Myth of Consensus Explodes: APS Opens Global Warming Debate

  • Thread starter Thread starter Yerusalyim
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
I urge interested folks to visit www.climatechangedebate.org and sign in and read … for example, the fellow with the Spanish language Web site, who posted that graph showing temp declines … posted this material today.

If the links don’t work on this “translation”, then visit www.climatechangedebate.org and search for “NPP & CO2” … the poster’s handle is “Eduardo”.

Don’t forget that the Idso’s website has the biggest database on scientific studies on the subject.

co2science.org/

AND … Just in case someone hasn’t read the latest news in Idso’s website:

Editorial
Responses of Tree Species to Global Warming: Are the locations where they can successfully grow and reproduce in the future really as rigidly defined by their current “climate envelopes” as climate alarmists make them out to be?

Medieval Warm Period Record of the Week
Was there a Medieval Warm Period? YES, according to data published by 588 individual scientists from 348 separate research institutions in 38 different countries … and counting! This issue’s Medieval Warm Period Record of the Week comes from the Collins Ice Cap, King George Island, Antarctica. To access the entire Medieval Warm Period Project’s database, click here.

Subject Index Summary
Legumes: How are they affected by atmospheric CO2 enrichment? … and what do the results portend about the future of the biosphere?

Plant Growth Data
This week we add new results (blue background) of plant growth responses to atmospheric CO2 enrichment obtained from experiments described in the peer-reviewed scientific literature for: Oilseed Rape, Trembling Aspen, and Wallaby Grass.

Journal Reviews
Global Drought Conditions: 1950-2000: How did they vary over the last half of the 20th century?

Storminess in Northwest Europe: How has it responded to 20th-century global warming?

A “New-and-Improved” 1500-Year North Fennoscandian Summer Temperature History: What does it suggest about the degree of warmth of the Medieval Warm Period?

Elevated CO2 and Surgarcane: Can the atmospheric trace gas we all exhale make the sweet crop even sweeter?

Fine Roots of Sweetgum Trees Growing in CO2-Enriched Air: How do they impact carbon and nitrogen (name removed by moderator)ut to the soil in which they grow?
 
Darn, I guess no one wants to see the data. But they’d like us to visit their websites for idoctrination.
 
Now from a source that is more credible than the global warming “scientists”
Old Farmers Almanac: Global cooling may be underway
By David Tirrell-Wysocki, Associated Press Writer
DUBLIN, N.H. — The Old Farmer’s Almanac is going further out on a limb than usual this year, not only forecasting a cooler winter, but looking ahead decades to suggest we are in for global cooling, not warming.
Based on the same time-honored, complex calculations it uses to predict weather, the Almanac hits the newsstands on Tuesday saying a study of solar activity and corresponding records on ocean temperatures and climate point to a cooler, not warmer, climate, for perhaps the next half century.
Yes, I said “credible” and there is no sarcasm in this post. :mad:
 
Among today’s posts to www.climatechangedebate.org is this gem from one of the regulars:

My point is one can’t take a number that represents a GLOBAL average
and apply it to a specific time and place and then draw conclusions.

What we can see from the graphs is the predominate amount of warming
is POLAR and in the COLD half of the year.

Its IMPACT on plants during their growing season is thus much less
than the YEARLY AVERAGE GLOBAL temp would indicate.

Further, there is no empirical evidence that the plants in the
temperate zones are FRAGILE, particularly as regards to HIGH temps.

Here are the high temp records that still stand that are over 50
years old (you know, when the globe was supposed to be 1 degree
cooler)

