AbeOman,
Killing apostates is in the sharia. Muhammad did it according to the hadiths.
You are dancing on the graves of the millions who were persecuted and/or killed for apostatizing from Islam.
First, let’s not exaggerate and loose sight of what is true and what is not. moreover, in no certain terms, I consider what you said a discredit to Islam, I believe lots of so called Muslims are doing that just fine.
2- The law of Islam dictates that anyone who presents a clear, present and active danger against Muslims must be stoped, there is no second guessing in this, so if a Murtad raises an army or starts killing Muslims or taking what is theirs then the correct answer is “Death” by war, the sword, AK47 or dingo dingo, no matter…!
3- Can you present one single Ayah “verse” from the Quran that out-rightly and clearly states “kill whoever is a Murtad” anyone leading the way becomes a Murtad…? No you can and please let me advice you on one thing, The Quran does not contradict itself, rather it clearly explains itself, the basic presentation of the Quran is clarity no ambiguity or No ill defined versus are found in the Quran, so keeping in mind, that I’m talking about the original Quran not the translations of the meanings of the Quran done by men in so many languages.
4- There are different school of thoughts in Islam and each school has it’s own way of dealing with Ridah, now I can not vouch for what"s practised in certain islamic countries in respect to their interpretations of the hadiths or the version of Sharia Law they apply, for instance, but you will not find anywhere in the Quran instructions clearly or indirectly implying “Commit suicide” or take your own life to kill and mime innocent civilians, or mass killing of innocent folks, just like 9/11. if it was against army in war then I know it’s allowed, but what some so called Muslims do, well as you know they do quite the opposite and you will always see the person who is crying out is indoctronated through hate, other ambitions and always is someone who is not well educated, young or very underprivileged in his or her life.
Sure, exteremism has different facets and un denying we have plenty of sickos are as much happy in killing fellow Muslims as none Muslims. if I’m not mistaken so does other religions or political movements.
4- What I object to is what you present and clearly lack of Quranic or Hadith evidance to backup your claims or basic knowledge of Quran and the Hadiths. No hold on before you rush to your own conclusions and run to Google, yes, you can find plenty of sites out there on the net that will give you whole lots of fall evidences and twisted quotes for reasons I’m going into, but the simple question that you have to ask yourself is how much do you know what you are copying, how much do you understand the intentions of folks who put it up there and for what purpose, why it’s so and so on so forth.
5- I have discussed this issue with Montalban in very tiresome manor and till exhaustion and without any meaningful conclusion. so may best and sincerist suggestion is that you separate your feelings toward Islam and Muslims and your knowledge about it. because I can deabte you on the merits of what you know and not how you feel about it.
6- If you ever come a cross a Muslim on this Forum or another Forum who makes false or untrue claims or insults Christianity or catholicism or any other faith, tell him he or she is a lost Muslim and he or she actually does not much about his or her own religion.
to conclude, I strongly object to your false accusations and if you care to share with all reader some facts to back your claims up, then do so, otherwise, let no ill feelings come between us.
I leave you in peace,
