Natural moral law?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tyrion
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
Distinguish between that which is Divine Revelation and or a precept of the Church (like attend Mass on Sunday and Holy Days) and that which would be particularly part of natural moral law --like do not murder.
Well, I read your post, and there was NOT ONE WORD about the explicit questions I asked. If you cannot answer them, why don’t you admit it?

Besides, that “law” is supposed to be “natural” and not “supernatural”, so no revelation would be needed. The assumption is that one can look at the physical reality, employ reason and logic and arrive at the conclution that certain behavior is “immoral” under ANY and ALL circumstances. Obviously there is no such thing, and your “silence” about it is an excellent evidence for that.

There are only a few examples which are usually mentioned, like “murder” and “theft” as being prohibited “universally”. No one ever cares to argue for the prohibition of certain sexual behaviors, or public nudity, or for a specific type of “marriage”. With good reason, since there are no arguments to support those views. There are no arguments to support that “murder” is universally disallowed in EVERY society. A miniscule amount of historical knowledge will bring up numerous examples where “murder” was not just not forbidden, but it was a way of life for certain parts of the pupulation. Review medival Japan, where the bushido (the samurai code of behavior) revolved around the proper time of death, either in battle, or by seppuku, and they slaughtered everyone who did not bow down to them.

To say that “sin” clouds our reason, and that is why the “revelation” was necessary is just a cop-out. If that “moral law” is “natural” and can be discerned by reason alone (the ancient Greek philosophers came up with it, without any “revelation”) or not. Looking at history one can see that there is no “moral system” which would have been accepted across ALL societies and ALL times.
 
I have pointed you to good sources (one can add somewhat "The Abolition of Man by C.S.Lewis)–but I do not have any interest in an on going discussion here. Catholic Answers Apologist line too can provide you with more resources. I bid you well and a splendid day!
 
“I am interested in secular, rational and reasonable arguments about many difficult questions. I am already familiar with faith-based (theological) arguments, so don’t waste your time to repeat them. --Thank you for your consideration.”

This is the Moral Theology Forum --so do not be surprised that we discuss Theology here…
 
Such is not a “cop-out” and I will note this is a forum of Moral Theology…so do not be surprised if one finds members discussing Theology 😉

Compendium:
  1. Is such a law perceived by everyone?
“Because of sin the natural law is not always perceived nor is it recognized by everyone with equal clarity and immediacy.”

Our intellect became clouded…and our will weakened…etc.

I have pointed you to good sources (one can add somewhat "The Abolition of Man by C.S.Lewis)–but I do not have currently have an interest in an on going protracted discussion here. Catholic Answers Apologist line too can provide you with more resources. I bid you well and a *splendid *day.
 
Well, I read your post, and there was NOT ONE WORD about the explicit questions I asked. If you cannot answer them, why don’t you admit it?

Besides, that “law” is supposed to be “natural” and not “supernatural”, so no revelation would be needed. The assumption is that one can look at the physical reality, employ reason and logic and arrive at the conclution that certain behavior is “immoral” under ANY and ALL circumstances. Obviously there is no such thing, and your “silence” about it is an excellent evidence for that.

There are only a few examples which are usually mentioned, like “murder” and “theft” as being prohibited “universally”. No one ever cares to argue for the prohibition of certain sexual behaviors, or public nudity, or for a specific type of “marriage”. With good reason, since there are no arguments to support those views. There are no arguments to support that “murder” is universally disallowed in EVERY society. A miniscule amount of historical knowledge will bring up numerous examples where “murder” was not just not forbidden, but it was a way of life for certain parts of the pupulation. Review medival Japan, where the bushido (the samurai code of behavior) revolved around the proper time of death, either in battle, or by seppuku, and they slaughtered everyone who did not bow down to them.