Ala. 112 Sept. 5, 1925 Centerville
Alaska 100 June 27, 1915 Ft. Yukon
Calif. 134 July 10, 1913 Death V.
Del. 110 July 21, 1930 Millsboro
Ga. 112 July 24, 1952 Louisville
Hawaii 100 April 27,1931 Pahala
Ark. 120 Aug. 10, 1936 Ozark
Idaho 118 July 28, 1934 Orofino
Ill. 117 July 14, 1954 E. St Louis
Ind. 116 July 14, 1936 Collegeville
Iowa 118 July 20, 1934 Keokuk
Kansas 121 July 24, 1936 Alton
Ky. 114 July 28, 1930 Greensburg
La. 114 Aug. 10, 1936 Plain Dealing
Maine 105 July 10, 1911 N. Bridgton
Md. 109 July 10, 1936 Cumberland
Mich. 112 July 13, 1936 Mio
Minn. 114 July 6, 1936 Moorhead
Miss. 115 July 29, 1930 Holly Springs
Mo 118 July 14, 1954 Warsaw
Mont. 117 July 5, 1937 Medicine Lake
Neb. 118 July 24, 1936 Minden
N.H. 106 July 4, 1911 Nashua
N.J. 110 July 10, 1936 Runyon
N.Y. 108 July 22, 1926 Troy
N.D. 121 July 6, 1936 Steele
Ohio 113 July 21, 1934 Gallipolis
Ore. 119 Aug. 10, 1898 Pendleton
Pa. 111 July 10, 1936 Phoenixville
S.C. 111 June 28, 1954 Camden
Tenn. 113 Aug. 9, 1930 Perryville
Texas 120 Aug. 12, 1936 Seymour
Vt. 105 July 4, 1911 Vernon
Va. 110 July 15, 1954 Balcony Falls
W. Va. 112 July 10, 1936 Martinsburg
Wis. 114 July 13, 1936 Wisconsin Dells

That’s the majority of the states who have NOT set high temp records
in the last 5 decades.

In fact, only ONE state (SD) has posted a new high temp record in the
last decade.

What these records also show is that the plants CAN take it.

They don’t whither up and die even at temps well over 110 F.
 
Interestingly, 1936, which seems to have a lot of the records for high temp, was cooler than normal.

So it appears that measuring climate by one temperature reading per year is not a very accurate way to go. 😉
 
Dr. S. Fred Singer posted this today:

SEPP Science Editorial #3 (9/13/08)

It’s become quite clear that the climate has not warmed for a decade, since 1998, the year of the strong El Nino. But what about the two decades before 1998? The iconic graph of global mean surface temperature of the IPCC seems to show a strong warming trend of 0.2 degC per decade (see Fig 4a of NIPCC report, based on the GISS analysis). But not so fast: The well-controlled US data show no such trend (NIPCC, Fig 4b). Tree-ring data (see “Hot Talk, Cold Science” Fig16), not subject to any local urban heating, show zero trends; ice core temperatures (NIPCC, Fig 2) show no warming either. The notorious Hockeystick proxy data mysteriously stop at 1980, just when things become interesting. But we have tropospheric temperature data from balloon-borne radiosondes and from microwave instruments in weather satellites. Both of these data sets show essentially no warming between 1979 and 1997. Climate models tell us that if greenhouse (GH) effects dominate, then the surface trend in the tropics should be about half that of the troposphere. And half of zero is zero. Hmm, maybe there has been no significant GH warming between 1979 and 1997 at all, then an upward jump in 1998, followed by slight cooling. A look at the satellite data (NIPCC, Fig 13) seems to suggest just that.

Read more at www.sepp.org

In addition, the current issue of The Energy Advocate (September 2008) has an interesting discussion on the temperature anomaly decline.

The Energy Advocate is a paid, mailed, paper newsletter. Visit www.energyadvocate.com for more information and misc articles and subscription information. Dr. Howard Hayden, editor and author of The Energy Advocate has written several books which are also described in the website.
 
Thanks Al for more evidence that “global warming” is a complete fraud.
 
Fred Singer writes:
It’s become quite clear that the climate has not warmed for a decade, since 1998, the year of the strong El Nino.

Well, let’s take a look; here’s the data Fred is talking about:

1981 40
1982 9
1983 34
1984 15
1985 12
1986 19
1987 35
1988 41
1989 28
1990 48
1991 44
1992 45
1993 19
1994 32
1995 47
1996 39
1997 41
1998 72
1999 46
2000 42
2001 57
2002 69
2003 67
2004 60
2005 77
2006 66
2007 73

For each year, the mean temperature anomaly, in hundredths of a degree C, for combined land/water measurements.

Those interested in seeing just how far off the farm Fred has wandered, should graph this data, and then (unless you know how to calculate a regression line) draw a straight line that gets as close to as many points as possible. That will be a good measure of the trend for average world land/water temperature.

A regression line would be slightly to a lot more accurate, depending on good you are.
 
