My marriage is invalid, are we living in sin?

  • Thread starter Thread starter ellam25
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

ellam25

Guest
So I got married before I came back to the church and my husband is not baptized. I am pregnant, due November. I knew when I came back that my marriage needed to be made catholic to be considered a sacrament, but I didn’t know that if my husband wasn’t baptized and I didn’t formally leave the church or get permission to marry that our marriage was invalid. We plan on getting remarried in the church after the baby is born, but now i am scared because people are saying that if you’re in an invalid marriage, you are fornicating and living in sin. I plan on talking to a priest as soon as we move to our new house. However, until then should I be refraining from sleeping with my husband? I feel like no matter which way I turn it’s not right. Thanks, and God bless.
 
Sorry to break the bad news, but YES, you will need to NOT have sex with your legal husband. Yes he is your legal husband, but God does not see him that way yet. I suggest you get your marriage convalidated NOW, ASAP! In situations where there are children involved, such as yours, the convalidation process is usually expedited. You can have a very small, private ceremony with just you two, the priest and two witnesses. You don’t need to have money for a second wedding with all the works. 😉
 
Yes he is your legal husband, but God does not see him that way yet.
Actually, it’s the Church that does not see him as your spouse.
We don’t know what God thinks.

I personally, wouldn’t sweat it. But you should refrain from the sacraments until you are convalidated and legal as far as the Church goes. If you join a club you are expected to follow the rules.

I got my marriage convalidated because I wanted to participate in the sacraments.
I found that I needed them. And I needed the Church.
It was worth all the fal-der-al. And my situation wasn’t as simple as yours.
 
I wouldn’t necessarily call it fal-der-all, but I would contact my priest NOW. Get it done NOW. No, “let’s wait till November or December, after the baby comes.” Why wait? It’s august - November may seem a very long way away for you and especially, for your husband.
 
From what I understand, yes, you need to have your marriage convalidated. Your husband is not baptized, and not sure how that would be handled.

As for not having relations with your husband until you have your marriage convalidated, from what I understand, that is not necessary.
 
Actually, it’s the Church that does not see him as your spouse.
We don’t know what God thinks.

I personally, wouldn’t sweat it. But you should refrain from the sacraments until you are convalidated and legal as far as the Church goes. If you join a club you are expected to follow the rules.

I got my marriage convalidated because I wanted to participate in the sacraments.
I found that I needed them. And I needed the Church.
It was worth all the fal-der-al. And my situation wasn’t as simple as yours.
Thank you for your answers, everyone. I was just wondering when you say refrain from the sacraments, does that include confession? Because I need confession, almost everyday.
 
I wouldn’t necessarily call it fal-der-all.
I meant that MY case needed a lot of Fal- der-al. It was complicated by deaths, divorces, mothers that couldn’t remember and International documentation.

In the end I just hired a geneolgist in Europe to find the documents I needed and have them sent to me. Best $300 I ever spent!

And yes, why wait. If there are documents needed, starting now can save agro later.
And you never do know what fate has in store for you…you really could get hit by a car tomorrow…
 
Thank you for your answers, everyone. I was just wondering when you say refrain from the sacraments, does that include confession? Because I need confession, almost everyday.
I was told confession was included.
You could confess having relations your irregular marriage, but without a firm determination to stop having relations until convalidated the priest would not be able to absolve you.
Repentance means not just being sorry, but and honest desire and effort to not sin again.
So if you can’t say you’ll stop with the relations, you can’t go to confession, and everything else has to wait too.

I’m so glad I did it. I was lonely in top of everything and having a Church full of people to welcome me is a great boon to me.

But God was already a friend…
 
So I got married before I came back to the church and my husband is not baptized. I am pregnant, due November. I knew when I came back that my marriage needed to be made catholic to be considered a sacrament, but I didn’t know that if my husband wasn’t baptized and I didn’t formally leave the church or get permission to marry that our marriage was invalid.
Your marriage can be made valid, and I urge you to do so at the soonest opportunity.

But as long as your husband remains unbaptized, your marriage cannot be a sacrament.
(But there is nothing wrong with having a valid, non-sacramental marriage).

tee
Who Is Not A Canon Lawyer
 
So I got married before I came back to the church and my husband is not baptized. I am pregnant, due November. I knew when I came back that my marriage needed to be made catholic to be considered a sacrament, but I didn’t know that if my husband wasn’t baptized and I didn’t formally leave the church or get permission to marry that our marriage was invalid. We plan on getting remarried in the church after the baby is born, but now i am scared because people are saying that if you’re in an invalid marriage, you are fornicating and living in sin. I plan on talking to a priest as soon as we move to our new house. However, until then should I be refraining from sleeping with my husband? I feel like no matter which way I turn it’s not right. Thanks, and God bless.
Do everything possible to get started on your Convalidation of Marriage. Contact the priest in the area where you’re moving to, and let him know of your situation. He’ll give you things to do so that you can get ahead of the game and be ready to hit the ground running with your process as soon as you move into your new place.

As far as what to do in the meantime, that has to be a decision you make with your husband - don’t spring something on him without a discussion about it, and be prepared to see things his way. You are, after all, intending to be married to him, even if the Church doesn’t recognize your marriage yet.
 
