The antiquity of Catholic vestments make them no less odd to an outsider than do the robes and cloaks some Wiccans use.
My friends do no use robes and such…they do have a set of clothes that they use in their rituals however…he a lose fitting pair of pants and tunic like shirt…she a loose fitting skirt and peasant top. The coven they lead does not have a dress code so any one can wear what they like. They keep a special set of clothes however…dedicated to use when in Circle…their “Sunday go to Meeting” equivalent.
While many of the Celtic and Anglo-Saxon culture DID fear the “witch”…their legacy of history comes down mostly thru “Christian” sources. However another tradition also comes down in the form of the “wise woman”…“midwife”…“shaman” of a tribe…“lore keeper”…and “teachers” of the village or clan…these are also part of the “pagan tradition” the Neo-Pagans seek to “reconstruct”.
While the Wiccan tradition of the Neo-Pagan Reconstructionist movement may be a small part of a greater Neo-Pagan movement…many of them have risen to leadership and spokesmen roles in the greater community. Selena Fox, Starfire, Margot Adler, Janet Farar, Gavin Bone, Isaac Bonewits have published numerous books and tomes seeking a deeper spiritulaity among the Neo-Pagan sub-culture.
To dismiss them out of hand and portray them as foolish individuals seems to lack charity…a perspective from my Quaker heritgage perhaps…but to diminish others to build our selves up…seems out of place for one calling oneself a “Christian”…perhaps that too is a Quakerly influence not shared by the greater Christian community.