Near Death Experience Catholic theology

  • Thread starter Thread starter nguirado
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
near death experiences are not very reliable. I’ve read lots… some really support Catholic theology, others are very Protestant, and some are new agey and deny Christ, or the existence of Heaven, or hell.

I’d just stick to Scripture, Tradition, and the writings of the Saints 🙂 if you find a near death experience account that is interesting and goes together with Church teaching, it can be encouraging… but if not, - remember they are VERY varied and we don’t know if these people experienced something from God, or from the enemy (deception).

God bless
 
Me too.We are always safe sticking to the SacredTraditions.
 
near death experiences are not very reliable. I’ve read lots… some really support Catholic theology, others are very Protestant, and some are new agey and deny Christ, or the existence of Heaven, or hell.

I’d just stick to Scripture, Tradition, and the writings of the Saints 🙂 if you find a near death experience account that is interesting and goes together with Church teaching, it can be encouraging… but if not, - remember they are VERY varied and we don’t know if these people experienced something from God, or from the enemy (deception).

God bless
I do remember seeing an old Mother Angelica program on tv some time ago where she interviewed a catholic priest who had near-death experience that totally conformed to catholic theology and teaching-------he was judged by Jesus to not have been a good, proper priest and was about to condemn the man to hell when Mary interfered and begged him to hand the man over to her----and if he still did not live up to his priestly calling then his “will be done.” The man reformed and became a devotee of Mary. He was very believable and Mother Angelica appeared to fully believe his story.

I would say Mother Angelica is a very believable person to trust in this matter----if she could be convinced, then that would be good enough for me.

I would say----by all means stick with tradition and the gospels----but if the near-death experience upholds to Catholic theology and it is attended to by respected, honorable people, then it is not foolish to believe it. 👍🙂
 
I do remember seeing an old Mother Angelica program on tv some time ago where she interviewed a catholic priest who had near-death experience that totally conformed to catholic theology and teaching-------he was judged by Jesus to not have been a good, proper priest and was about to condemn the man to hell when Mary interfered and begged him to hand the man over to her----and if he still did not live up to his priestly calling then his “will be done.” The man reformed and became a devotee of Mary. He was very believable and Mother Angelica appeared to fully believe his story.

I would say Mother Angelica is a very believable person to trust in this matter----if she could be convinced, then that would be good enough for me.

I would say----by all means stick with tradition and the gospels----but if the near-death experience upholds to Catholic theology and it is attended to by respected, honorable people, then it is not foolish to believe it. 👍🙂
“Ordinary Melkite”

Thank you for reminding us of that! I do remember a friend loaning me a tape of that sharing by a priest. I forgot the name of the priest,…but, yes, it was very inspiring to hear about this and see the grace of God at work in the priest’s soul.

Thanks be to the Lord!

Dorothy
 
I’m reading this book.

amazon.com/Evidence-Afterlife-Science-Near-Death-Experiences/dp/0061452572/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1301785329&sr=8-3

How does near death experiences challenge or confirm Catholic theology?
I have read this book and others, and I have had a near death experience. It changed my life completely and I started a web site and blog on the subject. The truth is that NDEs are not religious experiences. I know that some experiencers see Jesus or God and it is easy to say this is religion. The experience is spiritual but not religious, there is no doctrine in them. I have read thousands of them. They are about love as Jesus taught, spiritual love and compassion. Now the core teachings of Christianity are of love as taught by Jesus. To love one another, forgive, don’t judge, love your enemies, and help others. This is not religious doctrine, it is about spiritual growth and love. It stops there in ninety percent of NDES.
 
Mother Angelica, herself, had a near-death experience. She saw her soul leave her body three times, and return three times. Also, I know of a priest who said his sister died in childbirth, but was revived. She told of being given a choice to stay or return. She returned for her child’s sake, but found “the other side” very beautiful. He said that most didn’t believe her. She told him that she knew that, but regardless of what they thought --she knew!
 
A friend gave me a book called “Descent into death” by Howard Storm. He was a college professor at No KY Univ. and a confirmed atheist. He had a NDE while on vacation in Paris, as is today a minister affiliated with the United Church of Christ, but closely works with the Catholic Church in Honduran missions. I don’t know for sure, but I tend to believe this guy based on where he was, what happened and what he’s like now. Jesus saved him while he was being dragged to hell. His account of the experience is horrifying until he calls out for Jesus, that is.
 
