My Dog Max's Soul

  • Thread starter Thread starter Pray3x
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
If nothing else, I wish you would at least understand what many people have been saying from the beginning: this is not a theology sub-forum. If you honestly think there’s something deeply inappropriate about the OP’s request, there’s a report button right in the corner. Otherwise, you’re engaging in a conversation that shouldn’t even be taking place.
So are you saying your entitled to your thoughts but I am not. I am a people too. It doesn’t take a theologian to know that praying for a dead dog or any other animal is against Church teaching. Do you think animals will be resurrected too at the end of the world or are they already there? Hopefully you don’t believe that Jesus died for them too. This can get really carried away. I am just trying to use some good ole common sense in the situation.? Your right, this conversation should not even be taking place because it is against Church teaching. I think the movie, “All Dogs go to Heaven,” has opened up Pandora’s Box on the subject. God Bless, Memaw
 
Why can’t we all just admit that our LORD left this question open, pray for the OP’s intention, or not, and get back to working off our Purgatory?

The OP didn’t ask for a theology of animal afterlife, he asked for prayer.

ICXC NIKA
 
Why can’t we all just admit that our LORD left this question open, pray for the OP’s intention, or not, and get back to working off our Purgatory?

The OP didn’t ask for a theology of animal afterlife, he asked for prayer.

ICXC NIKA
He’s asking for prayers for his dead dog’s souls!! He is opening the discussion if it is possible to pray for a dead animals,(dogs) soul. I have swatted plenty of mosquitoes but I never ever thought of praying for their soul. Good grief, get real ! As I said, I will pray he can deal with his grief as we all have to do at times, but I will not pray for a dead animals soul, no matter what or who’s pet it was, not even my own. God Bless, Memaw
 
He’s asking for prayers for his dead dog’s souls!! He is opening the discussion if it is possible to pray for a dead animals,(dogs) soul. I have swatted plenty of mosquitoes but I never ever thought of praying for their soul. Good grief, get real ! As I said, I will pray he can deal with his grief as we all have to do at times, but I will not pray for a dead animals soul, no matter what or who’s pet it was, not even my own. God Bless, Memaw
You don’t need to, but neither is there any need, if you disagree, to burn on his request.

ICXC NIKA
 
Hail Mary, full of grace. The Lord is with thee.
Blessed art thou amongst women,
and blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus.
Holy Mary, Mother of God,
pray for us sinners,
now and at the hour of our death. Amen
 
Not burning, just trying to be reasonable! God Bless, Memaw
There’s a time and a place for being right. There is a time and a place for being charitable. Truly, sometimes a person may be right, but in charity refrains from making a point.

I think that is all anyone is saying.

Based on Church teaching, and what we know of what results in a living being going to heaven, do we have any reason to suppose that animals go to heaven? No. Based on what has been revealed of the love and mercy of God, do we have any reason to suppose that God’s love and mercy is far, far greater than anything we can remotely imagine? Yes.

Let’s leave the definitive, “This or that person or creature is definitely NOT in heaven,” to God.
 
There’s a time and a place for being right. There is a time and a place for being charitable. Truly, sometimes a person may be right, but in charity refrains from making a point.

I think that is all anyone is saying.

Based on Church teaching, and what we know of what results in a living being going to heaven, do we have any reason to suppose that animals go to heaven? No. Based on what has been revealed of the love and mercy of God, do we have any reason to suppose that God’s love and mercy is far, far greater than anything we can remotely imagine? Yes.

Let’s leave the definitive, “This or that person or creature is definitely NOT in heaven,” to God.
I believe Mo. Angelica would call that misguided compassion. To encourage one in wrong thinking is not the right thing to do. Like I said, I have sympathy for his loss, I have felt that same loss many times. but to pray for the soul of an animal to be in Heaven is wrong thinking. Against Church teaching and should not be encouraged out of sympathy. Will that same animal be resurrected at the end of the world.? Are all dead animals to be given the same consideration, or just the ones we loved? What about the ones we eat?? This could go on and on. Like I said before I am just trying to bring some common sense into this subject. My intention is not to hurt anyone’s feelings over the loss of their pet. And I do pray he will be able to adjust to his grief, but in a spiritually healthy way. God Bless, Memaw
 
I am reminded of the song from the movie Frozen - “Let it go, let it go”

obviously there will not be a total consensus on this so I feel the debate will just keep recycling the same arguments.

the OP is grieving the loss of a long time companion and I feel we should respect that. that is my :twocents:

God bless.
 
Praying that you will meet again and they will rest in
peace.
I will not go into details but my rescue cats Bonnie and Milo have been there for me without reservation through my darkest days.

I can wake in the night and find both of them asleep on me on areas where the pain is concentrated, usually purring, sharing the warmth of their bodies and their unconditional love.

Words simply do not do justice to what they mean to me.

For the original poster, I am just starting on the path to join the Church and would never go against Church doctrine but I would be lying, which I refuse to do, if I did not say that a good sized part of my heart longs to know that if we cannot be reunited, that at least they will have bright skies, fair winds, trees to climb and always be able to visit their home even after the physical building itself has gone to dust.

I hope you find Peace. It is simply hard for me to believe that such love does not continue on after its body is no more. I do not know if any of this helps at all; just know that you are not alone in either your love or your wishes.

OAD
 
I will not go into details but my rescue cats Bonnie and Milo have been there for me without reservation through my darkest days.

I can wake in the night and find both of them asleep on me on areas where the pain is concentrated, usually purring, sharing the warmth of their bodies and their unconditional love.

Words simply do not do justice to what they mean to me.

For the original poster, I am just starting on the path to join the Church and would never go against Church doctrine but I would be lying, which I refuse to do, if I did not say that a good sized part of my heart longs to know that if we cannot be reunited, that at least they will have bright skies, fair winds, trees to climb and always be able to visit their home even after the physical building itself has gone to dust.

I hope you find Peace. It is simply hard for me to believe that such love does not continue on after its body is no more. I do not know if any of this helps at all; just know that you are not alone in either your love or your wishes.

OAD
that is a beautiful post.

for all pet lovers I recommend a movie called Hachi with Richard Gere. Based on a true story of a dog in Japan.
 
I am reminded of the song from the movie Frozen - “Let it go, let it go”

obviously there will not be a total consensus on this so I feel the debate will just keep recycling the same arguments.

the OP is grieving the loss of a long time companion and I feel we should respect that. that is my :twocents:

God bless.
I agree and I believe in Heaven all things will be in their proper prospective. God Bless, Memaw
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top