My JW experience: Back from JW hell.

  • Thread starter Thread starter MrZetterlund
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
M

MrZetterlund

Guest
If anyone has been following my former threads, then you know I was invited into a Jehovah’s Witnesses lifestyle for the weekend. So here is a review of my experience:

I never realized that so much of my biological father’s side family is Jehovah’s Witnesses. My father has lived a low life for some time. He lost his faith at an early age (almost all former JWs are atheist) He had a drinking problem; lost his wife (my mom,) lost his home, and lost his family’s trust. Luckily for him, his Jehovah’s Witness uncle took him in, and he’s now trying to get right with “Jehovah” again. His uncle is an elder at their church. Knowing I’m the spiritual leader of my family, they invited me over for the weekend.

IT. WAS. HELL.

They are just so… Persistent in trying to convert you! What I did was basically state the points I disagree with. I told them I do not believe that only 144,000 are going to heaven. I tried to explain that that the Scripture they were referring to dealt with the tribes of Israel, or who are safe from the Apocalypse (I’m not really sure which one. Perhaps both?) 🤷 I even brought up when Jesus was crucified, the criminal beside Him confessed his faith, and Jesus said to him “today, you will be with Me in paradise.” They weren’t convinced by my case and tried to explain to me “the definition of paradise” 🤷

Of course, that lead to the debate about the crucifixion. I won this one rock solid. :cool: They argued that the mixture of blood and water from Jesus’ side was from the weight of the Man’s body being forced down on Him, and that it wasn’t possible in the case of a cross being used instead. But of course, that wasn’t true. Infact, being crucified on a stake instead of a cross would remove some of that weight. I brought up the Shroud of Turin. I explained how serum is the liquid component of blood, and how the side wound on the Shroud had the highest levels of serum in it. And we know that the Man on the Shroud of Turin was crucified on a cross, because the blood from the hands, when they ran down the arms, ran to the elbows and not inward towards the biceps. They asked if I knew the latest information on the Shroud of Turin, I said “There isn’t a thing in the world you can tell me about the Shroud of Turin that I don’t already know.”

We also discussed the use of the name of the Lord. Of course, the most stressed part in the Jehovah’s Witnesses religion. They said, “The name Jehovah appears in the original texts (what was it?) 17,000 (?) times! I think it’s clear Jehovah wants you to use His name!” I explained how ironic I believe it is that the JWs stress this so much to be conservative, when the Hebrews abreviated YAHWEH YHWH to be conservative by protecting the name from being blasphemed. Their combat was “Hebrew was written without vowels.” 😛 And at the meantion of “Yahweh” instead of “Jehovah” they chimed in again and said, “Well Yahweh is Hebrew, Jehovah is english. Just like it’s Allah in Islam. So if you say God’s name in Hebrew, you might as well say Jesus’ in Hebrew as well.” Which I actually do sometimes 😛 “Yeshua Hamashea!”
 
And then the topic of hell was brought up and they said “we don’t believe in hell.” When I heard that, I looked like this guy —>:eek: Probably because I had just read 23 Minutes In Hell by Bill Weise (amazing book! I recommend it to anyone.) :thumbs up: and was shocked I suppose because the entire message of the book is about why hell is a literal burning place. Bill Weise even goes through the entire Bible and underlines anything that had to do with hell and his experience. And his most famous quote is “if you don’t believe my story, my hope is that you believe the Scriptures and avoid hell just the same.” My uncle said “Look, not to offend you, or this “Bill Weise” fellow, but there’s enough in the Bible to suggest that hell is metaphorical.”

And, of course, we talked about the person of Jesus. Oddly enough, I couldn’t find anything in the Bible to combat Him not being the angel Michael. Of course, if Jesus was Michael, it wouldn’t so much nullify Jesus as it would exhalt Michael as Jesus. They firmly believe Jesus to be “Son of God,” so I don’t think they so much don’t believe in Jesus’ divinity as they don’t believe in the actual dogma of the trinity which states, apearently, that Jesus and God are equal. In which case, Jesus did say “My Father is above Me,” and “all power I recieve from My Father who is in heaven.” I brought up when Jesus said “I and My Father are one.” Of course, that was “metaphorical” too. 🤷

My father had a personal Bible study with the missionaries that I attended as well. That was funny. 😃 Someone decided it would be a good idea to tell them that I plan on going into the ministry as a Baptist. LOL :rotfl: the old guy went so wide-eyed! Almost like, “:eek:YOU’RE NOT A JW!!:mad:” He said, “Now Jared, if you want to go into the ministry, you want to make sure what you’re teaching is right, right?!” My response in my head was “Yes, that’s why I’m not a JW.” 😛 During the Bible study, evolution was talked down on. And yes, I accept evolution! I explained evolution in current day understanding (not Darwanianism which EVERYBODY assumes is what it’s like) they accepted it much more because I explained it from a theistic point-of-view. Of course, they had to give me a couple of pamplets that terribly represent evolution! :rolleyes:

All in all, though, it was a good time. It was nice to see a part of my family I’ve hardly ever seen before.

Thoughts, comments, & questions are apreciated. As well as material for arguing in the future.
 
