My dilemma

  • Thread starter Thread starter Worried_girl
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
W

Worried_girl

Guest
Hello everyone

I have a very sensitive personal dilemma which has been on my mind for over a year now. It is really getting to me, but it’s not the kind of thing I could ever talk to anyone about in person so I’ve decided to join this forum because I know the members are good people and I am hoping for some compassionate advice.

Before I explain any further I just want to say how awful I feel about my part in this situation. I am not usually a bad person but I did a very bad and messed up thing and now I am living with the consequences. I just don’t know what to do for the best at this point. I’ll admit further that I am and have been a coward (but that will become clear from my story).

The short version of this is that just over a year ago, I told a serious lie - I’d rather not go into details about it. The lie had to do with a member of my family, and the person I told is now my boyfriend. In every other respect our relationship is very good and we are hoping to have a future together, but I have reached the point where I am thinking of splitting up with him because this lie is weighing so heavily on me.

It’s hard to explain why I lied. All I can say by way of mitigation is that it was not premeditated and I certainly never wanted to hurt anybody (and so far the only person I’ve really hurt is myself). The lie was part of a complicated situation at that time and it just sort of… happened. And then took on a life of its own, because I couldn’t admit I had not been telling the truth. Looking back on it, I was in a lot of emotional turmoil and feeling very vulnerable and I’m sure that had something to do with it. Now, over a year later, telling my boyfriend the truth would almost certainly result in losing not just the relationship but all his love and respect. The thought of that makes me miserable.

What are my other options? Well, I suppose I could just keep quiet and hope it never causes a serious problem, and try to forgive myself for my mistake. Or I could break up with my boyfriend and make a fresh start, and just learn a painful lesson from what this. Or some other option I haven’t thought of.

So I am here to ask what to do. Before you tell me I have a duty to tell the truth though, please consider how much I have to lose. And please try not to think too badly of me. i’m not usually ‘this person’ 😦
 
Worried Girl,
I prey for you and hope that you can get past this and things work out for the best. As for your situation, the lie and what it dealt with. You seem to truly regret the lie, which is a good step in forgiving yourself. We all make mistakes, the thing is: not to keep doing those mistakes. My advice would be to sit down with your boyfriend, explain to him that there is something very serious that you need to tell him. Tell him the truth about the lie and that you cannot keep it to yourself anymore and that you care for him too deeply to let this stand between you.

Be prepared that he may be angry / hurt / depressed the whole range of emotions. He may even leave to go and think, after he calms down he will be able to think clearly and be able to cope with the lie, this may take a few days also.

It is best to tell him the truth now, for if you have a long term relationship this will always bother you and it may cause more problems and issues between you both, especially if he discovers the truth on his own. Then that opens up a “whole different can of worms”.

It is best to tell him now and work it out as opposed to letting it continue and get worse – till it cannot be repaired. What ever the lie, it was only once. He may surprise you and be strong enough to understand and help you work past this.

May our Heavenly Father Bless and Keep you.
 
What ever the lie, it was only once. He may surprise you and be strong enough to understand and help you work past this.
It wasn’t a one time only lie. It started a year ago but I haven’t backed down so essentially, I have repeatedly told him the same serious lie. He’s not going to get past that. I’ve lost him, and it’s all my fault 😦

Thank you for your friendly advice though.
 
It may be that the lie is still there, but it is still just a single lie. If you are thinking of leaving him because of the hurt you feel, I still suggest that you talk with him about it. He may surprise you; and if he is not strong enough to accept your honest repentance and your desire for forgiveness from him. You will at least know that you have done the right thing and tried to set things right. Thus allowing you to begin to forgive yourself, for you are already forgiven by God.
 
Thank you. Your response is so kind. It made me cry.

I’m in such a mess about this but… i can’t tell him. I just can’t!
 
Thank you. Your response is so kind. It made me cry.

I’m in such a mess about this but… i can’t tell him. I just can’t!
Go to confession. Tell the priest everything, all of it. He will advise you. Think of him as being a stand-in for Jesus, because he is! If you have the opportunity after confession, spend time in front of the Blessed Sacrament, and ask Jesus to speak to you and give you the strength for whatever He tells you to do. Pray for the willingness to do as Jesus wants you to do. I don’t know if He will tell you to come clean. If He does, trust that He will be there for you as you do.

:hug1:

Most of us have done something similar.

And, please do not leave your boyfriend without telling him why! Think of the pain THAT can cause in his life! You owe him more than that.
 
You are very sorry for your lie that is very obvious. I truly feel for you; and wish there was something that I could truly say “type” to let you know that you are not alone in your pain. God is always with us, regardless of what we do / have done. Look to God for support, talk to your Priest, or another Priest at a different church if that helps you. Just remember you are not alone and that God will look out for you.

As a side note I sent you a private message also that may help in understanding how God can help you get past certain events.

