My girlfriend and death

  • Thread starter Thread starter Epistemes
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

Epistemes

Guest
My girlfriend had leukemia when she was only about 2 or 3. I don’t know much about cancers, how they form, how they go into remission, if they can come back. I love her dearly. She has trouble enough going into hospitals and seeing needles, and death is a topic which she doesn’t like discussing or thinking about because of all the time she nearly died herself. Death, though, is a topic which I’m fascinated by and serves at its pivot, in many ways. The best thing I know to do with her is recognize that her life was almost cut short, and that the best thing we can do is enjoy all the happiness, sorrows, twists, turns, and whatever that life brings. Unfortunately I do think about losing her and what my reaction would be and a tear forms in my eye; and she won’t even let me hint at my own eventual death. We went to see Clint Eastwood’s new movie “Hereafter” concerning death, but she hasn’t responded – which may just be because it was an okay movie. Not much to talk about, really. What I’ve found with her, though, is that I must live my life here and now and let the future take care of itself.
 
No, you are not being sweet or romatic. Your continual obsession over your girlfriends state of mind and your own emotinal health or lack thereof is troubling. You need more help than we here at CAF can provide…and for everyone’s sake I suggest you get it. You have posted multiple threads with gutwrenching proclimations about your gf…many shut down by our wonderful mods who DO have common scence. I would also ask you stop posting about your gf because many of us (if we knew who she was) would provide her with material about narcissm and how it would invalidate a marriage. But your posting accomplishes one thing…it makes me remember to look out for my female friends least they enter such a relationship.
 
My girlfriend had leukemia when she was only about 2 or 3. I don’t know much about cancers, how they form, how they go into remission, if they can come back. I love her dearly. She has trouble enough going into hospitals and seeing needles, and death is a topic which she doesn’t like discussing or thinking about because of all the time she nearly died herself. Death, though, is a topic which I’m fascinated by and serves at its pivot, in many ways. The best thing I know to do with her is recognize that her life was almost cut short, and that the best thing we can do is enjoy all the happiness, sorrows, twists, turns, and whatever that life brings. Unfortunately I do think about losing her and what my reaction would be and a tear forms in my eye; and she won’t even let me hint at my own eventual death. We went to see Clint Eastwood’s new movie “Hereafter” concerning death, but she hasn’t responded – which may just be because it was an okay movie. Not much to talk about, really. What I’ve found with her, though, is that I must live my life here and now and let the future take care of itself.
Every relationship has it’s own “speed” that it moves. It may not be that she is ready to or not ready to talk about losing you. It just may be that she is not at “that point.” You are in a relationship that is less than a year old and has still been at a distance. These kinds of conversations would really more be creeping me out and sending me running the other way if I were dating. After all truly as Christians - especially Catholics we do believe in the corruptible body but the incorruptible soul. So we are not dead but living.

Also I would say with this past trauma pushing her beyond her comfort levels at such a young point in your relationship shows a lack of respect for your girlfriend.
 
I’m new to CAF, so I don’t know your whole past history as the other posters seem to. (You may prefer that.) The only post by you I read was one the other day in which you said your girlfriend doesn’t understand death, which I thought was a bizarre and kind of disrespectful thing to say about her online. I don’t understand why you believe this topic is so important to discuss with your girlfriend right this very minute, and why you are fixated on it. I do agree with the PP that if a boyfriend had brought up this topic repeatedly, I would have been creeped out.

My DH and I dated and were engaged for just over 2 years prior to marriage. The only conversation about death that we had prior to getting married was a very brief discussion of organ donation. Since we married, we have had just a couple conversations about death, to make sure we understand each other’s wishes about end-of-life care and funerals, and to discuss the proper amounts of life insurance particularly now that we have children. That’s it. And believe me, both of us understand death intimately… I lost my parents at a fairly young age, and he lost a sibling in childhood. We don’t feel the need to discuss death in any great detail or dwell on it repeatedly. There’s nothing wrong with occasionally considering the end of one’s earthly life, but I think a constant focus on death (a constant thanatopsis, as it were) is very unhealthy.