The Old Farmer’s Almanac, in its 206th edition, predicts a cold winter. Should you rush out and buy a parka? The almanac is “usually inaccurate,” says John Margraf of the National Weather Service. Larry Gebert of Channel 7 News in Boise, Idaho, says “the almanac is as accurate as any long-range forecast here.” When held up against the National Weather Service’s 120-day forecast for that region,
I think I know why it’s been just as accurate… 😃
 
Do you believe your senses, what your eyes see? Watch the programs on the tele. See large portions of ice as big as football stadiums falling into the ocean as scientists convey the possibility of global warming? Feel the rising temperature? See clusters of hurricanes and tornados unprecedented in this century? I am in my 50’s and I can state from my own experiences in the Northeast that that weather patterns are on a curve ball status. Not normal, not following the pattern, off the grid…

And, it can be attributed to man. It is not a coinscidence that China, India and Russia are having their industrial period, like the one we had back in the 40’s, and it is not contributing to cleaner air to breath. Not here not there. Hoping and praying this goes away won’t do it. Conning a con won’t do it either.

There is also a monitary and political benefit to defend that there is no global warming. That would be for the oil and coal companies to Drill Drill Drill and continue to pollute the earth to make dollars.

I know what you will say, but there is a price we pay for using oil and coal. America finding and utilizing another source of energy is DEATH to the oil and coal industry that are Powerful, frightened people. Think about it.
 
This in this morning. No link was provided, so here’s the article as received:

Climate change chicanery


By Christopher Booker
Last Updated: 12:01am BST 14/09/2008

Recent events have seen the scare campaign over global warming descend to the level of a Monty Python sketch.

Much publicity was given, for instance, to Lewis Gordon Pugh, who set out to paddle a kayak to the Pole to demonstrate the vanishing of the Arctic ice. At 80.5 degrees north, still 600 miles short of his goal, he met with ice so thick that he and his fossil-fuelled support ship had to turn back.

But this did not prevent him receiving a congratulatory call from Gordon Brown, nor boasting that he had travelled “further north than anyone has kayaked so far”.

It took the admirable Watts Up With That blog, run by the American meteorologist Anthony Watts, to point out that in 1893 the Norwegian explorer Fridtjof Nansen found the Arctic so ice-free that he was able to kayak above 82 degrees north, 100 miles nearer the Pole than our hapless campaigner against “unprecedented global warming”.

Then there was the much-publicised speech to Compassion in World Farming by Dr Rajendra Pachauri, chairman of the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, pleading for people to give up meat, on the grounds that the digestive methane given off by cattle contributes more to greenhouse gases than all the world’s transport.

Although hailed by the BBC as “the UN’s top climate scientist”, Dr Pachauri, who holds PhDs in economics and engineering, is nothing of the kind, but just an apparatchik.

A vegetarian Hindu, Dr Pachauri not only used highly tendentious figures to promote his cause but said nothing about the contribution made to global warming by India’s 400 million sacred cows, which presumably would still be free to vent wind even if the rest of humanity is converted to eating veggieburgers.

There has also been an acclaimed new paper by Michael Mann, the creator of the iconic “hockey stick” graph, purporting to show that the world has recently become hotter than at any time in recorded history, eliminating all the wealth of evidence to show that temperatures were higher in the Mediaeval Warm Period than today.

After being used obsessively by the IPCC’s 2001 report to promote the cause, the “hockey stick” was comprehensively discredited, not least by Steve McIntyre, a Canadian computer analyst, who showed that Mann had built into his computer programme an algorithm (or “al-gore-ithm”) which would produce the hockey stick shape even if the data fed in was just “random noise”.

Two weeks ago Dr Mann published a new study, claiming to have used 1,209 new historic “temperature proxies” to show that his original graph was essentially correct after all. This was faithfully reported by the media as further confirmation that we live in a time of unprecedented warming. Steve McIntyre immediately got to work and, supported by expert readers on his Climate Audit website, shredded Mann’s new version as mercilessly as he had the original.

He again showed how selective Mann had been in his new data, excluding anything which confirmed the Mediaeval Warming and concentrating on that showing temperatures recently rising to record levels.

Finnish experts pointed out that, where Mann placed emphasis on the evidence of sediments from Finnish lakes, there were particular reasons why these should have shown rising temperatures in recent years, such as expanding towns on their shores. McIntyre even discovered a part of Mann’s programme akin to a disguised version of his earlier algorithm, which he now calls “Mannomatics”.

But Mann’s new study will surely be used to push the warmist party line in the run-up to the IPCC international conference in Copenhagen next year to agree a successor to the Kyoto Protocol.

Meanwhile, back in the real world, temperatures continue to drop. The latest Nasa satellite readings on global temperatures from the University of Alabama, one of four officially recognised sources of temperature data, show that August was the fourth month this year when temperatures fell below their 30-year average, ie since satellite records began. The US National Climatic Data Center showsis showing that last month in the USA was only the 39th warmest since records began 113 years ago.