May God keep and protect you always.
 
I’m so sorry that this is eating you up inside. You should see a priest. I’ve no idea what is the right thing for you to do, but I hope you won’t preemptively dump your boyfriend rather than come to terms with this; it doesn’t seem quite fair.
 
You need to tell him. It will be difficult, no denying that, but if you hope to have a future together, you need to be honest with him before that can happen. You don’t want to have this in the relationship, always having over your head.

You’re obviously very troubled and hurt about this, but be brave and know that Jesus is with you. You are in His heart and He adores you. There is nothing you can do that will make Him stop loving you.

I also think you may be selling your boyfriend short. You believe he loves you. He may not like what you’ve done, and be hurt, but if he loves you he will forgive you. It may take some time, but it will happen. Trust in his love for you and believe that it will work out, even if it takes some time.

I will pray for you and for him, that you will be able to tell him as soon as possible, and that he will be loving and understanding.

Scout :tiphat:
 
Accepting responsibility for our sins, repenting, confessing, restoring what can be restored…is a wonderful thing. Having Jesus forgive you completely - PRICELESS!

It takes a lot of courage and conviction.

Prays for you friend - as you journey along that path.
 
I second the suggestion to go to confession and seek advice with your priest and in prayer. It will give you a chance to lighten some of your burden without telling your boyfriend yet. I truly believe you will feel better and stronger afterward.

And, my dear, you say your lie has only hurt you up until this point, and has not hurt your boyfriend. But think of the pain you will cause him if you leave him over it without telling him. Without giving him the background. This is something to consider.

I think you realize you can’t leave things as they are…your heart is already broken and time isn’t making it get better. It’s probably making things worse. But running away in shame and leaving him clueless might not be the best option. Own up to the mistake…lay the cards on the table…and come clean. Come what may, you will be the stronger for it.

Also understand that we all have lied. We all have made mistakes. We all are in need of forgiveness. You aren’t alone.
 
When you begin a relationship sometimes you must use decit.

For instance. I have a big part of my life that I (at some point) would of directly “lied” to my boyfriend about. However, by the time we had been dating for 3 or 4 months I revealed it to him. He has also revealed things to me. He also never lied.

If, for instance my father was in jail and I told my boyfried (whom I just met) that my father is deep sea fishing I think he would of understood why it would be innapropriate to have told him earlier. Some personal facts…especally in regards to families…are not yours to share.
they could cause trouble to you or others.

Also. If it has to do with your sexual past or other indescretions. Its legit to wait till you’re engaged or married if such actions have been forgiven by the church.
 
When you begin a relationship sometimes you must use decit…
I disagree with this statement. I think it’s okay not to share everything at the beginning of a relationship. You can always say something like, “I’m not comfortable sharing that information right now,” or “That information concerns not only myself, but someone else, so I need to speak with them before I share this,” but not to flat-out lie.

Scout :tiphat:
 
Hello everyone

I have a very sensitive personal dilemma which has been on my mind for over a year now. It is really getting to me, but it’s not the kind of thing I could ever talk to anyone about in person so I’ve decided to join this forum because I know the members are good people and I am hoping for some compassionate advice.

Before I explain any further I just want to say how awful I feel about my part in this situation. I am not usually a bad person but I did a very bad and messed up thing and now I am living with the consequences. I just don’t know what to do for the best at this point. I’ll admit further that I am and have been a coward (but that will become clear from my story).

The short version of this is that just over a year ago, I told a serious lie - I’d rather not go into details about it. The lie had to do with a member of my family, and the person I told is now my boyfriend. In every other respect our relationship is very good and we are hoping to have a future together, but I have reached the point where I am thinking of splitting up with him because this lie is weighing so heavily on me.

It’s hard to explain why I lied. All I can say by way of mitigation is that it was not premeditated and I certainly never wanted to hurt anybody (and so far the only person I’ve really hurt is myself). The lie was part of a complicated situation at that time and it just sort of… happened. And then took on a life of its own, because I couldn’t admit I had not been telling the truth. Looking back on it, I was in a lot of emotional turmoil and feeling very vulnerable and I’m sure that had something to do with it. Now, over a year later, telling my boyfriend the truth would almost certainly result in losing not just the relationship but all his love and respect. The thought of that makes me miserable.

What are my other options? Well, I suppose I could just keep quiet and hope it never causes a serious problem, and try to forgive myself for my mistake. Or I could break up with my boyfriend and make a fresh start, and just learn a painful lesson from what this. Or some other option I haven’t thought of.

So I am here to ask what to do. Before you tell me I have a duty to tell the truth though, please consider how much I have to lose. And please try not to think too badly of me. i’m not usually ‘this person’ 😦
Dear Worried_girl,

I would suggest that you tell him, and explain all this to him, just as you have said it here to us. I would first of all open with telling him how much you love, respect and care for him, but this has been weighing on your mind and soul. Ask his forgiveness, and tell him that you understand he may have to be by himself for a bit to digest this information, but that if he can see it in his heart to forgive you, you will never be dishonest again, for you have learned a painful lesson.