And then the topic of hell was brought up and they said “we don’t believe in hell.” When I heard that, I looked like this guy —>:eek: Probably because I had just read 23 Minutes In Hell by Bill Weise (amazing book! I recommend it to anyone.) :thumbs up: and was shocked I suppose because the entire message of the book is about why hell is a literal burning place. Bill Weise even goes through the entire Bible and underlines anything that had to do with hell and his experience. And his most famous quote is “if you don’t believe my story, my hope is that you believe the Scriptures and avoid hell just the same.” My uncle said “Look, not to offend you, or this “Bill Weise” fellow, but there’s enough in the Bible to suggest that hell is metaphorical.”

And, of course, we talked about the person of Jesus. Oddly enough, I couldn’t find anything in the Bible to combat Him not being the angel Michael. Of course, if Jesus was Michael, it wouldn’t so much nullify Jesus as it would exhalt Michael as Jesus. They firmly believe Jesus to be “Son of God,” so I don’t think they so much don’t believe in Jesus’ divinity as they don’t believe in the actual dogma of the trinity which states, apearently, that Jesus and God are equal. In which case, Jesus did say “My Father is above Me,” and “all power I recieve from My Father who is in heaven.” I brought up when Jesus said “I and My Father are one.” Of course, that was “metaphorical” too. 🤷

My father had a personal Bible study with the missionaries that I attended as well. That was funny. 😃 Someone decided it would be a good idea to tell them that I plan on going into the ministry as a Baptist. LOL :rotfl: the old guy went so wide-eyed! Almost like, “:eek:YOU’RE NOT A JW!!:mad:” He said, “Now Jared, if you want to go into the ministry, you want to make sure what you’re teaching is right, right?!” My response in my head was “Yes, that’s why I’m not a JW.” 😛 During the Bible study, evolution was talked down on. And yes, I accept evolution! I explained evolution in current day understanding (not Darwanianism which EVERYBODY assumes is what it’s like) they accepted it much more because I explained it from a theistic point-of-view. Of course, they had to give me a couple of pamplets that terribly represent evolution! :rolleyes:

All in all, though, it was a good time. It was nice to see a part of my family I’ve hardly ever seen before.

Thoughts, comments, & questions are apreciated. As well as material for arguing in the future.
As I said when you infomed all of us that you were going to one of their Kingdom Halls, you have to get them to admit their religions own inconsistencies. For example, if you go to the “Jehovah’s Witness” thread, I posted a example that I came across that shows the timeline of their changing views on the “Generation” doctrine. Before you engage them again, know what they are going to say before they say it. If you really want to know how to converse with them, know their history. For example, ask what their explaination is for this:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beth_Sarim

I plan on posting scans of their Greek Interlinear that will show that they don’t even adhere to their translation of Greek, so that might be something to zero in as well. It makes me chuckle when I hear them try to tell someone how to read Hebrew or Greek.

The fact is, if JW’s were to encounter someone who really knew their stuff, like Scott Hahn, Peter Kreeft, Thomas Howard or our host, Karl Keating, they’d fold like a lawn chair and just say, “Well, you’re just not one of God’s sheep…” and throw in the towel and run. They prey upon those who don’t have a very good understanding of the bible.
 
You survived! …and nobody got hurt! 😉 I think you seemed to handle it well. 👍

Good for you for at least trying. Not many would want to go through the time to debate with a large group. 🙂

GOOD JOB!
 
Thoughts, comments, & questions are apreciated. As well as material for arguing in the future.

John 1:1 “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.” is how it is in all Bibles except the JW version. Their version says “and the Word was a God.” They insert the word “a” before God, which implies there is more than one God. Doesn’t that conflict with the first commandment? JWs may not know that their Bible has been altered to fit their doctrines. For example, compare their Rev 7 with ours. Theirs supports the 144,000 in heaven thing. In ours, the “multitude no one could count” is in heaven. "9 After this I looked, and behold, a great multitude which no man could number, from every nation, from all tribes and peoples and tongues, standing before the throne and before the Lamb, clothed in white robes, with palm branches in their hands, 10 and crying out with a loud voice, “Salvation belongs to our God who sits upon the throne, and to the Lamb!”
That sounds like heaven to me.

John 20:27* Then he said to Thomas, “Put your finger here, and see my hands; and put out your hand, and place it in my side; do not be faithless, but believing.” 28 Thomas answered him, “My Lord and my God!” 29* Jesus said to him, “Have you believed because you have seen me? Blessed are those who have not seen and yet believe.”
If Jesus was not God, He would have corrected Thomas.

This verse says Jesus was not an angel.
Hebrews 2:7 Thou didst make him for a little while lower than the angels, thou hast crowned him with glory and honor, * 8 putting everything in subjection under his feet."

Matt 4: 10* Then Jesus said to him, “Begone, Satan! for it is written, ‘You shall worship the Lord your God and him only shall you serve.’” 11* Then the devil left him, and behold, angels came and ministered to him.
If the angels served Jesus, then He is God.
 
MrZetterlund,

Crisis of Conscience by Raymond Franz is a book that you should own and read. Just don’t tell any of your JW family you have it. I’m not telling you what to do, but since you have family in the org., you must get this book and read it.

A good discussion forum of mostly ex-JWs with lots of personal stories is jehovahs-witness.net/ you will find this forum very useful.

Take care,
Jon
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top