To say that “sin” clouds our reason, and that is why the “revelation” was necessary is just a cop-out. If that “moral law” is “natural” and can be discerned by reason alone (the ancient Greek philosophers came up with it, without any “revelation”) or not. Looking at history one can see that there is no “moral system” which would have been accepted across ALL societies and ALL times.
Another poster directed you to the old CE. That is a good place to start:
Passing from the primary principle to the subordinate principles and conclusions, moralists divide these into two classes: (1) those dictates of reason which flow so directly from the primary principle that they hold in practical reason the same place as evident propositions in the speculative sphere, or are at least easily deducible from the primary principle. Such, for instance, are “Adore God”; “Honour your parents”; “Do not steal”; (2) those other conclusions and precepts which are reached only through a more or less complex course of inference. It is this difficulty and uncertainty that requires the natural law to be supplemented by positive law, human and Divine. As regards the vigour and binding force of these precepts and conclusions, theologians divide them into two classes, primary and secondary. To the first class belong those which must, under all circumstances, be observed if the essential moral order is to be maintained. The secondary precepts are those whose observance contributes to the public and private good and is required for the perfection of moral development, but is not so absolutely necessary to the rationality of conduct that it may not be lawfully omitted under some special conditions. For example, under no circumstances is polyandry compatible with the moral order, while polygamy, though inconsistent with human relations in their proper moral and social development, is not absolutely incompatible with them under less civilized conditions.
 
Such is not a “cop-out” and I will note this is a forum of Moral Theology…so do not be surprised if one finds members discussing Theology 😉
Generally speaking that is perfectly fine. However, when wishes to discuss a “natural” something (be it moral law or anything else) then it is a logical error to refer to “theology”. Especially since the “natural moral law” was a secular concoction by those aforementioned Greek philosophers.

I also wish you a happy amd prosperous day and life.
 
Generally speaking that is perfectly fine. However, when wishes to discuss a “natural” something (be it moral law or anything else) then it is a logical error to refer to “theology”. Especially since the “natural moral law” was a secular concoction by those aforementioned Greek philosophers.

I also wish you a happy amd prosperous day and life.
Tis the Moral Theology forum…😉

And God made nature…and the Greek philosophers…including their minds…(whatever their contribution to the understanding of the natural moral law)

And we have “natural theology”, “natural rights” etc…all such (including natural law) come from the Author of nature.
 
Tis the Moral Theology forum…😉

And God made nature…and the Greek philosophers…including their minds…(whatever their contribution to the understanding of the natural moral law)

And we have “natural theology”, “natural rights” etc…all such (including natural law) come from the Author of nature.
This is where we must stop this dialog, because it is useless. If you could PROVE that there is a god, and that god is the God of chistianity, and that PROOF would be fully secular (rational) then there would be a ground to continue. But it is impossible. You need “faith” which is not acceptable for non-believers.

The funny thing is that I would not care if there would be some people who cannot perceive that alleged “natural moral law” - for whatever reason. There are people who cannot comprehend the higher complexities of mathematics and that does not invalidate the theorems of mathematics.

My question still is (and I do not expect a rational answer any more): is it true that the ancient societies of cavemen simply did not comrehend that public nudity, public sex and spreading the genes into whatever “womb” was available are “immoral”, or was their “morality” significantly different? Did they misconstrue “marriage”, even when they had no idea about the role the males played in the conception and people had sex with different partners? (I hope you are aware of the matriarchial setup, since only the mother’s identity was known?) These are some of the questions I keep presenting, and which are ignored.

Please check my signature. I could not care less about theology. If there are no secular arguments, then there are NO arguments. Case closed.
 
The conclusion is that without a separation of “obvious” and “not obvious”, the whole idea simply collapses into subjective incoherence.
No; that’s an example of the continuum fallacy.
 
Tyrion

The devil is in the details. Just what are the paragraphs of this “natural moral law”? Even if you cannot provide an exhaustive list, but surely the church has at least a partial list, which is applicable to all societies across all times. An empty “law-book” is not much of a help, is it? Please provide the contents in it. I am eager to see those pesky details.