See the priest TOMORROW. Don’t delay.
Internet people can give you advice, but you’ll have to work with the priest anyway.
Don’t postpone this.
 
I would refrain from relations until you talk to a priest and the marriage convalidated.
 
I was told confession was included.
You could confess having relations your irregular marriage, but without a firm determination to stop having relations until convalidated the priest would not be able to absolve you.
Repentance means not just being sorry, but and honest desire and effort to not sin again.
So if you can’t say you’ll stop with the relations, you can’t go to confession, and everything else has to wait too.

I’m so glad I did it. I was lonely in top of everything and having a Church full of people to welcome me is a great boon to me.

But God was already a friend…
So does that mean none of my sins can be absolved?
 
That’s the way I understand it. But I’m no scholar.

Because I lived far from any church, I had contacted a priest by phone, calling a number I found on the archdiocese website. We had a couple of very nice, comforting conversations with him about my situation. He totally put me at ease with him, with the process and with the general situation. He told me what documents I needed and I got right on it the next day.
I organized it all and sent everything into him as soon as I could.

Then after I was granted the annulment and dispensation, my husband and I travelled to the church. It was the first time I had met him.
The priest and I had a conversation, papers were signed. He then heard my confession. Then my husband had a separate short conversation with him also, and signed some papers. Husband is not anything close to Catholic, so he didn’t have to do anything else.
Then we went into the sanctuary and were married.
So my confession came before the convalidation, and I did confess to relations with my civil husband,not yet my sacramental husband.(among other things). I guess it was done that way because there was no time to have relations in between the confession and the ceremony. So I was “clean” and was able to stay clean until we were sacramentally married.

So to follow… If you were to go to confession and get “clean” you would have to abstain from sex until you could get convalidated. (Could be a sweet, sweet honeymoon!). Then you could take the other sacraments as long as you stayed “clean”.
This is the way I understand it.

If this break is not possible, then I’d start talking to my priest yesterday.
I didn’t have access to a priest where I lived, so the priest who normally handles such things for the diocese handled everything. He even came up with two witnesses for us since we didn’t know anyone. We were married in the cathedral and it was beautiful.
But as I say, I’m no scholar in canon law.

Talk to your priest. They are people, just like you, and they have heard everything. And it’s their vocation. No one goes through the agony of seminary just to have a low paying job that will get you up in the middle of the night. They do it because they love God, love you, and love the Church. You might even make a friend along the way.

And I know that confession is more involved than “getting clean” it just the way I thought about it in this instance. I can’t think of a better way of saying it just now.
 
Actually, it’s the Church that does not see him as your spouse.
We don’t know what God thinks.

I personally, wouldn’t sweat it. But you should refrain from the sacraments until you are convalidated and legal as far as the Church goes. If you join a club you are expected to follow the rules.

I got my marriage convalidated because I wanted to participate in the sacraments.
I found that I needed them. And I needed the Church.
It was worth all the fal-der-al. And my situation wasn’t as simple as yours.
Actually we do. God gave the Church authority to teach in matters of faith and morals which means everything the Church teaches has the full authority of God behind them. In short, if the Church does not recognise a particular marriage it means God does not recognise it.
 
So I got married before I came back to the church and my husband is not baptized. I am pregnant, due November. I knew when I came back that my marriage needed to be made catholic to be considered a sacrament, but I didn’t know that if my husband wasn’t baptized and I didn’t formally leave the church or get permission to marry that our marriage was invalid. We plan on getting remarried in the church after the baby is born, but now i am scared because people are saying that if you’re in an invalid marriage, you are fornicating and living in sin. I plan on talking to a priest as soon as we move to our new house. However, until then should I be refraining from sleeping with my husband? I feel like no matter which way I turn it’s not right. Thanks, and God bless.
My wife was not baptized either. We married outside of the church, then I returned to Catholicism. I talked to our parish priest and he scheduled a convalidation ceremony. It was quite simple - all you need is a couple of witnesses.

Why wait? Do it now. It took less than 20 minutes.

You’ll be amazed at the weight it will take off your soul.

God Bless.
 
Your marriage can be made valid, and I urge you to do so at the soonest opportunity.

But as long as your husband remains unbaptized, your marriage cannot be a sacrament.
(But there is nothing wrong with having a valid, non-sacramental marriage).

tee
Who Is Not A Canon Lawyer
I’m not sure that is true.
 
I’m not sure that is true.
What part do you believe isn’t true? The fact that it can be made valid or that the marriage between a baptized and non-baptized person can’t be sacramental?

Convalidation (or radical sanation) can make the marriage valid. As for the sacramentality, both parties must be baptized for the marriage to be sacramental. Baptism is required before any other sacrament and since her husband is unbaptized he could not receive the sacrament of matrimony. A marriage cannot be sacramental for one party, but not the other.
 
So does that mean none of my sins can be absolved?
Yes. Absolution doesn’t pick and choose which sins are absolved. Even if it was possible it still would not cleans you to be able to receive the Eucharist. To use an analogy, if a doctor removed all cancer from your body but you still had a brain tumor you would not be cured. Even if they removed 95% of the cancer, the other 5% is still potentially deadly. This is the same with unresolved mortal sin.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top