It is high time, however, that we took all this chicanery and wishful thinking seriously - as was evidenced in Maidstone Crown Court last Wednesday, by the acquittal of six Greenpeace campaigners tried for criminal damage to Kingsnorth power station.

They were attempting to stop a new coal-fired power station being built, to produce 1,600 megawatts of electricity (two and a half times as much as is generated by all the 2,300 wind turbines so far built in Britain).

As gleefully reported on the front page of The Independent, and at length by other promoters of warming alarmism such as the BBC and The Guardian, the jury agreed that the damage they had perpetrated was lawfully justified - because the damage done by the new power station, in raising global sea levels and contributing to the extinction of “a million species”, would be far worse.

The court was swayed to this remarkable verdict by the evidence of two “expert witnesses” for the defence: Zac Goldsmith, one of David Cameron’s envrionmental policy advisers and a prospective Conservative MP, and James Hansen, head of Nasa’s Goddard Institute for Space Studies.

Dr Hansen, who has been the world’s leading global warming campaigner for 20 years (along with his ally Al Gore), claimed that the proposed Kingsnorth power station alone would be responsible for the extinction of “400 species”.

It is extraordinary that two such partisan witnesses were accepted by the court in this role, since the rules, as defined by Mr Justice Cresswell in 1993, insist that the function of an “expert witness” is only to give “objective evidence”. He must not be an “advocate” for one side or the other on any issue on which experts are divided.

This should have ruled Dr Hansen out at once. Question marks are raised over his institute’s temperature data. Last year he was forced by Steve McIntyre to revise his figures for US surface temperatures, to show that the hottest decade of the 20th century was not the 1990s, as Hansen claimed, but the 1930s. He has also campaigned tirelessly for the scrapping of all coal-fired power stations.

Yet we are critically dependent on coal-generated power: it supplies 35 per cent of Britain’s needs and 50 per cent of America’s. Thanks to EU rules, we will be forced to close six coal-fired power stations before long, and without new ones, such as that proposed for Kingsnorth, our economy will judder to a halt.

David Cameron could well be prime minister by then. That one of his closest advisers believes that criminal damage is justified to stop coal-fired power plants being built is just as alarming as that the British courts now seem to agree with him.
 
Meanwhile, back in the real world, temperatures continue to drop. The latest Nasa satellite readings on global temperatures from the University of Alabama, one of four officially recognised sources of temperature data, show that August was the fourth month this year when temperatures fell below their 30-year average, ie since satellite records began. The US National Climatic Data Center showsis showing that last month in the USA was only the 39th warmest since records began 113 years ago.
That is kinda interesting. If your guy is right, this year seems to be a relatively cool one compared to recent years, and yet half the months so far were higher than the 30 year average. Think about it. Every single one was hotter than the benchmark made back in the 50s, BTW.

And this year, which is going to be cooler than the most recent years, is still in the top third of all-time warmest years. Have you ceased being a denier?
There has also been an acclaimed new paper by Michael Mann, the creator of the iconic “hockey stick” graph, purporting to show that the world has recently become hotter than at any time in recorded history, eliminating all the wealth of evidence to show that temperatures were higher in the Mediaeval Warm Period than today.
Odd, the first workable thermometer was built about 1714. I was under the impression that only proxy data (which is inherently unreliable, according to deniers) is available from that time. Who was taking temps in the medieval period?

Because of the rapid warming in recent years, the “normal” medieval temperature assumed by Lamb is actually colder than the average today.

There are lots of opinions, all of which vaguely agree, but none of which show the medieval period as being anything like the one we are currently undergoing. Here’s a graph showing the results of different studies:

http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/pubs/ipcc2007/fig6-10b.png
ncdc.noaa.gov/paleo/globalwarming/medieval.html

So proxy data is at best, tenuous, even if it can give us some general idea of what happened. But note, that no one has actually produced data that shows the medieval warm period is as warm as we’ve seen in the last decades.

Sic transit erratum.
 
Interested folks are invited to visit www.climatechangedebate.org

Where the debate has heated up recently … as the climate has actually cooled down.

The carbon dioxide is going up … but the climate is cooling. Not quite what the computer models are predicting.

Really bad surface data being confirmed from all over the planet (reading high). But excellent buoy data recording steady or declining temps in the oceans. And similar data from satellites.