Discussions about death are the kind that dating couples often do not feel ready to have, and each relationship moves at its own speed. If your girlfriend is not comfortable discussing this topic, then drop it. (If she were your wife, that would be a bit different. I think spouses need to have one conversation to set the ground rules for end-of-life decisions, and decide on life insurance to provide for the family. But unless a spouse is seriously ill and death is an approaching reality, I think a single, basic conversation is probably enough.) You are only dating, so if she doesn’t want to have that conversation – either because of her past illness or because your relationship is not yet at that point – then do not pressure her or push the issue. Pushing the issue would be disrespectful to her.
 
Epistemes, I’m kind of semi-educated on cancer, and I will share what I know, but you really need to talk to a specialist. I know that cancers really fall into two major categories, namely those that strike early in life (childhood, young adulthood - certain kinds of leukemias, brain tumors, and bone tumors), and those that strike later in life. And your girlfriend might be safe from her leukemia for the rest of her life, simply because she is beyond that age range at which the conditions are optimal for that particular kind of cancer to develop. But as I said, this is just some stuff I picked up from here and there. What did her oncologist doctor tell her? Is she at risk of recurrence? Is she expected to go to routine follow-up visits, every 6-12 months or so? Or did her doctors tell her that she is no longer considered being at risk, and she doesn’t need to go to routine follow-up visits aimed to check for signs of a possible recurrence? Humanely, the smartest thing you can do, don’t panic, and follow the advice given by doctors who treated her. Do what you can on a humane level, use whatever solutions and precautions medicine has to offer to her, but beyond that, really just trust our merciful, loving God, and let go of fears. And pray for your girlfriend’s health and safety, ask God to take care of her and to protect her of a recurrence. In my family, my mom had breast cancer and underwent surgery in 1978 and 1979. It was a scary thing. I was 12 years old, and my sister was 14. But, by God’s grace, my mom is still OK today, more than 30 years later. Oh, and ask also St. Anthony of Padua, to intercede for your girlfriend. In my family, we prayed a lot for my mom, and we especially asked St. Anthony to help us. You do the same, pray and trust God. 👍
 
Epistemes, I’m kind of semi-educated on cancer, and I will share what I know, but you really need to talk to a specialist. I know that cancers really fall into two major categories, namely those that strike early in life (childhood, young adulthood - certain kinds of leukemias, brain tumors, and bone tumors), and those that strike later in life. And your girlfriend might be safe from her leukemia for the rest of her life, simply because she is beyond that age range at which the conditions are optimal for that particular kind of cancer to develop. But as I said, this is just some stuff I picked up from here and there. What did her oncologist doctor tell her? Is she at risk of recurrence? Is she expected to go to routine follow-up visits, every 6-12 months or so? Or did her doctors tell her that she is no longer considered being at risk, and she doesn’t need to go to routine follow-up visits aimed to check for signs of a possible recurrence? Humanely, the smartest thing you can do, don’t panic, and follow the advice given by doctors who treated her. Do what you can on a humane level, use whatever solutions and precautions medicine has to offer to her, but beyond that, really just trust our merciful, loving God, and let go of fears. And pray for your girlfriend’s health and safety, ask God to take care of her and to protect her of a recurrence. In my family, my mom had breast cancer and underwent surgery in 1978 and 1979. It was a scary thing. I was 12 years old, and my sister was 14. But, by God’s grace, my mom is still OK today, more than 30 years later. Oh, and ask also St. Anthony of Padua, to intercede for your girlfriend. In my family, we prayed a lot for my mom, and we especially asked St. Anthony to help us. You do the same, pray and trust God. 👍
From what is being said - she does not want to discuss all that - they are in a long distance relationship - around six months and the OP is pushing the boundaries rather than respecting leaving the conversation alone. He doesn’t need more reference material - he needs to back off and let her open up when she is ready.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top