If he truly loves you, he will forgive you and your relationship will be that much stronger.

Pray to God and the Holy Spirit, to help you before you talk to your boyfriend. I am sure we all will be praying for you as well (I know I will).

Blessings, and hugs, (be brave!!)

CEM
 
I second the suggestion to go to confession and seek advice with your priest and in prayer. It will give you a chance to lighten some of your burden without telling your boyfriend yet. I truly believe you will feel better and stronger afterward.

And, my dear, you say your lie has only hurt you up until this point, and has not hurt your boyfriend.** But think of the pain you will cause him if you leave him over it without telling him. Without giving him the background. This is something to consider.I think you realize you can’t leave things as they are…your heart is already broken and time isn’t making it get better. It’s probably making things worse. But running away in shame and leaving him clueless might not be the best option. Own up to the mistake…lay the cards on the table…and come clean. Come what may, you will be the stronger for it.**
Also understand that we all have lied. We all have made mistakes. We all are in need of forgiveness. You aren’t alone.
This is good advice (I’ve highlighted it)!!! 👍

blessings,
CEM
 
I disagree with this statement. I think it’s okay not to share everything at the beginning of a relationship. You can always say something like, “I’m not comfortable sharing that information right now,” or “That information concerns not only myself, but someone else, so I need to speak with them before I share this,” but not to flat-out lie.

Scout :tiphat:
I disagree. First, one must have the decorum not to ask imprudent questions. That can prevent 99% of the need to lie. Second, deciet and omission arent always malicious…and therefore not sinful. For instance my boyfriend was discussing something before I reveled my secret and point blaned asked me “could you immagine being x and feeling x” i replied no, even tough i was x and could very much identify. He didnt hold it agaist me. Nor i would hold him if I did something similar. He works 2 jobs…but for the longest time I knew of only 1 because the 2nd requires a degree of confidentality in his opinion.

We have a phraze " doors best not open" and know that we will not get an answer…or do not want the answer.

We have respect and do not play manipulative games. That, i feel, is more important.
 
I disagree with this statement. I think it’s okay not to share everything at the beginning of a relationship. You can always say something like, “I’m not comfortable sharing that information right now,” or “That information concerns not only myself, but someone else, so I need to speak with them before I share this,” but not to flat-out lie.

Scout :tiphat:
I agree. I had a similar situation and when I first met my (then future) in-laws. When they asked about my parents I quickly said, “They are out of state” (no lie, to my knowledge) and quickly changed the subject.

To the OP, I have no advice. Been in similar situations. Will pray for you. :hug1:
 
I agree that it would be good to tell him. Though to make it easier, you could write him a letter so that you have time to think exactly how you want to tell the truth. Either read it out loud to him or have him read it in your presence. I know I have a hard time actually saying things sometimes. Writing always seems easier to me. Hope this helps.
 
I disagree. First, one must have the decorum not to ask imprudent questions. That can prevent 99% of the need to lie. Second, deciet and omission arent always malicious…and therefore not sinful. For instance my boyfriend was discussing something before I reveled my secret and point blaned asked me “could you immagine being x and feeling x” i replied no, even tough i was x and could very much identify. He didnt hold it agaist me. Nor i would hold him if I did something similar. He works 2 jobs…but for the longest time I knew of only 1 because the 2nd requires a degree of confidentality in his opinion.

We have a phraze " doors best not open" and know that we will not get an answer…or do not want the answer.

We have respect and do not play manipulative games. That, i feel, is more important.
It is one thing to omit information and another to deceive. I have been deceived by ones I cared about. It hurts. It’s just wrong to treat people this way.

And it’s no good to say, “It’s alright to lie, because if the truth comes out, he will understand why I lied”, because that’s just taking him and his feelings for granted. If we care about people, we shouldn’t treat them this way.

It’s understandable to be afraid to lose someone we love, and perhaps culpability can be diminished because of this fear, but if we do love, then we should not manipulate by deceit, but allow them to make decisions freely, taking the chance that we will suffer as a result. Deceit is manipulation.
 
It is one thing to omit information and another to deceive. I have been deceived by ones I cared about. It hurts. It’s just wrong to treat people this way.

And it’s no good to say, “It’s alright to lie, because if the truth comes out, he will understand why I lied”, because that’s just taking him and his feelings for granted. If we care about people, we shouldn’t treat them this way.

It’s understandable to be afraid to lose someone we love, and perhaps culpability can be diminished because of this fear, but if we do love, then we should not manipulate by deceit, but allow them to make decisions freely, taking the chance that we will suffer as a result. Deceit is manipulation.
I completely and totally agree with this. You put it so much better than I did. :bowdown2:

Scout :tiphat:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top