Love God and one another.

Do no harm.

Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.

I should think even a caveman could have figured out those laws, even if he didn’t intend to obey them.

This is minimalism, of course. A more complex ethical system would develop as civilization became more complex.
 
This is where we must stop this dialog
I refer you to the sources above (including further sources from Catholic Answers --including a radio program on the broad topic of NML…and also the Staff at CA can point you on to further good sources)
Please check my signature. I could not care less about theology. .
If one does not wish to discuss Theology …perhaps do not come to a Theology forum.

I bid you now – a splendid eventide for where I am the day star is setting.
 
My question still is (and I do not expect a rational answer any more): is it true that the ancient societies of cavemen simply did not comrehend that public nudity, public sex and spreading the genes into whatever “womb” was available are “immoral”, or was their “morality” significantly different? Did they misconstrue “marriage”, even when they had no idea about the role the males played in the conception and people had sex with different partners? (I hope you are aware of the matriarchial setup, since only the mother’s identity was known?) These are some of the questions I keep presenting, and which are ignored.
You are looking for an ideal textbook or cookbook? Culture, present and past, can be closer or farther from the natural moral law for a variety of reasons. That is not proof it does not exist.
 
It is the Natural Law that was used* by the world* to convict the Nazis at the Nuremburg Trials. Research there.

I dare say one bright, sunny day the same Natural Law will be used to incarcerate the Planned Parenthood Provider perps, IMHO.
Don’t hold your breath. :sad_yes:
 
Love God and one another.
Do you really think that the cavemen were aware or the God of christianity, who has not been suggested for tens or hundreds of thousands of years? There were zillions of gods invented by people during the millenia. People were attempting to figure out the “why”-s of nature, and the simplest “explanation” was some “god”, who had to be appeased. Every religion is based upon this simple though incorrect concept.
Do no harm.

Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.

I should think even a caveman could have figured out those laws, even if he didn’t intend to obey them.
Impossible. The level of abstraction needed has not been achieved then. Members of the tribe were “kins”, while everyone else was enemy.
This is minimalism, of course. A more complex ethical system would develop as civilization became more complex.
The concept of the golden rule is an excellent starting point. However it would never lead to those complex and usually ridiculous ethical sytems which were developed later on. And the conclusion is that the ethical systems are dependent upon the society, its prevailing customs, in other words, they are not universal.
 
You are looking for an ideal textbook or cookbook?
It is your assertion that there is a uniform “natural moral law”, unchanging across all societies and all times. Well, I call your bet. Produce the that “law-book”, or fold.
Culture, present and past, can be closer or farther from the natural moral law for a variety of reasons. That is not proof it does not exist.
Of course it is. The concept of morality is not something complicated. It is simply the summary of socially accepted behaviors, part of which is codified, and the other part is simply expected. Deviation from the latter can carry a social stigma, but no criminal repercussion.

The fact that you realize that culture, present and past is so varied, should give you the realization that there is no uniform code of acceptable behavior.
 
It is your assertion that there is a uniform “natural moral law”, unchanging across all societies and all times. Well, I call your bet. Produce the that “law-book”, or fold.

Of course it is. The concept of morality is not something complicated. It is simply the summary of socially accepted behaviors, part of which is codified, and the other part is simply expected. Deviation from the latter can carry a social stigma, but no criminal repercussion.

The fact that you realize that culture, present and past is so varied, should give you the realization that there is no uniform code of acceptable behavior.
This doesn’t follow in the least.

We could develop a parallel argument to “prove” any form of truth to be equally non-existent. To rephrase your statement as it could be applied to scientific understanding:

The fact that you realize that scientific knowledge present and past is so varied, should give you the realization that there is no uniform set of scientific principles to be had.

A similar misstatement can be made regarding truth in general: The fact that you realize that the nature of truth, past and present is so varied, should give you the realization that there is no uniform set of axioms that can be referred to as truth.

