslims, Why do you defile Religious sites of other Religions

  • Thread starter Thread starter Cursilista
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
C

Cursilista

Guest
Hagia Sophia in Turkey, once the main church of Christianity in the east turned into a mosque. Building a mosque on top of the remains of the Jewish Temple in Jeruaselum.
Blowing up the Buddas in, I believe, Afgahastan or Pakistan.

Im sure there must be other examples as well. Could you explain why your religion does these things. It is an insult to these people.
 
Hagia Sophia in Turkey, once the main church of Christianity in the east turned into a mosque. Building a mosque on top of the remains of the Jewish Temple in Jeruaselum.
Blowing up the Buddas in, I believe, Afgahastan or Pakistan.

Im sure there must be other examples as well. Could you explain why your religion does these things. It is an insult to these people.
The Temple of Athena in Athens was turned into a Christian Church. The Great Mosque at Cordoba was turned into a Christian Church. The al-Aqsa mosque on the Temple Mount was turned into a Church by the Crusaders.

As to the Bamiyan Buddhas, I believe you have the same thing in Christianity, the commandment about graven images. It appears that some Muslims take it more seriously than you do.

If you are ever in Spain then a visit to the Mezquite in Cordoba would be educational.

(Please Note: This uploaded content is no longer available.)

Not many other Christian Churches look like that inside. Well worth a visit.

rossum
 
Excellent answer, rossum.

OP, you are approaching the question from a very American point of view, one which is not religiously based. If the US conquered another country, we would not put American houses of worship in native houses of worship, because there is no such thing as an American Religion.

However, when a culture with a single religion has conquered another, houses of worship frequently ARE replaced. Rome is full of pagan temples converted to Christian churches. And why not, since the conquering culture views the native one as idolatrous, or at least wrong in their worship if they acknowledge the same God? They see it as a benefit to the people - putting them on the right path.

I don’t like the fact that Hagia Sophia is a mosque/museum either, but that’s what happens when you lose.
 
Also, you have to take into account how different religions spread. The beginning of Christianity was not involved in destroying and killing. There was indeed a conversion throughout the ancient Roman world.

I saw a program on EWTN. Iraq and Syria were heavily Christian countries, and they fell through the sword. Islam spread through the sword into Northern Africa, but it fell in part due to many heresies among the people as well as losses from the bubonic plague.

Islam spread into Christian Spain whose sovereignty was always up for grabs until Islam took over Spain for over 700 years. Hard to imagine that…but then the Spanish finally overcame them.

The Byzantine world was first attacked in the 600’s but overcame the Muslim military forces. Then Constantinople fell hundreds of years later and the streets were deep in blood. The area of Bosnia had the child tax put on the Christians so that the oldest and brightest son was forced to become Muslim and work for the spreading of Islam.

The Barbery Coast was the source of kidnappings of Christian women used for sex slaves as well as their children enslaved, and the older boys were then forced to become Muslim soldiers. Check out the European white slave market of those times. The Barbary pirates and the Battle of Tripoli…that is our first American military excursion after our independence.

What set off the Crusades was not only the slow coming (400 years) of pleas by Christians in Jerusalem to restore the Holy Lands, and the attack on pilgrims by the Suljak Turks, but the Calilph’s exclamation that St. Peter’s Basilica would be used for horse watering and stables. I heard a militant Muslim speak within the past 2 years that they tried two times to take over the Vatican, the third time they will.

The Muslims were advancing into France and the turning point was Charles Martel and the Battle of Tours. There is also reference to the Battle of Lepanto and the exhortation to pray the rosary. My friend works in a diocese whose cathedral displays the skulls of 800 Italian Catholic men who were beheaded for refusing to submit to Islam. Sicily and Sardenia were under Muslim rule. Richard of Avalon drove out the Muslims.

Since 9/11 I have studied Islamic expansion and what I heard last night coincides with the various and contradictory sources I read. If we had not had these battles, the Europeans would be studying Islam. Unfortunately, when it comes to militant Islam the response is prayer, fasting and diplomacy for our times and realizing we are dealing with a very different mentality and world most foreign to us. When it comes to protecting the remains of Christianity, when all else avails, then what would we do?

There are empty church buildings in my town that are being purchased and used for other purposes. So it is also worthwhile to know the context of how the Buddhist temple was turned into a church.

Otherwise, as a human being I would be offended to by taking someone’s place of worship for their own.
 
what was the name of this church which changed to mosque ?

can you give us references with some details ?

thanx 🙂

editing

In 638 the Islamic Caliphate extended its dominion to Jerusalem.[54] With the Arab conquest, Jews were allowed back into the city.[55] The Rashidun caliph Umar ibn al-Khattab signed a treaty with Monophysite Christian Patriarch Sophronius, assuring him that Jerusalem’s Christian holy places and population would be protected under Muslim rule.[56] Umar refused to pray in the church, so that the descendant Muslims would not request converting the church to a mosque. He prayed outside the church, where the Mosque of Umar (Omar) stands till the present time.

When the Muslims went to Bayt Al-Maqdes for the first time, They searched for the site of the Far Away Holy Mosque (Al-Masjed Al-Aqsa) that was mentioned in Quran and Hadith according to Islamic beliefs. They found the site full of rubbish, they cleaned it and started using it for prayers thereafter.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerusalem
 
what was the name of this church which changed to mosque ?
The reference may be to al-Aqsa which was turned back from a Christian Church to a mosque after the Moslem reconquest of Jerusalem from the Crusaders.

rossum
 
The reference may be to al-Aqsa which was turned back from a Christian Church to a mosque after the Moslem reconquest of Jerusalem from the Crusaders.

rossum
thank you , i doubted in that either , so that i edited my post with what wiki site said about it
 
Christians turned religious sites of others’ into churches in lands they conquered in Medieval times as well. Hagia Sofia is not going to be turned back into a church and the Grand Mosque of Cordoba is not going to be turned back into a mosque, just get over it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top