My dilemma

  • Thread starter Thread starter Worried_girl
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I disagree with this statement. I think it’s okay not to share everything at the beginning of a relationship. You can always say something like, “I’m not comfortable sharing that information right now,” or “That information concerns not only myself, but someone else, so I need to speak with them before I share this,” but not to flat-out lie.

Scout :tiphat:
I agree with the with what Scout said. Just say you don’t feel comfortable discussing that yet. It’s one thing to divert the subject or even give an answer that doesn’t reveal much (e.g. jailed parent “is somewhere he won’t come back from very soon”) but a flat lie is not acceptable, nor a must.
We have respect and do not play manipulative games. That, i feel, is more important.
With respect, PurpleSunshine, and I’m not saying this to hurt you, but every lie is a manipulative game. There are better solutions than lying. Truth may be difficult but ultimately it will set you free. In the context of relationships, it may help you see the other person’s worth. I too have had to face difficult questions about certain aspects of my family situation. I lied when I was a kid, I stopped at some point. It felt better. Nowadays when women ask, I give them the answer, and if they run away without understanding, that’s their problem, not mine. Some do. Others are probably not my type of person anyway. On the other hand, the more I man up, the more I am prepared to tell a woman that her question (or any other behaviour, for that matter) is not appropriate, with all the consequences that could have for my acquaintance with her.
 
Now, over a year later, telling my boyfriend the truth would almost certainly result in losing not just the relationship but all his love and respect. The thought of that makes me miserable

Or, he may have more love and respect for you, by you coming clean with this lie.
 
My heart goes out to you because I can tell by your original post and your comments in response that this is tearing you up inside. I have to agree with “chipeto” – please speak to your priest. He can give you advice on what you should do. I will certainly hold you and your boyfriend in prayer over this. If you truly love him and don’t want to lose him, please don’t consider this a lost cause, no matter what the lie was or why you told it. But the important thing is to confess it and go from there. Again, my heart goes out to you, and I will pray that you have strength to do the right thing. :hug1:
 
I would suggest that you tell him, and explain all this to him, just as you have said it here to us. I would first of all open with telling him how much you love, respect and care for him, but this has been weighing on your mind and soul. Ask his forgiveness, and tell him that you understand he may have to be by himself for a bit to digest this information, but that if he can see it in his heart to forgive you, you will never be dishonest again, for you have learned a painful lesson.
I like this very much. Worried_girl, I’m sorry you’re in this situation and hope the outcome is positive. :hug1:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top