And yet, here you are arguing about whether moral codes can be “true” in any sense. Obviously, you must have as a basic guiding principle that there is such a thing as truth, otherwise why waste your time arguing about it?

The fact that debate can be waged over whether specific moral codes are better than others is an indication, just as in debates about theories in science, that some objective standard by which codes can be assessed does, indeed, exist.

The moral state of certain cultures in the past can, likewise, be analyzed. If, and you have provided little in the way of evidence for this contention, primitive human-like groups engaged in immoral behaviour, that does not suffice as evidence that no objective and binding moral code exists. The actions of Hitler and his cohort can be assessed morally. To deny that is tantamount to the admission that any action is en par with any other, morally speaking. If no moral standards exist, then wantonly raping or murdering another individual is qualitatively no more or less laudable than a firefighter rescuing someone from a burning building. Is that what you propose to be the “truth” about moral codes?

Surely, this is nonsense. It would mean that any actions that we carry out are totally devoid of any meaning since whatever we do makes absolutely no difference. Human actions would be en par, qualitatively, with molecules colliding or rocks falling down a mountainside.

Are you really saying that rape, child abuse or murder are, in reality, no more or less moral than heroic generosity or caring for the sick?

If that is your position, then apparently, there is nothing more that can be discussed since your position is not a reasoned one, but an irrational one that has abdicated basic axioms of human existence.

You do realize that all logic and reason begin with axioms (premises that are presumed, but accepted by all or, at least, most rational beings)? These are the grounds on which all reasoned discussion can continue. They are self-evident principles that “cannot” be disputed because they are undeniably true. You either “see” and accept them, or you don’t. It is the failure to recognize these basic principles that distinguishes reasonable individuals from those who are incapable of rational thought. The “law” of non-contradiction is one such principle. Another is to treat similar things alike in the respects that they are similar.

This second basic premise leads to the natural moral law. Human individuals are alike and therefore, should be treated similarly. Actions that harm me, likewise harm others. I should treat others as I would will them to treat me. Life is the one “good” upon which all other goods depend, therefore actions that promote life are those which are to be carried out.

That is the basic ground of moral law. As to whether humans at all times and places have recognized that or not makes no difference as to the truth of it, just as the fact that humans at all times and places have not understood chemical interactions or basic physics disproves our current understanding of these.
 
Since science is about what “IS”, while ethics is about what “OUGHT TO BE”, you post was void of rational content as such it does not deserve any consideration.
 
Since science is about what “IS”, while ethics is about what “OUGHT TO BE”, you post was void of rational content as such it does not deserve any consideration.
Your conclusion appears to be that ‘ought’ is a meaningless abstraction simply because it is distinguishable from “is.” What exactly justifies that conclusion?

Let’s take your position to its “logical” terminus, shall we? That means whether one event (the annihilation of all human beings) or another (human beings live in security and peace) occurred would make absolutely no difference to you because the “quality” of various outcomes has no bearing on anything?

If that is your “rational” position, then we must part company because this point of view demonstrates a complete abdication of reason and humanity. That would indeed suffice as evidence that you are incapable of understanding the difference between a rational argument and nonsense. Say it isn’t so :eek:
 
It is your assertion that there is a uniform “natural moral law”, unchanging across all societies and all times. Well, I call your bet. Produce the that “law-book”, or fold.
I was asking you exactly what you seek? Why would there be a book? Is a book the only “proof” you would accept?
Of course it is. The concept of morality is not something complicated. It is simply the summary of socially accepted behaviors, part of which is codified, and the other part is simply expected. Deviation from the latter can carry a social stigma, but no criminal repercussion.
So it is all relative?
The fact that you realize that culture, present and past is so varied, should give you the realization that there is no uniform code of acceptable behavior.
How does that follow? As I said that is not proof no objective standard exists.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top