A friend gave me a book called “Descent into death” by Howard Storm. He was a college professor at No KY Univ. and a confirmed atheist. He had a NDE while on vacation in Paris, as is today a minister affiliated with the United Church of Christ, but closely works with the Catholic Church in Honduran missions. I don’t know for sure, but I tend to believe this guy based on where he was, what happened and what he’s like now. Jesus saved him while he was being dragged to hell. His account of the experience is horrifying until he calls out for Jesus, that is.
video.google.com/videoplay?docid=2094001112814040004&hl=en&emb=1#
 
It seems likely that NDEs are hallucinations caused by electrical discharges in the brain as the brain is slowing dying due to the lack of oxygen. They can be produced artificially:
When the right side of the human brain is probed during surgery, it can produce out-of-body experiences, psychic experiences, feelings of deja’ vu and mystical experiences. Artificial stimulation and/or seizures to this part of the brain can also cause classic near-death experiences. These experiences, which include the tunnel experience and our personal vision of heaven, can sometimes be played, again and again, apparently without meaning.
See this page and this page for more information.
 
A well written, short, and entertaining novel, HOME FOR CHRISTMAS, by Fr. Andrew Greeley, is based upon his many years as a priest. Not about Christmas, the novel is about a near death experience. It is an enjoyable Christian love story.
 
Mother Angelica, herself, had a near-death experience. She saw her soul leave her body three times, and return three times. Also, I know of a priest who said his sister died in childbirth, but was revived. She told of being given a choice to stay or return. She returned for her child’s sake, but found “the other side” very beautiful. He said that most didn’t believe her. She told him that she knew that, but regardless of what they thought --she knew!
You are describing classical near death experiences where the experiencer is given a choice as I was, this is very true, and it doesn’t matter the number that don’t believe, they were not there, I was there and I know for sure it was real, it changed me forever as it has millions of others. Thanks for the post.
 
It seems likely that NDEs are hallucinations caused by electrical discharges in the brain as the brain is slowing dying due to the lack of oxygen. They can be produced artificially:

See this page and this page for more information.
No near death experience has ever been reproduced by anyone. People who believe this have not read any real near death experiences. There has been 35 years of research into near death experiences showing consciousness continues to live after the death of the body. Near death experiences are real spiritual experiences. I will leave a link.

wp.me/pvtV5-Sm
 
It seems likely that NDEs are hallucinations caused by electrical discharges in the brain as the brain is slowing dying due to the lack of oxygen. They can be produced artificially:
When the right side of the human brain is probed during surgery, it can produce out-of-body experiences, psychic experiences, feelings of deja’ vu and mystical experiences. Artificial stimulation and/or seizures to this part of the brain can also cause classic near-death experiences. These experiences, which include the tunnel experience and our personal vision of heaven, can sometimes be played, again and again, apparently without meaning.
I didn’t find the source of the quote at either website, perhaps I missed it. What’s true, however, is that the NDE is not reproducible by any means we have, though some of the subjective perceptions can be initiated. Also, there are many cases of NDE/OBE where the person was not close to death, their brain was not dying or oxygen-deprived.

This quote is from your skeptic site:
Based on their findings, van Lommel et al. (2001) concluded that we now require a new approach to consciousness – one that gives provision for non-irreducibility of the mind to the brain. In other words, the mind is not what the brain does and may indeed be independent of it. This neo-dualism is worrying.
Nothing “neo” about the concept that the brain does not generate the mind, or the individual consciousness. It’s what we believe. We inhabit these bodies, we pass on and leave them behind. We depend on the intervention of those who have gone on before us.

To read someone who started with no agenda, read Melvin Morse who was an atheist, not changed to a new view by a personal NDE, but by what his scientific mind observed in others that went far beyond the limited references in articles by skeptics, no matter how scholarly the language of their offerings.
 
As someone who had a near-death experience myself, I can see only support for the afterlife. I was given to see my life in a nutshell, kept hearing a voice telling me “It’s alright, it’s alright,” when I was terrified at leaving my son, and when I insisted that there was no one to take care of him and that I couldn’t go now, I was allowed to come back. It’s as simple as that. How could that be a problem with my Catholicism?

kind wishes to you, the reader
Francesca
 
As someone who had a near-death experience myself, I can see only support for the afterlife. I was given to see my life in a nutshell, kept hearing a voice telling me “It’s alright, it’s alright,” when I was terrified at leaving my son, and when I insisted that there was no one to take care of him and that I couldn’t go now, I was allowed to come back. It’s as simple as that. How could that be a problem with my Catholicism?

kind wishes to you, the reader
Francesca
It isn’t a problem.
 
NDE’s would fall under personal or private revelation in the Catholic Church- which is acknowledged but not required to believe…

If you want a book that will enhance your faith and confirms the basic truths of Catholicism via spirit images…check out
What Do I Have to Do…Paint You a Picture? It’s available on Amazon.com

Sorry- don’t have the link
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top