And this posted yesterday:

Sep 23, 2008
“Alaska Chukchi and Beaufort Sea coasts are 2 to 8 degrees Celsius colder this year “
Thanks to Tom Nelson Blog for this NWS statement

Sea surface temperatures along the Alaska Chukchi and Beaufort Sea coasts are 2 to 8 degrees Celsius colder this year than at the same time last year. Significant ice will begin developing along the Alaska coast north of 70n within the next 10 to 14 days.

Yes. I know. It’s because warming means cooling.

But I haven’t been able to cool my beer in the kitchen oven… yet. I’ll ask Hansen how he does it.
 
Post hoc ergo propter hoc -

“Astra non mentiuntur, sed astrologi bene mentiuntur de astris.”

(“after this, therefore because of this”)

(The stars never lie, but the astrologs lie about the stars.)

Hey fellas keep it up. And “B”… EGO nunquam accersitus vos a Populus Socialist. Enjoy your day!
 
No sun spots => global cooling.

canadafreepress.com/index.php/article/5011

Excerpts:

… a report in DailyTech.com was not likely to get much attention, but it forecast a very cold world in the years to come. The Earth has already started to cool and scientists date the change from 1998.

Headlined, “Drop in solar activity has potential effect for climate on Earth”, the news is that, for the first time in 100 years, “an entire month has passed without a single visible sunspot being noted.” The author, Michael Asher, noted that “The event is significant as many climatologists now believe solar magnetic activity—which determines the number of sunspots—is an influencing factor for climate on Earth.”

As the DailyTech report notes, “In the past 1000 years, three previous such events, the Dalton, Maunder, and Sporer Minimums,” of reduced sunspot activity, “have all led to rapid cooling,” adding that, “For a society dependent on agriculture, cold is more damaging than heat. The growing season shortens, yields drop, and the occurrence of crop-destroying frosts increases.”

An article by William Livingston and Matthew Penn of the National Solar Observatory in Tucson, Arizona, “Sunspots May Vanish by 2015”, predicts that sunspots will disappear completely. “Such an event would not be unprecedented, since during a famous episode from 1645-1715, known as the Maunder Minimum…” That solar cycle “was shown to correspond with the reduced average global temperatures on the Earth.” In other words, it’s going to get COLD.

The Little Ice Age had an effect on history as you might imagine. The French Revolution is attributed to it insofar as the cost of bread rose as wheat crops failed. Riots followed. Similarly, Napoleon’s invasion of Russia met with defeat thanks to a winter that killed thousands of his troops. In America, it was reflected in the travails of Valley Forge.

Over at IceAgeNow.com, Felix posts the latest news from around the world that tells of anomalous events ranging from freak early snow storms to expanding glaciers. Soon enough, those living in the northern hemisphere will become more aware as winters lengthen and become more severe. After that, the scenarios grow quite serious.

Even the venerable Old Farmers Almanac is making news these days forecasting a far cooler winter and suggesting that the Earth is already in a cooling cycle.

No doubt some diehard Greens like Al Gore will continue to spout nonsense that the cold weather is due to global warming, but it has to do with the Sun that’s gone quiet. It’s not myth. It’s reality.
 
And “B”… EGO nunquam accersitus vos a Populus Socialist.
I don’t think deniers are necessarily socialists. Far as I can see, warming deniers and socialists are alike only in their belief that if they really, really want something to be true, reality is obligated to make it true.
 
*Global Temperature Trends: 2007 Summation
The year 2007 tied for second warmest in the period of instrumental data, behind the record warmth of 2005, in the Goddard Institute for Space Studies (GISS) analysis. 2007 tied 1998, which had leapt a remarkable 0.2°C above the prior record with the help of the “El Niño of the century”. The unusual warmth in 2007 is noteworthy because it occurs at a time when solar irradiance is at a minimum and the equatorial Pacific Ocean is in the cool phase of its natural El Niño-La Niña cycle. *
data.giss.nasa.gov/gistemp/2007/Fig1_2007annual.gif

Figure 1 shows 2007 temperature anomalies relative to the 1951-1980 base period mean. The global mean temperature anomaly, 0.57°C (about 1°F) warmer than the 1951-1980 mean, continues the strong warming trend of the past thirty years that has been confidently attributed to the effect of increasing human-made greenhouse gases (GHGs) (Hansen et al. 2007). The eight warmest years in the GISS record have all occurred since 1998, and the 14 warmest years in the record have all occurred since 1990. - NASA

In short, it should be getting cooler now. But it isn’t. And that is a cause for concern.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top